Did I mess up by coming back to consulting? Recent MBA. Interned at T2. No return, was told I'm an analyst-level w/no strategic/communication skills. With no job, I panicked and re-recruited and found myself at an MBB this Aug. I am so anxious I'm in the wrong place. I was a high performer at my prior role (F500 chemicals) w/ a strong enough network to return to industry if needed. Do I stay in consulting when I've been written off already? Or go back for less $ but higher chance of success?

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

??? You made it to MBB - stick it out if you can. If it doesn’t work out you’ll get some time to pivot.

like

Congratulations, you are self aware. This is the highest level of intelligence. You’re where you’re at because you have skills and you’re authentic. Don’t go backward. Fight, use your skills, work on communications and assess your comfort level a month from now. Then repeat.

likeupliftingsmart

You went to a T2 firm and they said you weren’t good enough so you showed them up by going to MBB. They can suck it

likesmart

They may have been right, or not. We’ve all got fair criticism and we’ve all got bs criticism.

OP, congratulations on landing a better job. You’ll make mistakes like everyone, just learn from them and move on.

And don’t ever, ever let the b…stards get you down!!! You’ve got this!!! 💪

like

You are brand new at an MBB - you have a clean slate so don’t worry about being written off in the previous role

likeuplifting

Just be better this time

likefunnysmart

Just don’t be Mid bro, you got this playa

like

I got no return offer from my first consulting gig (a tier 2/3) and now I am absolutely thriving. I think a few things to consider:

1) different firms are looking for different things - tier 2/3 may be looking, at a post mba level, for managers that can easily fit into the job (usually those that have done consulting before)

2) these smaller firms don’t have time / space / culture to coach and grow folks at a certain level - they may have seen your development goals and thought they didn’t have the structure to help you improve

3) larger institutions (Ie MBB) know very well how to take folks from all different starting points and help them to become great consultants

You’re well positioned going into MBB that tend to hire more on your potential than current ability to do the job - learn everything you can and see if you like it! Maintain your industry connections and if you decide consulting is not for you, you can surely go back. I’ve heard a few stories of this kind and know it’s possible. Good luck!

like

You often learn from failures. By the way an internship is an accelerated process so making mistakes can easily ruin your offer. As a new associate you will be given a clean slate but it will definitely be harder at MBB than T2. Good luck, learn quick and you’ll be just fine

like

Which MBB

funny

STAY. You won’t get fired before at least 16-18months. And then you get to go on transition which is free money for 2-4 months. So that’s almost 2 years of MBB on your resume. Then you can leave to whatever role you feel you’re better suited for, with a super strong resume :)

likesmart

Round 2 🥊 focus on using the learnings from the T2 to show them up. I had the exact same scenario, going from a boutique with non-existent training to Big 4 where I'm the go to guy for decks and strategic communication now.

If you still aren't finding your groove at MBB you'll have at least a year with the performance improvement plan and all, and can make up a resume justification in terms of leaving to a better opportunity or for better wlb.

like

Dude why are you so anxious? Don’t let your worries and doubts kill a new good thing you got now. Maybe you need to get your anxiety under control. Learn from your mistakes and move on.

likesmart

You’ll figure it out

like

It’s a tough situation to be in.
I hate to say it but fake it till you make it mind set has to be used.
Good luck and you’ll be surprised at how fast you can adapt sometimes.

like

Rejection is redirection. You’ve got this! Stick it out

like

Look up “imposter syndrome”. You got where you’re at for a reason. Don’t give up now.

Consulting is an art. It takes time to figure out communication, CYA, the ability to say no, mentorship- giving and receiving, all while providing valuable insights and solutions to clients.

Give it time and continue to play the game. Who knows, maybe you’ll be far more competent than you imagined.

Ty all, this gives me a good feedback to work off of.

Related Posts

Hi Fishes,

I am currently working as an associate consultant in Infosys. But my work is of manual+automation testing. I want to switch now, but I am confused b/w Business Analyst and Automation tester role, which role would be better for me to switch? Also regarding salary which is a high paying role among the two?

Experience-3 years
CTC-7.5

Are there any disadvantages of joining a C2H role purely on the basis of high CTC even though it is for a big client of the contractor company?

like

Anyone looked into an exit to Lordstown Motors, Canoo?

like

What are some good agency internship programs other than the Kennedys (Amsterdam/London) or The Pipe (Ogilvy London)? Even better if the chances of hiring are high.

helpful

I am looking for a full time media sales, ideally sales mgmt role. After a failed start up attempt, independent consulting has been disparate and lonely. I feel like all my networking feeds and certifications are geared to technical roles and technical buzzwords. Any solid advice how I can include buzzwords in my CV so that the algorithms can signal my sales management interest?

like

Anyone here regret pivoting from B4 management consulting to F500 Corporate Strategy? Specially CPG companies.

like

Any BCG consultants or knowledge experts willing to chat? Super interested in the space and role but unsure what the best fit would be. Have 2 YOE in sustainability.

like

What’s the most effective way for producers to network for new job opportunities?

like

How does health insurance at MBB & T2 strategy consulting firms compare to Tricare Reserve Select for a family? I’m 99% getting out of the Reserve within the next year and, assuming things go well with recruiting, would switch to the firm insurance as my primary once I start. Just want to confirm that there’s no reason for me to stay

Does anyone have any advise on how to become a staff video editor at a creative production company? They usually don't have any "job openings" listed on their site.

I have 5+ years of experience working at a creative ad agency, but much of the work was pitch/sizzle videos (yuck).

I'm freelancing now which has been a great step in the right direction but I'd eventually love to be on staff at a post house like The Den, Cut+Run, Company 3 etc. pumping out cool work. Just seems hard to break in.

like

I’m looking to hear about anyones experience with RA, thinking of pivoting to RA from PM. What is a typical day like for remote RA roles?

Hi guys,
I am currently working as a servicenow consultant in Infosys and I want to get into a BA profile in future. I have an MBA in HR and marketing and a BTech in CSE. I have already cleared my ECBA certification and I wanted to know what all skills should I acquire to transition into that role in or outside of ServiceNow.

Looking forward to your tips and suggestions

TIA

Light & Wonder Let me know if anyone is interested in the below openings Light & Wonder

Post Photo
like

You can get into FAANG but remember you will become good for nothing. As when u try to switch you will have bug fixes in your resume no productivity. Beware...

like

Looking for some pay range information. I’m a national manager for a home health type setting for Neurodiagnostics. I run 2 departments (EEG technicians and EKG technicians) I have 7 direct reporting managers below me and 100 technicians who umbrella under them and they are scattered across the US. Im in charge of monthly reporting, hiring/firing, assist with recruiting/forecasting where we are having growth, mentor, coaching for development, oversee unit and supply inventory, cont in comments

like

Looking to get a referral for MBB, can any fishies help?

like

Need a referal for automation testing openings

like

Openings at Accenture. DM for referral.

Post Photo

Hey all! Anyone willing to chat with me about their experience at CapTech with regard to WLB, salary, travel? Would love to consider a career there!

like

How is Microsoft's Customer Value Engineering team? How is the work culture, work life balance and growth opportunities?

like

More Posts

How does everyone feel about body-cams? Necessary or not?

like

I used to like Christmas carols. Retail fixed that for me. WHY do they start earlier every year?

like

I have never turned on my camera for my meetings, and i dont care what others think of me, and mostly no one cares. whats your experience ? are you forced to turn your cameras on ? or you got excuse ?

like

As a manager, how do you expect your employee to deal with a diffcult customer?

like

I had two recruiters today reschedule a meeting. And this is the second time rescheduling. Honesty, not sure what value recruiters bring. Is this common now? Is it hard to have respect for people’s time and their schedule? Reschedule once I can understand. But twice is just stupidity. I hope AI wipes out all bad recruiters who don’t give af. Sorry for the vent. Maybe it’s just my bad luck then.

like

How do PE exits look like for emerging market funds in Middle East (e.g Abraaj group type firms)

I finally got through to the Hiring committee round at Google. Should I be excited or nervous or not read into at all?

likeuplifting

Just got another rejection... Is exiting to FAANG or MB really this hard? Trying to go tech.. or mbb, but not getting anywhere. I have 2 masters (mba, ms) from top schools, been in consulting for over 10 years, I am confident that I know my stuff well..but still I keep getting rejected. Interviewed with Google, Amazon, Cisco, McKinsey, and a few others and every-time there is something that is not a match... are the hiring managers looking for like 100% match? That will never happen!!!

like

I recently joined TW some months back and I dont know why I think have made a wrong choice for myself. I am feeling like I am lost. I am not able to fit in in this high expectations environment. I am used to working in a place where we always worked by taking help from others and here it is sort of assumed that we would be knowing everything right from day 1. Also there is no pairing in my project. Any suggestions on what should be done would be welcome.

like

Out of curiosity and to see how we all compare to one another, what are people seeing as raise changes from Senior 1 to Senior 2? I want to see if an 8% raise is fair or poor

like

I got an offer from GE Global Research. I have around 5 years of experience and my present CTC is 17.5 LPA. How much should I ask for? GE General Electric Company

like

How important are “assigned” courses to complete ? Any issues if I do them after the due date ? Or are they as important as “required”learning .

like

What field is everyone here working in?

like

How’s wrinkling on BB shirts? Have had issues w CT

I’ve been weightlifting at my boyfriend’s home gym, but when I’m home I’m a bit scared about using sizable weight without a spot. What have you guys been doing regarding solo workouts? I go to a local gym, but I don’t know anyone there

like

Can someone share any openings for JPMC Bangalore related to freshers.
Tech stack is SQL and Tableau. I am a fresher with 10 months of experience in internships and 1 month of full time experience.

Thank you for your help!

Hey FB fam. I’m putting together Financial success resources. If you have any books, articles or podcasts in relation to personal investments or real estate you recommend, please feel free to share 🙃

like

Who do you think the jags will pick first in the draft this week?

How do you show God’s love in the classroom?

likeuplifting

What productivity hacks do you employ? I like to shut off my email for 25 min intervals to focus on real work. It’s like a sprint of focus without being “unavailable” too long.

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Does McKinsey New Ventures sponsor people for MBAs or not?

like

Senior in Chicago making $95k. What salary increase can I expect for cost of living if I move to San Francisco?

like

Boss Makes a Dollar, I Make a Dime,
and I have given up all my personal time. Going for 105% Utilization

Post Photo
likefunny

Is there any advice for networking into projects when you don’t know many people at the firm yet? I always to help on BD work when I’m on the bench, but it never turns into any billable work. Every time I have talked to a partner/senior manager I was told I don’t have the skill set they’re looking for, but I don’t know how to build up from there. Feeing very lost but I want to improve my approach.

likehelpful

Best consulting firms without the massive ego?

like

Utilization director told me today that the layoffs won't affect me. My heart goes out to everyone that had to hear otherwise. Here's to hoping y'all find something better and prosper.

like

if there's no pension anymore and a significantly lesser lump sum payout, why become a partner at EY?

like

Benefits at your firm:
Firm Name | Level/Job title
PTO
Sick Days
Personal days
Maternity leave
Wellness benefit
Phone reimbursement
Monthly mobile plan reimbursement
401k plan
Pension plan

likefunny

Why aren't more people going independent?? We have skills, we have a rolodex, surely we can earn a lot more doing independent consulting?????

like

I didn’t know I have been given access to this Bowl. Welcome to me

funnylikeuplifting

Going to Dublin for a few days, any cool suggestions on what to do?

like

Capgemini 🐠- are you allowed to use personal credit card for official expenses?

like

What is everyone’s top 1 or 2 favorite books on personal finance? I’m always looking for a new one to bring into the fold of what I’m doing

like

Good consulting books? Not talking case prep but a fun read about the industry and what it takes to succeed, etc. Thank you!

like

What should I do in LA tonight? Staying around west LA.

like

How does Accenture’s cell phone reimbursement policy work if you don’t want a new device and just want reimbursement for the plan? From what I am reading we have to charge the cell plan to client?

like

Are any top consulting firms hiring for experienced analysts currently? I know ACN and some others are cyclical for resources 2-3 years out of college, but I’m looking to make a move sooner than fall

like

Hey FB fam. I’m putting together Financial success resources. If you have any books, articles or podcasts in relation to personal investments or real estate you recommend, please feel free to share 🙃

like

What's the best all-in-one credit card for traveling consultants that pay for their own expenses? I want to maximize rewards (whether it be cash back, points, miles etc.).

like

Best consulting firms with best WLB? Do they exist? Young professional starting to think about where I'd like to work hard to end up in the next 5-10 years.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal