Got dinged at final round for Bain and was heartbroken since it was my top choice (by a lot) over Mck and BCG (where I’m also interviewing) primarily because of the people and culture. Having trouble now motivating myself for these other interviews so wanted to ask you fishes if the differences in people, culture and teaming really is that big as I’m making out to be between firms. It’s probably shortsighted to only be laser focused on one MBB but the org culture/people are critical for me.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

There are going to be more differences within any MBB between offices and project teams than there are on average differences between the MBBs

likehelpful

Appreciate the insight!

Felt the same way in undergrad - everyone at my school went to Bain I was the only BCG person. But it worked out really well, loved being at BCG and obviously still here years later. Don’t worry too much about it just focus on getting an offer.

like

You right.

You’re honestly blessed to be smart and accomplished enough to have interviews with all MBB

Try to Get over Bain for now and crack the other 2. On the outset , There’s no major differences between the 3 for a new grad or even a mba grad unless you know exactly what type of clients you want to serve , how etc

Good luck!

like

Digging the positive attitude and appreciate the advice.

I was in a similar position . I didn’t get an interview from bain (top choice) but got from BCG and McK. Cleared Both and took signed BCG. To be honest- BCG people were so much fun and do not regret a bit about missing Bain.
Give your best and talk to more people. You might find the same culture and people. As BCG1 said, it differs from office to office.

like

If I have to give an advice! Don’t go into the interview with the mindset “I need to absolutely crack this, this is the biggest chance of my life.” This way it will take the pressure off and enjoy the process. Talk to the interviewer like you are trying to crack a problem together. Good luck

like

Have faith in the selection processes. If Bain dinged you but BCG/McK give you an offer then that's probably best for you. They're all pretty good at identifying the right people for their firm.

like

Hard to… everyone I talked to, including my first round interviews, told me I was a great “cultural” fit (or the like). But point taken.

Related Posts

How are you guys handling your mental health with job rejections or not getting interviews? I’m trying to stay optimistic but it’s soul crushing to see people you know get better jobs when you have been on the job hunt for awhile. I understand not comparing yourself to others but it’s hard when you realize you’re at the bottom of the totem pole and everyone else around you is progressing.

like

Hi Fishes, Does Pwc AC Bangalore give Mobile phone reimbursement of 34k like in Kolkata AC? Is there WFH one time allowance given now for new joiners post august 2022?

Hi,

I am joining Citi next week kharadi pune location.
Just wanted to confirm a few things.
C12 AVP Role

Is Citi providing laptops? What kind of work model is followed? Hybrid/wfh/wfo

How is the onboarding process? Virtual or do we need to visit the office on the first day.

Is free cab transport is provided ? How people from far distance are managing to commute to office?

How is WLB?

Please guide.

likehelpful

Ready to leave my current org to continue the process of learning and growth. Which companies actually have Account Executives hitting quota consistently, have a great product market fit, and have a positive culture geared towards career growth?

like

Have a 30minutes free consultation session with Stacy Blackman next week. Any preparation required on my end? I mostly want to get their thoughts on applying in R1 vs R2 for HSW given COVID deferrals

like

After a final interview, how many days after can I expect an answer from the recruiter?

At the end of the interview, the person told me I passed the interview and they were going to talk to the Director who’s a level under them. It’s a yes for them and they’re happy to work with me.

I also sent my references. I don’t know when I can expect an reply. Recruiters from that company aren’t really organised

Hi what is the maximum salary that can be provided in Verizon for the role 'Senior Engineer Consultant-QA Test Automation' ?

Will Verizon Hyd employees get cab service and food for morning and afternoon shifts ?

like

For staff/seniors in public accounting. Would you rather be paid 1 1/2 for your tax season overtime hours or would you prefer to wait for a big fat bonus check at the end of the company year? I heard KMPG paid overtime at 1.5 back in the day when the others didn't. I am sure they have now cut that out though.

like

Is HPE product based company? what kind of work will be there for a data engineer?

How is growth, wlb and job security?

skills : Python, Spark, Sql, AWS, Airflow.

like

Any thoughts if Virtusa would be better or HSBC India for life insurance domain as business analyst.

like

1.What are different band levels in LTI?
2.Is senior specialist level above the manager level in terms of payscale/destination?
3.What does working in salesforce vertical looks like & onshore opp. for US visa holders?
4.Avg hike / variable pay per year?
5.What is the notice period in LTI?
6.Any hidden components included in salary that can be avoided or restructed before joining?
7.What can be avg hike for 9 yrs of Exp in senior specialist track?

Thanks in advance,it will cover most of the quer

like

I am interviewing with Accenture UK for AWS Architect role. Total exp is 12 years. What base pay should I be looking at? I am moving from another country. So, no idea about UK pay-scales.

like

Any one currently working at EY LLP?

Hi Fishes,

Does
Hexaware Technologies have fixed Time in/ Time out policy in office or are they allowing wfh? Hexaware Technologies

like

Hey fishes,

Does EY provide relocation expenses for moving inside same city? From one end to another end? To shift home in other area?

like

Hi All, I have YOE of 9 years
KPMG offering a role of Manager
Fixed salary 30 LPA
Variable component I am not sure.

Can you suggest if this is a good deal?
I already have offers from CapG Invent 29LPA (26.3 fixed) and Infy Consulting 32LPA (25 fixed)

like

Wipro is offering 28LPA for 15 yoe managerial role. If it worth going ahead for any reason?

like

Hey Fishes,
Can you help me with test and interview process related information for Analyst roles

More Posts

Need help, I have relevant experience and good reputation among team. I want promotion in this cycle to manager level but the thing is the seniors I have, managers and senior managers are with PwC SDC for long time, so they are not ready to promote me with 4.5 years of experience. Can you please guide me on how can make it work?

like

Any book recommendations for grieving the death of an estranged parent?

like

23 F Maharashtra, wanted to try virtual dating.. not sure if its worth the time or not let sees

like

Are US markets or Emerging markets the smart move for 2021? We have the fed but they don’t have the burden of future debt 🌎

like

Accenture federal what’s the day to day like as a manager? Is it hands on or more review? Is there a lot of business development at the manager level?

like

Does paid internship in Canada, that relates to my degree count as work experience for express entry? This internship was not required for me to graduate.

like

How is the current market for moving to another consulting firm? Currently at a T3 and was thinking about trying for MBB or T2 next year

like

Is any from valueLabs? I have cleared 2 technical rounds there and they have scheduled 3rd round which is going to be a coding round taken by manger. Any idea what type of problems they may ask ? I am interviewing for automation tester position with java/ python

like

Hello folks,
I have an offer in hand by value labs and Accenture and I’m more leaning towards valuelabs. However, I’ve seen a lot of comment online which were made in 2022 and before as well that the job security is an issue in value labs and they will fire a chunk without any prior notice.
Is it true?
I would really appreciate if anyone can shed some on light on this.

like

Hi Fishes, need your guidance. I am having below offers. Please help me to decide.

Publicis Sapient - 16LPA + PWFH
Valuelabs - 18LPA + PWFH

I want to know in terms of Brand value, WLB, career growth, learning opportunity & job security.

*Also is it safe to join service based company with such a high package in respect to my YOE?

My Info:
YOE - 2.3Yrs
CCTC - 7.25LPA
Techstack - Frontend Development (React) College - Tier-3

likeuplifting
like

Would it be bad to chew Nicorette even though I don't smoke?

like

At some Big 4 companies there is a Partner / Principal group that has equity and are part owners of the business and an equivalent Managing Director group that does not have equity and are essentially employees.

How does it work at McKinsey / Bain ? Do those same distinctions exist across partner types, owner vs non owner?

like

Why in EY GDS orientation, they are calling Gurgaon people to office on the second day?

Can I join the EY GDS session virtually on the second day also as currently I am not in the base location?

For laptop also I've opted to be couriered.

Will there any issue if I join virtually on the second day for Gurgaon location?

like

Hello! I am a Technical Sourcer/Recruiter at a reputable FinTech company. I would like to transition into Project Coordination/Management within the tech space. Any tips for the transition? Recruiters: I am open to entry level & contract roles to gain experience! Thanks in advance for the assist!

BigLaw M&A: what do you consider to be “big deal” vs a small and medium deal? For example, what do you consider a $150M deal?

like

How does approval process usually work with rolex ADs? I have a purchase history with a current AD and been on a waitlist for a while. Got a msg saying they have one in system and waiting to get approval to sell me one, but no promises. Does this mean I am likely to get one soon?

like

Question: In Maryland, a limited liability S Corp shareholder can’t be sued individually but can they individually sue someone else on behalf of the corp? Or does an attorney for the Corp have to be the one to file suit? What abt in small claims court where lawyers aren’t even required?

like

Additional Posts in All Things MBB

Networking: I’m trying to build a network with MBB employees but I’m searching for roles in another country where I’ve got minimal school connections. Should I start by building a network in my home country and ask them if they can put me in touch with someone in my target location? Or just go straight to people in my intended location with cold requests/emails? Thoughts and views welcome!

like

At McK does integrative = generalist? Or are practice aligned consultants also integrative

like

Do referrals from people below associate partner level actually help?

like

is BCG hiring a experience hire class of associates in march?

like

Anyone who has been through both rounds at MBB - does case difficulty get any harder between round 1 and 2? Or is it just the level of interviewer?

like

Apologies if this is repetitive, but here for some inspiration stories… I prepped hard for the first (phone interview) McK 30-min evaluative case study (Digital Associate role) but failed it cause I couldn’t calm my nerves… is it realistic to hope that with more hard work, I can at least make it to the final rounds next time round? Any tips to not be anxious for a phone interview?

like

Read that McK is paying 2K higher than BCG this year which means BCG will probably raise again next year to at least match. However, they can’t just copy McK with 2K to match because that would look bad so they’ll have to beat it again. Then McK and Bain will follow. Barring a devastating recession, I’m guessing this means MBB is all getting raises again next year?

likefunny

Bain & Company Got dinged after a final round AC interview with Bain & Company as an experienced hire with 1 YOE. Currently at $75k base salary and on average work 30-40 hours a week.

Considering $15-25k increase in salary, but double the number of work hours, is it worth reapplying to Bain next year or better to wait to apply until after business school?

like

Bain & Company Got my first round Bain interview coming up. Any tips on what to focus on these last few days prior? Bain & Company

like

Bain & Company Are consultants for the CPG practice area/having CPG clients travelling yet? McKinsey & Company Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company

like

Just joined from B4 without a referral. Any questions?

like

McKinsey & Company Would anyone at McKinsey & Company be willing to chat for a referral for an analyst position?

like

Preparing for a Digital Associate position interview.

Have an upcoming phone case interview.
1. How are digital cases different than general consulting?
2. How complex are the phone case interviews?
3. Resources/ books/ YouTube channels I should be looking at?

This position would help me a lot at this point in life. Appreciate the help!!!

like

How bad is it to sound shaky during the case interview? I got everything right and nailed the math but I feel like I sounded like I was about to cry even though I was confident 🤦🏻‍♀️

like

Can someone explain what the Boston Consulting Group red zone report is and how it works?

like

Best GMAT prep books/ material ?

like

what phone can you get at bcg? how often upgrade. for NAMR

like

Could someone please comment on first year EM salary at McK? Both base + bonus? I have an offer and wondering if it is at the level of those hired to EM from within.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal