Hi everyone, I’m hoping to start an informal discussion and learn from HR, recruitment, and hiring perspectives.

In your experience, what feels most broken or inefficient in today’s hiring process?

Is it application volume, resume screening, candidate fit, time-to-hire, AI-generated resumes, ghosting, or the gap between resumes and actual role needs?

I’d appreciate any insights from the employer/recruiter side. Thank you!

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

To be honest, it's all of the above. Leadership generally wants HR to do more with less, candidates mass apply and often ghost because it's a numbers game on their side.

I'm old enough to remember recruiting before the internet ruined everything. Lol it's definitely a blessing and a curse...

like

would love to learn more about your insights. I have a questionnaire below on the study I am doing for application and hiring research: https://forms.office.com/r/bXb2DjaNKN

I guess its application volume as we cant give our 100% in so much of pressure.

like

would love to learn more about your insights. I have a questionnaire below on the study I am doing for application and hiring research: https://forms.office.com/r/bXb2DjaNKN

Applicant tracking/AI is what is wrong with the recruiting process. I don't advocate going back to the days of posting in the newspaper want ads, but ever since the beginning of internet recruiting, it's been on a downward spiral.

First, recruiters posted jobs on every site known to man, got so many resumes all at once that they were unable to view them all.
Then came ATS/AI and recruiters set the criteria so that most candidates were screened out and they complained that there was a candidate shortage.
Candidates knew that they were being screened by ATS/A so they apply using AI resumes, and recruiters complain that all the resumes look alike.
Recruiters, you have created this problem. You want only the resumes that are a perfect match for the position without having to work to find them. Relying completely on AI to find candidates neither works for the company nor the candidate, Some of my best hires have been candidates that were not perfect matches, but had qualities that attracted my attention, or maybe they were good candidates for another role in the company.
As a candidate myself, I am usually not looking for exactly the same thing I've done before. I am looking to grow, so my resume is most likely not an exact match. Why would I want a new job doing exactly what I do now?

like

Would love to learn more about your insights. I am conducting a study on this and would greatly appreciate if you can share your thoughts on this: https://forms.office.com/r/bXb2DjaNKN

IMO, an accurate job description will affect all things you have listed.

like

Would love to learn more about your insights. I am conducting a study on this and would greatly appreciate if you can share your thoughts on this: https://forms.office.com/r/bXb2DjaNKN

AI has ruined the entire process, on both sides. Workday and other platforms has made hiring managers and entry level recruiters too reliant on automated sorting and filters, and they are not looking hard enough at related skills and possible progression/growth into an idea candidate. Candidates using AI to write their resumes makes everyone look the same, and has made recruiters and hiring managers even more skeptical and less trusting of what appears on paper in terms of skills.

like

Would love to learn more about your insights. I am conducting a study on this and would greatly appreciate if you can share your thoughts on this: https://forms.office.com/r/bXb2DjaNKN

I think communication is still one of the biggest issues. I have seen strong candidates disengage because of slow timelines, poor updates, or unclear expectations.

like

Would love to learn more about your insights. I am conducting a study on this and would greatly appreciate if you can share your thoughts on this: https://forms.office.com/r/bXb2DjaNKN

wouldlovetohearyourthoughts:https://forms.office.com/r/bXb2DjaNKN

Related Posts

Transitioning from biglaw to IRS Chief Counsel?

Hi all, has anyone here transitioned to Chief Counsel from biglaw? What was your experience like? When did you transition? Any tips or general comments?

Current jr. associate. Love tax, not loving biglaw. Have an llm. Looking to transition in the next few years (or earlier if possible).

Thanks for any help.

like

Bonus for EY S&O?

likefunny

Can we extend the notice period in Tcs for 2 weeks?

like

I want to thank me for believing in me, I want to thank me for doing all this hard work. I wanna thank me for having no days off. I wanna thank me for never quitting. I wanna thank me for always being a giver and trying to give more than I receive. I wanna thank me for trying to do more right than wrong. I wanna thank me for being me at all times.

Post Photo
likesmartfunny

Got couple of openings for HR professionals in India . Middle to Senior level . IM me with your CV if keen. Thanks

likefunny

Hi fishes,
How many of you have an MBA in HR. And how important an MBA in HR is to excel in the field of HR. Because I'm pretty mba in Marketing isn't that important to get you a Marketing job.

like

HR professionals,
If you could immediately acquire any new skill, what would it be? If you're comfortable doing so, tell us why.

like

Sometimes I look at myself in the mirror and feel that if I worked on myself a little more, I’d be hot af.

like

At EY is I was reimbursed for a stationary bike 2 years ago. Would EY reimburse me for a road bike this coming year? There's a stipulation that says every 5 years but I'm not sure if that means for another stationary bike or if I can get a road bike and be reimbursed.

like

Loads of Tech Roles open at WebMD. Message me if you need referral for any of these roles.

Post Photo
likehelpful

Best month to find an apartment? Currently a nomad working abroad so want to strategically time my move back to NYC. Lived here for 5 years but always stuck in the summer rental cycle

like

Hello Amazonian,

Did anyone got to know their revised compensation ? And any idea how much it could be ?

like

Is cybesecurity as lucrative as software engineering careers.

I know cybersec covers a wide field. Any sub areas within cyber that pay more than other?

like

Thinking about moving to NYC! Graduated in 2019 with a SCOM degree and International Finance from UW-Milwaukee. Currently a material management consultant in Milwaukee. Any of you know of any opportunities in the city ? Would prefer a lgbtq friendly place 😅

Anyone in search of dating / LTR?

I’m 26, 5’10” (prefer same height or taller), Libra, live in Manhattan, have a dog, drink socially, socially active but not a working out kind of person/super fit (dad bod), full time professional, live alone, have goals, ambivert, side ↘️

Feel free to HMU. 😊

like

Is anyone willing to look over my resume to let me know if I’m qualified enough to be a consultant at Deloitte? TIA

like

Let’s talk decanters. Does anyone have a specific shape they recommend over others?

like

KINDLY HELP!! 🙏🏻
Hello Amex Fishes, I have an offer from Amex. If I get a better offer from other companies, Can I re-negotiate here at Amex? ( I have received and accepted the OL, accepted LOI 2 weeks back, and BGV has also started)

like

When is 2023 on-cycle kicking off? I've been reached out to by a couple HHs to fill out intro forms

like

Hi Fishes anyone here working in ADDA project

Additional Posts in Human Resources

What's something you've seen a manager fired for almost instantly?

likefunny
like

Am I being paid competitively? I have been the Onboarding Sup for my HR dept for over a year now and I’m being paid the state min for salary, which for CA is 62,400. I have not gotten a merit raise since the last 2 January’s, the state raises the threshold for salary folks. My company says that was my raise. Is this right? I bring a background from the clinical operations of my company, scheduling, field work, and what the average employee faces. I want to look else where but I’m not sure.

like

How do you improve critical thinking skills? If a manager tells you this, how do you respond and how do you get better?

like

Anyone prepping for the SHRM-CP test? I’m taking a prep course this fall and would love tips or to know if there are any study groups out there!

like

Question: an employee was asked by his boss for same day turn around on responses/deliverables on a days he requested PTO. He completed the work. The manager wants to know if she can still deduct PTO time for the days requested, even though he completed work on those days. Help.

I’m studying for the SHRM-CP with the Mometrix (study guides, online course, and flash cards), however I’m super overwhelmed with all of the information. What are some best practices to ensure I grasp all of the concept ? Any advice would be much appreciated!!!

As a 1 person HR show, what would your first hire be?

like

Bilingual Talent Sourcer in Canada (French and English) seeking remote work. Please message with available opportunities 😁😁

like

Can someone tell me if a HRBP III is more senior level than a HRBP I? I’ve never really dealt with those titles so I am a little confused!

like

I am in the process of finishing up my MBA but considering also getting my SPHR or PHR cert. Is it even worth it or a waste of time and money?

like

Hi all!
Would love some insight on how you went from an HR assistant/coordinator to an HR Generalist. I’ve been in the HR world for 8 years, and only in the last 2-3 have I really done real HR work. The first company I was at didn’t have a solid HR team so I don’t really count that. I feel like I’m ready to take on more responsibility and learn more. And of course make more money.

I have looked into getting SHRM certification. But should I go back to school and get my masters in Hr?

like

Does anyone have a recommendation for an HRIS that includes time tracking, will integrate with QuickBooks and is reasonably priced or has a nonprofit discount?

likehelpful

Does your company offer Volunteer Hours? If so, how many per year?

like

Any thoughts on the best certifications to get in order to help move forward? I have considered the CCP from World at Work, but it’s fairly pricey to get by the time you wrap up everything. I was looking at both SHRM-CP and SPHR. Everyone that I have spoken to has the SHRM, but that’s also only looking at individuals in a small geographic footprint and within 3-4 different companies. I was hoping to get some thoughts on this from others? Thanks

Does anyone have recommendations on recruitment firms that specialize in Product Management roles specifically in e-commerce?

like

PwC EY Deloitte KPMG I've just landed a Senior Associate role with PwC as a recruiter.

How much are recruiters making across the Big4 to use in my negotiations?

like

Recently obtained my aPHR and I’m considering next steps in advancing my career. I am eligible to sit for the SHRM-CP presently and will not be able to sit for a PHR until 09/2023. Any pros/cons with either certification? Should I wait to sit for PHR or go for SHRM-CP now?

like

I am a career changer on mo 4 of a 6 mo sourcer/researcher contract that I’m not sure will be renewed due to team re-organizing. I have 5 YOE basically in an HR generalist role at a company that didn’t have an official HR function, building systems from the ground up. I also have my SHRM-CP. I am looking for a perm, remote HR generalist or program manager position and getting no traction despite a well-reviewed resume. What do I do? Should I go to grad school?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal