I hate the McKinsey culture but enjoy consulting. Might I enjoy BCG more?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Generally low values people. Annoyingly insecure. Incremental mindset. Lack of ambition for clients. Too Disingenuous. Over index on Kool Aid drinking. Just don’t like the machine. And I’m a Partner!

like

You have to be terribly insecure to be a high achiever and desperate for the badge of mck. They want that personality because they will do anything to work and get ahead

Have done studies across maybe 8 international offices. Cultural differences and team norms are vast. Best advice I've found is 'find your tribe'. I was on the verge of leaving back to industry, but am in a better place now than I was 6 months ago. Agree there are colleagues who will do anything for personal gain, but I don't think this is particular to our firm.

likeuplifting

What is the McKinsey culture? I hear the differences are M-vanity, BCG-academic, and B-frat. If you have your textbook chops about you then you might fit in better at BCG.

likesmart

M4 - why do you ask?

like

Yes we need more information. But if it’s anything about the actual nature of the work probably not

like

Doubt it any different from BCG and Bain. The firms are large and accept a certain "type" but everyone is different

like

I love BCG— have been here ~5 years and met many, many incredible people. We do overindex on creating intellectual property and building a “knowledge platform”, and index somewhat less heavily to relationships (although obviously still key.) We are hiring a ton, so definitely worth asking the question. What office / offices?

PS I also know a recent McKinsey transplant partner if helpful to have a name to reach out to

like

That is refreshing. I saw a post from PwC on LinkedIn today that said “Technology unlocks possibilities, but it’s our people who are at the heart of our business.” I thought....no. If you’re on a technology project they aren’t hiring you for your bedside manner. You deliver and get out of there like a utility function. Could you imagine if we said that quote about doctors? I would go see the biggest jerk if he would cure my health. Intellectual property and knowledge are where things are at. Everything else is just buzzwords and schmoozing. It is fake, and has no real ability to drive clients forward unless the service is a soft skill service.

I’d choose knowledge and substance over personality in the workplace any day. At home is a different game...

like

I doubt it’d be meaningfully different here but agree you need to pinpoint what you dislike. There’s an element of luck though - you might find a team here you click better with but probably wouldn’t be worth the switching cost

It's also difficult to know the difference in culture without more details. From what I've seen at McKinsey the culture can be very different between offices and client teams. I'd recommend reaching out to anyone you know at the BCG office you'd be interested in joining and asking them about the culture there, since YMMV in here.

Related Posts

like

Which organisation to choose IBM or NTT DATA or Luxoft .? I'm a retail banking business analyst with 5.5 YOE. IBM and NTT DATA provides same fixed component plus NTT in addition provides an variable of 6% from the fixed. From the perspective Of WLB and growth

I've cleared 2 rounds of interview , Technical and Managerial for Luxoft Poland. They are also in process of going for Client round. I opted for Advance hiring process. Will there be offer only after Client round qualification from Luxoft?

Can anyone please help?

like

Is there any notice period buyout option in legato?

like

Can anyone tell me how is the work life balance in Citi Bank? The opening is for credit analyst role in GCB group, which I think of the retail division.
I am currently in Commercial banking and the work life balance is pretty bad.
Also what salary can I expect at C11 level?
Citi

Pharmeasy offer

YOE - 2
Tech stack - .NET

Position - Senior Software Engineer
Base - 19LPA
ESOPS - 24L over 4 years

Rejected - Due to bad work life balance
@pharmeasy

like

How is Telco client in Tech Mahindra

I’ve put myself up for L4 promo this cycle. Assuming I get it, what would be the best next steps to optimize for long-term growth/TC?

My understanding is that L5->L6 is extremely painful at
Google. It may be easier to leave for a handful of years and gain managerial experience before returning.

L4->L5 is less challenging; however, I’m under the impression I can do this quicker at another company (if I leave after being freshly promo’d) AND get higher TC.

TC: 270K

Google Facebook (Meta)

like

Accenture India I have an offer from Accenture, but my company matched the offer. I wanted to revise my offer letter from Accenture.

How should I reached to HR, call or email? What will be better to get quick response, my joining is 1st of November.Accenture India

like

I don’t see too many Marketing Manager specific requests here so thought I’d take a crack. Any advice or interview prep insight for marketing roles. Specifically for Amazon Music. I made it to the first chat with a HM. Any guidance on possible questions would be awesome.

like

Hi fishes, i came accross a msg that EY GDS is currently a burning train And is like going to bankruptcy.
How much true is this news ?

funnylike

Equifax What is the salary bracket for 6 years experience candidate at Equifax in Atlanta and also St Louis?

likefunny

I’m having offer from EPAM Anywhere of 19.4 lpa for 5 yrs React exp. But concerned about policies of EPAM anywhere. So I did not resign yet. Also cognizant and HCL delaying offer discussions due to 3 month notice period. Any suggestions how should I tackle the situation to get the offer?

like

Is Manager in FIL same as AVP in HSBC or similar investment bank.

Bain & Company What is the likelihood of getting an offer at MBB consulting firms as a GCC National with Western education? Job is in Riyadh. Are the chances higher than elsewhere?Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company McKinsey & Company

like

Hello Fishes,
One query, I have received an offer letter from Wipro (Career Group: C1) with package of 28 LPA, out of which INR 420000 is allocated as 'Variable Pay' which will be paid on quarterly basis'. Need to know how much % would generally be paid out? Is it 100% or less as per the individual/organization performance.

what is the salary range for a consultant at progression level 1 with accenture in a tier 2 city?

like

Anyone familiar with Comvest Partners’ direct lending team?

like

More Posts

Best Halloween parties in Los Angeles?

like

What role “generally” pays more at Google? Product Manager or Sales Engineer?

likehelpful

Those of you who have left a firm, do you still keep in touch with any of your former supervisors, via email, happy hour, or otherwise? How long did you wait to re establish contact? I’m in a small market and worry about perception at my current firm. TIA

like

Any F 🐠 in their 30s in DC interested in connecting?

like

Recently divorced after 10+ yrs (40M, Denver)... Starting to figure out dating again. What age difference is it too cringe to try to date?... 10 yrs younger ok? If you're low 30'sF us a 40M in play?

like

Looking for possible Google referral, interested in positions out of Reston VA and Washington DC ( security clearance, DoD work)

like

Has anyone tested positive with COVID while pregnant? My spouse just tested positive and I’m staying someplace else to keep safe. But curious how worried I should be if I end up getting the virus?

like

I just started a new job 2 months ago, benefits and PTO don’t start until 90 days in so I still have a month before I can take off any time, and today found out my company doesn’t offer paid maternity leave.
I’m really struggling handling the symptoms and maintaining my full time job. Thinking about looking for a part time job to have more time to myself through the pregnancy since I won’t be getting a paid leave anyways, but lost on where to start looking. Any recommendations?

Hey Fishes,

I am holding two offers one from LTI and another from JPMC. Which one should I go with, LTI is offering 5% more salary then JPMC... Confused which one will help me for future.

like

Any referrals on JP Morgan please.i got the job id.Thanks

like

Anyone have financial services mock cases they can share ??

like

Why are relationships so difficult!!!

like

Tip: How to take advantage of 90 days notice period
Please find the attached photo 😀

Please share your thoughts..

Post Photo
likesmarthelpful

Hi folks,

I have 2 offers in hand
1) TCS 13LPA CTC
2) Tech Mahindra 14LPA CTC
YOE : 3+

Please help me choose between the organisations. I have only 2 weeks to join.

Qualcomm or Cisco ?
YoE : 5+. Tech stack: C,C++, DS & Algo. Both are offering the same CTC.

like

Hi All,

What is the wlb in Areteans for a pega developer.

like

Hi fishes,

Could some one Please help with in-hand salary with this E2 band structure ?

Post Photo
likehelpful

I'll be based in Tampa but living in the Orlando metro as of 8/30 (official paperwork lags a bit.). I can’t wait to be back

like

Is there an easy way to switch XLOOKUPS to INDEX MATCH? Have a large file with bunch of formulas that don't work on all client machines (different excel versions).

like

What’s the best way to make your email stand out to a recruiter?

Additional Posts in Consulting

So who here visited the Chicago Yacht Club at Open House Chicago and decided they wanted to grow up to be an old white guy? 🙋🏻

like

Do most of you all do your initiative work at night? That's what I'm used to but I'm on a new one and the lead keeps asking for meetings and updates during the work day

like

Deloitte guys - Serious question.
How is Analytics & Cognitive doing at D? I have an offer and I am not sure if there will be layoffs again. I am on work visa so will be difficult.
Role will be for Google Cloud & Analytics. Current job doesn't suck much though.

like

Soooo hungover... Had to drop off a call to puke, reconnected and claimed technical issues. Damn team dinners 😜😡. And as for the team -you know who you are- thanks...

like

FAANG ranking: Google, Netflix, Facebook, Apple, Amazon. Is this correct?

like

What's the best trick in consulting?

like

Under trump tax plan: earn 120k, pay 33% taxes, net pay is 80k. Earn 112k, pay 25%, net pay is 84k. Approaching a salary bump, what would you do?

like

Got home at 10pm tonight to a cooked meal, vacuumed house, and my husband cleaning the kitchen. Cried like a baby.

like

Top 10 books to read about consulting life ?

likefunny

Best books on leadership and sales skills?

like

How do I check my actual utilization (not the effective one). Mybusiness only tells me the effective utilization

like

Those who left consulting for software engineering, what kind of eng did you switch to, was it worth it, and how did you accomplish a switch?

likehelpful

Feeling lost in my career (10 yoe, 9 in consulting). Anyone feel this before and how did you get through it (career coach, books, etc)?

likefunny

Do you guys have Any good books on business? Not those self help books

like

Bain & Company Which are the best consulting firms and practices for Climate Change & Sustainability, especially in the Canadian geography? Also, please suggest the best Canadian city for consulting jobs.

McKinsey & Company | Boston Consulting Group | Bain & Company | Kearney | LEK | EY | Oliver Wyman | PwC | Deloitte

#ClimateChange #Sustainability #Water #ESG

like

Desperately want to get into healthcare strategy consulting. 13 years of healthcare clinical experience including project work. MBA. But keep getting told by recruiters that I don't have enough experience to be a Consultant or Manager but that I have too much experience to enter in every level such as a Senior Associate. Just one rejection after another, even when applying with internal referrals from Director or Partner levels. What am I doing wrong?

like

So, what happens if you miss your utilization/billable hour target by like 70-150 hours? Tons of "impactful" PRD work

like

What are the best Sales books y’all read?

like

Any good recommendations for books on management techniques? Trying to understand how management manipulates junior employees.

like

No Pain, no Bain!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal