I have found out I am being paid significantly less than my colleagues despite taking on the most responsibilities in the team. I am earning much less than a junior analyst despite me being an analyst (about £20k less).
The only difference is the junior analyst has had 6 months of prior work at another company before me.
Am I reasonable in thinking I should be receiving a higher compensation package and do I have grounds to raise this politely to the firm based on the above?

likehelpfulfunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

You can only build you case , and ask for a pay rise, look at other jobs on the current market to back your case, maybe don’t use the fact about other colleagues, be self assured at you own worth , and put your case to your manager , it seem you quite enjoy working for your current firm , but it might be time to consider moving company’s to feel more financially valued if you don’t get any results from asking for a pay rise 20k is quite a difference to you quality of life !

likehelpful

You really have two options: either continue suffering in silence and letting it gnaw at you, or go to your manager and tell them you either want more comp or fewer responsibilities. You can present that option to them respectfully and dispassionately. It's nature of business and employment: Employees should be paid based on the value they provide. All else is irrelevant--education, prior experience, friendships, etc. If those don't add value to your work, they shouldn't matter.

like

Leave

like

The company is not going to raise your salary unless you have significant leverage to use.

I.e you have an actual job offer from another employer, a competitor, and therefore it can be demonstrated to your existing employer that you are underpaid.

Unless you are crucial to their operation, in such a way, that losing you would make their life very difficult, they're not going to raise your salary by £20k just for asking.

Any payrise (if any) would be meagre, and not come close to being equal to, or more than the junior analyst.

The best way to increase your salary is to negotiate a higher salary by jumping ship to another company, but then you have the risk of not enjoying working for the other company. So you will have to do your research on the other company, including but not limited to on here.

The Junior analyst may have moved around more, they may have lied about the salary they were on at the other company, in order to get a higher salary at the company you work for.

like

How did you find out that you colleague was making more money? It will matter as to how you bring it up to management.

like

That makes your conversation with managing a little dicey. Will your colleague mind your taking on this battle based on a private conversation?

This is why employees should never discuss their comp with one another. If you negotiated your salary on the way in and you haven't been there that long it is on you. That said, I do think you should present your case to your manager by referring to your independent research in the market. I would not refer to the other employee or compare your workload to some else. You build your case based on your experience and accomplishments alone.

like

This is exactly why employees should talk about their comp. More senior staff should be paid more.

If you are an employer & you pay a junior more than their senior, expect to lose experience from your own fault.

You have just insulted your employee, it is worse if you have the senior training them.

like

I think you should ask for a pay rise based on your own experience, not referring to your colleagues, because some organisations are very sentimental about who they like and who they hate so based on that judgement, promotion is done.

like

Do you people really think the company's gonna raise their pay? You people are so delulu

I'd build my case and find supporting analysts to back those claims I intend to highlight. I would also be looking for another potential job in case plan A doesn't pan out. Also, you could ask for a raise or fewer responsibilities that are consistent with your pay grade. Wishing you the best.

like

Tell the company to increase your pay

like

The possibility of your junior colleague being your senior is high before you bargain for a paycheck rise, how competitive are you? your junior may have more experience and also education besides he may be in to learn the system before taking leadership responsibility for your company or departments.

like

Leave

like

Go have the discussion and ask them to outline what they think is stopping you from having the pay rise in line with your peer(s).

That way a) you know the reasoning b) you have a way forward c) you went in with not just a demand but a conversation willing to explore d) you have then made them nail down some specifics - if you have those or go away and get those, then what excuse can they have left & e) you may just leave the meeting with a pay rise agreed rather than having to jump through hoops, if you can clearly demonstrate you are meeting requirements. Good luck!

like

Sounds like this is protected under pay discrimination if it is gender or other factor based and not based on experiance/education - totally worth it to bring up.

You are not being unreasonable! Know your worth!

Related Posts

What’ll the exact inhand salary??

Post Photo
like

Does this look like a good offer for a first time paralegal job? I'm in Ontario, Canada if that makes a difference.

like

Hi Fishes,
I got offers from Capgemini and HCL with the highest CTC in HCL. I negotiated with Capgemini and they matched the HCL offer.
Now HCL is ready to revise offer again.
Please suggest Is it good idea to take HCL offer now after negotiating with Capigemini.

As far as I heard HCL is having good projects in my domain.

like

Is $22.10/hr for Technical Support Specialist decent? Been with the company going on two years and have supported that particular department quite a few times. Currently sitting as an IT Tech and support general help desk and between tier 1 and 2 tickets. This will also be my highest paying job yet lol. Thanks in advance for any guidance!

like

Thinking of making a switch. How much should I ask for when interviewing for a GPS Advisory Manager I position?

What is the highest base salary percentage increase you’ve seen or heard of after performance year?
My situation is a C going for a SC

like

PwC Pricing and Profitability practice. Senior associate offer at $123k plus 15k sign on. Offering another 7.5k if I agree in 24 hrs. Any advice where I should land?

like

What are some negotiation scripts you people have used to negotiate a higher salary after the initial offer?

like

Starting the interview process with another company in industrials, and my current TC is ~$600k. Headhunter wants to chat about comp expectations - anyone have advice on how to approach? Is there a minimum bump people tend to shoot for before making the jump (e.g. 25%)? Trying to keep it clean and focus on annual TC, but plan to also communicate I expect to be made whole on my unvested RSUs . TIA!

funnylikehelpful

Solutions Architect with 20plus experience. 70/30 OTI is about 255k in the Washington DC area. Can I can make more elsewhere? Commision plan is favorable but just curious if I can get more just for 100% of quota.

like

Any Group Life & Disability Underwriters out there? Wondering what the salary range is for those with 5-10 years experience in the US. In your response could you please include what segment size you work with?

like

Has any companies given their employees good raises to help with the rising costs of everything? I was a top performer and only got around 3% this last year.

likehelpful

I need an opinion, which field is better in terms of compensation and work/ life balance , a sales producer or adjuster ??

like

Being on salary and in sales selling farm equipment, we are based on 40 hour pay week. M-F. Can your employer make you come in on Saturday’s?

like

Any thought on comp for a Valuations Sr Associate / VP with ~8 YOE at a mega fund?

like

Hello Fishes, what does grade 28 signifies in Optum. Wht is the salary range in this grade?

like

What was the salary hike for deputy manager and assistant manager this year?

like

What is the salary range for a newly promoted Partner in Deloitte Federal (S&O) including bonus potential?

like

ATL - How much does a senior consultant make at Deloitte? 2 YOE.

like

Hi Fishes,
I cleared LTI all rounds and in HR discussion we came on mutual agreement for 16lpa .I have 7 years of experience and they gave me Specialist - Data Engineering(P3) role. And we agreed I will join with after 60 as I had to serve 60 days notice period. I was waiting for offer letter and when I received the offer letter I was shocked to see that CTC mentioned was 14LPA and joining date was only 15days from now ,which is way early.
Continuing the POST (++)

like

More Posts

Unpopular opinion on flattening the curve: ok we all know we need to extend the tail at the end... how bout that tail at the beginning? I mean I'm in a midwest city where cases are hardly [cont]

likehelpful
like

American Airline q - if I have Gold status and an American Airlines credit card - does that mean I get two free checked bags or one

like

Deloitte field my application for AOS, EAD, and I-131 concurrently in November. The online status for AOS changed to “case is ready to be scheduled for an interview” over 2 weeks ago. How much longer

like

Any Sloan calls yet?

like

HELP!
I have raw sales data on one tab, which includes a sales rep ID number. My second tab has that sales rep ID number in column 1 and the rep name in column 2. How can I get the rep name added to the correct line items in the raw data?

Determining if I should buy an investment property to rent out and earn side income. For those who bought a house / condo / apartment as an investment, teach me your ways! Is it worth it?

like

I’m planning on getting my real estate license this spring! My biggest hesitation is that I currently live downtown Chicago and do not own a car. I really do not want to buy or lease a car as the area I live in requires a garage spot to park. Is it realistic to believe that I can be a real estate agent in Chicago if I rely on Uber/CTA?!

like

How is the work culture of BNP Paribas Bangalore Bagmane ? Do they offering work from home , what's the dressing style ,is it formal which needs to follow ?

like

Hey folks, anyone has experience doing case interviews for social impact? (Think Dalberg, Bridgespan, FSG). New to casing — anything I should look out for, any tips to prepare? Thank you!

like

What is one classic that you have substituted with a more cultural relevant text?

like

Is it possible to make a transition to VC (ideally senior associate / vp role) after a two year Associate stint in MM PE? I worry that the prior interest in moving late stage will be frowned upon by early stage investors among other issues

like

I have offers from,
Infosys 9.4L + 1L Joining Bonus,
IBM 11L + 1L Joining Bonus,
Oracle(OFSS) 12.5 + 75k Joining Bonus,
UST 13.5 + 1L Joining Bonus and
Cognizant 14.5L + 1L Joining Bonus

I'm a Java FSD, My Exp is 3.3 years and my CCTC is 4.6L + 80k variable

All the above are fixed pay, please guide me to pick the best company in terms of knowledge, career benefits, and all. And please advise, and can I negotiate between these companies with the highest offer?

like

Any advice on how to actually FIND a mentor? I’m a first-gen black girl trying to navigate this whole ~career~ thing by myself. I would love to meet someone that’s actually done this before to help 😩

likehelpful

I’m shooting for the moon and applying to jobs I am mentally ready for and can qualify for but my resume is very short sweet and to the point because I’ve worked at the same place for 6 year and climbed the ladder & wanting something new. How do I explain that to my future employer?

like

Hi Fishes,

I have applied for few open positions at EY which are related to my profile (Risk and Compliance), I am shortlisted for two profiles (as mentioned in Applied Jobs section) but haven't got any call from Talent acquisition team. Can someone please help me schedule a call for the same, will share the details in DM.

Thanks in advance

Hi IBM sharks 😊

So I joined IBM in May 2022 and was on bench for 5.5 months since then.I will be allocated to a project next week. Also my probation got confirmed a week back.

I have following queries-
1)With me joining a project so late, can I expect a Variable Pay in March 2023?
2)The manager told me I have flexibility to choose 2-11 shift or work in morning as everyone is flexible here. What must I do officially to get that monthly shift allowance?

Any inputs r highly appreciated guys 😊

like

Hi guys,
I have got offer letter from pwc sdc (bangalore) my joining date is 6 th june.
I have not recieved any confirmation regarding laptop delivery,Wfh or wfo.
I have asked from my HR so ge mentioned please be ready,You MAY need to work from office as per business requirements.
And my colleagues who have been hired through same process have got mail already regarding laptop delivery and wfh.
I am confused 😕

like

Anyone wanna refer me to KPMG or EY? Lol

like

Quoting yourself as if you just quoted some profound thought leader.

Post Photo
funnylike

Additional Posts in Finance

What are 3 things clients don't know about our services that would scare the shit out of them if they did?

like

Hypothetically what’s the shortest amount of time you should stay in a job without switching. I kinda wanna try my hand at a different industry but don’t wanna kill the experience I have now by leaving too early

like

I should probably know this, but are companies required to refinance their debt if they are acquired?

like

Have ou ever interacted with anyone in the C-suite at your firm?? What was it like?

like

NASA What is the salary range for JPL- Financial Analyst III?? @nasa@JPL

like

Any one have any advice on how to deal with lack of focus and concentration? Been having trouble concentrating the last 6 months and it's bringing me down.

like

Hi guys, I am working as an Investment Analyst for a boutique asset management firm in Toronto, Canada (4bn AUM) making 70k annually. I am 5 months into this role. Credentials: 6 months of prior experience in this industry at a small startup + 2 years of work exp in retail banking, CFA L2 candidate, part time masters of finance student, bachelors from outside of Canada. I want to find out if I’m being paid fairly or I should aim higher. I don’t know my bonus yet (discussion in Dec)

like

Trading stocks. Anyone notice hedgefunds going HAM with energy stock purchases since November 2021? These bank jobs aren’t about doing pivot tables for some bozo. It’s about looking at the data and conveying a message. Financial Forecasting. Try it. The answers to retirement is out there.

like

Knowing that I’m 50% tier in my level, how can I go up to the 75% or the higher end of my level? My manager says I’m a competitive hire but it’s not reflected in the comp. So I’m super confused

like

Best self-help books on the market? I've been consistently unhappy lately. Something needs to change.

like

North Korea - the boy (country) who cried wolf?

like

I freaking love wearing khakis

like

Who knows how to PM on this thing?

like

Poor Pats 😥

like

Cryptobros on suicide watch

like
like

We have a big project going on and I am the only point person(initiate it, did lot of work, and knows the deets well), seems like my mgr wants to get a headcount. But I want to use this opportunity to get promoted, how can I get this across? Mgr is new(they fired my old mgr), mgr’s mgr is new too(re-org). So not sure if I should/can make a case, or how.

like

That Friday feeling...

like

What would you say is an appropriate amount to gift a friend for his/her wedding? This isn't a close friend but someone I've known for a while

like

I realized a slow pace at work is really bad for me. A couple years ago I was experiencing burn out from my fast paced job supporting transactions, and believed by moving to a slower job in a lower cost area, I would be sailing off to the sunset. Wrong, I spend weeks following up with other teams, often times they forgot what we discussed, so I spent 50% if the time reminding them of the topics and next steps. I spend most of my time writing memos no one will read.

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal