I have two job offers for a design intern role at 2 top design agencies - one in SF, one in NYC.

SF job:
+ pays a lot more
+ tech clients (i want to be in tech after)
- wont sponsor visa
- strict NDA so i cant put in my portfolio

NYC job:
+ more interesting projects for my portfolio
+ product design role
+ will sponsor visa
- pays less

Considering rent in both cities, I feel $$ is a factor.

Should I tell NYC job about my other offer and negotiate salary? Any advice on how to approach?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

More interesting work and potential of getting hired beats higher pay. Money comes later. Pick work for now.

like

Depends how much that visa is worth to you tbh

like

I would say pick the job that allows you to put good work in your book. This is the time to do it and money will come later. Bring up the other offer and relocation situation (if there is), plus bring up your value as a designer and see if they can budge on pay if that’s a big factor

like

Negotiate salary with NYC. IMO, as an intern you should be looking to fill your book with professional work…BUT if you wanna be in tech, then SF is the spot to be

like

Makes no sense to me to do an internship and you won’t be able to put anything on your book. Unless, you just want the recommendations and an “in”…

like

I think for company A, it will really be more the client name. E.g Working on projects for Google/Meta etc. but not being able to add any case study in my portfolio due to nda whereas company B i can have more ownership but not 100% certain if client will be tech. I consider the tech exposure as i want to be in tech after this role

I would for sure bring up the salary and see what they say. Also pretty wild the pay difference is so drastic considering they have similar cost of living

like

It sounds like you have your answer in the SF one. But I know, the visa factor of the NYC one is tempting.

like

NYC definitely. The SF sounds like a death trap if you need a visa

like

Intern role? Always go with what you can put in your book. I would tighten my belt and take less money for the first five years of your career if it meant getting significantly better portfolio work.

That investment in yourself will pay much greater dividends later in your career. It can make a different in 50-100k as a design director or in whether or not you’re able to have a lucrative freelance career. Portfolio first, money will come.

like

NYC hands down

like

How can you work in SF if the company won’t sponsor your visa? Are you planning on getting your own lawyer? Do you know how much that will cost and how long it will take?

2K is not very much, esp if you’re getting paid 2K+ more at your sf job

like

Related Posts

With 6.5 Years of YOE how much I can expect from Cognizant for Senior Associate position?
Tech Stack : Informatica PC | IICS | Snowflake | Azure Cloud | Teradata | UNIX Scripting

like

Helo everyone,

I have put down the papers from infosys and my LWD is near . I have to choose between DXC with 22 LPA and TCS with 18 LPA . I am a mainframe developer with 11 years of experience.
I have asked TCS to revise the salary but that seems unlikely that they will match the difference.

I am a mainframe developer with 11 years of experience.

Please let me know your inputs .

likehelpful

Hi all, NEED REFERRAL in Accenture ⚠️
~ Analyst Roles ~

(Navi Mumbai or Mumbai office, priority in that order)

For more background I'm a Fresher with internship experiences in major startups.
Please help since I've been applying for jobs for over 4 months and no progress yet.

like

Will EY announce raises soon?

funnylike

I am looking to leave Deloitte but I have not been around long enough to satisfy my signing bonus. How do you bring up a signing bonus in negotiations with a new employer?

like

Hi,

What base salary could I expect for 13 years experience to work as Senior System Software Engineer?

like
like
like

I have 2 offer 1 from epam anywhere and other is from deloitte, which is better to join. Epam offering 17 fixed and Deloitte offering 15.75 fixed ( 2.5lakh variable). I am confused which one I should join

like

How much will I get in hand after tax deduction??

Need help.

PwC

Post Photo
like

How much Max CTC to expect from nagarro?
Yoe: 3.5
Skills: .net, .net core

TIA

like

LTI-Larsen & Toubro Infotech is Hiring
*DM your EMAILID with JOBID to Apply*
All LTI Location!!

Post Photo
like

How is the work life balance in Citi?

Here is the scenario: Have 2 offers from IT MNCs and 1 from Citi. Citi's offer is the highest. Almost 5 lakhs diff in the fixed component. Although money is important, but I am also seeking a little balance with life. I was previously in ZS Associates and to be frank, life was hell. I am not looking to relive that phase again.
What are the daily actual working hours?
Shall I join Citi or let go it for a lower package offer?

Seeking honest advice here.

likehelpful

I applied to EY in November through a referral and didn’t get selected. I’m applying again but this time just using the same account as I applied with last time. Will the system move up my app because it’s still within one year of getting a referral?

like
like

How much does an entry level Sourcing Specialist earn per year?

like
like
like

Would anyone in a product analyst role at Visa or senior product role be open to chatting? Looking to pivot into payments industry from financial services and would love to get a better sense of product

like

More Posts

How do I calculate customer lifetime value at a company that is new and hasn’t experienced much churn?

like

Does anyone have a referral for Rancho Biosciences?

like

Do wheelchair-accessible apartments (i.e with an elevator) exist in mid-Cambridge / Central / Harvard / Porter / Kendall? Seems like everything in the area is a walk-up

like

Do we have managerial round in LTI or only L1 and L2

like

“The shaft is not always welcome, but but hole always is.”

likefunny

If FIS retains an employee with a new salary in November/December....do they consider you for Yearly Appraisal ?

like

I need to rent a car and drive from NY to PA. Any Cody effective recommendations?

like

Anyone work in Global Mobility at Grant Thornton? How does it compare to big four?

like

Hi everyone... Does anyone have referrals for Oracle apps DBA in UK/EU region? Please help.

like

Is anyone interested in subleasing a 2bd/br apartment (unfurnished) in South Austin May-August? It’s right next to Lady bird lake, pet/handicap friendly. $1903 a month.

like

I am beyond stuck in my first 1.5 years of my career.

I was over promised opportunities at my first gig and then Covid hit. Leading me to have no portfolio worthy pieces from this 💩 agency with nothing great in sight. (place hasn’t won a pitch in my entire time here + lost clients)

I’m juggling re-vamping my site and a side project to hopefully make my book more robust.

With no kind of leadership or mentor, I’m just figuring out how to dig myself out of this hole. Any advice for this chump?

like

Is it possible to order chair, monitor from barclays. Are they still giving those items?

like

Hi guys. Has anyone attended the @Autodesk frontend interview? How was your experience?

Guys, If salary & all perks are equal then which place is best for job working.
Ahmedabad or Goa, in terms of living, quality life, opportunities etc.

Please sincere replies.

like
like

Moving from the US to Singapore soon. On a 90k salary, how much should I budget for rent? Ideally I want to live in neighborhoods close to central locations such as Tanjong Pagar, but I’m not sure if it’s possible.

like

Is there anyone who is into market research ?

Starting a new job in Pyrmont in January. Where should I live? I'm a single female in my early 30s, looking for 1BR ~$500/w. Ideally somewhere near the water/beaches.

Been doing some research and Pyrmont is a pain to get to. I'm new to Sydney so any advice is much appreciated!

like

Is it mean to feed my Midwestern American in-laws' kangaroo meat when they come to visit? ...Without telling them what it is first?

like

Anyone else been impacted by the teacher strikes?

like

Additional Posts in Creatives

Alright y’all.. I started a new job about 3 months ago and I have basically hit the ground running. I’m kind of new to my industry (SEO) and my team is INCREDIBLY smart! continued...

like

I’m a Sr AD about to step into an ACD role. This will be my first time being direct report to creatives and being involved in briefing process. Any tips on how to be an awesome direct report? How does a creative successfully contribute to a brief? Please, teach me your ways.

like

Did anyone else watch the One Show special awards ceremony earlier? Did you also find it irritating?

like

How long do you give your juniors to settle into their new roles before considering letting them go?

like

How hard is it to get a job in another country? There’s a bunch of international agencies I admire, but I don’t know anyone who’s searched for an international job.

like

Do you present a creative treatment when you pitch a brand campaign idea?

like

ok so you actually really like your current shop, good brands, work life balance, clear progression (believe it or not?!)

Then you get approached by a place a lot of people on this app see as one of the best in the biz

What do you do? Stick or twist…

like

What's the over/under on the number of people who post the aviation gin peloton woman ad?

I think we're at about 6 already...

like

Nike picking Colin Kaepernick as the face of your campaign is questionable at best. Why choose someone so divisive when you have so many other athletes that are more broadly viewed favorably?

funny

What’s the worst review experience you’ve had?

like

Dear CDs and ecds who give all the good projects to your favs, know that we all see you and your favs will be the first to leave because you stacked their books too fast. Love, everyone else.

likesmart

Has anyone ever decided to work part time? If so how did it work

like

Thoughts on Bo Burnham's Inside? It's honestly depressing not only in content but also to see one person create something so amazing just on their own. Here I am struggling just to make an alright ad, meanwhile I should probably just forget ads and actually make something decent instead. Sigh.

like

Ever look at your CD (/ECD/CCO) and wonder how the hell they made it there?

likefunny

Can anyone explain why agencies seem to favor hiring a ton of freelance people over full time creatives? I can’t imagine it’s cheaper than paying someone a salary.

like

Any good packaging places in NY? I’m looking for more packaging focused than branding so not JKR, elm wood etc

like

Is it bad or is there a polite way to ask an agency to see their work when they haven’t updated their site for a few years, during an interview?

like
like

For creatives who work at PR agencies, what’s the work like? And how is it different from an advertising agency?

like

Does your company pay for parking (if they don’t have a designated lot)? If no, do you believe they should they pay for it? Thoughts on this?

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal