If my goal is m7 MBA->MBB, should I work for a no-name IB or a lower tier MC?

I am heading towards a Tier 3+ consulting firm (think Capgemini, Guidehouse, Huron, etc.) this summer after graduation.

A boutique IB (~20 ppl, small trans. size but good deal flow) recently reached out for an interview. They rejected me last fall but now want to hire more analyst. IB comp is def much higher.
I had IB internship before, but recruited for management consulting for traveling and broader experience.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Don’t make a decision solely in the bubble of getting an mba.

like

I was thinking about the same thing until I realized that I need an opportunity for a better career trajectory. My undergrad college was okay but I wasted lots of opportunities. Now I want to use MBA to pivot towards a more desirable future.

like

Agree with EY. Without knowing anything else, the bank seems like better experience to me. Good deal flow is likely to turn into good experience, and in my experience, it’s a lot easier to get stretch experiences at a small firm. I don’t think Capgemini, for example, is really that great of work experience though experiences will likely vary a lot

like

Thank you for your advice. I think your point makes sense. Ad com probably don’t care about who the client is - might be multi billion global firm if I work in MC, might be series-B company if I work in boutique IB.

IB experience will look better than T3 Consulting experience to AdCom if you’re solely making a choice based on MBA

like

Disagree. There’s a ton of tiny no name boutique IBs. Even T3 consulting probably has better exit ops. I’d suggest OP do consulting for 2 years and exit to a strategy type role at a more well known company before applying.

like

Agree with the answer above. If you’re more excited about consulting and enjoyed the teams you met, take the consulting offer. If you didn’t, take IB. Think about what skills and experiences you’ll gain rather than name brand.

like

Consultant 1 has a good answer.

Whatever gets you solid strategy consulting experience. I would look for boutique strategy firms that deal with growth strategy.

like

If you’re working towards an MBA as your next goal and will make a decision solely based on that, think about which experience will give you more leadership fodder for resume, essays, and interviews.

Related Posts

How easy internal mobility in Atlassian India for EMs if they don’t like work in the team?

Hi fishes,
I finished my B.E (CSE) this year. Working in TCS since 6 months on a CRM Project. CTC : 7LPA (I also had offer at Accenture for 6.5LPA)

- I know basics of many languages/ technologies : C, C++, Java, Python, HTML, CSS, Javascript, React, Azure

- Basic level Problem Solving, DSA, OOP

I am a quick learner. I am currently learning DSA using C++ & Azure.

Can anyone in Hyderabad hire me for a better package at a company where I can work in development or Cloud Role?

Thanks

like

What is typical salary for M1 - Accenture Strategy ?

like

What designation i can expect iat Capgemini of joining as a Lateral?

I have total 11.5 YoE

like

Any AVP from CCB operations here? What is your CTC in JPMC?

like

How much max ctc can be asked for in QA manager post ?

like

How much salary should I ask from CTS ? I have total 4.4 year of experience in full stack development in dot net core and current CTC is 13 lpa ?

Hi Fishes

I joined
IBM now Kyndryl back in Oct 2020, I have completed my mandatory trainings supporting an account and also cleared Rhythm Level but didn't got any increment yet.

What do now?
Anyone from Kyndryl knows about this thing like when we are supposed to get increment?

McKinsey & Company Any advice to help prepare for data science analyst role at top consulting firms (McKinsey & Company EY Boston Consulting Group etc)? Any materials, open source platform recommended to take on freelance data science project? When should I start actively looking and applying? I am a new grad who is working in tech as a marketing analyst I’m looking to pivot to marketing& sales data science consulting next year. Would like someone with similar backgrounds offer some practical tips.

like

How much does an entry level Sourcing Specialist earn per year?

like

Does anyone know the compensation for a senior analyst at McKinsey with a Master degree and 2 YOE? Looking for base pay and bonus.

like

Hey there!

I got offers from Accenture with 6 LPA + Variable pay and from PWC with 7 LPA + Variable pay (Screenshot below). I would like to join acccenture but the amount seems very less. I have 2.3 years of experience. Should I negotiate with accenture? Please give me some expert opinion.

Post Photo
like

How does base compensation vary across the accounting advisory roles in big 4? PWC CMAAS, EY FAAS, KPMG AAS, DT advisory. Specifically for senior managers.

like

Going to Wharton in the fall. Is it worth going MBB over returning to big 4 (sponsored)? Is this a common path?

like

I am new joinee,Still unallocated.Can i get first month salary ?

like

Hi Folks, salary credited?

like

Does anyone have any career insight for a tax associate in corp dev? Is it as lucrative as regular corp dev? What do you do on a day-to-day basis?

like

How much does a McKinsey 1 st year partner make?

like

Hello everyone,

I love in Europe and was wondering how difficult or easy getting remote front end position in a US company would be and if the salary would be the same as a US citizen who lives in the US?

like

S&P Global what is the salary of a 9A grade employee with role Quality Engineer II in S&P Global?

like

More Posts

What does it mean when a partner gives associates, especially junior associates, origination credit? Practically, I don't think it makes a difference except maybe for bonuses, but I'm wondering if there's any deeper meaning than extending gratitude?

like

Can we get rid of the “formerly Booz & Co” tag on this bowl?

I mean, seriously, Strategy& has been around longer than Booz & Co at this point…

like

I joined an agency about 2 months ago and every single day I get more responsibilities, to the point that I don't even know what my actual job title is. I'm frustrated, to say the least.

like

Anyone interested in below Job profile, please share your email I'd.

Post Photo
like

What are the technical rounds for UI - Angular Developer in EPAM ?. How is the difficulty level?
Experience: 8 Years

like

Hi fishes. I am a third year and I was extended an offer to lateral to an Amlaw 100 firm, but as a second year. Is this common? I am coming from a specialty firm with four offices nationwide with a good reputation in our field. The lateral position is in the same field. Thank you!

like

The basis of my bitcoin investing thesis

Post Photo
likefunny

What salary would you feel comfortable buying a $100k car? Trying to gauge how bad of a decision that would be…

like

Is it wise to go to my company’s competitor for a promotion and risk burning a bridge?

For context, my small company was suddenly bought out by a large corp. I was about to get promoted to leadership but the new company doesn’t want to honor the title/salary increase we worked out. We only have one significant competitor in our industry, and it’s likely my best option. Love my company, been with them for years, but I’m really struggling with how frustrating this situation is.

like

Has anyone here got relocation bonus from CitiusTech?
Can you please tell how much amount you got?

like

Fishes, Please let me know if there are any openings for Analyst Relationship Management.

Feel free to reach out to me if you want a referral for TikTok! Happy to help

like

I have a 760 gmat but think I am capable of better, all of my practice exams were higher. Should I? I am not humble bragging so serious replies only please 🙏🏻

funnylike

Have y’all ever heard a COMPANY giving an employee 30 days notice and after those 30 days an employee is no longer with the company?

likefunny

Queen has a cameo in the latest promo spot for Paddington 3. 📺

Post Photo
like

today my joining in Hexaware Technologies but still they not send revised offer and onboarding mail

they told today will sent

what should i do now?

like

If anyone is interested in a referral to EY, I can help.

like

Hello Team, Could you please let me know, how much salary will be sufficient to live in malaysia with family.

How much salary can we expect for 10yrs of experience.

Additional Posts in MBA Applicants

Solid background and thinking of a dual MBA/MS degree at H/S. Class of ‘19 — worth applying R2 or wait a year? Didn’t get in the H/S deferral program in 2019 and heard this year is quite competitive.

like

Prior to applying, on average how many current students, alumni, or adcom members did you connect with from each program?

like

Do schools ever admit applicants without interviewing? I didn’t get invited to interview at SOM/Darden — does that mean it’ll 100% be a rejection?...

like

Going to Wharton in the fall. Is it worth going MBB over returning to big 4 (sponsored)? Is this a common path?

like

How much does work experience impact your chances for MBA? Currently in a PMO function and the point of getting an MBA is to exit out lol

funny

How hard is Haas to get into?

like

Any Consortium R1 applicant to CBS or Stern heard about interviews yet?

like

Use savings to (partially) pay for business school or invest and fully cover via loans?

like

Kellogg results thread here!

like

What are my chances at M7?

White male, 3.6 GPA at top public school (like UVA), 700 GMAT, 3.5 years work experience (2y in big 4 MC, 1.5y in corp dev), letter of rec from HBS grad CFO of my company.

like

Got into Stern’s Jan 2020 EMBA intake but want to give a shot to Wharton and Columbia too whose results are not going to be out until Feb. what are my options, friends?

Anyone from EY consulting get into H/S/W?

like

Does anyone have a helpful recommenders guide I could give to my recommenders?

like

HBS interview in 1 hour - tie or no tie?

like

Princeton Review for GMAT/GRE prep, good or bad?

like

Anybody else fell uneasy after their Sloan interview? Felt like she asked me three variations of the same question expecting a different example for each which also had to be different from everything I talked about in my application 😞

like

Campus visit (non interview) says to wear business casual. Jeans and dress shirt tucked ok?

like

Anyone start a new relationship before business school started? How did it work out?

likefunny

Can I get into m7 with a 3.5 gpa and 3 YOE at a T2 and tech startup - not a URM or have any hooks

like

My manager asked me to help sprint this proposal. I’m out in 6 weeks. How do I kindly tell him to GTFO

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal