I’m deciding between two in-house roles and would appreciate any insight from those who have made similar transitions.

Option 1: Associate General Counsel at a private company, focused on collections, litigation, and compliance. It offers a strong legal title but has little structure, requires five days in-office, and is farther from home.

Option 2: Claims role at an insurance company, handling coverage and risk assessment. offers better work-life balance with only two days in-office.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Based on the description of Option 1, all else being equal, it doesn’t seem like Option 1 is attractive. If the only upside is the title, I would take Option 2. As a general matter, titles are less important vs. the substance of what you’re doing since AGC at one company is not the same as AGC at another despite what the title may imply.

like

Option 2

like

Honestly, Option 1 will look better on paper, so if you ever need to jump ship, you can jump into similar roles. That may be worth the hassle for 1-2 years and then switch to another role.

likesmart

These seem like wildly different jobs! The second doesn’t even sounds like it’s an attorney role (which is fine).
What exactly do you want to do for a living?
Do you want to be a corporate attorney with a fancy title and (presumably) a nice office you’ll spend every day commuting to? If so…Option 1
Do you want to do solid work with a less fancy title and enjoy your life outside of the office? If so…Option 2

like

Thank you for this I am strongly leaning towards two because option one is not a nice office at all it’s in a factory where they handle food shipping and I don’t think I’ll have work life balance the number one reason I left law firm life was for work life balance. I think I’m getting more comfortable with option 2. Maybe do option 2 and a part time legal job. Idk I’m still trying to figure it out

like

Is there a big pay difference between the two?

No

Second option. You could be doing the least legal work you’ve ever done in your life with Option one with what seems like little infrastructure and resources.

Option 1 for 1-2 years and jump ship if it isn’t working out. This option seems better for resume building to get the job you ultimately want.

Related Posts

Anybody work for CVS Heath/Atnea in a case management/ UM position? Thoughts good and bad.. pay work environment? All info I’d appreciated!

likesmart

Please tell me how is insurance vertical in coforge@

like

Deloitte experienced hires, who all received written offers and in process of visa/ onboarding, have you heard back anything about hiring freeze? Or recruiter asked you to delay joining date?

My visa got submitted couple of days back and waiting for decision. When I reached out to recruiter to give her an update and mentioned once there’s decision will discuss on the start date before putting my 2 weeks, she mentioned “Yes, we should talk before you put notice” - Am I overthinking? Deloitte

like

Hey ,I applied 3 weeks ago to Bank of America USA ,with a decent resume and referral. But still did not heard back.Need a human eye who is willing to check my application and help me moving to the next step? Bank of America USA. I'm based in NY.

likehelpful

I recieved an offer from barclays as a process advisor. ( BA2) Can someone tell me is the work hectic for that role in barclays?
And what are the growth chances in this role within the company?

likesmart

Hi, I got selected in S&P. Hr gave me an link to apply for some position but I am not able to do login to that link

Facing issue like user name doesn't exist in tenant s&p global.

Did anyone face the same, if yes could you please help me on that.

Any openings for a CA , with 4 years of experience in CFO advisory services, current ctc is 10 lpa, looking for a switch to KGS similar profile or some other department ( Corporate Finance, FPnA etc), any leads would be appreciated

like

I just applied for a Delta flight attendant role and my page glitched right in the middle of my application and now it says I’ve applied even though I didn’t finish answering questions. Has anyone else had this happen? So scared it has completely ruined my chances.

like
like
like

Have an offer to move from senior associate to NEP role at insurance defense (toxic tort mainly) firm in Chicago. Base salary $175,000 - fair base compensation in current market or below market value?

like

Hi All.
I am looking for Salesforce Functional BA roles in Accenture. I am currently working with Persistent Systems. Please let me know if there are any relevant openings.

Hi All,

Kindly help me in resolving the dilemma

MBA with Total YOE - 7+, relevant YOE- 5.3 , Skills - CYBERSECURITY,GRC, Audit.

I have got two offers
1. Genpact - 27 CTC (24 fixed + 10% variable plus gratuity) Manager level
2. Airbus - 23 CTC + 5 L JB
I really wanted to work with Airbus but they are not budging from the offer of 23 even after I told them I have a better offer from Genpact with better position. HR said they will come back..

You think Airbus will come back with better offer?

like

I'm hiring soon for a clinical pharmacist roles to do prior authorizations from home. It's state programs and mainly 9 to 5. What should the compensation be? It'll include 3 weeks vacation and all holidays off btw.

like

Hi fishes,
If anyone need referral at Thomson Reuters
DM me with req Id
Happy to help.

like

On the news, there was a report that "stress" causes negative health effects. Um. OK. Don't people feel "stress" just by being alive? Like, what would be the control group that you could measure the results against? I don't know why, but it always makes me wonder

like

Any insights on Cloud consultant role in GCP PSO in terms of project pipeline, growth opps , wlb , etc.

like

Hi Fishes,
Any CA openings, apart from big 4s. Kindly help with referrals, already serving np in Deloitte USI.
YoE is >2years.
Thanks.

like

Google Hey I am finishing up 3rd round of google interviews, for software engineer position, does anyone know what the offer is for NYC? I have 2.5 YOE.

like

More Posts

What is the most number of documents you’ve filed at once using Federal ECF? I had reason to look back today, and my record exceeds 170. Reaching that “filing submitted” page is a core memory at this point, but I’m sure it’s not that uncommon?

like

Hello Fishes,
@Mindtree,
After CTC discussion with HR,she said she sent for approval.
Still no update from her end.
How much time it may take to get her back,as i have resigned in advance.
Resignation was based on technical rounds clearance confirmation and also due to headache for shortage of calls,for 90 days NP.

like

Hi everyone,

I have 3 years of experience in developing apps/microservices using Java, spring boot, spring security, spring cloud, Google cloud platform, docker, kubernetes, MERN stack and Vue Js. How much can I expect based on above tech skills and my experience?
My current CTC is 6lpa.

Thanks.

like

So who here visited the Chicago Yacht Club at Open House Chicago and decided they wanted to grow up to be an old white guy? 🙋🏻

like

Recommendations for books and podcasts on business, strategy, management, etc. that have helped your career?

like

Hi , need likes for DM Feature , Thank you.

like

Uh this could get bad fast if this holds through open. Protect your downside if not already.

like

Hi..
I'm looking for job change.
YOE - 3 years.
Please help.

like

Anyway to get GSAP approved before your eligibility? They changed the eligibility to 2 years of working prior GSAP to 3...

like

How do I invest in Secure Gold Bonds? Any reliable procedural steps or blogs or videos available?

like

Alvarez & Marsal Any 🏳️‍🌈 🐠 that have worked at Alvarez & Marsal? I’ve got an offer for the PEPI group and would love to hear any insights.

like

28M in NYC area. Chat with me

30 M, Based out of Midwest, looking for someone interesting to talk and then let that talk decide next

like
like

Hi Fishes,

Need your suggestion. I have given an interview in EXL for Senior Business Analyst role and been shortlisted. Could you all please suggest how much should I expect and ask.

YOE :- 4 Years and 9 Months
Skills :- SQL, Power BI, Tableau
CCTC :- 5.25 lakh

like

How to stop customer service from ruining your day?

like

Writing a report for the first time and feel way in over my head. Team didn’t discuss what adjustments we want as a group before divvying up—new transfers what has been your experience?

Non-eng... Got past the hiring committee! 🥳 does anyone know the process from now? And how long it typically takes? Thanks !

like

Additional Posts in Attorneys of Color

I handleda very difficult and convoluted succession for a black family. My client was astute and intelligent. We got along great. His family was difficult. Willfully ignorant.

Part of the succession dealt with clawing back $450,000 in insurance proceeds that a niece fraudulent received from the decedent by making herself the beneficiary on policies. A separate attorney was hired to handle that part before I was hired to handle all other matters, including settling a $500,000 debt with the...

like

Anyone in this bowl based in Central Florida that would like to connect?

like

how does anyone actually bill 8.5 hours a day?? Even on my most productive days I can only hit 6, 6.5.

like

Starting at a new firm, What can I do to leave a good first impression?

like
like

Okay so I’m a newly licensed attorney in a very conservative part of TX. I just got my first job offer and I was worried at first thinking that I was in “Trump” territory, but I tested the waters in my interview and spoke about police injustices and how prosecutor’s job is not only to protect victims, but also defendants from police injustices. I have to let them know by tomorrow, but thoughts on if this is a good career move for someone who wants to work in transactional work-RE or Bankruptcy?

like

I saw that Orrick had an Attorney's of Color retreat in New York. Does anyone work there who can speak on how it was? If not, is there a retreat/coalition/group for Attorney's of Color at your firm?

like

Roo to my bruhs. Happy founders day

Post Photo
like

Anybody having to participate in/listen to discussions at work regarding the recent events at the Capitol where your views are in contrast to others in the discussion? If so, how have you handled this?

like

What's your typical work day look like? Where do you work/what size firm do you work at?

like

Might be a silly question but I will throw it out there. Anyone have any tips on best practices to preserve a silk press overnight? Currently have silk pillowcases but wrapping always ends up a fail.

likehelpful

Hey all, I’m starting a new job soon (in 2 weeks to be exact), but I haven’t been contacted by the firm. Should I be concerned?

like

Thinking of pivoting from insurance defense to something more meaningful and (dare I say it) with more work life balance. Currently in my 7th year of practice and am just tired of ID. Anyone make the transition? Any advice?

like

Ketanji did not come to play! Came out of the gate ready to fight and turn these racist arguments on their heads. The way she was dropping 14th Amendment bombs on that man made me so happy. And this is only her first day. I just hope they protect her well.

likeuplifting

I feel like I'm going through really bad imposter syndrome, How do you manage it ?

like

Does anyone feel like it’s difficult to gain acceptance and find allies when you’re a POC? I have attended happy hours, social events, and lunches, but I am not getting the same amount of traction as the other new lawyers who are white. Don’t know whether I should keep trying or just give up. Also don’t know whether it’s my personality or people at the firm. 😢

like

With all that is going on, has anyone seen any positive changes in their organization?

like

Any one here based out in the Middle East? If so, what's your experience. Would you recommend it. I am 32F - African Descent planning to relocate to the UAE.

like

How do I professionally decline a second interview? I know for sure I don’t want to work at the firm.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal