In the interview process at this creative agency I’m excited about, but they mentioned having to fulfill a small project brief in the final round of interviews. Suddenly it’s a huge turn-off for me.
I don’t know anyone personally who has done a project before getting hired. But working for free feels icky, even just brainstorming. Any positive experiences here?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I did it twice and got the job both times. Both times it was brainstorming for a made up brand. It basically depends on how bad you want the job. If it's a place you really want to work I say go for it, if not pass.

likehelpful

This is correct.

I did it once, but got paid an hourly freelance rate. I think no matter what if feels icky.

likehelpful

I may inquire about potential compensation if I get to that step!

I did it once, got hired based on it. It’s annoying but it got me the job and I got out of a place I had been wanting to leave.

helpful

Ask about the expectations on time you should spend on it. I think 1 hour or so is okay. But like a serious assignment with real deliverables that takes 4-8 hours you should share your hourly freelance rate.

Years ago I did one, took about 1 hour, it was a piece of cake and got the job.

like

They got back to me that it is paid! Don’t know why they didn’t mention it up front, though!

like

Related Posts

I’m interviewing for a start up and the role sounds interesting. Usually for the “test” part of the interview I’ve had to analyze data. This company wants me to develop a growth strategy that outlines key initiatives for growth, different opportunities, experiments I’d run, KPIs, and working cross-functionally.

Is this a lot for an interview?

I’m a little afraid of doing all this work to then just have them take my ideas and not hire me.

like

After 3 rounds of Apple interviews, recruiter has requested a call. Do we think it’s more likely a rejection or an offer?

like

What's the bench policy at IBM ? For how long one can stay in bench.? How much time it will take generally to get the project/assignment. IBM Tata Consultancy

like
likehelpful

I am appearing for an interview next week for .Net profile. What should I expect in the interview Resume based questions or DS and Algo related questions?

Hi All,

My profile was shortlisted approximately 2 weeks ago and I had my HR discussion. They have been telling that my profile has been sent for approval from Business team. Till yesterday, my profile status was "shortlisted" but now it is showing "parked". Any idea what does it mean ? Can I expect an offer letter from Mindtree and if yes, how long does it take generally ? Mindtree

Turned on the "open to work" flag on LinkedIn and the recruiter messages have already increased in quality & quantity after one day. Highly recommend.

likehelpful

Any tips on how to get started on prepping for VC interviews

like

Just had a phone screen today for the Account Strategist role. The recruiter said that the target level is l3 or l4 (I have 5+ yoe in performance marketing). Should I push for l4? Additionally, how long does it usually take before I hear back from the recruiter. Thank you!

like

What is the best way to transition from radiology to healthcare project management? Thank you

like

To HBS admits - any of you thought you didn’t interview well but managed to salvage through the post-interview reflection essay?

like

I JUST LANDED A PHONE INTERVIEW WITH GOOGLE!!! can I get some google phone interview tips, advice, etc.? (Forever grateful) 🙏🏾

like

I’ve been trying to get into The Walt Disney Company for years and can’t seem to make any progress. I’ve tried introducing myself and connecting with recruiters on LinkedIn and of course, applying to jobs on their site. Would anyone happen to have any words of advice for someone trying to transition from the ad industry into the entertainment industry?

like

I’m in the process of interviewing for an associate position at biglaw. They sent me a form asking what my class year is with regards to my current position. My current position is at a law firm, but I’m a staff attorney and not an associate and I’ve never been classified by class year. Any idea what to fill in here?

like

Currently interviewing for a remote account manager position with USI Insurance in NC. I have over 20 years experience in personal lines as an agent. Can anyone provide insight as to the average pay for this position?

like

Any tips on recruiters in Tokyo? I’m finding it hard to come across someone

Hi All,
Does any know more details on AM PPM role(HRST) at Deloitte.I got an interview call.requesting valuable insights and support please.

like

Anyone have tips on writing a cover letter without referring to anything in the resume?

like

Hello there. I have been interviewing with Okta and got through all 5 rounds of interviews. They say they want to offer me the job but there is a global freeze for all marketing roles at the company. They want to offer me a contractor role instead. Does anyone here know if that is the case? I haven't heard anything as they seem be on wellness week. Thanks for any guidance :)

like

I am interviewing for nCino as a entry level Support Engineer. They ask for 2 years experience in the financial services industry and knowledge of Salesforce. I have over 1 year experience in the financial industry and 2 years working with Salesforce. I live in Louisiana and it's Remote. What salary should I be aiming for? Total compensation also if you can! What do other Support Engineer get paid

like

More Posts

Is 19LPA for 3.5 YoE - Full Stack developer is good?
Should I look for long term at Nagarro?

helpful

Is it normal for a company to directly share offer letter to sign without me accepting verbally, they know I have competing offer.

like

Does this benefit cover procedures such as freezing eggs?

like

Thoughts on brk.b for long term? Thinking of getting in at this point.

like

Is it financially irresponsible to buy a home that requires you to divert what you’re currently saving / investing monthly to pay the mortgage?

like

I’ve found it very hard to order with my team and still be keto with the places we decide on. What are some common substitutions or adjustments y’all make when ordering?

Anyone wants go for drinks in the evening? New to SF and would like to explore new bars and clubs.

like

Anyone put on administrative processing when applying for a b1/b2?

I am an experienced hire. My case might just take you by surprise. I joined EY GDS 10 months back at 40% hike (leaving PwC) and now Deloitte (DIJV) is offering me 2 level up designation at Manager level with another 40% hike. This has effectively doubled my salary in the last one year bt still I am confused to switch or not considering the amazing bonuses GDS payed off today. Please suggest.

like

I know Trump supporters on here are too embarrassed to side with him on here regarding “stop the count”, “voter fraud” etc. hence the silence.. I hope you can now see him for who he really is 🤡

like

Still using Ally Bank savings account, but the APY had dropped to .60%. Time to move. Any recs on personal savings account? This is my emergency “savings”

like

Today the cash register broke down while a customer was waiting with 4 pallets of Monster. He yelled at me.

like

Is it safe to order from flipkart ?

like

My boss is always making last minute changes to my schedule. Adding shifts or asking me to cover for other people. Any advice on how to handle this? I want to be a team player but the last minute changes stress me out.

like

Looking for a 1 bed in sf for a couple weeks any time in july/august

Those who recently joined ARA how was the transition? Any advise on what I can look/research on now to help on my first couple of assignments?

like
like

How does a panel interview feel like? Is there anything that I should be prepare for it? Any tips?

like

Had my 2nd interview with the hiring manager this past Friday & sent a thank you shortly after. It's now Tuesday (for those who see this on another day). At the end of the interview he said they've had other people who were interested but only one other person besides me were they considering. Said he would talk to his team and possibly have me fly out to meet in person. How long should I wait to follow up without seeming pushy? Also welcome any other tips to separate me from other candidate.

Additional Posts in Creatives

Curious to know how closely you (creatives) work with your strategy/ planning counterparts. What is the dynamic you share?

like

What other creative outlets do you have outside of your job? Not necessarily side hustles, might just be something you do just for fun or creative nourishment?

like

Creatives that use PowerPoint disgust me that is all have a good day.

likefunny

What advice do you have for someone who wants to make a quick and seamless transition from operations to creative?

Serious question time:
Do you have everyday work (banner ads, generic social, microsites, brochures, etc) in your portfolios and what's your stance on this?

I came across a copywriter position that I’m interested in, but one of the requirements is 8 years of experience. I’m currently just over 5 years. Would it be ok to still apply?

like

Anyone want to work for us in our chicago office and make me some referral money?

We’re looking for ACD’s, seniors, and a mid-level writer. Send me a DM with your book(s) and i’ll refer you.

likeuplifting

Did anyone else watch the One Show special awards ceremony earlier? Did you also find it irritating?

like

Nike picking Colin Kaepernick as the face of your campaign is questionable at best. Why choose someone so divisive when you have so many other athletes that are more broadly viewed favorably?

funny

When sending a cold email to a recruiter, should you include a reason why you’re interested in the agency? Or keep it short and sweet with your book, resume and what you’re looking for?

Raukten covers Rocket Man. Smh. I feel bad for Elton John.

like

What we really need to know is, which clients are yet to have their brand logos dissected and distanced.

like

The lack of honesty in this industry saddens me. Dear CDs and ECDs, if you're gonna put work in your book that you barely touched/had nothing to do with, at least credit those who came up with it.

like

Who made the Apple video that everybody is gushing about? Elephant or Apple In-house? I’m too cheap to pay for Ad Week so I didn’t see the credits. Congra to the writer. You won advertising this week.

like

If you have previously declined an offer from an agency, how long should you wait before applying there again - if ever?

like

Any other copywriters write on their phone when the computer seems too daunting?

like

Can anyone explain why agencies seem to favor hiring a ton of freelance people over full time creatives? I can’t imagine it’s cheaper than paying someone a salary.

like

Anyone know of any good portfolio programs in the Seattle area?

Ever look at your CD (/ECD/CCO) and wonder how the hell they made it there?

likefunny

I feel like 80% of my job is producing. Is this normal, or am I just working with shitty producers?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal