Is it possible to have multiple interviews at an agency and for them to turn you down because they think your portfolio isn't strong? Or does interviewing mean they already approve of your book?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Sometimes CDs pre screen. Other times they don’t. Often they won’t dig deep and use the interview to see what you actually did in the work . You wouldn’t believe how much fraud or extreme stretches you see.

“Oh yeah, that Grand Prix TV campaign, I was in the room when it was pitched by another team but I wrote the tweet for the CMO that mentioned it, so I was involved. ”

Actually happened.

likefunny

holy shit🤢

Don’t recruiters always share the book with the hiring CDs before inviting someone to interview? I always thought that’s what got someone an in-person interview.

like

OP- Most people don’t get hired on the quality of their book alone. I’d be willing to overlook some areas of a portfolio if someone could sell me on their potential and hunger to learn.

That being said, someone could have an immaculate portfolio but bomb the interview and I might not hire them.

You need to be selling yourself, your projects and your knowledge of the agency at every step of the interview process.

like

It means that whoever is the gatekeeper for starting the interview process i.e. recruiting thought your book was strong enough to bring in. But it doesn’t mean the Creatives on staff will agree.

like

That might genuinely be that they’re struggling to release the budget for it. If the CD/ECD doesn’t like your book, they’re not going to keep conversations open. They’re gonna shut it down.

I find it hard to believe that your book wasn’t approved before bringing you in. It would be a waste of your time as well as those interviewing you. However, it’s possible that the agency had stronger candidates for the position. If true, then that should had been the feedback to you vs your portfolio isn’t strong.

like

Interviewing is how they find out if they like you as a person.

like

Related Posts

Hi Fishes,

I got offer Letter from infosys 2.5 months back, now when I am trying to decline the offer by sending a mail to HR, it was not getting delivered as HR left the organisation 1 month back, I forwarded mail to feedback team of infosys but still got the mail from onboarding team with joining details and WebEx link, kindly suggest how to proceed in this case.

funny

Do any of you follow your career center’s resume template/ guide in terms of formatting or do you use something else?

like

How much of your gig is spent interviewing candidates? I feel like that’s a solid 30% of my role these days.

like

Hi People at KPMG Canada. I have applied for entry level consulting position with Technology, Strategy and Digital Transformation. I have my first round interview in a couple of days. The interview is 30 minutes behavioural and 30 minutes case interviews. Kindly provide me with any tips or suggestions. TIA 🙏

like

Hi,
If I get referred at
IBM, get a mail for details from the HR but do not reply as I currently don't want to switch because of some reasons, can I get referred again after say 3 months?
Asking cuz the profile blocks for an year after applying/getting referred at Accenture.
Please help with the answer.
IBM

like

Can I ask any of you that have experience with resume to take a look at mine? I need some work on it. My background is a mechanical engineer getting a master in PM.

Post Photo
like

We Indians are so poor we can't think anything else except money. Whole Fishbowl is all about YOe and Salary. No one interested about if any company doing any innovation or not. B-Tech colleges put ads with Package and Campusing only. Almost 99% Indian YouTube thumbnail is like "5 lakh to 40 lakh", "Interview Experience in bracket 50Lpa" etc.. Hardly we can see Foreign Editorial things marked with Packages.

#sharing thought.

likeuplifting

732 applications the last 11 months that doesn’t include since the start of the pandemic looking for work. Out of that only 117 have been viewed that’s 6% viewed! the hiring process is completely broken, human resources, managers, and hiring managers are not capable! The same jobs open for 2 1/2 yrs reposting salaries after interviewing 100 then cutting the salary by up to $50k They say can’t find people but they fire you in 90 days when your working 80 hours a week or people are walking!

like

Does anyone have a resume writer or career coach they could recommend? Feel free to PM if easier!

Hi guys,
I have cleared all the rounds for LTI post which I received autogenerated mail and then later HR asked to upload documents. In how many days can I expect offer letter?

like

Is Word or PDF format resume more compatible with ATS? P.S. I have invisible tables underline my resume. Please advise. THANKS!!

like

Any suggestions for resume writing/updating services? I think I’m not getting call backs because my resume is too busy and unfocused

like

During interview I was speaking to the hiring manager. Felt interview was going well. He seemed impressed by my answers, excited by my skills, and even gave me a tour of the office. At the end, he asked about my home life. When I spoke of my 3 young kiddos, the manager got a little taken back and replied Oh you have children? I said yes ages 3, 5, and 7. He then proceeded to ask me about daycare arrangements and if I can be reliable. Red flag as his demeanor changed and made me feel unworthy.

likesmart
like

Is there any benefit (or detriment) to applying to a job via LinkedIn/Glassdoor over the company’s website?

likehelpfulfunny

Hello Everyone, I had an interview on Friday and the interview went well. Now I'm waiting for response but I've not received any updates yet. Can I contact the HR person who had organised the interview for the update on the same?? Please guide.

Thanks in advance

like

Has anybody recently hired a professional resume writer? Was it helpful and in what ways. It would be great if you can share. thanks.

like

Recruiters, is it frowned upon for candidates to reach out to you on DM on Linkedin? Or does it show that they’re more interested than just submitting an application?

likehelpfulfunny

More Posts

I want permanent work from home..please someone refer me for Business Analyst profile.

Thanks in advance!

like

Any1 in this bowl working in bristlecone ?

like

Any one who's worked at Big 4 and ZS. How has your experience been ? Could you give a sort of comparison on it ?

like

Considering a move in-house to NBC Universal in any litigation role (though I’d really go to wherever there is a need, whether litigation or business affairs generally). Coming from 4th year law firm litigation experience in a variety of areas but mostly data breach, e-discovery, breach of K. Do I apply with an employee referral or via LinkedIn recruiter that reached out? Alternatively, if anyone has experience applying/at NBCU, I’d so appreciate general advice :) TIA.

likehelpful

I’m a first-year MBB analyst. My dream role is helping energy / climate tech companies grow (more interested in ops/strategic work than in cutting checks). Are there funds that might be a good fit?

like

Hey Fishes,

Capgemini is looking for experienced candidates (4+ years exp) in SAP for following open positions.
If interested or someone in your network is interested let me know.

Post Photo
like

Does anyone else feel like distribution is the most behind-the-times of any department within a company? I work for a major automotive brand and some of the facility managers write and read at a 9th grade level, cannot properly use virtually anything in Office, etc.

like

Hi

Can someone list all the benefits and reimbursement provided by
Deloitte India ?

I saw a post for Deloitte USI , like to know whether those things are applicable for Deloitte India Deloitte

like

Is there any chance to postpone the joining date once the offer letter is released

like

How much hike% I can expect with 3 rating in Capgemini. This is my first year with the company, Joined 10 months back.

Capgemini

like

Breakup etiquette- we broke up and I was supposed to go to his relatives’s wedding in a couple of weeks. I know the couple, not super well, but have hung out and texted individually as well. Should I let them know I won’t be attending and wish them well or don’t reach out to them?

like

First time seeing a fire boat on the lake

Post Photo
likeuplifting

My company blames my generation for not being able to hire everyday. “You guys don’t want to work” coming from some overweight, racist, old coaster. I’ve barely taken any days off this year and pick up “skeleton crew” days any chance I get. I was able to work out a deal with my company before I came because of prior experience luckily, but they offer a terrible base salary and sham of a commission structure to new hires + no remote. Then sit here and can’t figure out why…

likefunny

Who’s up for sharing B&W portraits of your furbabies? Let’s see all those beauties 💕💕💕.
.
.
[and no...he’s not sad, its a bulldog happy face]

Post Photo
like

Waddle or Theilen?

like

What bars do men in their 30s frequent?

like

Thinking of moving out of Google, which companies do Xooglers move to in Dublin?
(L5 GBO Dublin)

like

I recently got an offer from UBS, had some questions regarding firm policies and work culture. It would be really great if anyone could help me with those.

Does Uniqlo have the best budget plain t’s?

like

I have an accounting degree and am looking for something where I spend most of my time using excel. Surprisingly, audit —at least at my company— doesn’t really do that. Any suggestions would be helpful.

I’m not sure if this is the right place to post, it’s my first time so please excuse me!

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

We should make a shareable version of those templated AICP Awards Judge Portraits, but for people in furlough.

It will be an exciting series of job seeking announcements.

likesmartfunny

I guess it’s common now to not bring a laptop to show your work at an interview? We’ve had 10 art director candidates come through and maybe 7 of them did not come with any way of showing their work.

like
likefunny

Inhouse LA? Any reccos

like

Thoughts about Giant Spoon?

like

Why are Product Design portfolios so boring? Has anyone seen a good one lately?

funny

Just saw this focus factor ad on CNN and I was speechless. What the actual f*ck?

Post Photo
likefunny

Any creatives impacted by Forsman Bodenfors layoffs? That agency does beautiful, powerful work.

like

I'm extremely happy working at Havas, so it pains to me say what the leadership has done is both embarrassing and demoralizing. (cont.)…

likeupliftingsmarthelpful

Looking for senior designers that knows shopper marketing. Please DM with books!

Drinking Soylent for multiple meals a day so I don't have to waste time getting/making/eating food. Let's see how this goes...

like

Most won't give a shit but what work do you think will win this year at Cannes?

like

How long did you stay at your first job?
And what made you change places?

likesmart

Want to get your opinions on the best small agencies in LA in terms of work produced (media and creative)

like

What are some questions to ask/things to look for before the first time you’re jumping ship that helped you decide whether it was worth it (other than remoteness, salary, and benefits)?

like

O&M Creative: more shuffling still to come? And by shuffling, I mean layoffs too.

like

As part of the interview process, a company is asking me to concept a 360 integrated campaign with presentations to multiple teams. Is this normal?

likefunny

I totally understand the hustle of emailing people you don’t know to create opportunities. I just don’t understand why obscure vendors email creatives rather than production 🤦🏻‍♂️

like

Curious how other people’s brains work.
When you get an activation brief, what’s your process for coming up with a solid idea?

Look for cultural moments that you can adapt? Look through award show books? Scroll YouTube videos until 3am?

I know that every brief and every idea is different, but I’m more interested in the process and what you’re creative routine is to get the wheels turning.

Thanks.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal