Is strategy consulting (even MBB) losing it's charm nowadays with the world moving more towards implementation projects and better opportunities available outside which have good pay as well as better WLB?

Something like what happened with IB roles which were all the rage in B Schools few years back but now have tapered off a lot.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

If you really analyze the industry, it has matured and is all set for a decline in the coming years.

Some of the early markers for decline that i am seeing as part of various proposal discussions are -

1. Competition from start ups, data analytics firms, etc.

2. Reducing price points and exclusivity of MBBs.

3. Fewer strategy projects with mane clients preferring to do these in house.

Senior partners (not all, off course) are turning a blind eye to this and just want to harvest the current situation and retire.

Smart consultants have begun to realize this and are leaving strategy firms for upcoming sectors/ data analytics roles and product roles.

likehelpful

I think there’s still a question of the combination talent and timing that most even top organizations lack -
For instance, Pepsi may have really strong talent at the top, but they are busy with 500 other things to do a focussed project for a strategy build within a short span of time, and do full justice do it - if n such cases, the CEO would call on his Partner friends at MBB whom he trusts and knows are worth their salt to come and do a focussed project for him (without any Line function related issues / corporate bureaucracy redtapes).

For this reason I believe consulting firms that invest in client relationships will remain successful even in the future as information asymmetry reduces and their differentiation based on knowledge/content expertise declines.

like

Temporarily, consulting seems to be losing its charm in business schools - and this might be due to COVID and consultants losing some of their perks (read points).

In the longer term however, while there are definitely opportunities available elsewhere (outside consulting) and at similar pay scales, the stability of progression (and associated comp raises) is tough to see elsewhere.

For instance, as a consultant, you will be making 20 percent more year over year not accounting for cost of living / inflation related adjustments all the way until you reach partner.

This is very very tough to mirror in other industries, therefore I believe the supply side will still be strong.

likehelpful

Many people prefer to work in product management roles these days instead of consulting. I see many people leaving MBB in 1-2 yrs for a product role. It has interesting work and much better wlb. Plus no travel.

like

I never understood the point of strategy consulting. People who have not worked in a particular industry are giving advice to people/companies who have been working in the same industry for decades. If I was a shareholder of a firm and the CEO told me that we need to hire MBB to help us come up with a product launch strategy , i would fire the CEO. Whats the points of having a leadership team which can't do this work on their own. It's a different thing if we need help with ERP implementation or software deployment, but when it comes to making a core business strategy, leadership team should be competent at doing it.

likefunny

Fair point.. And the industry is evolving to what you mentioned. Pure strategy projects are becoming lesser. Previously the lack of information gave these strategy consulting firms an upper hand because they have a wealth of knowledge from working with different clients across industries for decades. But now with information being available easily this leverage is reducing. Also in house strategy roles like CEO office, CFO office are becoming common which attracts bright talent.

like

I think so, at least from a long term career perspective. People may not want to stick around for too long but it's still reasonably prestigious and a good indicator of your potential / value. Also a great way to accelerate growth + earning potential.

like

🔔

This is because of the boutique consulting firms.. also india may pick up individual contracting jobs in future..

Related Posts

Getting an opportunity to move from ZS Associates India to IQVIA UK. Can’t compare the pay because they are quite far apart (ZS pays much more than IQVIA). Thoughts on moving from ZS to IQVIA in the long run?

like
like

Working in Risk Advisory-Internal Audit at EY. Looking to move into valuations. Have knowledge of valuations through FRM and CFA level 2 but no direct valuations experience. Anyone willing to help?

like

So l just started a new job (I work in
higher Ed) but I would like another
stream of income. I am interested in
adjunct faculty but I find it so hard to
get into and I think it's because of
experience teaching. Can anyone be if
help with landing an online adjunct
position for teaching college
readiness or success? I think to start
my teaching journey that type of
course would be best.

Hey All, which is better Fractal or Happiest Minds for Data Scientist ? Both are offering same CTC. Got to decide soon as my joining date is next week. Thanks.
YOE : 7 years.

like

Are there any pharmacists here who transitioned out of retail?

How do I get a job at a startup? I have an accounting/finance background, but don’t enjoy that work and want to get into the startup space (been interested for years).

like

Need career advice. Trying to break into a finance role, preferably an Analsyt role but I have no transferable experience. I worked as a mortgage loan officer (which is sales) for 2 years after college, but since mortgage is such a niche industry, no hard skills transfer and have no relevant undergrad internships unfortunately. I know I can essentially get any sales job I want in finance IE: financial advisor etc. but don’t want to be stuck in sales forever. Any advice?

like

What’s your average base and OTE for sales development/business development roles in UK?

like

Transparent moment: I,recently,was laid-off a week ago. At this point compensation and work culture are the only things I’m looking at. I don’t want to compromise my mental health and I don’t want to work somewhere that is super fast paced. How can you tell if a team has a burn out culture?

like

I am a Basis Consultant, but finding interest in project management profile i have experience of 11 years in IT. Need Guidance/ help to proceed further

TECH STACK - SAP BASIS
YOE - 10.8
CURRENT CTC - 27

Cleared interview with HCL. How much can I get, I'm expecting above 35LPA. Is HCL GOOD FOR SAP BASIS profile?

like

So what’s the deal with bonus payout this year?! If a target bonus is 20%, what are we really gonna get?

likehelpful

How much is the max salary band for Specialist designation?

like

Any good resources (books / videos ) to learn Automation Anywhere. YouTube videos are not really helpful.

Bain & Company Hi Fishes,
Age- 23
YOE- 2.8
Current Pkg- 4.62 LPA
Current In hand Offer- 7.2 LPA
Current Field- Procurement Operations (PR 2 PO)

Please advise new technologies which I can learn to get a better package. Accenture Tata Consultancy Deloitte EY Bain & Company Boston Consulting Group PwC KPMG Wipro Infosys

like

Hi Fishes,

I am an AWS data Engineer with 8 years of experience, how much maximum salary can I expect ?

like

Say I work in tech and have a decent finance experience. Would my 3 yoe of domain "expertise" in tech make me an attractive bet for the banks Tech coverage team? In other words, does having experience in Tech make me more hireable for IBD?

like

Received an offer at 300k/year and a Google offer at 200k/year.
I wanted Google since I started the whole interview process, but I am now not sure given the salary difference.

The position at Google is more junior and the team is just being formed, which involves more risk. However, I like the team at the other company.

The difference in salary is really considerable to push me to rethink this. Is it worth it? Can you share your experiences of when you accepted a lower job offer and why?

like

Looking for thoughts.

I have 13 years of experience as a Business Analyst at various capacities (Regulatory, Data Verticals) in Banking with Bachelors degree in Accounting & Semi Qualified management accountant

Currently pursuing PGP in Data Science and in verge of completion.

Alongside I have got certifications in Cloud & Visualization tools.

Now I want to move completely to the Analytics/ML side. Will the companies consider my BA experience in Data & Regulatory experiences?

like

More Posts

This might be a long shot ... but I have a Statistics assignment due for tonight in a few hours

Does anyone know how to do Linear Discriminant Analysis with more than one predictor - by hand? I know how to compute in R but my professor wants it done by hand .... fml

likefunny

I have been working in healthcare clinics and health techs for a few years now. I’m an independent consultant. Bust, a friend of mine referred me to a big bank job. The role is of data governance manager. What should I know for the interview, or how can I prepare for it? Any thoughts? They told me I don’t need financial background. Data is data, but they wanted to know metadata management and how do I build frameworks/implement enterprise systems.

like

I probably always have had low lying depression (per my therapist) but I think my break up finally broke me. After two months, I'm not any better. So I'm hopping on medication for the first time. Day 5 of using Zoloft. How long before I should consider it is or isn't working?

like

Thoughts on specialty life insurance? I don’t have my LLQP. This is based in canada. They are offering paid training

like

Amazon L7 equivalent in PWC?

like

How much is coforge offering for yoe 6 java developer?

like

For EESP - which is better share withholding or payroll withholding? Thoughts?

like

Was lowballed and don’t want to play catch up for the rest of my life. What is the best timing & ways to ask for a raise? Or should I exit to correct my mistake. Happy to dm with my specific info

like

McK/Bain fish, do you guys get free leatherbound notebooks?

likefunny

Anyone from EY parthenon Dubai who’s willing to chat and guide me on the process there.

like

About to start work in ME, with the office being in Business Bay. Any recommendations on the areas I should look for accommodation? With pros and cons if possible

like

I don’t trust cheese that doesn’t melt

likefunnysmart

What is wrong with people these days?

Post Photo
like

Any recent communication on push /mandatory to come to office for KGS gurgaon?

like

Anyone work for Uproer? How is it? Im looking for a role at a place that will help support and train me.

like

I have 1 year of experience in HR. Is there anyone who can refer me for HR operations in ABB technologies? Infosys Tata Consultancy Accenture IBM Flipkart

like

I’ve got a case of short putting yips. Any tips on how to make them lol. I feel like it’s all in my head...left about 5 strokes out there from short misses the other day

like

Moving to Charlotte in the fall and will be in Charlotte in a couple of weeks to look at apartments. Any recommendations for buildings in the South End or NODA? Looking for a large (1,300+ sqft) two or three bedroom apartment.

Additional Posts in Management Consulting India

Anyone here from EY Parthenon SSG Group?

Need some help

like

Is it possible to move into Management consulting roles without an MBA?

If yes, which companies can I apply to?

like

Got a offer for 16lpa fixed for Associate 2 at Bain with 3.5 YOE?
Any idea what's the range and should I negotiate?

like

Is it acceptable to re-negotiate designation after accepting the offer letter?

like

Any tips to clear HSBC initial behavioural assessment round ? The last time I attended could not clear.

like

Hi Advisors,
I gave one interview and Solve Game assessment for McKinsey & Company - Specialist / Teamlead role Client Capability Network CCN.
Could some one guide me.. on what will be the next steps in Interview and hiring process
How can I prepare for next rounds
What's approximate time taken for hirng cycle
What would be the base salary for this role

Current CTC 15L, 7YoE

Thank you
- McKinsey & Company

like
like

Hi! Folks who have exited Deloitte USI recently, from M level - can you please share insights on %hikes you were offered on fixed / range ?
Want to be equipped with this as a potential negotiation lever, and not be lowballed. Thanks!

like

Any Strategy consultants here?

like

Only For MacBook Users -
I slightly dropped my MacBook and apparently (slightly) damaged the keyboard and trackpad as per service Center. I don’t see any visible damage to the system but that’s what they say and are charging me about 28k for this even though my system is in warranty period (will complete a year in a few days). Are there any workaround for this? Like I can use external keyboard or maybe negotiate, anything else?

like

How is Prescient Healthcare Group as a firm? What is WLB like? What do senior roles at director level look like? Professionalism? Brand? Compensation?

like

Has anybody seen fast-track promotion within 2 years at Accenture Accenture India? I am told fast-track promotions are given when you complete 2 years at a level.

like

Hi. I am completing my MBA in 2 months from University of Toronto. Due to family reasons I wish to move back to India( Delhi) and looking for consulting roles. I have 4 yrs of workex in Audit and about a year’s experience in VC and incubators for startups. Anyone willing to refer me for open roles for Associates/Sr. Consultants? Or which companies might be hiring right now? Thanks!

like

Hi,
I recently gave 3rd round of interview with Gamma and it went very smoothly.
I answered every question even interview ended on a very good note andI was confident that I will definitely make it to the next round then after an hour later I got the rejection email.

I still am in shock what could have gone wrong. Seriously what could have gone wrong.

like

Flunked in an interview 😞
How do I pick back up? This is exhausting! Any tips to come out of dejection and feel some energy.?

like

What are your go to sources for news? I am considering subscribing to The Ken.. is it worth it? Alternative suggestions welcome.

like

Why isn't Deloitte USI allowing to work from anywhere/work from office locations of your choice?
I tried getting a transfer to Kolkata but apparently Cloud Engineering service line transfers to Kolkata is currently blocked as conveyed by an HR. Any help/suggestions on the same would be hugely appreciated.

like

Does anyone have an insight on the kind of work an Analyst does at Deloitte Global Business Services? I was told by the recruiter that this division works on pure play consulting projects. Which I earlier thought fell under S&O (Strategy and Operations) entirely.

like

Thinking of exiting into Banking / Payments space from USI S&O. Anyone has any leads into places recruiting actively?

like
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal