I’ve noticed that HR, when explaining why a candidate didn’t get the job, tend to lean on “You’re great, but we had candidates with more experience in [skill relevant to the job].” I do believe this is true in some cases, but it can’t possibly be for all of them.

HR folks — what feedback have you obscured by offering that line instead?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Could be a slew of things but we stick w the above if feedback is misconstrued and used by applicant to demonstrate discrimination

If the hiring manager didn’t like you or you didn’t jive well with the team, it’s not really something you’re going to pass on to an interviewee. A lot of it comes down to fit - if you have 6 people in the second round and it’s clear the goals/background/what the interviewee has said isn’t going to a fit for the role, that’s a good way to slim down the final interview pool.

If I can point to something on their resume the candidate we ended up making an offer to, that’s what I’ve done in the past. [Note: I worked at a small startup with 30/40 people and was hiring until we reached about 80ish before leaving]. Also, there’s legal issues that can come up around discrimination so this sounds pretty boiler plate.

Related Posts

Hi,
what will be the inhand salary after TDS deduction for 16.5 LPA.

No investments nothing.

like

Fishbowlers. I got a bad performance review. I need to knock my next one out of the park. Open to any suggestions. S1 in month 6 of starting. I need to get quicker and be able to be a ‘lead senior’. How can I make a manager and directors life easier?

like

Hi folks! My interview at Google scheduled in next two weeks. I do my best at preparation, but I am so anxious, I feel like my destiny is depend on this interview and I will fail because of my emotional instability. Ask for advice how to overcome this and do not take denial too personal

like
like

We are in counter-trend longs this morning, trying to move up to 3032 HWB for the intermediate HWB short. There is a micro long here at the 3011 level. I would be a buyer of ES between 3007.50 - 3011.00. Anticipating a rally back up to the all the way half back level, 3032 - 3040.50 level. Gap Fill comes into play at the 3007.00 level as well. Short Term - Bullish above 2997.50. Longer Term - Bearish Below 3034.50.

Post Photo
like

How do you get ahead on work during the weekends? Do you have a no work on the weekends policy?

Sucks when you have a bye week :(

like

Is it just me or have you also noticed that during the endless back to back zoom/teams meetings, people drift away and not take down action points?

like

Hi fishes,

I'm looking for job switch in Manual testing role.Kindly refer my profile if your organization has any openings.
Thanks in advance.
Skill set-manual testing,functional testing,SQL
YOE- 5 years
LWD- 14/01/2023

Walked into a Rolex AD yesterday just to browse. Walked out with this bad boy!

Post Photo
likefunny

Yaaaaaay about time this bowl exists!

like

OH: (RE: required meeting attendance)

"Ok, fine. I will say yes now but fair warning I may fake my own death beforehand."

likefunnysmart

How do you work with people who think you are not smart? For the next few months, I have to work with 2 people who have almost gaslighted me into thinking I don’t have substance. I’m looking for a new job but not as actively as I should.

like

 I want to extract the data from a word file into
 sql server tables. Like after uploading a word
 file it will pull the data from it and then 
 update the various tables in SQL server. 
 I google it and found something called 
 Smart Forms. Anyone have any idea about this?
 Or any way to perform this work.
 
 Note: We can create the Word File as we want.
 Technology: C#, .net

Anyone joined IBM GBS recently... what are the contents in the welcome kit/ goodies?..which brand laptop are they sending?

like

Just in time for busy season - latest Facebook watch raffle group win - Ball Engineer M Marvelight NM2128C-S1C-GY, an upgrade from my Tag - have a great afternoon fellow watch lovers!

Post Photo
like

How to answer the question “why do you want to change your career path” in graduate application/interview?

like

Hi all

I am looking to start my own recruitment firm
Any experts here to help me with guidelines or can share the documentations/ paperwork required

like

Is Canada visa initiated for anyone in TCS

Is there some specific time when visa will be initiated for Canada

I joined capgemini on aug 19 2021 but no appraisal has happened till now.
HR said that I appraisal will happen in April 2023 ! Is that true..
That is a very very long time .
Please can anyone tell if that could be true.

like

Additional Posts in Ask A Recruiter - Advertising

Hey guys. I recently graduated with a bach in business, a graphic design bach, and an MBA this past May. I thought this would help make me look like a stand out on job applications along w/ my international internship but I can’t get an interview for an entry level job at big companies like Deloitte, Goldman Sachs, or Leo Burnett. Should I take my MBA off my resume?? What am I missing??

like

I have recently received an offer to join the recruiting team at Horizon Media. Could anyone share thoughts about culture in company and/or team? I would join remote. I’m trying to decide in between 2 offers. Thanks.

like

I have resigned and my agency is not counting my approved PTOs for two weeks. I put notice for 30 days, is there any way I can negotiate? Or is there any law that prevents companies to cancel hard earned PTOs?

like

Any advice on how to find new creative interns in NYC? We aren’t a big agency but we have some great opportunities!

likehelpful

I'm a Canadian AD and I'm thinking of working in Europe. Is there a well known staffing/ recruiting agency for creatives out there?

Any recruiters on here who have never reached out about a job and then not followed up? Asking for an industry.

like

Hey all, started my role as a recruiter at an agency recently and had my first placement! It was great until the candidate wants to renegotiate the base and benefits after the current company counter-offered when the candidate no longer sees the future. Any tips on what to say to bring back to focus? The current role is a Sr. Acct Receivable (less than 2yr) and going into collections specialist at a global law firm.

like

Hello! I know this is an advertising bowl but is there a bowl for recruiters in tech industry,

like
likeuplifting

Is it concerning if a recruiter is dancing around giving you an offer? or is it just busy bc of Q4, coordinating teams, start dates, and covid?

like

Found out my interview this week will be with PMs of different levels so they can decide who wants me on their team, but recruiter won’t give me any specifics on client/brand, print or digital, etc...

like

I'm nearing the end of an interview for process for a job I'm meh on and recently began the process for my dream job. I'm slightly underqualified for the dream job but it's at a startup in a category I'm extremely passionate for. Should I let them know I'm nearing the end at another place?

I'm unemployed so I don't want to lose out on a job but would really like to hold out for the dream job.

like

When a recruiter sends you a posting for an agency where you worked before…

Post Photo
like

My AD coworker (not currently my partner) just got hired at a new agency and wants to bring me along as his writer. I'd love to join. He told the recruiter at that agency about me and sent my book. I also have another former coworker (creative) who put in a good word for me.

Should I reach out to the recruiter, too? Or is that overkill after two recos? I don't want to be bothersome. But I do want to show interest..

This all happened on Friday, if that matters. Thanks!

likehelpful

Recruiters, is it frowned upon for candidates to reach out to you on DM on Linkedin? Or does it show that they’re more interested than just submitting an application?

likehelpfulfunny

Why do agencies prefer to hire freelancers on payroll/W2 vs 1099/true freelance?

like

Are their recruiters that specialize in placing CD level creatives in Creative Director roles at cool brands? Brands like DWR, Casper, Aesop, SweetGreen. Tired of surfing LinkedIn, Indeed etc. Help!

like

Agency recruiters, how would you rate today’s market for creatives? Is it more of a freelancers’ market or is it tight for everyone at the moment?

like

I’m reviewing my resume getting ready to start my job search and have a question for recruiters, hiring managers. I’m looking for a role brand-side not agency side. Specialist roles aside, such as digital, when you see someone describing themselves as a “generalist marketer” is this a resume you’d pass on? My past roles have been such that I do a lot of marketing projects, tasks etc. but I’m not a specialist. I’m worried if I use this terminology I won’t even be considered for a role. Thank you

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal