McKinsey and Bain 🐠, do you feel like your firm values you? I really like consulting, but I’m considering a switch since BCG’s culture is somewhat toxic.

likefunnyhelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

OP, just out of curiosity, what is your role/tenure? I think you’ll find that a lot of people in a lot of companies are struggling right now. I’m struggling to balance the stress of this pandemic, finding time outside of work to support my immediate family, and financially supporting other family members who have been affected way more than me during all of this. Yes, this job is hard. But not for a moment have I not felt supported by case team leadership to do what I need to do or by BCG at large to take space where I need it. If you haven’t been around a while, the struggles you are experiencing may have to do with how hard this job is to do remote, especially early in your career. If you’re more tenured, the stark contrast between pre-COVID and now is tough to deal with (at least I know it is for me). There are plenty of folks in leadership here who take care of their people, and I hope you find them.

like

Ex-Bainee here - I feel better at BCG than I did at Bain overall (different geographies though) What I like about BCG: MUCH better WLB (most important to me), smarter people overall, lesser grunt work (i.e. easier to outsource grunt work), lesser forced fun and way less groupthink (I think in the name of culture Bain has a tendency to force everyone into the same mold), more directness (e.g. marginally higher transparency on staffing) What I miss about Bain: I made real friends at the office, some of whom I'm still very close to... didn't have the same experience at BCG (it feels a bit more impersonal and professional) but that obv can be due to a host of other reasons, also the language at Bain (CYA, CLM, Answer First, NUTSAC) was very powerful and everyone spoke it Overall Bain has a more homogenous cultural identity and that comes with its pros and cons

likesmart

Which office are you at now - I know hours vary a lot by location with places like NL being the best and EMs being the worst

Recent IconRecent

No corporate company values you. Just another employee number

likesmarthelpful

Consulting jobs “pay ok”? 🤔

funny

“Top Tier” employers (MBB, IB, FAANG, Big Law, etc.) target insecure overachievers almost exclusively and then employ up or out cultures to keep them from ever feeling secure. This generally results in high productivity, but high burn-out rates.

likesmarthelpful

And also terrible success rates with marriages & families 🤣

like

I spent six years at BCG, got promoted twice and yet never felt valued at the firm. I never even felt like I ever had a great mentor. BCG over values on “horsepower” and it heavily under-indexes on personal relationships. I’m only one data point but that’s my perspective.

likehelpful

My last comment on this topic is that 20% revenue CAGR has real costs to culture even with the best of intentions. There is reason no other large or mid sized firm tries to consistently grow at those levels.

helpful

Can’t speak for every office or every team (I’m in NYC) but yes, I genuinely feel our culture is built around a good-faith effort to make our lives happy and successful. I am not saying the success rate is 100% but there is a genuine effort there.

likesmartfunny

Even if “the company” only cares about culture to increase ROI, that doesn’t mean it’s the incentive for those you work with. Also, I would argue most good decisions in business lead to increased ROI in some way.. a top performer staying because they enjoy working at a firm = increased ROI but there is nothing wrong with that. If a decision is made that increases ROI and benefits employees, that’s a win win. Nothing wrong with that. You get your benefit, they get $. This is a good transaction.

helpful

I would say you’re going to struggle to find any really company or Firm that truly values you as a person. They might value your skills, your potential, and/or your ability to contribute, but not you as a person / personality. I’ve found great people that I feel value me within the Firm, but the Firm itself probably doesn’t really care if I stay or go. I think that holds true for many larger organizations. I hope you find people whom you like and who like you, wherever you end up going. Good luck.

likesmarthelpful

Maybe that culture (capitalizing) is why people don’t come first

I feel infinitely less valued at BCG, than I did when I worked at Bain. In fact, I am having mental breakdown at BCG, and often go and cry and open up to my Bain mentors, who have also now left sadly. If there is a Bain soul, that would be willing to talk to a former Bainie, I’d love to! I would love to come back home.

likehelpfuluplifting

@bcg7 dm me if you want to talk

Lol no

like

Good to know. At least BCG is the same as their peers. I guess I’ll jump to industry instead.

like

I feel completely valued and supported at Bain. Work is surely demanding, but everytime I needed something, I could count on senior leadership, HR, and mentors to get it. South American office btw.

like

Bain is tough, don’t get me wrong, but I’ve felt supported every step of the way. In super dark moments, I’ve legit cried to my mentors and advisors (support structure outside of my actual case team) and have been met with zero judgement and tons of empathy for my personal/professional needs. Not saying that’s standard or recommended though lol. Would echo that you need to be your own advocate, but I have always felt that Bain has been responsive in staffing, giving time off, early nights, wellness resources, etc. They also invest heavily in fun, team bonding, food, and other perks. People are generally extroverted and choose Bain (often over McK/BCG) because they care most about relationships.

like

You realize we are all the same company with different names right?

likefunnysmart

My sister worked at BCG for a year and I have been at bain for 5. I think we hire very similar people and do roughly similar work, but the culture is truly different. If you don’t believe culture matters then your statement is 💯 right

smart

Echoing what every other Bainee has said on this chain - I feel really supported and safe at Bain. I can say how I feel and be received fairly and kindly, I don’t feel at risk of being judged. Don’t get me wrong, I also work really hard and the job can be super tough/demanding, but at the end of the day someone has my back and I get to go in to work everyday and hang out with my friends

like

I was based out of APAC when at Bain.

I really do feel valued. Here in Texas, Bain engaged an emergency response firm at its own cost to get food, water, and heat to stranded bainies. They didn’t need to do this, it wasn’t for their bottom line. It was because the firm genuinely cares about its people (and knows that it’s the people that make the firm and generate revenue and they will be more profitable with higher retention). So by having a strong caring and supportive culture we can have budget retention and be a stronger company. The disaster response firm is just one of dozens of examples of the company going the extra mile to show it cares for its people. I also feel like I have numerous advocates at senior levels in my office.

like

And sent a nationwide message with an update and to ask out of regions bainies to support local TX relief organizations.

like

Fwiw I think Bain has an average tenure of ~50 months. I’m not sure about other firms but I’ve heard the average is somewhere closer to ~20 months. This is likely a function of size as well as culture, but it does speak to people feeling valued by the firm.

likehelpful

^ without knowing any detailed data re: the above, I’ve also heard that 40% of Bain LT in North America started off as ACs. Take that as you will. Without trying to gut check any data, Bain gives you pretty generous b-school sponsorship, stipends, etc., apparently more so than McK/BCG’s already generous sponsorship packages, according to some anecdotes from friends. Externship is more common here and can be subsidized by Bain too depending on the opportunity (which I believe isn’t the case always at BCG/McK)...so that serves as a retention driver. So maybe the AC to SAC and SAC to M retentions alone are each a notch higher than peers’ (even if not wildly different), and these little differences here and there add up?

like

I have had a terrific experience over a decade at McK. But remember, of course we value you, we pay you a salary to show you just how we value you. Keep your skills relevant so you can keep contributing, and we will keep valuing you.

likesmart

I’m wondering if it is unique to BCG or if all up or out firms have a negative internal culture.

like

Exactly. Feature, not bug.

like

Lol I’ve considered moving over to BCG for this reason

like

I feel much more valued at BCG than I did when I worked at Bain

like

Culture matters, and differs slightly between firms — operative word is SLIGHTLY. The people that work at these 3 firms all graduate from the same schools with the same degree, go through the same recruiting process testing for the same skills, and are doing essentially the same job. Culture likely varies just as much within a given firm (between offices, practices, teams) as between firms. There ARE amazing, nice, genuine people in every firm who will value you but you might just need to seek them out. That being said, I do perceive Bain’s brand and culture as being more “fun” though which on balance probably attracts people who don’t take themselves quite as seriously as McK / BCG...

like

Very well said

like

Related Posts

The most interesting part of consulting to me is being dropped into entirely new teams where no one knows each other and immediately having to adjust to a new team culture.

like

Any advice for applying for a new position while currently in one? (Esp. being in one of the big 4 holding co where talent portal will flag you applying for positions)

like

Got to final round interviews with a tech company back in March. They said they were very interested, but because of COVID they were closing the requisition with hopes of reopening it Sept. The position requires a lot of networking, conferences, and meetings, which would drive why the decided to put off the position. Have not heard anything from the company, is it a lost cause at this point?

like

Is a switch from IT Audit (b4) to Product Management (industry) role a good move? C1. Significant pay bump as well.

like

Considering moving from Capgemini tech consultant role after 2 years, to Program Manager role at a tech company in Bay Area. I think it’d be a step up in responsibilities & exposure. Would that be viewed as progression and a positive move in the eye of the MBA Admission Officers?

like

Having an informational interview that I’m hoping will lead to an exit opportunity. I’m compiling a list of questions to ask and was wondering if anyone had recommendations or go-to questions?

like

Folks planning to go for L1, considering the remote situation, what should be our justification that this role requires a physical presence in the US? One cannot work for Deloitte US if not in the US is the only thing I can think of. Any better responses?

like

Are agencies hiring more full time or freelance positions? What’s the future look like?

like

Does anyone have any insights on Nielsen? How’s culture, WLB, career growth?

like

Pondering. How many creatives struggle with the imposter syndrome. And even though you get into this business because you have talent, how do you stay true to that and not listen to the haters/ cancel culture that makes you feel like an imposter. I feel like I’m not alone, but I’d love some advice on how you guys paddle your own creative canoe.

like

anyone here jump to industry and end up not liking the role? what did you do? how did leaving to join industry effect your career? what are some things that you wish you knew/considered before taking the money?

like

Anyone have knowledge of Cloudera? Culture, comp, appropriate title exiting from EM/D level?

Evaluating whether to take up an Investment Strategy role with a unicorn wealth-tech firm. Does this pigeon-hole me into wealth-tech? Are there paths from Investment Strategy to other fin tech or investing or Corporate strategy roles?

like

Fastest way to Marriott status? I am currently Diamond with Hilton but want to switch. Do they offer any challenges? I already was told no status matches.Also not interested in opening a Marriott cc..

like

It's hard enough to get people on board with an idea in your head even when everyone in the room has a similar background and culture. How do you handle cultural barriers in the workplace?

like

My Truth: I recently left a large firm with great pay, terrible culture, & subtle racism for a small firm, bad pay, & great/open culture. Already looking like one of my better career decisions. (cont)

likeuplifting

Started at a local firm and become manager, then joined a nation firm for more brand recognition. After one year, I don’t think I fit in the culture. I want to love to move to industry, but

like

I’m just starting in a consulting role out of undergrad but want to keep my computer science skills up should I decide to exit to a technical role. Does anyone have recommendations on how to do so?

like

Yelp is hiring in BizOps / Strategy, Data Science, product management, and engineering. Let me know if you’d like more information. Happy to give out referrals!

likesmart

In your opinions, what qualities make for a good corporate culture?

like

Additional Posts

Can't wait to go on my vacation

like

After a year in big 4 and being beyond miserable and unhappy with my client and the firm, I have a great opportunity with CLA thanks to a sr mgr there. Thoughts on dipping for CLA?

like

Comp for ACN Ventures and Acquisitions Integration Specialist? 5 years experience In Tier 1, not NYC. Have an offer and wondering if reasonable. Glassdoor of no help. TIA

like

What exit ops from consulting provide the ability to eventually get to a 200k+ salary / minimal travel?

like

Any post-MBAs from Deloitte recently laid off that were expecting GSAP tuition reimbursement? If so, did you receive any?

like

How do y'all deal with being lonely while traveling? I know no one at this client site and I have no family or friends or coworkers in the area.

like

Graduated in 2014. Make 150k as a manager now. Looking for Corporate Strategy roles in f500. What should I shoot for for total comp?

likefunny

In my early thirties, still an Engagement Manager only making $355k basic, plus benefits and guarenteed minimum bonus of $100k. What did I do wrong? #Satire #DoesAnyoneElseFeelThisTypeOfDiscussionHappensWayToMuchHere? #WhyDoSoManyPeepsNeedValidation? Not trying to put people down, but seems there are far too many people on the hamster wheel just churning and in need of validation. Any thoughts? Am I off base?

likefunny

How is the proposed tax holiday going to work? You don't pay taxes now but owe it by April 15 2021?

like

I’m just saying...if I ever were to get pregnant. I would trace it back to the night(s) we boned to conceive that baby. Anyone else?

likefunny

MBB 🐠 is health strategy (general, not payer and provider) a priority or existing area at your firm? Are those sort of positions easy to come by? Always trying to keep my eyes open.

like

I hate that I can’t just enjoy a quiet period instead of feeling like it means I’m about to get laid off

likefunny

If I were to jump ships to EY, how would the work mix between local and non-local look like. Doea Transaction Advisory do more local jobs or is it the usual travel M-Th. I see fewer EY guys at airport

like

Mini poll - Best firm among Tier 2: (also would be lovely to know why) 💜 - GT ❤️ - BDO 💚 - RSM

likefunny

I will likely leave my new consulting job soon after 3 months. My current job is causing me to (almost) burn out already - I’m essentially doing the job of 2 people due to the project being understaffed. Management style is also severely micromanaged. I am in the process of interviewing & will likely get an offer. Thinking ahead, I am unsure what to say to my current company as the reason for leaving. I have a feeling things will turn hostile.

likehelpful

How doe Deloitte's tuition reimbursement work for grad school?

like

Any advice for breaking into product management without prior experience? Looking for a place to start! I heard product school and the PMP weren’t too helpful but nice to have?

like

MBB folks - what's the AP/Principal salaries at your firm vs Y1 Partner? I've seen some threads where first year partners suggested they make lesser in Y1 than Principal. Curious to hear how big of a difference the two levels are in terms of comp

likehelpful

Say you have $1M available to invest in cash. Would it be possible to join the fund raise of a PE/VC/HF? Or is that not enough? If so how does one get exposure to such asset classes?

likesmart

QQQ is now restricted due to taking a job in B4. What are some good alternatives?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.