Need advice: If you were asked to complete an assignment as part of an interview process (for a high level CD position client-side), how would you politely decline this request?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

“i would be more than happy to work out a short-term freelance arrangement, but as a rule, i don’t do work for free, even if it’s not directly related to client work”

like

i went through this same thing 2 months ago. an agency i had never heard of in the middle of the country filled with supposedly “nice folks.”

i answered very matter of factly and politely. the recruiter replied very passive aggressively and dismissive. like okay, good luck getting better candidates!

2 months later i’m freelancing for an A list agency making good money on a dream tech client.

also the ask was insulting. it felt like a student assignment. i’m so glad i didn’t take them up on it

like

Do you want the job?

like

Ask them to sign a doc stating that any ideas that you create are your own intellectual property.

like

Do it on an unrelated product if they refuse

Personally, I’d do it.

I’m against these kinds of tests in the agency world. But my guess is that client side jobs don’t translate 1:1 with what’s in our portfolios, so it’s a good opportunity to show if / how our skills transfer.

like

Yikes.

I did something similar,against my better judgement, for a gig that I really needed. They said to see if I could work with their way of doing strategy. Was actually a fun project that I did in a day, and got the gig. Then the gig sucked. Should have not done it in the first place, as this was an early indication of how they viewed creative.

like

I would hop on a video call to discuss it.

What’s the real reason for the assignment?

Is it some business protocol imposed on the marketing department? Or is it because they are unsure about you and want you to prove yourself?

If the test assignment could be used as actual work, then I would insist on charging money. Basic day rate. If they refuse, consider it the world’s biggest red flag, and you dodged a bullet.

like

Its not uncommon for client side roles to ask for this, although the better/more established ones shouldn't. I suspect its often because they haven't totally figured out how you'll integrate into the team and their process. Dont do it for free. Tell them you'll do it for a project fee (charge fairly and based on what you'd hope to earn there) and then make sure they see the value you'd bring beyond just creative work - again they're likely looking for culture fit and integration with the broader team.

like

Exactly, at my last client-side role it was non-negotiable corporate procedure (and an extensive personality/IQ-ish test!) They required every creative from JD to SVP level to do a creative/design test. I tried declining but no dice, as well as requesting payment for my time and it started to escalate that I was being difficult. Eventually I just got over my annoyance and did it so I got the job.

like

If they are viewing the request as a way of determining if you’ll “fit” into the way that they think, it’s a sure sign that they won’t value your thinking. Run.

like

Three words and a punctuation mark: Pay to play.

like

Say you’d be more than happy to get involved in a freelance capacity, this is a respectful stance but working without payment is kind of abusive and devaluing. Good agencies freelance people with a view to a permanent hire all the time.

The last place I worked started requiring these when a VP of Product was hired and my design team started reporting to them. Their justification for this request was to see if the applicant can actually do the caliber of work they said did in their portfolio. I worked with that VP for 6 months and then left.

My point is just be careful with the culture of the company you are looking at.

Related Posts

Morning all. I am looking for a favour/solid advice. I've been in the interview process for a dream role over the past month or so and just found out I didn't get the job after final round 🙃.

Unfortunately this isn't the first time this has happened during the past year searching. Looking for a SC level role within healthcare/public sector consulting firm. I know the job scene is a bit miserable currently but if anyone in the bowl is aware of a role I would love to have a chat.

Thanks all

like

I am looking for an opportunity in snowflake(sql), power bi.can anyone help me in getting a referral in bosch..yoe: 3yrs

like

I currently work in Tech Consulting on the software implementation side with 2 YOE. I don’t see myself long term in this area and am interested in pivoting to strategy and potentially business school along the way. Does anyone have advice for the best way to prepare and land a role for someone who doesn’t have a strong strategy background?

like

Looking for a position in the ICU at Loyola Gottlieb Memorial Hospital, are there any recruiters out there?

like

Hey all! Any openings in your company for copywriting/copy strategist role?

like

Hi Fishes,

I am a software specialist having 8+ yoe, currently working at Mastek with a CTC of 17lpa. Can anyone help me with the current market CTC considering the below:
Current Role: Tech Lead
Tech Stack: Full Stack in Java, Springboot, Angular, Mobility, AWS beginner.
Your responses will be much appreciated.

like

Received a job offer. Was wondering if anyone had any thoughts on a concern I had about it. It's an entry level position, and I don't have much experience. The billables are 2040 a year. For billable hours in civil litigation and insurance defense, is 2040 hours for a 1st year associate on the high end in this field for a small or midsize firm? It seems like most attorneys I know have minimum requirements of around 1800. The compensation is around 80k a year.

like

How often are hiring committees? Does it depend on the group?

like
like

Anyone at EY willing to talk about their experience and potentially refer for a salesforce senior dev position ?

Information required before your Amazon interview. Amazon

What is this mail ? And the position was not mentioned in the form, and I have applied to 3 different roles.

like

Urgent joining coming up:
Robert Bosch 23 or Palo Alto networks 22 + stocks $6k per year for Sr Analyst role? Bosch hybrid and palo wfh?? Palo client role
And Bosch service Role

like

Year 1: Should I be applying for analyst roles and studying for CFA if I know I don't want to stay in audit or work on getting my CPA and wait another busy season before I apply/request for transfer?

like

Invited to a recruiting/networking session for an analyst level role at a Bain Capital. Excuse my naivete, but is business professional (full suit) the expectation here? Unfortunately my only well fitting suit was torn recently so trying to see if I can get away with another outfit

like
like

Hi Friends, need a help with a referral link for Deloitte USI based role.

hey fishes,

I have applied for this role gCare - Customer Support Senior Associate - Ads Generalist. I'd like to know what type of interviews & rounds will be conducted... what will b the first round for it. hve 2 yrs of experience in Amazon & Accenture.

Trying to chart my next move and not sure what direction to go. All I know is I’m tired of being always “on” in a client-facing environment.

Any podcasts, books, etc I can read for insight into more internal roles like biz ops, corporate dev/strategy, other??

4 YOE total all in consulting. Currently a SC. Clients/work have been commercial healthcare implementation & public health strategy, risk, process imp etc.

like

Opentext is hiring, please reach out to me for referrals, thanks.

Post Photo
like

Hello I have given Last round of knowledge management associate profile. When can we expect the results ?
Does ZS send rejection mail also ?

like

More Posts

Going to Italy end of October, planning on visiting the Lamborghini and Ferrari museums. Which Ferrari museum is better? Modena or Maranello? Or is it worth it to visit both?

like

I left Accenture on 11th Jan.
Prior to that I had submitted iT declarations, from where can I get Form 12B?@Accenture

like

Just took a look at the Riveron. So white and so male dominated. But what do you expect. It is a TX based firm.

like

What is the entry level salary expectation for data analyst in Mumbai please share your thought also...

Anyone interested to participate in kaggle competition?

like

Has anyone gotten to the point where it is physically painful to try and concentrate? Not sure what to do at this point; had Ritalin for a bit, but I adjusted in like 10 days before the benefits went away. Now I’m scared I’ll just keep getting worse

like
like
like

Okay so, going to a shoot next week in LA and it’s my first one with no client attendees. Given the traditional account role will be null, wondering the best way to be useful?

Any advice would be greatly appreciated!

like

Just got the tentative government offer_ does anyone have tips on negotiating steps when hired? I understand GS level is not negotiable.

like

Hello everyone. Happy Monday! Is there anyone here that will give me a referral for the New Home Sales Consultation position with LGI Homes in Atlanta please? I’ve been trying to break into this sector of the Real Estate Industry for almost a year now. TIA

Any helpful soul here can consider referring me to Siemens and Wipro for their consulting role please? 6 years of Project Management experience with MBA and came across roles that can potentially be absolutely fit. Happy to share more info and CV and go from there.
Siemens Wipro

likehelpful

I am curious how other inclusion teachers are being utilized when the school is doing remote learning. I find that I am sitting in the zoom class and have very little opportunity to contribute. I am having discussions with my teachers on ways that I can better support them and the students when remote.

like

Does anyone here work for Corporate Value Associates?

If so, could I please get in touch via DM?

Shukran

Why doesn't Bran take control of a few crows in Kings Landing & drop Hellfire (that green flammable stuff) on Cersei and get done with this? Will be a better story than where this is headed

like

Can we leave CG a month after joining?

like

Happy Friday! To spread joy, who do you want to give flowers to today?

like

Anything to think about or look out for when another vendor at client loses their recompete? I’m expecting lots of rebadging but new to federal and don’t really know what this is going to look like

Today I messed up doing a delivery. The client was expecting the supplies at 3pm in the warehouse, however, there was an accident on the highway and traffic was insane. It slipped my mind to let them know about the delay. Now, they believe it was me being irresponsible and are threatening to fire me for not reporting on time and possible losing them a client. What can I do to fix the situation?

like

What is it like working as a full-time graphic designer for a company (not an agency/firm)?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Anyone have a recommendation for books or resources on upping my sales game? Open to in person class, online class, books, etc!

like

If you got fired today would you have a Bach up plan? What would it be?

like

Best (non-agency) company to work at in Boston??

likehelpfulsmart

Scenerio: Its Friday. You're working on a crazy detailed RFP and you're so close to finishing the $$$ part and the office internet DIES. Do you:
A) tether to your phone and get 'it dun
B) go for beer

like

Here’s to hoping the start of the new Serena Lincoln navigator ad is the end of the Mathew mcconaughey Lincoln Navigator ads

likefunny

Manager texted me at ~10pm asking for a non-critical update. I chose not to respond (until morning) because I don't want to allow a bad habit to form. Thoughts?

like

Can someone from Leo Burnett explain why your LinkedIn titles say “Human Being”? It adds an extra step since I have no idea what industry the person inviting me to connect is in or what their title is

funnylike

Can we really just not with April Fools ads? So cringe inducing, so bandwagon-y, so god damn corny & depressingly expected...🤢

like

Anyone on here worked with Edelman? Pros? Cons?

like

When my boss asks me to send him a recap of what I’ll be working on next week but things are slow because all my campaigns are paused due to the upcoming Civil War.

Post Photo
likefunny

Future 'Havas Health & You'ers (yes I know terrible name)... what's the verdict. Are they moving the 200 Hudson folks to 200 Madison?

like

Why does DMA keep on bringing up race?

likefunny

How long are those quick Orange Vanilla Coke videos airing on the NCAA Tournament? I counted about 3 seconds

like

👏🏼🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼👏🏼🙌🏼
A-list #2!! And congrats to wieden I guess whatever

Post Photo
likefunny

Got any jokes?

like

The dickiest of dick moves is to schedule a 9am meeting and then move it at 8:45 the morning of.

like

People ask me all the time why I have to work evenings and weekends but I don’t have a real explanation aside from “it’s just how ad agencies are 🤷🏻‍♀️” What makes a better agency?

like

What exactly is going on with Havas NY? I've heard many complaints about how it's a disaster, just curious specifically why.

like

Has anyone received a job offer after being initially ghosted by recruiter? How long did you not hear from them? Feeling down after not hearing anything for 2 weeks after a round of seemingly promising interviews.

like

What do account people do at your firm? At mine it seems to be just forwarding emails between the client to the strategy/analytics/creatives who do the work and back. Surely not like this everywhere?!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal