Offer 1 (B4 Tech consulting, SC, ATL) -
135K base + 15K sign-on + upto 10% bonus

Offer 2 (Bank, Senior Lead Data Engineer, Remote) -
160K base + 5K sign-on + 12.5% bonus

~10 YoE in Banking Industry with Masters.
Which offer would be better looking forward 3-5 Years?

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Why are you asking this question?

like

One offer is monetarily much better than the other, what is the question you are trying to ask?

like

OP, I am guessing here that the B4 is EY. Kpmg and Pwc don’t have SC title and the bonus is usually mentioned as up to 17% for Deloitte consulting for SC.
With that said, bonuses and raises in consulting are probably higher than industry but banks pay bonuses well too. At EY, you will probably need to get promoted before you hit 160k and that would probably take 2-3 years. At offer 2 you would probably be higher in five years too, and your bonuses will be paid respective a much higher base. Unless you hate offer 2, their offer is much better.

likehelpful

Offer 2. It is remote, and the pay is way better. Unless you just didn't like the people or it wasn't a good fit. There is no reason not to take Offer 2.

likehelpful

Even if everything else is the same, aka same company, same compensation, same wfh policy, a “senior lead data engineer” will open you to more tech jobs than a “senior consultant”, not to mention it sounds way more senior to most recruiters, whether or not that’s actually the case.

likesmart

Offer 2. You will make more money over the course of 3-5 years, even assuming you get promoted to manager in 3 years with offer 1.

likehelpful

Offer 2

like

What’s the 10 year plan? If you know it’s Data and Banking no chance go consulting. If you’re still not sure go Consulting.

Related Posts

Please, help me to know how much will be I hand salary before qtrly bonus or after qtrly bonus. I am very confused with salary structure.

Post Photo
like

Do you think WFH will end suddenly once a vaccine is available? What if you don't get the vaccine?

like

During phone screen I asked for a certain amount and after researching, I realized I asked for way lower than the going rate for this role/level. They want to bring me in for onsite. How/when do....

I have a hand full of k-5 students who have gone the first half of the school year without music because of remote learning. Our district is moving to 100% traditional teaching after the MLK holiday. Any suggestions for reintroducing concepts to the group of students that’ll be joining us f2f for music the first time this school year?

like

Anyone here work in a family office role? What are the hours and salary like?

like
like

Hi ,
anyone help on the HCL retention bonus ?

They added 2L per year in separate letter,

will 2L added in every year ?

They added condition of need to stay for 24 month .

How HCL retention bonus works ?

@HCL Technologies

likesmart

HR opinion: Do I have any leverage as a hospital nurse case manager in negotiating earned time? I have 15 years within the organization, left for 10 months to be remote during the pandemic while sorting out childcare as immunocompromised family helped. Now HR is restarting my ET as a new employee. I realize I left, but not on bad terms and I am an exemplar and respected employee. I thought I’d have the upper hand with the nursing shortage but I’m getting the “rules are rules” response. Help!?!

like

in offer letter of Mastercard they have mentioned variable pay achievable 250% is it true and what are chances are getting it????

likehelpful

Hi. Can i ask Axtria to match the offer with 20 percent hike ? I almost have one more offer of around 10 lpa. Axtria offered 8lpa for analyst role. YOE- 1.5+.

What is an average salary of senior BA?

like

Hi guys

Holding offer - Bosch(17LPA) - Coimbatore
ZF(16LPA) -hyderabad

Total exp:3.5
domain AUTOMOTIVE (MBD)


Which company should I choose??
current CTC: 10LPA

Should I negotiate?? pls suggest

like

Hybrid vs WFH?

like

What will be the in-hand salary

Post Photo
like

Have any of you moved to PE for a slight pay decrease from the crazy banking comps last year?

During my interview process I clearly stated my salary expectations of 95k-105k. They came back with an offer at 80k. Is it even possible for us to come closer to a better agreement with them being so low? All other aspects of the job are in line with what I'm looking for, so I really want to make this work.

like

Hi All,

I have 4 yrs of exp as full stack developer and my current CTC is 15 lpa and notice period is of 3 months. I got an offer from another firm for 24lpa but they have shared the offer letter of DOJ after 2 months and asked me to negotiate my notice period or look for buyout. What should I do in this case? Should I connect with my current hr to negotiate? Cause I tried convincing the new hr to share the offer letter of DOJ after 3 months but she is not in the favour of that.

like

I haven’t been at a B4 firm since 2018. Do you still require a professional certification to be promoted to Manager?

like

More Posts

Hey Fishes,

Does anyone know any reliable password generator and store application within PWC app store or network?

There is multiple applications and I dont want to strore passwords outside of pwc or in google linked pwc account

like

Want to join new company after h1b transfer completed. Need to give 2 weeks notice to current employer. Can I work for current employer for those 2 weeks notice period after h1b transferred to new employer?when does the current employer get notified of h1b transfer, in case that happens?

like

GF is 32 and I’m 28. She wants kids within 2 years, understandably. I never envisioned having kids that early (more like late 30s), but I like her a lot. Anyone else gone through something similar?

like

after receiving the portal link to accept the offer letter, what is the deadline to I accept it?

like

Obligatory Rosh Hashannah post:
Shannah Tovah to my fellow Jewish consultants!

like

Hey anyone has advice on fixed income execution trader in a buy side firm? Sizable firm, good team, very low pay, okay wlb, been here for a year and working for 4 years in total, was sales/ small firm analyst before. Though trading is fun, but can’t think of executing orders for another 10 years. Trying to get on track of fixed income analyst - am doing some research in my spare time for my team now. What do you think of trader to analyst? Any good advice or same concerns? Appreciate any cmts!

Guys, I need your expert suggestions. All figures are in INR
I am living in Europe with my wife. We both are earning.We save around 4.5 to 5 lakhs every month based on exchange rate. We have SIPs of around 60k. Please help me to invest my savings. Apart from mutual fund SIPs I don't know much.

like

Any recommendations for a nice SoCal AD who gives generous discount? Looking to buy my my first JLC :)

likefunny

For those in corporate development, can you talk about the financial modeling aspect of the job? How detailed do you get? Full three-statement or something much simpler? 50 tabs or less? It would be helpful if you could say what size company and whether it’s public or private. Thanks!

like

Bain & Company McKinsey & Company Bain & Company Boston Consulting Group what are the main services you offer within M&A group?

like

Are Booz consulting and contracting services two completely separate business units?

Anyone here work for Viacom, WarnerMedia, Disney, Netflix etc. (Or know somebody who does)? I'm brand new in New York, and I would love to do some networking in the entertainment media industry. Any, contacts, leads or even just a hello would be appreciated! :)

like
like

Is there a need for a pharma/HC agency to build and maintain a curated trusted publisher network and execute buys programmatically with them?

Looking for insights and chit chat on the topic —>

Going to join CitiusTech. What we can expect in welcome kit???

How does IT SOX audit in industry usually do during recessions?

likehelpful
like

An aspiring investment banker (college student) sent me their resume and inquired about an internship. However their previous internship appears to be in “Incestment Banking”.

Not sure if anyone on here (maybe from Alabama) has any idea what this means, but if the work is applicable to investment banking please let me know.

funnylikeupliftingsmart

Should a DevOps Cloud Engineer with 2 years experience earning around 10 LPA (base salary) in a Fortune 200, switch to a startup which pays almost 20 LPA base salary?
The reason to ask this question is, wouldn't it be difficult at the time of second switch, to move to another big organisation after one is already at 20-24 LPA with just 3-4 years of experience at a startup?
All thoughts are welcome.

like

24.5 LPA for a solution architect role in TCS.
Is the ask is high or low for 8+ yoe with javaa, aws

like

Additional Posts in Compensation in Consulting

A promotion from analyst to senior analyst OR analyst to associate OR analyst to consultant should increase your salary by what %?

like

For EESP - which is better share withholding or payroll withholding? Thoughts?

like

What is the etiquette for negotiating when you have multiple offers? Do you actually share the offer letter with the other recruiter or just communicate verbally over phone?

like

What's the comp range for an experienced hire M1 in healthcare management consulting at Deloitte in the NYC area?

like

Bain & Company Is MBB going to raise comp in the UK too? Just signed the offer recently McKinsey & Company Bain & Company Boston Consulting Group

likefunny

Expecting an offer today from Deloitte consulting (commercial). Would love to hear tips and advice on how to react to the call and negotiate/what to negotiate more for. I was laid off back in the fall and will 100 percent take the offer - super excited!! But don’t want to show my emotions. TIA

like

Wondering what the comp is for SC’s & M’s at Canadian firms? All these American numbers are making me feel very underpaid...

likehelpful

Salary for PwC Revenue Cycle SA? 4.5 years experience, CPA?

likehelpful

EY 🐠, promoted from Sr3 to Mgr with a 5 rating in FSO Advisory, based in NYC. Anybody know the pay band or percentage increase to expect?

like

What is the current range of base salary of an L5 at Accenture Strategy & Consulting?

like

How much did y’all paychecks went up by from the tax law?

like

Non-MBA experienced hire with 2 years, federal, C level: 86k. Where am I in the salary band?

like

What’s the general comp for EM level at Strategy&? Assuming a Chicago or comparavle COL

like

Pre-tax 401(k) or after-tax...thoughts?

like

Hello Fishes - Have received offer from Citibank for C14 ( SVP Data Science) role. Offered comp - 220K base. No signing bonus. Bonus range -20%. Location - NY. Is this good offer? What is range generally? Citi fishes please help !!Citi

like

How do I figure out the salary expectation for flat organisation like Facebook ? Also have very little idea about the group I am interviewing for.

like

Going through first full cycle with EY as Advisory PI Manager in Tier 2 city.

What in your experience is average raise for high performer vs meets expectations?

like

PwC Senior Associate salary band (advisory)? Have masters and 3 YoE.

Thoughts on offer?

Experience
6+ YOE in Financial Services Industry
Skills MBA, CFA, FRM
Currently in Big4

Offer
Base 130K
SignOn-5K
Location New York
Firm Non-Big4
Title Senior Associate

like

McKinsey consultants- I remember hearing that you have a different comp model from most firms (where title and pay aren't necessarily linked). Does anyone mind elaborating?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal