Opinions on pre-hire assignments? I’m in the final stages of interviewing for a senior strategist job and they’re asking that I put together a robust presentation to refresh a program. They want me to think through messaging, channels, competitive, measurement, etc. I then have to present my strategy in an hour long meeting with the hiring manager and higher ups.

Is this normal? I’ve never been asked to complete something so comprehensive for an interview process.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I typically give a hypothetical assignment. A brand we don’t work on and an assignment I make up, just to see how they think. The presentation shouldn’t be more than 10 slides and I make sure to tell them to not slave over it.

I’ve always done this because it allows some folks who may not be good in an interview a chance to shine and it can expose others who may just be good interviewers.

I had a guy interview who was a copywriter and wanted to get into strategy. I was hesitant during the interview because he said nothing but jargon, I gave him the assignment and he did a great job on it. Changed my perspective.

like

There is someone we have at my agency who is literally incompetent and it’s been a long road to firing her.

If we had done this with her she never would have been hired.

So generally I am in favor of it.

You can say no, of course.

like

I’ve done this before but I was paid to do so by the HR department.

like

I've been asked to think about old briefs they've done or bring one of my own in a few interviews. Usually it's to get a better sense at how you approach assignments and if you can fill a gap in the agency.

Is this a live brief the agency is currently working on? If it's a live brief, I'd be cautious as they could be fishing for free work.

like

This. Make sure it's not a live brief. And if the assignment is very comprehensive, be wary and ask for payment.

like

I have a crazy robust one I’m working on now too. In previous companies I’ve asked for payment for my day rate, after which they scrapped the assignment and hired me after letting me show old work. I’m doing it now because I really want this job but it seems very shady.

likehelpful

It used to be rare and now I fear, in this economy, it’s becoming standard which is gross.

like

It’s completely standard in Europe for mid-weight and above. Makes total sense for the hiring company to want to get a feel for how you think and approach work. Having completed one last week, it is also very stressful! Especially when they say “don’t spend more than 4 hours” - impossible!

like

I agree. No way can you complete a project worthy of demonstrating what you offer in four hours. I think it’s almost a mind fuck to see how badly you want it and your willingness to go above and beyond.

Hi I’m experiencing this too and just posted a question about it. What they are asking me to do will take at a minimum a full days work of worth. I’m not sure if I should move forward or push back. It feels like free work. What did you end up doing?

Depends on your status. I hate it and think it’s scummy but it was a job I wanted and in this economy I did it. I pushed the date back so I could do it over the weekend and signed an offer two weeks ago.

like

Related Posts

Hi Fishes,

I have attended two interviews with cognizant for the same role. From that, I have got an offer letter from one panel and I am discussing with the HR about to make some salary revise.
Unfortunately, the second panel also processed my profile and it got short listed and they come back for a talk to process the offer letter. Now the first panel HR called me and asked about the second process why it got happened.
Does this results in any drawback for the offer letter i have got already?

like

Any opening for data scientist in EY GDS. I have total 8 YOE and 3 years in data science. I am seeing vaccancy for GDS team in LinkedIn, if there are any can someone refer me ?

like

Looking for UI Architect candidates that have heavy front end enterprise wide application experience including knowledge of Angular and/or React. Remote position but need to be legally able to work in the US with no sponsorship. No C2C or agencies please.

like

Hello FishBowl community,

I am a Talent Acquisition Partner with
leadership and management experience,
and my previous role was a Talent
Acquisition Specialist. I have a bachelor
degree in Business Management, and I'm
looking for a remote role.

Any TA / Recruiting referrals or job opportunities
would be greatly appreciated! :)

like

Hello,
If anyone can answer ,
On how time it will take normally for HR discussion and final release of offer after clearing the interview?

like

I have 2 years of experience in Financial Services External Audit. However am currently looking for exit opportunities, any suggestions?

like

Accenture India Hi Guys, Is anyone attended interview at Accenture India for the role of SAB ABAP HANA... How is the interview process,how difficulty the level of interview is? What is the salary package we can expect? Can anyone help?Accenture

like

I’m up for a promotion at work and I have no idea how much to ask for since it’s not a standard position. Currently I’m a team lead and manage about 8 technicians, my promotion will be to a regional service delivery manager, and I will be managing over 30 in 3 locations. I went from a tier 1 engineer in managed servers to team lead with about a 10k increase in salary.I’m thinking about a 15k increase this time from 65k to 80k. Anybody in managed services have a similar position to compare

like

what tech companies are still hiring?

Tips to switch with 90days notice period currently trying but either they cancel interview or don't schedule it after I tell them the np.

like

Is the layoff spree ended in PS? No new scapegoat opening up in last two days. Anyone affected in recent couple of days? Please speak up to make the public aware.

likehelpful

Know that many members of the adv community are looking for work, I have a great role in Chicago. Ideal candidate is a CD/ACD/senior writer who loves gaming & has experience w/branded content.

like

Hi friends
I have been working with Oracle since four years in a sales role my total experience is six years
I am keen to change my career and move out of sales can someone suggest what all options are available after having been selling IT solutions
Your suggestions and advices or highly appreciated

like

Hi fellow bowlers,

I am currently working as a Marketing executive for a SaaS startup and have an experience of almost 3.5 years in this field. But I am looking for a job change that helps pivot my career into Marketing Analytics. I have some understanding of SQL and Marketing Analysis. Anyone here knows of any opening or is hiring?

Thank You

like

Would like some tips on how to prepare for Senior Fullstack Developer tech interviews. What kind of questions should I expect? Any other tips on how to prepare? TIA

like

Hi all, I am looking for a job role in sales/business development manager for Gujarat, India location. Please let me know if any...

like
like

Hi, everyone! My company is hiring for Sales Director’s in all regions across the US. I am looking for Director’s that have a book in Central and East Coast region with about 5+ years of experience. We are looking for professionals that have a background in selling various Ad-Tech solutions. We are offering remote work and a competitive base+commission. Message me if this sounds like you!

like

After 3 years in TCS, I'm looking for a job switch. It would be highly appreciated if anyone can provide me with a referral to HCL.

Profile: Data Scientist/ML(Computer Vision, NLP)

Relevant YOE: 2

Hi, I need referral in Accenture. Can someone please help me with the same. Accenture India

Post Photo
like

More Posts

Alteryx stock - thoughts on the company as a longterm investment?

like

Just put my deposit down for a 6 mo wait for a datejust… any ways to speed up the wait time? 😬😳 Want it on my wrist already!!

like

What do you do if you feel stuck in your career?

like

What are the best provinces to move to in Canada per your experience. Some information about me-
1. F, 32, Single, Indian
2. Working in Financial services
3. Have a dog and looking for an active lifestyle
4. Do not drive.
Any insight is greatly appreciated. Thanks!!

Legato Hi All, Does anyone got recently selected at Legato and waiting for the HR to call? I was told last week that HR would call and I haven’t received any call or email

Just registered for WAATBP end of this month and am looking forward to it!

like

McKinsey & Company What is McKinsey’s policy for Green Card applications? Do they initiate the process right away or is there a tenure requirement?

McKinsey & Company

like

List the college you went to. When you graduated. How much you pay monthly on student loans and when you think you will be done.

like

Hi everyone, I currently work at IndusInd Bank. I have 1.5 years of working experience in bancassurance. I am looking for a change. I have decent proficiency in MS Excel, Word and PowerPoint. Can anyone help me out??

like

Any ideas for a 40th bday venue? Dinner with a good vibe and lounge after? Did MaD last year for him and they had a semi private but still very much in the mix for 15 people. I honestly can’t think of what to do but he’s bougieAF. Steak48 is an option. Looking for any other cool things you’ve hosted or attended lately?

like

Anyone noticing their feet getting super cold? Room temperature is at 76f, body is also at regular temperature. Feeling perfectly fine otherwise.

like

Hi fishes, I just joined PWC SDC kolkata, so how is the work culture and the work life balance here...any insights!!!

The hours I’m working right now to meet a deadline are extreme, I’m only getting a few hours of sleep a night. How do you keep yourself alert during that final push?

like

Any thoughts on Strategy& and their life sciences team? How is the reputation in comparison to Life sciences focused places such as LEK, ClearView, ZS, IQVIA, etc? How is the WLB? And what is the compensation for a senior associate?

like

How feasible is it to transition out of compliance into legal practice?

like

Has anyone used SoFi to pay down credit card debt? I am drowning in interest every month with my BofA card and getting nowhere fast. Would love any advice re: SoFi or paying off credit card debt in general. Thank you!

like

DFW area - when will the rain stopppppp?

Post Photo
like

Anyone trying to travel to India and using united, looking for upgrade, please DM me.

like

Do you know what is the salary range for a Senior Manager II at Walmart Home Office?

like

Have a phone interview with Amazon for a sr technical program manager. Does anyone have advice or a heads up for what I’m walking into?

Additional Posts in Strategy & Planning

What brands are you really into at the moment? Would be great to think about and be inspired by those doing a great job!

What is your 5 year plan?

like

Wondering if anyone has a good example of a brand that originally sold a commodity/mass food and successfully introduced a premium/luxury line, under the same brand name. Kicker is the brand has to have started as mass then gone upmarket, nor vice versa.

like

Thoughts on VCCP London for strategy?

like

Honestly what's your thoughts on brand purpose? I have a concept that I'm presenting this week which is heavily based on a good cause but connected to the brand.

like

How common is it for a strategist to have a website/portfolio?

helpful

Has anyone ever worked with Mark Pollard or Julian Cole? Are they as great as they seem?

likefunny

I’d like to be a CSO one day. If you’re there, what helped you get there? If you’re climbing that organizational hierarchy what are you doing to prove you’re an asset?

like

Starting to think about making the switch from agency to brand side. Any tips from strategists who have already made the jump? And is there a level at which it makes the most sense (i.e. should I wait until I make Director and then make the switch, or does it not really matter)?

like

Thoughts on Eli Lilly/anyone open to sharing their experience and salary there? interviewing for AD level in media strategy - would be working out of nyc if that matters

where my mid 40s and up peeps at? where you working and what are your next career moves? life moves?

like

Can anyone recommend a good headhunter that has experience in placing agency strategists on the client side (not just agency only)?

likehelpful

Looking for strategy roles in Michigan (or telecommute opportunities)

like

Looking for reccommendations on best books on strategy and planning. Would like to get re-inspired and learn something new.

like

Anyone have any good diversity training resources?

like

What blogs, podcasts, twitter accounts, newsletters etc. should ever planner follow?

like

You're seen as a"job hopper" and decide no matter what, you're committing to this new job for at least two years. feeling super dedicated no matter what. Then they start making you do illegal sht.

like

I’m honestly tired of being at an agency and not feeling as fulfilled as I used with strategy as a career. Have anyone here make a career change? if so, what other jobs out there - outside of agencies and client side - can you apply what you know as a strategist? Curious if anyone has done it and has some advice.

like

Top agencies to complete an internship in Detroit area?

I'm thinking of moving strategy side, best bootcamps or programs to take? Assuming the company pays for it of course

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal