Does anyone talk about economic diversity? You know middle class and economically challenged people who cannot afford art schools and expensive private colleges?

likeuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I talk about it and agree that people from varying socio-economic backgrounds are a a value add to the D&I conversation. Though obviously unlike other points of diversity, it’s not necessarily visible. I would caution against equating economic disadvantage with the ability to attend expensive private colleges—spoken from a lower middle class kid who happened to be fortunate enough (for a host of reasons) to benefit from elite academic institutions.

like

Same as diversity imo. Most black students can't afford ad schools/aren't aware of opportunities in advertising for economic/financial reasons.

like

I do think the school pool you choose as a talent pipeline will effect that. I've been trying to get my company to build connections other than USC / UCLA which are great schools, but aren't that diverse or representative of Los Angeles. Cal States get overlooked, but CSUN and CSULA have student populations that better represent Los Angeles demographics.

I think another potential incentive employers can use is to help people pay their student loans. Financial stress can seriously effect your life and your work. Companies that invest more in their people will see better results. Culturally there has to be a shift as well because higher income people can be real oblivious and ignorant to how the rest of us live.

like

OP: If you're bringing up economic disparities then you have to acknowledge the racial wealth gap. If you're doing your part, then you should do research to make sure you're helping and not hurting by spreading inaccurate information. The issue is racial and classist. There are many people of color who didn't go to $150k schools but aren't considered to work in these fields because they didn't. And even when they do, it doesn't make it easier for them to enter and advance. If you're interested on hearing different perspectives, you should listen to the Mixed Company podcast.

smartlike

A handful of things—I think we need to be clear that race and class, particularly in America, are inextricably bound—nearly 1/4 black Americans (and 1/5 latin(x)) live in poverty, compared to ~ 1/10 of white Americans—in spite of their proportional representation in the population. We cannot separate the two and obviously, these facts inform the tenor of this conversation. What I do think is significant, and that is something law firms and other industries have also struggled with, is the concept of recruiting from the 'top’ schools with no heed paid to the lack of diversity within these schools or the people they ultimately enroll. That said, OP, your suggestions of recruiting at smaller, more diverse regional schools makes perfect sense.

like

*looksaround* From where I'm standing, it's definitely a race issue.

My biggest issue with diversity conversations is how folks tiptoe around topics so as not to "offend" or "alienate" dear white people.

like

All good points and this is not a race issue. There are challenges for all humans. It’s naive to think or state otherwise. That said yeah. The big schools are great, but hell even 30 years ago those schools were way out of reach for me. Now it’s insanity. That someone pays or gets a loan for a 150k education with the only guarantee of a degree. Film schools are even worse. Of course then there are the kids that get or learn their career in college. Having never met anyone in film or advertising and. It even knowing that it’s ‘a thing’. Meaning they have no idea it’s a real job. Until college and sometimes afterwards. I’d love for someone to spearhead as someone suggested reaching out to smaller schools. I am doing my part. With posts like this and asking this very questions across a wide spectrum.
Cheers

like

This topic is economic diversity though. Yes there is racial diversity. I know that and it’s not what I am discussing. Point being there are all types of humans that come from disadvantage. It’s a bit elitist to say it’s only a race issues. And elitist to say I’m not considering that, especially when I never have.

uplifting

Speak on it !

@Nadia. Okay, not equating. Simply stating that it's clearly linked. Singular instances don't change a narrative.

Related Posts

MBA background check: do they do detailed reviews of your essays? Like check anecdotes? Some of my verb choices likely give myself a bit more strict than I deserve. Do they call other managers?

funny

How long is too long to take off from GMAT? Spent~8 months on it plus working while living alone and think it’s started to take its toll (panic attacks, etc.). Need to get up ~30 points or so and thinking of getting healthy/deferring application to next year.

like

What kind of scores do folks target for the AWA section of GMAT? My writing is way below average (like a 2/6 on a good day), so just wondering how much time I should spend on AWA compared to other sections

like

What are the common reasons that applications to vet school get denied?

like

Do any firms in the forensics world offer to pay for MBAs?

like

Do GRE essay scores matter as much?

like

Looking for feedback on two opportunities and which opportunity would be better for my application for a M7 school in 2 years. 1) Stay at T2 consulting firm (already 2 YOE) and continue towards firm sponsorship 2) Take a substantial pay increase, go to a family office, and own more E2E work with direct contact with family (w/ no MBA sponsorship). Appreciate any advice! TIA

like

Have all SC justices really been from Harvard or Yale??!

like

If anyone needs a private tutor let me know. She tutors and has a great track record. She’s a u Chicago wharton grad and cfa

like

Anyone know if military experience prior to undergrad counts towards the 8 years of experience needed for the EA for Business school?

like

Hello London folk. There’s a lot of great chat about diversity in adland on fishbowl, but it’s all very US based. So I’ve just started a bowl on diversity in London specifically - 9qo8f

like
like

Anyone have any good diversity training resources?

like

Is MBA from upgrad worth??

Accountability correlates with Responsibility in this way: When a person accepts personal responsibility for how his/her actions and decisions impact and influence the lives of others, said person holds him-/herself accountable and accepts being accountable to others for the equity and inclusion (or lack thereof) in their spheres of influence.

Hello everyone, this bowl is just the start. We will make it big. Request you to stay here after joining. Meanwhile, do share this in your network. It would be a great help.

Till the time this bowl is growing, you can post confessions, advice, requests etc.

Use the format:
Age, Gender[M,F or any other]
Then your post.

like

General question: Is there any room in corporate America for real, actionable DE&I discussions and initiatives? I've observed so many corporate versions become an advertising strategy (SM posts, diversity reports) without doing the actual work (increasing representation in senior leadership, salary analyses, having an effective reporting system for bias). Is this just how it is?

like

From the moderator, for discussion.

Should white males be concerned that current focus on diversity will lead to negative results

If Yes, why and under what conditions
If No, why not?

like

Hello Everyone. Please does anyone know where I can go for practicum(kind of like clinical) to conclude my MSN in Nursing informatics. I am located in houston and I am currently attending Chamberlain university. Thanks in-advance.

like

More Posts

Hope you guys are getting recharged during (hopefully) your non-busy season! :)

like

When your best is never good enough 🙏

like

Hi All, just joined. Looking for some salary feedback. I am a risk analyst/credit analyst working for BMO. I working in commercial lending. I am in my fourth year of working post University. I currently make a base salary of $75K plus a 12% bonus. Looking to get salary insight on other roles/companies in this field of work.

like

Hi,
Can anyone let me know the working numbers of Accenture support team. I received laptop and trying to do the setup but facing some issues. The numbers that they have mentioned is not working. The numbers are not valid it says.

Thanks

like

What’s it like to be working at Droga5 lately? Any insights/personal experiences would be helpful

like

At this point in the game it doesn't make a difference where you at everybody is getting laid off at one point or another the only thing I say is try to repair yourself for it if it happens to you

like

What are your favorite suppliments to give students for lessons covering Civil Rights?

Need serious career advice about two jobs prospects. DM me please

like

How much hike can I expect if I joined citiustech in Oct last year and got 3.75 rating?
Yoe - 4

like

#LinkedInProfile

EY Tata Consultancy Infosys Deloitte Accenture

Post Photo
likefunny

Got screamed at again by my partner today. The other partners are wonderful. Glad I've been talking to a couple of recruiters as I'm now officially ready to move. Sigh😕.

like

I struggle with perfectionism and anxiety and this job seems to not help. How can I learn to be less of a perfectionist in a job that highly rewards this kind of behavior?

like

Are any of you aware of good therapeutic schools for high school kids in the South Eastern US? Looking for a recommendation for a boy who has anxiety and ODD. Thank you.

like

As an ADC applying this summer for 2022 start, I haven’t gotten a chance to connect with any L.E.K. Consulting members and I really want to get to know the company better before moving on with my application. Any L.E.K. Consulting fish out there willing to spare a few minutes to chat about their work, the company, the culture etc? Thanks!

like

Anyone know of a great freelance sales person in the F&B trade space?

Post Photo
like

Anyone want to try and go to top golf this coming Friday night or Saturday night? Thinking the Mount Laurel location but Philadelphia works too.

like

Has anyone successfully sold your gently used clothing for cash on the spot anywhere in Chicagoland? If yes, where? Have a lot of nice stuff that I’m bored of but Poshmark takes too much effort for me and I find consignment stores usually take months until anything sells and then getting your money is a pain. So looking for instant cash. TIA

like

How is it to work as NetSuite developer in Capgemini?

like

Has anyone heard of TechGC/DeputyGC? Thoughts on membership?

like

Additional Posts in A Diversity & Inclusion Workshop

Hi, Nadia!:) What's your perspective on white fragility? I'm a white immigrant who grew up shielded from racism in a homogeneous society and want to help white people deal with their fragility but...

like
likesmart

Does anyone else feel a lack of trust at work? A lack of trust in your judgement, reasoning, ideas etc...

How do you navigate that, other than proving yourself repeatedly?

Feeling very discouraged.

like

Does anyone have experience confronting workplace inequality? Any lawyer recommendations? Things to say/not say?

I don’t trust HR and I don’t know what to do.

I feel like this has what may be new info to some (of us):

Post Photo
like

Why is this so true and so known? Agencies are only giving lip service to this, but not taking real action. So what advice do you have for people struggling with this day in and day out?

Post Photo
like

Is the one D&I professional in this business that hasn’t had to create a grassroots movement?

As someone who isn't a PoC I'm always unsure of how I should refer to others correctly. First question:

African American vs Black - what is more accepted?

like

Hi people,

check out the Black in advertising bowl
https://joinfishbowl.com/bowl_t6agpu .
I saw a ton of job postings in there, might be a good place to post any positions we hear about.

like

Thinking about the NFL today and that I really don't want to work on anything connected to football. Given how dangerous we know this sport is I don't feel right supporting it. (Continued in comments)

like

Good people, it’s time to bid y’all farewell. Thank you 🙏🏾 Please keep this conversation going with each other and at your agencies. Will post a recap in a bit. Holler at me for anything at all—nadia@culturecipher.org.✌🏾

likeupliftinghelpful

Is there a Latinos in advertising bowl?!

like

Nadia, your Unconscious Bias training was so incredibly impactful for me and my team!! Brilliant. So stoked to see this crucial conversation on here. So many questions!

like

I’m sad that instead of showing that there are no differences between human beings, we are advocating for races (what I understand it is very necessary). Just afraid that will create more division.

like

I notice that your “visual identity” for this workshop represents different sexes and different cultures - but no older people - who are now bearing the brunt of ageism. Why have we been left out?

like

Day 1 of Glenn Singleton's Courageous Conversations About Race training today actually rocked my world. So many things I've never talked about or even considered talking about just bubbled up. 😱

like

We are a small shop of 10 and are sorely lacking any people of color on our team. How do we recruit interest without coming right out and asking for POC to apply?

like

How do you have a conversation with someone that makes an unknowingly inappropriate or insensitive comment that not only impacts you but others around your office?

like

I am a POC and just recently got pushed out of my new role. They told me I wasn't a good fit and failed to meet job requirements. Struggling to understand whether I was let go bc of my work ethic or

like

Based on your experiences, what are 1 or 2 traits that a company/ leadership has that allows diversity to be celebrated & encouraged. How does this affect employees (Black/non-Black) in & out of work?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal