Would McKinsey give you a harder case interview if you asked for a salary that was higher than what they'd prepared to offer?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

If you asked for a salary before you did your interview, I would be surprised if they actually gave you an offer.

like

If they asked me for my salary expectations before the final round, I'd be surprised if people think that you're half as smart as you think you are BCG1

like

I think McK's salaries are fixed nationally

like

MBB usually has pretty set non-negotiable salaries by level and bonus based on performance (partner level gets more complicated). Possible there's some room to negotiate on what level you come in, but MBB in my experience tends to be pretty inflexible on that too - they decide based on your experience, generally a step or two backwards for non-MBB hires from a 'tenure' perspective.

like

50%*(infinity)^(infinity)....= ???

like

Not sure what McKinsey would do, but we would come up with a hypothesis for your level based on resume. Your interviewers would test that hypothesis, which might mean a harder case or just higher expectations for how you would perform. If your salary expectations exceed the level hypothesis, we would probe in that direction in the interview.

like

I've heard a lot about the standard salaries but have also heard that experienced hires can negotiate. Not sure this is addressing the question about the interview difficulty / scrutiny yet.

Interviewers have the same case they use for everyone.

That's what I figured. Thanks.

Yes. You'd better be worth it.

ACN- how's you get the interview

I negotiated as an experienced hire but agree re coming in a level or 2 below where I was. Also, not a generalist consultant.

I have never heard of anyone negotiating a salary at mckinsey. Best of luck, but that's a battle I'm pretty sure you will lose. There is no incentive for the firm to pay differently at entry points unless you have a very specific skill that can't be gotten anywhere else.

Yep, very specific industry background here.

Don't think you can negotiate like that..

They're going to make me an offer but demanding to know my current salary. I don't want to tell them because Accenture has me low balled. What to do?

Lie

Then say "my salary expectations are..." and fill in the blank

Already did that and declined to provide my current salary. Now they're asking again.

Someone from McK should chime in, but here's why we would be asking. We'd want to make sure there wasn't a significant misalignment of expectations. If you wanted / previously were paid 50% more than we were prepared to offer, we would want to know that so we could manage expectations. We wouldn't use a prior low salary to low ball you if you clearly fit into a certain level that was ordinarily paid much more.

I obviously can't speak to McK. And given you already gave salary requirements, it might not be the same reason.

Related Posts

Should I join Dallas KPMG or RSM in Dallas for audit senior position?

like

Hi Fishes,

I am S4 ABAP developer having 9+ years of experience. I have HR round today. How much should I negotiate with HR. What's the standard package given by Wipro for 9+ years exp. Please guide.

like

I have got an offer from CTS for 13.6 + 1 JB.

And from IRIS for 16.5(fixed).

How do I negotiate with CTS now?

My joining date in CTS is 2nd Nov.

CTS

like

What would be a reasonable salary for a 3rd year lawyer in house at a real estate development company with a total of 3 lawyers (they are co-gcs for different parts of the company)? I’d be the 4th lawyer in the department as a whole. HCOL area.

like

Anybody here at Barclays Corporate Banking in NYC? Need advice and numbers..

like

Hi fishes, Can anyone tell me what is the salary offered for Monitoring Analyst II ( L23) in Paypal. I have 6 yrs of experience in same domain . How much to expect and ask

How high can google go on signing bonus ( currently $25k) and equity (currently $65k) for L4 position.. total exp 4 years .. should I negotiate?

like

How much do operational managers make at P.E forms?

like

Hello, what is the going salary for a chief of staff in technology?

Can anyone share their experience as an Aldi Store Manager? Mixed reviews on Glassdoor and Indeed.

likehelpful

How's the hike folks !!

like

Hi,
I have 5 yoe with frontend and 7.5 total yoe .
What can be demanded for Staff engineering position ?

like

Does Boston Consulting have an M&A and Private Equity Practice? Based on company webpage this is not quite clear…perhaps it is not a main focus as it is with, perhaps, Bain? Or the competencies are integrated within the practices of BCG?

like

People who got 10% hike being in that CTC that was alloted to them 2 years ago when they joined!!

Post Photo
like

How much package should a data engineer get for 3 year exp?

like

How much are new hires in advisory making now in Ny? Just curios to see how much it went up since I started 3 years ago

like

Do we get any confirmation mail once we accept offer in Accenture portal?

like

How is the United States Delivery center? They are recruiting me for that. Good or bad? anything to be aware of?

like

What's the difference between SaT and Consulting?
What exactly is the difference in their work?

like

More Posts

like

Hi everyone, if you have got an offer from Big4 in UK, can you please share your base salary, core skill, designation and YOE?

like

Has anyone worked at or heard of Rev Health in NJ? Wondering what the culture and work/life balance is like there.

like

What's the salary offered for SAP Technical Consultant with YOE 5 or more ?

like

When will the salary be credited in Optum.

like
like

If I take a job at Amazon in India, is it considered as prestigious to FAANG companies as Amazon in Silicon Valley?

like

Has an ALM in Management at Harvard Extension School led you to a career at any high power corporations such as Goldman Sachs?

like

What certifications can I earn to increase my market value coming out of college? I’m graduating with a marketing and digital applications co-major and I have 2 HubSpot certs (Digital Advertising and Social Media Marketing) + relevant internships. I’m just trying really hard to get over 50K in Indianapolis (I sincerely can’t afford to accept anything lower) and being a new grad seems to REALLY be working against me no matter what I do. Help :(

like

DM for refferal in IBM
#cloud
#QA
#UI
#Reactjs

like

Can anybody please provide me referal for mercedes benz.

Dm me for connecting further.

like

Opinions on AbleTo?

like

What is the salary of Sr. consultant 2 and Sr. consultant 3 in ey?

like

McKinsey Fish - how is the periscope solution/team regarded internally? Haven’t found much about it anecdotally and would love to learn more. Thanks in advance!

like
like

Hi everyone,

Sharing one incident.
One of TOP MNC offered me 18 lpa . I got counter offer of 28 lpa from CG .
Today I called that TOP MNC same. They asked me to share screenshot - I shared . Now they are asking complete offer letter of CG but I denied as I feel this is not right to share docs.

Kindly share your views.

What is the experience required to become senior manager in US taxation

Additional Posts in Consulting

Why do people hate Deloitte so much? I’ve been considering taking a job offer there and pretty much everyone at D that I’ve spoken to has advised me against it. What’s going on there Deloitte 🐠s?

like

What is the best consultancy for Media and Entertainment work? Considering a move…

like

Are any top consulting firms hiring for experienced analysts currently? I know ACN and some others are cyclical for resources 2-3 years out of college, but I’m looking to make a move sooner than fall

like

Book recommendations on leadership, career development, etc?

like

After getting kicked out of McK late last year, this gives me schadenfreude 🤣

Post Photo
likefunny

Not sure if I am getting laid off. What are some key signs. Thanks in advance for your help?

like

Flying into O’hare... longest short week of life. Anyone kind enough to pass on a United drink voucher?

like

OTS is growing rapidly and leadership has asked us SMs to assist with recruiting. One of our needs is for cybersecurity and data privacy consultants interested in M&A e.g. CISSP, CISA, CIPP, CIPM, etc

like

Hertz bringing the heat today! 😲

Post Photo
likefunny

Can anyone recommend a good resume/cover letter review or writing agency? Either digital or in NYC
I’m not getting the response I’d like from my applications and want to try switching it up

like

Happy Fly Day Friends!

Post Photo
likehelpful

Post MBA career goals that do not involve returning to consulting (or banking)?

like

Strategies for work/life balance? Especially while traveling? Thanks!

like

Hot take. Is FAANG even a thing? Or was Cramer just worried about the acronym if he took out Netflix?

likefunnysmart

When you find out your peers are compensated more even though your rating and utilization is higher :(

like

Recommendations for comprehensive books on the finance industry? I want to learn more about investment banking and modern financial instruments. Got a lot of free time during this lockdown

like

Pwc new ventures. Anyone have experience in this group? I'd love to chat

like

Tax question: I had a traditional ira which I moved to my employer 401k recently. I’m planning to do an after tax 401k to ira conversion. Would prorata rule apply since I had a traditional ira balance earlier this calendar year?

like

Hey 🐟 fam. I’m starting a new gig next week that’s 90% WFH. I’d love some recommendations on a second monitor. Nothing crazy pricy, but something that’ll work well with my MacBook Pro. Thanks y’all.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal