Would you take a job that pays you 25k more a year if you had to do an hour long commute both ways? Or the school that you can walk to for 25k less? And no, relocation is not an option. (For those who need more details, one salary is about $65k and the other is about $90k as a 5th year teacher.)

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

In Michigan the commute would unavoidably be on roads that are icy and/or snowy for a significant number of drives.
It wouldn't just be the time, it would literally be the risk.

likehelpfulsmart

I’m feeling similarly even though we don’t have snow. The drivers are crazy and the road I have to take to commute is a windy mountain road infamous for crashes. (And it actually did get snow for the first time in decades this year!)

like

I found an hour long drive a very good way to decompress in the afternoon (when I drove by myself..not so much with kids) I could blast music and be fully present by the time I got home.
on the way to work and hour drive isnt as much fun though

I guess it depends on if you like to drive and if it is an area that has a lot of traffic or if you are not on busy roads

like
Recent IconRecent

No brainer! 90,000 and you can be yourself at home!

likefunny

I feel like that'd be a really great opportunity for you! I drive 40 minutes to my job and I've been doing so for years!

like

Might be worth it for a few years, but over time commuting takes a toll on your health. When I was commuting an hour each way a few years ago, I got severe sciatica from constantly being in my car. So just be prepared for legitimate health (and psychological) effects of traffic on your quality of life

likesmart

Agree, it’s okay short term. Once kids came though my time became too valuable and I could no longer tolerate an hour or more commute.

like

I commuted for many years an hour each way. It gave me think time. I’d do it in a heartbeat.

like

It depends on the drive. I drive 50 miles each way for 7 years and it did a seriously toll on me. It was necessary but I wouldn’t go back no matter what they paid me.
It also depends on the drive. Is it 15 miles (and hr in traffic) or 60 miles of steady traffic?

likesmarthelpful

I’d only do it if there wasn’t traffic or weather conditions if it was a 2 hour-per-day commute. Those two factors would drop in importance if it was only 1 hour per day. Everyone makes those microeconomic decisions differently. I will say that my 60 mile commute for 3 years put way too many miles on a new car. I had 100,000 miles on it in just a few years and I still had payments. Ugh!

like

I would take the $90K job if I could live close enough to drive to work.

like

I'm confused by your response. The original post stated that it would be a 1-hour commute each way and that relocating isn't an option.

like

Also consider that the increase in salary translates to higher retirement contribution. Could come in handy...

like

Yes and that additional money adds up with salary increases each year!

Is it in a different district? If so, it would affect your retirement and you might be stuck doing the commute for years whether you want to or not. After you pay a little more in taxes on the $25,000, the rest goes to time and wear and tear and gas.

like

Sorry, I’m thinking wrong, it’s the state that would be in charge of your years counted toward retirement. But will you be vested in your new district? Is there any risk of being let go?

like

Take the money. If you need to leave later and the new job says why did you leave? I left for the money.

like

Or left for the commute?

On a side note, it might depend on how close I was to retirement, the future steps and increases, etc.

I get a pension and it is based on my three highest years of pay. If I only had to make the commute for maybe three to five years but it not only increased my salary while teaching but what I was seeing in my pension? Then yeah, I might suck it up.

Similarly, I would look at the pay schedule for each district five years down the road. Right now you would be making $25,000 more. What would be the difference in five years?

like

I would now (I like my 25 minute commute and wouldn't mind the extra driving) but I would not have when my own children were younger. The little time you get with your kids is so precious.

like

I've lived where I could walk to work. The harassment thrown at me and my kids was not worth it.

like

Interesting perspective!

like

Nope. That drive is crazy. I did it for a year and never again.

likehelpful

My current salary plus $25K? I'm in.

like

It depends on the other factors that come along w it. Are the benefits the same? Is the actual work load more? Do they expect you to fulfill extra duties? Are the admin up your ass even more? How Mmuch are you going to spend in gas’s every year?

likehelpful

I would stay were I was if I liked it. Commuting is not worth any amount to me.

like

I would stay! By the time you consider price of gas and vehicle upkeep, along with exhausting yourself more, I'd say it isn't worth it!

like

I hate driving. 25 mins is the max. I commuted 20 mins. Now it takes me 2 mins to walk to school.

like

Oh - that might be TOO close. I would feel like I had to attend everything and like any and everything I did could always be seen by admin, coworkers, students, parents...

like

About $25 in gas per day. You probably make about $50 an hour so if your time is worth that, it’s another $100 per day. 180 work days times $125 per day is $22,500. If you don’t value your time, you are only out $4500 in gas money. At this time in my life, I value my time too much to take that gig.

likehelpful

You teach math?

like

Related Posts

How is IBM GBS Nordcloud division.
How is IBM these days in terms of job security.
Is offered ctc is too high as per current market ?

Role: Infrastructure specialist Azure
YOE: 7 years 9 month
Offered CTC: 17 LPA.
Skill: Azure ,devops,linux ,kubernetes.

like

Please suggest in terms of learning, job security and work life balance which organisation to go for in the current time from the below offers...
Thanks in advance for your valuable suggestions.

TabSquare (22 fixed+ 1.5 variable)
Zensar (20 fixed+ 1 joining bonus)
Rightpoint (22 fixed+ 1 joining bonus)
Accolite digital (PKG not confirmed, estimated 24 fix + 1 joining bonus)

Tech stack Frontend Developer (react js, JavaScript, HTML5 and CSS3)

like

YOE : 6 yrs
CCTC: 17.62 lpa fixed
How much PWC AC can give to me?
Holding an offer of 23 lpa..
Please help guys...

like

Hi guys
I am from EY india
I have declared my investments in tax declaration portal , still I see in monthly salary that there is huge tax deduction.
In my previous organization, once I declared my investments in the tax portal , then my salary was very less affected by tax deduction.
But in ey india , I don't see any effect after declaring my investments.
Kindly help me how to declare investments so that there will be less tax deductions from my salary .
#EYINDIA

like

What is the Salary bracket one should expect from Big 4 for 5.5 years experience in Data Engineering?

like

What is the variable/bonus component percentage in Fidelity?

Received offer from Capgemini with approx 45% hike as Team Manager (C1), my current designation is AM here at TCS, is it good to accept the offer? All suggestions are welcome ...

like

Deloitte India I am confused which one to join below are the offers i am looking for job security and good projects
YOE: 3.2 & Tech Stack: JAVA, SELENIUM
Nagarro (14 LAC including 5% variable)
Deloitte India (12 LAC + 1 Lac Jb)
HCL Technologies(15.5 LAC)
TSYS (14 LAC) (will make till 15)
global payments Infosys Newco Tata Consultancy Deloitte

like

Does PWC accepts counter offer easily when produced other offer letter with more CTC?

like

What should be the average Senior software Engineer python salary??

like

I’m starting to think regardless where you go (agency side) the work will be there along with the politics and bs. Should we always base our next move with compensation as number 1 deciding factor?

like

Recently got an offer for 80k at Morgan Stanley as a customer service associate. Can anyone provide some insight on where this offer lands (high low) in the entry level/csa marketplace? Located in a major city

like

What should be the expected salary package in Wipro ? 6.7 yoe

like

At what point in my career as a receptionist should I consider asking for a raise? After one year? After five?

like

Salary check . Please add so we can compare . Amount , City would be helpful

likehelpful

Base/Equity expectations for Series A Fintech (non engineering leadership role) in the Bay Area? 10 YoE. Thinking about a move but trying to understand the risk/reward.

like

No hike like last year ?!

likesmart

Negotiating a settlement. I’m at $10k, opposing counsel is at $20k. My client won’t go higher than $15k. OC has come down to 17.5k and says his client won’t budge from that. Do I offer 12.5k so we can hopefully meet in the middle at 15k? Is that how the settlement game is played? Seems dumb we can’t just say let’s meet in the middle now and be done with this. (I’m a first year, first time negotiating a settlement on my own and I don’t want to screw this up!)

like
like

More Posts

After 10 rounds of interviews for a TPM position the recruiter says he will set me up for team alignment, and then take it to HC for a decision. Is this the normal process? Isnt HC decision done first

I am moving to Bucks County, PA in a few months after my graduation. My dream is to open a bookstore but for now I want to find a job in one. Does anyone have recommendations for places hiring? Do you have a recommendation about interviewing for a bookstore job?

like

Hi everyone. I have an interview with Cisco for their product manager SSO role, Has anyone interviewed for this role or with company, what kind of question are expected in their process. Thanks

like

Can you be a brand strategist and hate competitive reviews? Today’s philosophical pondering

like

Need help settling a debate with my friend. She thinks I will have an easier time getting research grants because I'm male. I think it's the opposite because companies are trying to change the status quo and get more women involved (which I'm not complaining about... please don't attack me.) Which one of us is more right than the other? I'm interested in getting as many viewpoints as possible, whether or not they agree with me or with her. Thanks!!!

like

Is it possible to transfer from CN India to Accenture Canada (if one gets a Canadian PR themselves)? How well is it taken by the leadership and is any kind of support provided?

likehelpful

I don’t get the hype about the new Spider-Man movie. Yes, it’s a good one, but why do people think it’s the best one yet? Am I missing something?

like

W south beach or Ritz Carlton Fort Lauderdale?

like

Best noise-canceling headphones that are comfy when worn for a few hours? Thank you in advance!

like

Hi Everyone!
Could someone refer me to Spotify in Program Mgmt? I have 3 yrs of experience. Please let me know 😬

like

No hike like last year ?!

likesmart

Negotiating a settlement. I’m at $10k, opposing counsel is at $20k. My client won’t go higher than $15k. OC has come down to 17.5k and says his client won’t budge from that. Do I offer 12.5k so we can hopefully meet in the middle at 15k? Is that how the settlement game is played? Seems dumb we can’t just say let’s meet in the middle now and be done with this. (I’m a first year, first time negotiating a settlement on my own and I don’t want to screw this up!)

like

Transactional associate. Lateraled 6 months ago and one of the biggest pain points has been my new firm’s inclination to “hop on a call”, which of course requires every single stakeholder to join. The end result being every call has 25 people on it and nothing actually gets done because no one wants to ask a question that could come off as silly. It’s destroying my ability to get anything done during the day. It’s a complete performance and it drives me nuts.

like

I am sick of seeing these SPG Marriott posts!! Can we talk about something else for a change?

likeuplifting

Does anyone ever redeem Marriott points for gift cards? Is it worth it?

like

Brand new single post divorce. Was with ex almost 18 years and never dated as an adult. What the hell am I in for? 35f.

Would you consider transfer pricing a high value tax service? I always thought it was compliance focused...

like

Is it normal to feel depressed/lonely during wedding planning? I almost feel like I can’t talk about it since other people aren’t engaged and I feel like I’m rubbing it in their faces talking about it. So I have to keep everything to myself and it’s kind of stressful

like

Do we observe a holiday on 1st November?

like

Hello seeking referrals for consultant roles. Have ~1 YOE in healthcare consulting and previous RA experience as well. TIA

like

Additional Posts in Teachers

Tis the season...
Anyone else have a love/hate relationship with NOAA?

Post Photo
like

I am the president of our school board at Franklin Country School Corporation in Brookville, In. I would like to start a NASA Stem project starting in school year 2022-2023. Does anyone know where I need to start?

likehelpful

Anyone here ever been to RCA? Is it worth it ?

like

What's your experience working with United Way?

like

@McGraw Hill any idea on salary for academic design roles ?

likehelpful

I read this super interesting article about how big companies like Toyota are investing in social-emotional training for their employees and seeing massive benefits. I actually think this could be a whole separate class for students of all ages. Learning about conflict resolution, growing your own self-regulation skills...it's really important.

likeupliftingsmart

Today Pfizer announced that trials show that their vaccine is 100% effective for teens ages 12-15. Do you think most of our students will get it for next year?

likehelpful

Western nc CTE interview questions? How do I prepare?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal