Asked for feedback at the end of a case interview today and was told the interviewer isn't allowed to give feedback. Is that typical?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

It was poor judgement to ask.

like

Yes. Interviewers are never allowed to provide direct feedback for liability reasons

like

Depends on firm. Oliver Wyman gives feedback.

My company tells me not to provide feedback as well. (Aka always defer to HR)

Ok, so it at least wasn't inappropriate to ask?

It doesn’t necessarily mean anything by itself anyway. Maybe you did do well on the case, but you bombed the behavioral or vice versa. Whether you get an offer depends on multiple inputs.

Depends on the level at which you are interviewing

What level were you interviewing for?

Related Posts

Hi Folks
How many rounds of interview conducted at Oracle for SeniorSystem Administrator position?
I have cleared first round . But they are telling there are other rounds too. I am curious please clarify if anyone from Oracle or recently joined .

like

What can I expect from EY’s case interview? Senior consultant position for Business Transformation. TIA

like

Hey ,I applied 3 weeks ago to Bank of America USA ,with a decent resume and referral. But still did not heard back.Need a human eye who is willing to check my application and help me moving to the next step? Bank of America USA. I'm based in NY.

likehelpful

Can anyone confirm, if hpe take Hacker Rank test for senior cloud professional after 2-3 rounds of interview

How high does L6 range typically go for Sr Program Manager roles? I am currently at ~250k TC and the position they were interviewing me for hand a max range of 200k TC. Is >300k TC possible?

like

Hello Googlers - I have a Business System Analysts interview coming up really soon. Any last minute advice that I can use?

like

Should I be bringing a hard copy of my resume to an on campus interview day?

like

Any tips on how to get started on prepping for VC interviews

like
like

Hello all,
I joined Accenture today. When can I expect project interview. What should I expect. Your inputs are appreciated. Thank you.

like
like

Did anyone here have Managerial round after submission of documents in Capgemini? If yes, did you clear it and receive offer letter on time?

like

Help me to clear me cvent customer service round

Been searching for work for about 2 months now, and I can’t tell what companies are looking for anymore. I have 2+ years as an AE full cycle. And I get rejected left and right. My resume is up to date, I’m applying non stop, what else can I do?

like

Accenture Can someone give me an idea of what an L9 vs L10 salary would look like for AFS Cyber? 1.5ish YOE, final interview coming up. Thank you!

like

My Accenture recruiter told me that in order to revise my current offer she would need to reject my current offer first and no need to worry on that part. Is this normal? Please provide genuine feedback.

like

So I've had 2 hiring managers and several recruiters from Amazon reach out to me about applying for some open positions with the company (android). I completed the coding assessment and now they want me to go through a round of 5 hour interviews next week. Is there a good chance I'll be hired if engineering managers are reaching out to me? I'm really not sure how badly I want to work for them and I don't want to be laid off months after being hired on. Anyone know what Amazon hiring is like?

like

Me: 4.5 years in audit, Big 4, interviewed and accepted an offer in industry. You can let me know if your background differs and I can help tailor my responses to you.

like

How does a panel interview feel like? Is there anything that I should be prepare for it? Any tips?

like

More Posts

My kids were really upset with me when I told them that my job as an engineer did not mean that I drove trains for a living

like

Fis mohali is now permanent wfh, they've closed it down

like

Anyone here know anything about Cope Health Solutions? Recruiter reached out about Manager level job. Looking for something that is faster paced than my current job but not as poor on work life balance as my previous role at Deloitte.

like

Is this bowl active?

like

Really struggling with attrition right now and we seem to be a cycle of countering people, trying to keep governance but being reactive! Any ideas on a reward strategy which enables us to be flexible when we need it but retain a degree of control so it doesn’t get out of control?

like

I am trying to land a role as a human resources business partner and I'm wondering which certification would be the best for me going forward. Phr? Shrm? Thoughts? Thanks!

like

It's getting extremely difficult to get a reservation nowadays. Does anyone feel the same?

like

Slalom 🐟: what types of work and industries can one work in Austin and Chicago? Looking to move to a firm with better work/life balance.

like

Why doesn’t Accenture give an inflation relief bonus like every other consulting firm?

funnylike

Do you ever find your mind wandering during Salah? I used to pray regularly when I was younger, fell off a bit over the last few years and am trying to get back to it.

like

Hello My real friends,

Hope everyone is doing good How much will be in hand salary any idea.

Accenture Amazon Accenture India Boston Consulting Group Cognizant CGI Dell Deloitte Dassault Systemes EY Fidelity Investments HCL Technologies HCL Technologies Wipro Wipro limted Wipfli LLP Tata Consultancy Infosys Newco

Post Photo
like

Best Andersonville restaurants? Veg friendly appreciated

I'm shameless! Who wants to hire me? Full cycle corporate and commercial real estate sales rep who wants to get into BDR/SDR roles. #ninja

like

Really excited for this sweetie to be coming home with us tomorrow. She’s an awesome 4 month old rescue mystery mutt and my other dog has been really lonely since his sister passed away.

Post Photo
like

A first for me, after 1.6 million miles. Thankful for a delay. The delay on the connector saved me a night at ord Hilton after the ludicrous delay on the first leg.t. Truly grateful united

like

Pakistani people-born and bought up in Pakistan. Anyone married to an Indian muslim girl or guy?
How different were cultures?
How did your folks and extended family react?

like

I’m not a sports guy, so I don’t care that sports are back.
If you do watch sports, how is it? Does it bring back any sense of normalcy?

like

Hello fishes! I have received my laptop won't i receive any other accessories with it like laptop bag, headphones along with it..(any joining kit?)

like

I promise you, whatever you have to tell me as I sit down with my lunch is not as important as eating my lunch.

likesmart

Additional Posts in Consulting

Which top consulting firms, if any, will pay for your MBA?

like

How true is it that people that stay in consulting long term are the middle of the pack? (The bottom get cut and the top move on to other endeavors)

likehelpful

I find myself struggling the explain things with the same eloquence as my colleagues. How can I improve my consulting speak? Any recommended books?

like

What are the best consulting firms in Europe to do AI strategy work in public sector? I have Canadian experience and I’m looking to move geographies.

like

Wow my iPhone 6 has such shitty battery! I literally charge it all night, attend a few calls in the morning and charge it all day 😓

like

Someone reached out to me on LinkedIn about becoming an author on the side. Has anyone heard about such a thing?!? The person said she’s worked with 800 consultants writing their books and marketing it for them.

like

With all the big AI push, can our firms build an AI that can do our expenses?

likefunny

Has anyone used gliders that stick on tyres of office chair, for better movement over the carpet?

like

Slalom 🐟: what types of work and industries can one work in Austin and Chicago? Looking to move to a firm with better work/life balance.

like

A first for me, after 1.6 million miles. Thankful for a delay. The delay on the connector saved me a night at ord Hilton after the ludicrous delay on the first leg.t. Truly grateful united

like

Looking for some material for a crash course in IT strategy consulting - books article etc. any recommendations would be appreciated

like

Best consulting firms to work for that will allow 100% remote work indefinitely regardless of what clients do?

like

Does anyone else think that PwC allowing all US employees to work from home indefinitely is BS?

likefunny

If you somehow couldn't Instagram your wedding, would you still get married? -John Oliver

like

What can I do outside the office to boost my resume and be a substantially more attractive candidate for top consulting firms in ~12 months time. Working in disputes and valuation role but want to go into management consulting next year (post MBA role). I feel like my job isn’t enough because skills aren’t considered as transferable outside this field.

like

IAH 🐟: Terminal C pre check is all the way to the lobby. Heads up!

like

Deloitte my S&A offer has 23 vacation days. Will I actually be able to use any of that? Does it count against my utilization? What’s the cultural expectation around using PTO?

funnylike

Any question ever asked to any consultant ever. Person: *asks question* Consultant:"Well, it depends..."

like

Anybody in ATL area interested in Manhattan GMAT books? I have the complete 6th edition plus the 2016 Official Guide, 2016 Quant Review, and 2016 Verbal Review plus a test simulation booklet

like

The client has no clue... But thinks he is a genius. How to let him run into his own trap?

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal