{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Be honest. You came out of a Top10 MBA program. Is anything but MBB underachieving?", "post_id": "570117e9cdfc5e1300dad65b", "reply_count": 7, "vote_count": 1, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting", "feed_type": "crowd" }
null

Be honest. You came out of a Top10 MBA program. Is anything but MBB underachieving?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Considering that more than ~50% of people attempt to get a consulting job receiving an offer is difficult enough. Obviously MBB are the most prestigious but all the other firms have their strengths.

like

I wouldn't say so. There are other options that do 'strategy'- for example, we only recruit from the list you're referring to.

I'm very happy w landing at KPMG strategy group, coming out of the top Chicago school. I think it was the best culture fit for me, and it's still pure strategy work, just like MBB.

I had no interest whatsoever in MBB

The term "Pure strategy" irks me a little bit. Everything is part of a strategy or they wouldn't pay you to be there is my opinion.

I agree that everything is part of a strategy. But "pure strategy" is 100% strategy, hence the "pure."

Pure strategy is silly. Speaking as someone who has to do both, planning is invaluable, however it's typically done without actual managerial line of sight and it almost always fails to take into account the organizational realities. Having done pure strategy work too it all fits nicely on a presentation but reality is oh so goddamn messy

Related Posts

Any current or ex MBB’ers willing to do case simulation to help a fish out? Advanced case’r here needing quality reps!

likefunny

I am at the 30’s mid-life crisis, so appreciate any advice. Should I buy a home and start a family or go for an MBA?

like

Looking referrals for sales, account management, business development roles. Any leads ? Zomato Cisco Zoho Amazon Microsoft Morgan Stanley @Oracle VMware Walmart Tiger Analytics

MBA with 2.5+ experience

like

Any MBB with life science focused roles looking for people? Have 4YOE from a boutique and a T2, looking for any MBB opportunities and potential referrals. Aiming for any UK or US offices. Any tips greatly appreciated!!

like

Have you ever wanted to delve deep into a competency but have a personality that is incompatible with it? I want to do an MBA and get into global business, but I’m a techie and have no social skills. Who knows if I’ll ever have any luck or ROI from investing energy into a realm that is the exact opposite of what I am? Relationship building is so important, but I just don’t have it. Should I do this MBA?

like
like

Hi Sharks,

Profile - Yoe- 5.10 years, Sr. BA (Capital Markets - BFSI), Btech+MBA(regular) current ctc -14lpa (13+1variable)

Wipro- 20L (includes 1.5L variable, B2 band, Location -Bangalore)
Fidelity International - 19.75 fixed (Sr. BA, Location -Gurgaon)

I need to relocate to bangalore , i am hoping for a better offer as LWD is 1st april., but assuming these are the only 2 offers in a worst case scenario. how much should i ask wipro over and above the fidelity offer? and also can i ask B3?

like

Anyone here looking to get an MBA?

like

How shot are your chances of getting into MBB from T2 generalist work at Kearney/ D S&O? I’m considering T2 as well as the longer game but if the chances are actually terrible then maybe not. Keep hearing things about how working elsewhere = trained poorly = they always fail.

like

Hi, I am considering two offers in Strategy Consulting (MBB) and PE (Tier 1 European fund) for a first job post studies based in Europe. Do you have any insights/advice on what I should consider to make my decision (compensation, career opportunities, professional development, work-life balance etc) based on your experience?Thanks!

like

What are post-MBA MBB salaries in Europe? Everyone keeps saying peanuts compared to the US but how much lower are they actually? (Asking as someone debating between M7 and intl MBA program)

like

1. What are some recommended readings to get smart for the Investment banking role? 2. Would you recommend getting experience before going to MBA? Do banks offer offcycle internships 4 nonstudents?

like

Do folks at MBB also have independence restrictions?

like

How's BCG WLB like? Do many tech people exit to MBB for better WLB?

funny

Anyone in the Chicago area that could point/connect/refer me to an absolute entry level it job (help desk or anything similar)

Making a career switch coming from healthcare background, so no IT experience. Currently working on a cert. I do have a bachelors.

Please let me know if any other info is needed!

Thank you in advanced! 🙂

like

Which firm has the best M&A tech focused practice for post MBA? Any thoughts and recommends?

like

Have you ever said no to someone when it comes to writing an MBA rec letter? I worked with the candidate but he didn’t report directly to me and I don’t feel like I have enough context to say anything

like

Which focus sectors have decent work life balance? Looking at an MBB position and met with people who were open/honest about their WLB and I wanted to know which industries or sectors are known for better WLB? I would assume Public Sector would be the best sense clients are 8-5 typically?

like

How important is knowing current consultants in MBB recruiting process?

like

Additional Posts

Curious. How do you work on/improve your legal writing? Is it just through work or do you do drills/lessons outside of work?

like

This question concerns how much financial freedom I have based on my current savings, debt, and age. I an 29, single, and I have about 185k saved and 80k in debt. How good of a position am I in in terms of my financial health and flexibility? My money is invested in the market, mostly through ETFs. Could I theoretically quit my job today, take another job that lets me just get by, and be in a good position for retirement? If not, how much further do I need to go?

like

Do you set out of offices?

I might be overthinking but I’m going on PTO I can’t back out of. There’s a meeting coming Friday. I’ve been coordinating efforts on this project so it would be unfortunate timing for my execs to see an OOO auto-response without them being aware of it (but my team is). I’ll check my phone if need be and respond but am not bringing my computer.

like

What are Geico briefs like? Just say something about the benefit and do what you want?

Spill the beans.

like

How can I encourage ELL parent involvement in the classroom and the school?

like

Just accepted an offer for an MBB internship position starting this summer (bar coronavirus delays). Given that I have basic knowledge of excel, how useful would it be to learn Tableau and Alteryx?

like

Currently a Senior Associate and received an offer for an Analyst position at Google, with 25% pay bump. 7 years of experience and non MBA Masters (but relevant to field) Would it be a bad decision to accept a title that is a lateral move?

likefunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal