Current B4 senior getting promo’d to manager. Have an offer to join a smaller firm (BDO, Grant Thornton, etc) as a Senior consultant for 1 year with expectation that I’d promo to manager next year. New salary would be higher even as a senior vs what I’d make as B4 manager. New B4 salary would be 105k. New salary trajectory is 110k this year to 120+ next year. What do I give up by leaving B4?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I’d take the title

like

Agree. Seen it happen a lot where the new firm says you’ll be considered for promo next year (usually a recruiter or your partner contact today). Then you start working and you never speak to the recruiter or the first partner who told you that ever again and the people you actually work with say it’s not happening but maybe next year.

Other thing to consider is sometimes (not always) manager spots are numbered meaning the group only has X manager spots they can give out in a year. Maybe they have 5 qualified but only 2 spots this year (because Covid). Next year there’s already 3 people ahead of you from people passed over this year, plus next year’s “on time” class who weathered the storm with the firm this year and will likely be positioned ahead of you because of their relationships and longer tenure at the firm.

like

I’d still take the title and look for a wfh role with the new title.

likehelpful

100% manager at big4

like

I’d take the title, and if you still want to jump aim for ~150 manager

like

Take the manager title at big 4 and lateral to $150+ to another big 4, boutique or industry

like

There’s a senior in my practice making 110, highly doubt there’s mgrs in my practice making lower than that

Your exit opp’s are way better coming from a big 4 compared to GT or BDO type shop that most in industry have never heard of

like

There is no guarantee you'd get promoted after 1 year. If market tanks, that won't be on the table. Get promoted. Get more money in long term

like

Take the title, job hunt after.

like

Another aspect of this situation is new job is completely WFH, which I highly value. Current position requires a lot of travel.

like

Former BDO here. Was told I'd get promo 1y after joining, that it was just internal politics/hr that couldn't hire me at level. Didn't get it. Left.

Take the level at B4 and then jump.

like

Interesting...while this offer isn’t with BDO specifically this is super helpful, thank you!

Others have already listed good points so I am hoping you already formed an opinion. But here is another piece of information. GT offers higher basic because the raises are pathetic and bonuses non existent. Also, the contribution to 401K is low and in the first year you don’t get any. Did anyone tell you that - I bet not. Also like big 4 there is not separate contribution to wealth management plans that’s another retirement plan. You lose a lot my friend. To top that - who moves parallel from B4 to GT?! The recruiters at GT always start the pitch with next level offer to get folks from Big4. I have gone thru it myself. So unless there is a specific motivation (which is fine), I would stay away with plenty of layoffs recently.

like

B4 manager 105k? Are you a management consultant? Sounds crazy low

OP, thanks for the clarification

Are B4 exit opps really that much better than say a BDO/grant thorton?

Yes big4 exits are better, but having that brand on your resume will continue give you credibility even after you move on

Related Posts

Looking to get a management job with Apple and would like to see what the pay scale is for a store manager Apple

like

When hike letters will be rolled out at Persistent?

like

Got an opportunity at a boutique firm. I’m a 2nd year in big law and never moved before. What are the pros and cons of leaving Big Law to go boutique? What should I be aware of before saying yes?

like

I’m a freelancer making $45 an hr. Is that too little? What’s the average rate for an AD?

like

I have got an offer from HSBC India Offer: 24.7 LPA YOE: 7.8 Skills: Devops Position: Consultant Specialist Looks like a reasonable one?? And what else should I enquire before accepting the offer ??HSBC India

like

Hey fishes, last week into my notice period. Help me choose between Nagarro (Staff Consultant), Aristocrat Technologies and Coforge (Lead BA). Nagarro Aristocrat Technologies Coforge Tata Consultancy EY Criteria: Quality of work, Growth prospects Thanks a lot !

like

How much severance should you expect after getting booted after 1 year. I got 3 months salary

like

I was promoted to manager in July 2020 (3,5 yr of experience). Currently preparing for YE but honestly, I couldn’t care less - what motivates one to push for SM promotion? Not my case atm, but wanted to hear what motivates ppl to keep going as I don’t feel like it’s worth it.

like
like

Hi Fishes,

I am currently having an experience of 3 years. I want to get into Data Science field. Have been preparing with the concepts mostly through self study. Will I get a job without any experience in Data Science field

like

Hi all,

Is joining bonus provided in L&T technology services. Please let me know as my joining is tomorrow?

Thanks

like

What is the CTC tht one with 14 yoe can expect in Globant if being hired for Senior Project manager position ?

Tier 2 MBA colleges and growth dilemma

At most companies your CTC is decided based on which tier your college is classified under. Most of the times even with a really high experience and stellar performance you won’t be able to match CTCs of freshers from Tier 1 colleges.

How do you solve for similar work profiles for Tier 1 and 2 grads but lower pays for Tier 2 grads?

like

Would you renege for an extra $17k sign-on bonus from a B4 offer if you’ve already signed with a boutique? Base is identical and I have 7YOE.

like

Hi all,

I would like to hear out your opinions on internal salary negotiations at the back of promotion.

I'm a Business Analyst with over 10 years experience, been in the same company for the whole time, Currently, I'm below Average Industry standards by approx. 10% for my (current) role.

I have applied for internal job which is effectively one level above, meaning it would be a promotion.

I got the job, awaiting offer.

Average Industry Salary for the new role, according to online research,

like

Those that have been promoted at a B4 firm already this year, has your raise been in line with prior years or lower because of COVID?

likesmarthelpful

Sinple advise those who are waiting for SA promotion... whatever package u r getting as A you will get only 15% hike for promotion to SA...so it's nt at well worth, Better switch.

like

How much have you heard of Media Buyers making at companies in the tech space? I'm thinking about leaving my market research company.

likeupliftinghelpful

Has anyone bought/ done the HRCI Certificate in Diversity and Inclusion in HR Management? I already have my PHR, but I’m looking to gain more knowledge/skills and beef up my resume. Is it worth doing? The course is $239 and you get 12 Recert credits with it.

like

Other than general tax and estate planning, what are some practice areas can a Tax LL.M. be beneficial in? I’ve heard it can help you in M&A, but I’m curious if anyone has additional thoughts

like

More Posts

Does Nagarro provide any hike at time of promotion?

like

Mask wearing inside stores: should it still be encouraged or not?

like

Last minute request...

Post Photo
likefunny

MACY’s (M), ROCKET COMPANIES (RKT), and Corbus Pharmaceutical Holdings (CRBP)

Appears to be heavily shorted!?!? Could EXPLODE!?

likefunny

Is anyone in this group spent 4 years in public accounting audit still waiting for his/her employer to start Labor petition perm process? I have only 2 years left with my h1b now, during this unprecedented time I am worried if the firm may not be willing to incur additional cost? Please let me know if anyone in this group have faced the similar situation?

like

Any Visa sponsorship opportunities available for the Java developers In EU/UK? Can somebody please refer

like

My annual perf discussion is monday morning. I work on a tough team for a tough place. I think Im a pretty good/almost high performer but only around 3 years and my boss seems to still act like I’m brand new (lifer boomer). I try to tell myself he has 6 direct reports and has to do this with everyone, Im no more or no less special - but I hate these convos and negative feedback even when most of it is unsurprising/fair feedback. Any tips? Just need to get through it! HR people are not immune!

like

We are hiring for Azure Data engineers. Dm me if interested in accenture.
Exp - 2.5 years or greater

like

Trying to do some initial research on laptops for business school and trying to determine if a new Mac book pro could be used at Wharton (or honestly any school!) for finance (not quant finance major though!)

like

Any F 🐠 want to get dinner and drinks in Atlanta tonight ? 28 M here

like

What to do when parents dig their toes into your relationship? They don't approve of who I'm with and very vocal about it.

In 10 years, this may be in the rear view or they may not let up. Anyone with experience in this?

like

Is there any advice for networking into projects when you don’t know many people at the firm yet? I always to help on BD work when I’m on the bench, but it never turns into any billable work. Every time I have talked to a partner/senior manager I was told I don’t have the skill set they’re looking for, but I don’t know how to build up from there. Feeing very lost but I want to improve my approach.

likehelpful

Music recs for deck building please

like

“Chatroulette, but for apartment peepholes."

likefunny

OH: (RE: required meeting attendance)

"Ok, fine. I will say yes now but fair warning I may fake my own death beforehand."

likefunnysmart

So a higher up made a new rule that for a service we offer , we have to offer it to the customers three times and If they say no a manager has to get involved and document. it is this not wrong?

like

Planning on staying in Japan in November for a week! Any recommendations on where to stay / things to do? Also, got some SPG points (<100k) I want to use!

like

I have accepted an offer for the role of Director of Data Science & Analytics and I'll be working with old colleagues. I am very excited. I haven't given notice yet because I am waiting for the background check to complete, but my boss just asked me about traveling to a meeting in November. I start at the new job Oct 25. I'm really struggling for how to respond. If I were not leaving it is absolutely a meeting I should be at. I don't want to respond with a lie. Any dvice on how to respond?

likesmart

Lowe's Hello, I am looking for a referral for the role of Product Manager at Bangalore. Can someone please help on the same. Thanks in advance Amazon Flipkart Lowe's Costco Wholesale

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Is it possible to move from Deloitte UK LLP to deloitte India within 1 month of joining?
Deloitte

funny

Bain & Company Which are the best consulting firms and practices for Climate Change & Sustainability, especially in the Canadian geography? Also, please suggest the best Canadian city for consulting jobs.

McKinsey & Company | Boston Consulting Group | Bain & Company | Kearney | LEK | EY | Oliver Wyman | PwC | Deloitte

#ClimateChange #Sustainability #Water #ESG

like

I tried asking this in my own bowl with no responses, so seeing if other consultants have run into this situation. I’m on parental leave, I got an offer for another firm, great opportunity and pay. How does one go about a resignation mid-leave when you would start the new job before the leave ends? Two weeks notice or just say I am not returning effective the day of the new job? Any things to consider besides potentially repaying the employer healthcare premium?

like

Which firm is the “best” (e.g., highest market share, works the most with the best clients, tough to win proposals against head-to-head, general market perception, whatever other metric you care about) in the food and beverage space and why? Interested in answers across the value chain

like

Any book recommendations on handling office politics?

like

Has anyone done the MIT masters in business analytics program? If so, please message me

like

I want to get an MBA to check a box for management. I’m Asian and have a bad undergrad GPA so I’m thinking online. USC Marshall would be great but it’s like 100k+. Lots out of pocket.

Thoughts on Boston University/Questrom for 25k? It’s got a bad rank but I’m not trying to do IB or management consulting.

like

Presented in person to a client for the first time last week, and it was way easier than over Zoom. Actually getting to pause and gauge reactions in real-time made life so much easier. Do y’all prefer in-person or virtual presentations?

like

Can anyone recommend me insightful books which can help consulting/career but not with titles like “how to be a successful manager” etc.

like

I am starting a new role with a new company and will have 6 direct reports. Although I have managed teams before in a consulting project setting, this will be the first time in industry. Any recommendations on how to sharpen my management skills (books, blogs, etc). Particularly looking at how to delegate effectively and practical examples on how to run day to day.

like

If you get laid off when you’re in the middle of an interview process elsewhere, do you tell the prospective employer?

like

Anyone have any recs for self help books? Looking for more relatable topics to myself I guess?

like

Uber driver at 5am - "Airport? Ugh I hate driving there." Uhh, it's Monday at 5am, no one except consultants are requesting rides...

like

Looking for some book recommendations :)

like

What are the best consulting companies in the US focused on Sustainability, either Strategy or Ops?

likefunny

When does recruiting for winter 2023 (new grad) typically end? Not talking about B4 but in general. I’m applying to tons of firms and am getting worried that the time is coming to an end. Do companies interview till December? Specifically trying to find a cloud implementation consulting position.

like

Scott Disick has the same temperament of a first-year analyst

like

Are there any good movies or novels that show skill development - like follow through? Self-management? Money management? I read a lot of self help books so I know a lot of the theory, and books peppered with examples help, but I feel like most 1 paragraph examples don’t five justice to how hard it may be to change a behavior.

like

What are the top consulting firms in the retail/CPG space?

like

Hey all, can you pls recommend resources to get up to speed on Fraud and Risk management for Payments in fintech? Books /sites? I’m not in consulting anymore so no access to internal decks. Thanks!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal