Do Big 4 Accounting firms still have an " Up or Out" policy in regards to employee progression.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I wish they enforced it more.

like

You have more flexibility in b4 the more senior you are.

A lifetime senior associate position is a huge burden for the firm (and also probably going to complain about not getting any raises other than cost of living). Say your group only has enough work for 10 seniors. If 8 people decide to stay seniors for life, now there’s a bottleneck that’s preventing associates from getting promoted and if manager turnover is high, there’s no one to fill the spots

Yes and no, depends on level. For example seniors are in very high demand so having someone perform well as a senior and stay in that role suits the firm fine but the firm has no need for a 5 year staff.

like

it's not a pure up or out culture, but realistically it ends up that wayfor the most part. if you get stuck at a level your raises and bonuses will flatten. at experienced director level some firms have alternative permanent paths than partner

like

Okayy

Move to CBS. I've been here 24+ years, rank 63 for 10+ years though my role has changed. Don't want the political bs that comes with rank 62.

like

I'm guessing yes, but not as much in the past.

I know in audit it was up or out when I worked at EY. I can’t speak to the other service lines. They may have relaxed some with the shortage of people.

It’s now sub service line dependent. For example EY has an edge tax practice that you can stay at your level forever.

Never heard of this. I’ve met plenty of people who have been seniors for 5-10 years because they didn’t want to be a manager. While it’s rare because I don’t know anyone who wants to stop progressing in their career assuming your performing at level I have never heard of the firm firing anyone due to not being promoted.

Also if your at the same level for an excessive amount of time at some point you will max out the pay range and stop getting raises as well.

No, they will need to keep more good Associate - Manager in position longer in order to accomodate the decreasing number of accounting major graduates in the pipeline

That is not really the case anymore. It's more of they take care of their employees now more than ever, at least it's that way in my company. Hope this helps

I haven't really heard of companies doing this in recent years. If they are doing it then its far and few in between.

Related Posts

Has anyone exited from B4 analyst level to a BizOps role at FAANG? I'm coming up on my 2 years at B4 as a BA, mostly involved in large scale tech implementation projects. Looking to move to something even less technical while getting a salary bump.

like

Is the IT infrastructure side of ServiceNow a good niche to focus in? My last 2 consulting projects were relating to APM & CMDB so I’m wondering if I should stick with this

like

Citi or Deloitte India Which would be better for long term career growth As I am in early stage of career.

like

Advice needed - boyfriend has almost 3.5 years of finance experience at a bank. Interviewed for PwC valuation senior associate and now recruiter says they want to hire him at “experienced associate” because he has no valuation experience. Is this too big of a step backwards in career? Should he push back and see if it gets him anywhere? If he does accept Associate, is it reasonable to ask for written, definitive timeline (1 year?) for promo to Senior upon meeting standards? Help!

likehelpful

Has anyone else turned down a tech job for banking? It was a hard decision but ultimately, I decided that the experience and training I'll get here is second to none. Hope I don't regret this decision

like

I’m currently an HR specialist and trying to decide what I want my future to look like. I would like to step away from the transactional, administrative HR work. I’m fascinated by employee satisfaction and like the idea of helping to improve retention and leveraging metrics to improve toxic work environments (I’ve seen a fair share of dysfunction in my career). I’m thinking the Consultant route may be best for this. Any other thoughts of roles or titles that may align?

like

Is a distribution supervisor job a decent stepping stone? Or a dead end for career progression?

like

Was skipped over for promotion until later this year but offered title change to Senior Art Director. Do I take the title and hope the pay comes later? Or hold out for it all at once?

funny

At what point are you too specialized to lateral to internal audit? (PA, consulting, or industry roles) Currently have 2 years of external audit experience and 2 years of forensics: I always thought of internal audit as a decent exit but I’m beginning to get worried about getting too specialized to make that move one day

like

Do you need an engineering degree to go into product management? I have a bachelors degree and a Masters degree in Digital Transformation, and I work as a C (soon to be SC) im Tech Strategy and Transformation. What are the next steps I should to to pivot into PM? (certifications, types of projects, etc)

like

When’s the best time to go client side? Wait till I get a promotion or try to switch sooner rather than later?

like

If these were the big 4, what firm would each of these men represent?

Post Photo
like

How is the Project Manager position at NTT ( Location : Mumbai) ?
Job security?
Pay scale to be asked for as minimum as where does this role stand in internal hierarchy in the company?
( Considering the high cost of living in Mumbai)

like

Hello All,
I have two offers, one for Stellantis (fiat chrysler automobiles) and another one for Bosch. Both are offering similar package. Please suggest where to join. Which option is good in terms of career growth, learning and culture. Thank you

like

I’m a newer registered nurse (2 years) and want to get into remote work. I keep getting denied due to lack of experience but to even get the job I have now (case manager) the company knew one of my family members and they gave me a chance to interview because of that. For these remote companies where I don’t have connections how can I transition over?

likehelpful

If I have 6 yoe as a Tax Senior, is there any chance I can come in as Tax Manager starting off?

like

I’m a finance manager for a Global 50 company, with 6+ yrs experience. I’ve considered switching to sales, and curious if there’s part time roles (preferred remote) that I could try. Any suggestions for me? Companies, role type, etc to look into. Thanks in advance.

like

I’m a college student studying data science. I’m interning at Deloitte currently is to become a data science consultant for non-profits. I don’t know if this is a role that even exists, let alone how I would start down that path. Any tips or advice would be greatly appreciated!!

like

How difficult would a move from Southern Europe strategy tier 2 to London strategy tier 2 be?

like

looking for referral to b4 consulting firms. recently let go from deloitte as part of current headcount reductions. any assistance is appreciated. please DM me, thanks

More Posts

like

Biggest stereotypes about working in diversity & inclusion....Go!

like

Let's get Meta with it here for a second. Since it's Monday, and I'm relatively jr. I'm interested to hear your experience breaking into the industry as a minority. What was it like.

I'll stick around for the bonus but want to make my side hustle my main career next year.
The side hustle is Scentsy...

funnylike

Hi fishes - Can you let me know product based companies in Mumbai that hire SAP consultants.
YOE - 6.5 yrs
Tech stack - Abap on Hana
Thank you

like

How many Invent folks do we have here? Where are you based?

like

Are therapists typically blunt? I just started seeing one and she made me feel uncomfortable. I wasn’t expecting her to be harsh and negative in her assessment of me.

likefunny

Hi fishes,
My LWD is 18th July and I chose vendor pickup for my assets(expected pickup is 10th July).
Is there any limitation or chances of facing issues on Not having laptop with me(for other exit clearances).
Also it would be great if someone can give guidance on exit clearances as I'm worried that I will miss out something.
TIA.

like

Any mid-level associates in the Sacramento region looking for a litigation role at a chapter 11 bankruptcy firm? We have a job opening up and are looking for someone with corporate bankruptcy experience.

like

Do solos get to write off pro bono work at all?

like

Has anyone here chosen Soluno over Quickbooks? Thoughts?

like

Hello everyone. Vinit Desai 📍London.
I have just graduated with a masters degree in finance from Warwick business school with over 3 of years of asset management and financial consulting experience.

I actively looking for financial roles ranging from IB, private equity, mergers and acquisitions. I'd be delighted if anyone would pass on a referral for a role they see open that aligns with my profile.

Here is a picture of my nephew who is the apple of my eye (the likes could help)

Post Photo
likeuplifting

I thought my nights and points would merge. How do I make that happen?

I received an offer from IBM Bangalore. However I saw openings at my preferred location Kochi only after the interviews. I called the HR after getting their point of contact mail and I asked if it's possible to switch. They said I'm already tagged to a project and that they'll check from their end if it can be done.

Anyone knows the chances of location being changed after receiving the offer and getting tagged to a project?

I have not yet accepted the offer.

like

How many days of sick leave a recently hired analyst can apply for? and will it get deducted from the annual leaves that are there? I could not find any section for sick leave in talent hub. Thank you in advance.

like

I’m interested in pursuing cosmetic dermatology (possible Botox and laser treatment) for the first time. I’ve done a ton of research and the derm I’m most interested in going to charges a $150 consult fee but does NOT apply that cost to any treatments you get, whereas from my research it seems like derms in my city usually do apply the consult fee to the treatments. Would you pass on her due to that additional cost, or consider it worth it to see the derm you want to see?

like

Anyone know where I can rent a small boat for 2-4 hours relatively cheap? TIA

like

Do Capgemini includes Health insurance amount in CTC...? Or will be seperate?

like

Looking for a referral to Cooley’s privacy group. Senior associate, CIPP/US, extensive data breach, privacy, and information security experience. Also open to recruiters that have successfully placed candidates there. Thank you!

like

Can anyone provide me a referral to Linkedin?

like

Additional Posts in Accounting

Anyone have their CFE? Just wondering what you have done or plan to do with it and what the test was like.

like

Does anyone else make small mistakes here and there because this job makes you anxious? I feel like I triple check everything and still get pings from my manager that I missed something

likefunny

Is it bad to put in two weeks notice next week knowing my last day will be first week of jan and one of the two weeks is within the firm’s holiday break?

like

FAANG is now MAMAA (Meta, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon and Alphabet)…Whoa Mama! As if there weren’t enough acronyms in our lives. Happy Friday All!!!

funnylike

AirPods for valentines.. too much?

like

Advice needed - boyfriend has almost 3.5 years of finance experience at a bank. Interviewed for PwC valuation senior associate and now recruiter says they want to hire him at “experienced associate” because he has no valuation experience. Is this too big of a step backwards in career? Should he push back and see if it gets him anywhere? If he does accept Associate, is it reasonable to ask for written, definitive timeline (1 year?) for promo to Senior upon meeting standards? Help!

likehelpful

I have one more thing that has to go out tonight and Outlook won't connect. Computer may be meeting my gun tonight

like

Anyone hear talks of layoffs in Advisory? I know my office is laying off Assurance and BTS (Tax) staff but haven't heard much of Advisory yet.

like

Do you think it is quite possible to get fired by asking too many questions as an experienced senior 1? If so, i might get fired after this busy season.

funnylike

Estimated tax payment question:
I converted $30k of rollover 401k into a Roth IRA and have $26k of realized ST Capital Gains this year (Roth conversion in end of Q1 and most capital gains in Q2).
My total federal withholding tax last year was approximately $12k and this year I will have 40% more in reported income on my employer W2 and anticipate higher that $12k federal withholding for my new job. Given this, what is the best way to go about making est. tax payments for the income (continued.)

like

Just heard EY is about to make more layoffs in audit too

like

How much of a percent is a senior bonus in FAAS in MCOL city?

like

When negotiating salary, what would be a good ask for tax Asset Management SM salary + signing bonus MCOL?

like

If I’m getting dragged heavily for my performance and am completely overloaded with work, is it best to start looking for another job? I suspect I might get PIP’d this summer unless our abysmal staffing issues prevent that.

like

Deloitte or dixon hughes goodman? Considering accounting advisory at one of the two. Deloitte has a better brand name but based on the talk here it seems like the pay and hours are dogshit. Thoughts anyone

likesmart

Exit opportunities for two years financial services?

like

How much does a big 4 marketing director make in the Bay Area?

like

I did audit in 2 hours for the whole exam did I fail ...

like

How long did it take before you learned to just embrace the craziness?

like

PPEDs: Just found out that a Partner, who was promoted in 2017, was fired. IDK the circumstances. What can they expect to walk away with besides 401k & normal pension plan?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal