Doing client work as part of the interview process? Red flag or standard practice? More info in comments.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Throw a big fat watermark on everything.

likehelpfulfunny

You have 3 options: 1) Just do it. 2) Inform them of your hourly freelance rate and ask them how many hours they want you to put towards this. 3) Tell them your lawyer has advised you that working on actual client materials puts you (and the agency) in danger of a lawsuit from the client for divulging trade secret materials, and even if you sign an NDA it would not be valid because there is no consideration (payment for your services), and thus no contract. You could also add that there may be state laws that ban posting an employment opportunity and then asking responders to work for free as the price of employment; that's called bait-and-switch fraud, and you're sure a company as respected as theirs would not do something like that, right?

likehelpful

Charge them a freelance rate.

like

Standard practice but a trash one. It provides them with free work and doesn’t show how you use the resources and other people on the team to solve a problem through design. They usually provide vague briefs and even more vague information.

like

Fingers crossed for you that they are actually looking to hire you, but that sounds like they’re using the interview process for free consulting not filling a role.

likesmart

Red flag!

likesmart

I had a recruiter give me the same deal this week. They guaranteed that I'd be paid a day rate for my time.

I suggest that you request the same compensation.

like

I'm interviewing for a senior position at a design/ad agency — independent, in business for decades, multiple offices across the US. During my first phone interview, the HR contact did tell me that there would be an assignment and presentation portion. However, I just received the brief, and it's actual client work for their actual clients. They shared the broader scope of the brief with me, so I can clearly see that this portion that I've been assigned is the first step of the broader project. I'm already not a fan of having to do a project on top of my full-time job for an interview (though I do see the benefits for the hirer,) but I'm even less of a fan of doing free work that could potentially be used for no compensation. A couple of my friends say that I shouldn't do it. I don't desperately want/need this job, but I do like the opportunity so far.

Is this a red flag? Standard practice? I know that spec work for interviews is relatively standard, but for existing clients and upcoming projects? If it is, fine, it'll be a fun exercise I guess, no hard feelings. But I don't particularly want to be taken advantage of.

Related Posts

One of my client is the greater Philadelphia area is looking to fill two roles: 1. Senior Manager Category Management, 8+ YoE
2. Procurement analyst 2-4 YoE.

like

Ideas/ apps to meet people outside work while at client site? Tired of eating alone Mon-Wed.

like

How is the infostretch UK? Is it good for career growth? I am an Architect and would like to continue my career in being an Architect. I have heard that people working on Goldman Sachs projects have higher visibility than others. Please advise whether I should join as I will be assigned to non-GS project.

like

During the interview, If the interviewer recommended you to talk to somebody else in the firm but not the original rescheduled interviewers,what does that mean? After the recommendation, he stopped asking me questions. And the conversation only covered about 60% of the whole interview timeline. Shall I follow up with him about the ‘mentioned talk’?

like

In general how many days does CGI takes to release the offer after all the rounds of interviews and HR discussion is completed.CGI

like

Hey all 👋🏻 I’m looking for a referral for the Named Account Executive - Large Enterprise Banking @ Salesforce. I currently work in commercial banking for TD as an account manager and have over 3 years experience in banking and 4 in finance. Anyone have advice to get an interview?

like

What can I expect from a recruiter call tomorrow? Anybody know the lengths I need to prepare?

like

Hi Sharks,

Today I had senior manger round for senior analyst
Deloitte.
What salary range I should be asking if I proceed.

Project Management Domain
Location Hyderabad
Year of experience - 3.5 years

Any advice??

like

Please suggest any good sources to prepare for data engineer interviews in GCP, Python, SQL, Pyspark. I have worked only in a few tools in GCP and done basic coding in pyspark and above average in SQL, but need to be prepared to handle all questions to grab some offer. YouTube has lot of resources but confused on which one to start with. I have an interview this Tuesday in another 2 days.

like

City of Houston Jobs - anyone have any insight into their hiring process? My applications get to the Referred List stage but then go stale.

like

About to start a side hustle writing smut for Amazon, who's got some story prompts for me?

likefunny

I have been tagged for this project that doesn’t start until June 10th. My utilization is going to drop significantly but at the same time the deployment team cannot present me elsewhere. Ugh!

like

Hello Fishes,

May I know what all the topics will be covered in the first round of interviewfor the role of "Data Analyst" in Comcast Company...

Thank you 😊

like

Is a “coffee chat” the same as a first round interview for on-cycle recruiting right now?

like

How long do offers vs rejections take post interview ?

like

📌 In hackerrank, code pair interview. Interviewer knows about hints, possible way to solve problem or solution in advance ?

How to give best or impress interviewer in code pair interview ?

Your inputs please.

like

Question my fellow Fish Bowlers♥️ I had a phone screen interview. The young lady stated to watch out for the email, attached will be the link for virtual interview w/ manager on Monday @10am but NEVER received an email. Should I email the recruiting analyst and advise I never received the email invite? Thank you all in advance.

like

DA AC profile interview, what all is usually asked?
Any help would be appreciated. Thanks

like

More Posts

Will CSPO help in Product Manager role?

like

I want to move to a Product based B2B or B2C in #Chennai or #Remote. I have a total of 6 years experience with a mix of Data Science and Product Analytics space. Currently an APM.

Please like this post.

Anyone working in Optum, please DM

like

There was interest on another thread to get folks in Dallas networking and connected post COVID. I setup a WhatsApp group if you’re interested in connecting. See thread

like

My wfh setup. I don’t know if I chose the wrong career being a consultant or should’ve been a pro gamer streaming videos on YouTube/Twitch. I spend way too much on computer and ergonomic hardware 💸💸💸

Post Photo
likeupliftingfunnysmarthelpful

Just got an offer Microsoft to work in Austin! What is the latest news on the return to work situation?

likehelpful

Has anyone tried to take an in-person GMAT recently? Are they allowing in-person tests or have you been rescheduled?

like

Recommendations for best suits in Dubai? Good quality but not 10k either.

like

My team and I have been looking at a deal that involves acquiring a construction company that brings in 4-5m in revenue but the owner tends to use check cashing services. Why does he do this?

like

I was one of the first people to get a CSR when it first came out - can I downgrade to a CSP and get the CSP bonus? Or how do I take advantage of the 100k CSP signup bonus?

like

What's the salary for a 7yrs experience Test Lead at KPIT. Domain would be electric vehicles Validation.

Manager asked me to give him formal upward feedback. Everyone in the firm hates him. Let loose the cannons or diplomacy?

like

What’s a profound way to start a business? The desire to make social and economic impact? Or personal wealth? What should be the main driving factor? I’m curious what your guys’ thoughts and opinions are on this. Feel free to drop a comment :)

like

Steel Case vs Herman Miller

Is Herman Miller the undeniable winner in the office chair market or is Steel Case a contender for first?

like

I already sent my scores to Sloan through ETS but decided to not submit scores. I see a “delete” option in the app- will that ensure adcoms doesn’t know that I ever sent in a score?

like

31 F, looking to date seriously and have a true connection, Nj area

like

Asking for a friend - average yearly salary for an Account Supervisor in NYC?

like

Can someone refer me in Accenture. I am currently working as Process Leader with 9 years of experience in project management and process management.

like

Should I shave my beard for MBA interviews?

like

Air Force’s Platform One + Kessel Run and Navy’s Black Pearl seem like promising examples of government working well. Anybody supporting these teams? If so, what’s your experience been like?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

What's the perception of BBDO NY these days? Still good?

likefunny

What's your policy on 'cold-call' messages from hopefuls asking for tips, advice, help? 😇 or 😈

like

Is it had to become an Art Director for a fashion brand? Because I was told if you aren’t familiar with Textiles, patterns and fashion merchandising it’s hard to get into.

like

Are the ideas that hit you right away ever better than the ideas that come through hours of banging your head against the wall with your partner?

like

Mute button horror stories.

like

📊 Curious to learn how diverse is Fishbowl? What's your age and nationality?

like

What big moves/life changes are you guys making in 2020?

likeuplifting

Managers - do any of you have the ability to check in on your direct reports’ webcams without them knowing to make sure they’re working? The green light next to the camera keeps lighting up on my company computer and I’m getting paranoid haha

like

TBWA NY layoffs today.

likehelpful

So I'm in a weird space at the moment. I've been interviewing with a lot of agencies in the past couple of months, and I keep getting the same response of "I need more agency experience." How am I supposed to get that experience if one of the things holding me back is not having enough agency experience?

like

How’s the job market?

like

Pretty excited to get back to the hustle on Tuesday... this break was really nice and much needed but I'm feeling a little antsy to get moving again. I can't be the only one ?

like

I read a lot of posts here about difficult bosses, difficult clients, difficult partners, terrible briefs and terrible agencies. All that might be true. But it’s getting old. What I’d be interested in hearing about are the stories of how people have overcome the challenges. How did you sell that big idea? How did you fix a relationship? The world is not going to get easier. So maybe we can help each other get better at dealing with it. Who had a win recently? How did you do it?

likeupliftingfunnysmart

Grey Merge with AKQA, VMLYR merges with Geometry. Are those „mergers” just the coverups for potential wave of layoffs?

like

It’s so nice that every agency laying off people, have those left standing (and other agencies) trying to hustle jobs for their unemployed friends, but there are also a ton of people who were unemployed prior to Covid...so no severance, job hunting lot longer, and not earning income for longer time...hurting even MORE due to quarantine.

likesmarthelpful

Any creatives impacted by Forsman Bodenfors layoffs? That agency does beautiful, powerful work.

like

Is Phenomenon really still that awful? Shocked by the reviews.

like

Has anyone worked on the creative team for Hilton corporate? As someone who loves travel (and Hilton hotels) this always appealed to me. Wondering if anyone can shed some light on the reality of working there.

like

Can you tell / sense that you’ll get the job after an interview?

I’m like 50/50

like

Curious how other people’s brains work.
When you get an activation brief, what’s your process for coming up with a solid idea?

Look for cultural moments that you can adapt? Look through award show books? Scroll YouTube videos until 3am?

I know that every brief and every idea is different, but I’m more interested in the process and what you’re creative routine is to get the wheels turning.

Thanks.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal