During a recent team discussion about diversity quotas, someone posed an interesting question: "If we hire someone just because they’re different, are we really being diverse?" It sparked a debate.
Having diversity involves creating a culture that values varied experiences and perspectives. However, others argued that focusing solely on diversity might overlook merit.
How do we balance embracing uniqueness while ensuring everyone is qualified? What’s your take on this complex issue?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I think the point of diversity hiring is not to lower the bar, but to widen the door. There’s no shortage of qualified candidates from underrepresented groups... they’re just often overlooked. The system needs balance, not excuses. But i have too often seen subpar candidates chosen to tick the box.

like

That's a really good way of looking at it, 'widening the door' I like that. I just wish it was already wide open for everyone.

Solely hiring based on diversity is the wrong approach IMO. So too is hyper-fixating on merit alone. I think finding some sort of middle ground is the way to go.

like

Absolutely, there's so many factors that come into play when looking at hiring someone. It's really opened my eyes.

I agree with both comments above, you can’t bas your decision on just going by diversity, that is the definite wrong approach.

Absolutely. Employers just feel pressure because it gets noted if there's only employees of a certain ethnicity for example. We can't just hire people because of this though.

Related Posts

Any one in JP Morgan FP&A (Bangalore location) ? I have a couple of questions about profile and work culture. Please DM if you know.

like
like

need review on Work life balance and work culture at Bank of America Global Banking and Markets FP&A Projects team, Gurgaon.

Please reply. I need to make a decision.

like

Quick question:

Can a New York registered attorney (solo practitioner) file a diversity jurisdiction lawsuit in a federal court of another state other than NY, (while residing outside the US, and not running an office in NY)? Any thoughts on this? Thank you!

like
like

Trying to think of some places to leave Citi for. Already applied to JP and GS. Someone reached out to me today via LinkedIn after one of my posts of places I’m looking to relocate to and they recommended Capital One. Never even considered them. Anybody know anything about them? Good company to work for, good culture? Any negatives?

like

How is work life balance at Tredence? Any input on culture as well please

Looking for Java, Springboot Developers. Kindly DM if you looking out for change if having experience in these Skill-set.

Location is not a constrainst as hiring PAN-INDIA.

Flexible work culture with Prominent WFH.

P.S: Currently hiring very aggressively, can offer better CTC as per the market standards.

like

How is the life and work culture in the exl?

like

ACN 🐠 Received offer to join Accenture Strategy T&O as a manager. How’s the culture and work? Is strategy the way to go? I’m having this gut feeling T&O might not be as strong as ACN is claiming?

like

Hi Everyone,

Could you help me answer few of
Question related to Tavisca Pune.

1 what is different in job profile Tech lead Cloud and Senior software engineer cloud? Is there any job responsibilities difference, seems both required similar years of experience.

2. How is the working model ? WFH/WFO/if hybrid how many days mandatory requires to visit in a week?

3. Hows the work in terms of AWS cloud ? DevOps/EKS/scripting?

4 how is WLB/work culture / office hours ?

Thanks in advance.!!

How is Capgemini in terms of job security and work culture?
How much CTC to expect from Capgemini with 10 years of experience in QA domain?
Capgemini

like

Hi Fishesh

Which one will be good to join for SAP technical consultant having 5.6yr experience?

Deloitte USI: 20 lpa fixed, 10% variable, 3lakh JB
Bristalcone, client: SAP Labs: 22 LPA fixed, 10% variable and 1 lakh JB.

I had worked with SAP Labs, work culture and Work life balance is good but I am not sure about Deloitte usi. Someone please help me

like

Can anyone speak to the analytics team within HIA at PwC? Good capability, culture, and people overall? Considering a move.

like

We’re hiring for a ton of digital marketing positions across the US, and have a great culture - consistently voted among best places to work. Reach out to me if you’re interested.

like

Publicis Sapient or TIAA, both for Mumbai location.. both giving almost same package, which one to go for?
WLB>LEARNING>work culture

like

Is the work culture at Siemens Technologies and Services Pvt. Ltd. good?
I heard it's like service based and the policies are different than other Siemens entities, is it? 😢

like

Hi All, I am offered 10 LPA for 1.11 months experience at Siemens . Is it good ctc for the experience? Or should I go with better ctc of other company? I would like to know the work culture and ℅ of hike every year...

like

What is the payband for Associate Prinicipal Consultant in Gartner. Also how it the firm culture wise.

like

More Posts

I’ve been a nursing assistant for 35 yrs I just got a new job as a Lead care manager working from home but this job is not what I expected I want to find a new job working in a hospital or doctors office as a receptionist or administrative assistant or something but I have little experience does anyone have any ideas they can help me with please thank you

like

Question : I want to change career from a support engineer to sales. Is that possible ? I have 4 YoE in technical support and want to change to sales.
Any ideas where to start, and what positions I should be looking for given I have not worked sales before ?

like

Jio has offered 15lpa and Vodafone 18lpa. HR trying to convince me Jio is more secured than compared to others. What shud i do?

like

What is the best method to learn SAP finance? Do people have recommendations on a specific book, website, or other best practices to learn it?

BDO India Hello fellow consultants, i have been offered a package of 66K GBP from Deloitte UK for the position of Manager, Cyber Internal Audit, Financial Services, Risk Advisory, Manchester. I am currently working for BDO India and will be relocating, what are your views on this? What are the extra relocation and accomodation benefits i can ask for? I am a 24 year old bachelor. BDO

like

Anyone use magnetic earrings to promote lymph flow? Notice any effects or have any info to share on that topic?

Those who moved nyc to nj- assm min change in rent, how much did you save on an avg cause of taxes etc.?

like

Where did you meet your significant other in the city? Looking for ideas to meet new people!

likehelpful

I everyone,
I have been selected for the associate position but till know I have not received my offer letter from legato company please suggest when can I except my offer letter discussion has happened on jun 27?

Soon to be graduating from an MBA, and won't be able to attend a graduation ceremony or grad party - is it something life changing that I'll be missing out on?

like

How many days a week do you manage to go out? Dinner, drinks or movie with friends etc.

like

What’s the difference between product marketing and product management at Facebook? Or any company? And product strategy …. So confused!

like

Hi Fishes, need your guidance. I am having below offers. Please help me to decide.

Publicis Sapient - 16LPA + PWFH
Valuelabs - 18LPA + PWFH

I want to know in terms of Brand value, WLB, career growth, learning opportunity & job security.

*Also is it safe to join service based company with such a high package in respect to my YOE?

My Info:
YOE - 2.3Yrs
CCTC - 7.25LPA
Techstack - Frontend Development (React) College - Tier-3

likeuplifting
like

Gloomy mornings are hard 😓

like

Whats the most reliable among german cars? I am worried about paying a lot for maintenance and repairs but also dont want a japanese tin can

like

To take advantage of the next big economic downturn, should I set up a Robinhood or Charles Schwab account?

likehelpful

I’m buying a new construction condo and will need some help with designing and installing lightning, closets, and cabinets. Any recommendations for where to get such services done in a seamless and customizable way? I know the Container Store can customize some closets and cabinets, but wanted to explore other options.

Has anyone dealt with coming to terms with an emotionally abusive relationship? I struggle to admit this (because more drastic examples come to mind), but my therapist mentioned that things like yelling/throwing things/blocking me from leaving the room are also abusive traits my ex demonstrated. It makes me feel alienated from myself — like “how could I have allowed myself to be treated like that?”. Also feeling ashamed to tell anyone

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal