Got offers from both- McK and BCG. Which firm is better in terms of culture, WLB and less internal politics?

likeuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Idk why leave Alix?

likefunny

Speaking from personal experience, I can think of plenty.

likesmartfunny

BCG is the new McKinsey

like

I heard BCG slightly wins, somewhat dependent on group.

Would you mind sharing your rationale for leaving?

like

Is this a comp cut for you coming from AP?

like

Left an AP like firm for BCG. Best career decision I have ever made. Excited for you!

like

Two totally different experiences - big fish / small pond or small fish / big pond.

I had a very comfortable life as a consultant before BCG. Great comp, reasonable WLB and total freedom to set my own rules due to a strong internal reputation / pyramids that relied on me heavily for delivery.

BCG is just a step change improvement in the entire consulting experience - internal network, knowledge resources, client access, breadth of work, opportunities beyond consulting, brand recognition, etc. While nothing is handed to you anywhere, if you have a clear idea of how you want to use the BCG platform (specific relationships, deepen industry experience, etc.) and work against that ruthlessly for a few years anything feels achievable.

For me it was worth the trade. It really just depends on you.

like

Deloitte

funny

BCG.. only by a hair though.

like

BCG probably

like

No WLB in either, BCG slightly better in client relationships and market depth, McK in topic depth and get the best global team in each proj. Minimal differences easily neglectable when considering local team variance

like

Bcg better WLB but not by much. Can’t speak for internal politics.

like

Congrats! I really like McK!

McK if you are interested in global staffing model and stronger support teams. BCG for slightly better WLB. Can’t speak to internal politics

MC2s face right now

Post Photo

It is consulting there is no work life balance. Go with the firm you enjoyed the people the best, they work on the types of projects in the industry you want to work.

I was at AP for 5 years, and just recruited to BCG from b school. I can’t yet speak to the day to day, but from recruiting and my summer experience BCG seems like a closer culture fit.

Best of luck either way!

I appreciate that AP5, I did join out of undergrad and while I loved my time at AP and stay closely connected to my network there, it was time for some new experiences. I’m a bit disappointed by the response here, as I’m a vocal advocate of our firm and culture for MBA recruitment.

OP - you can’t go wrong with these options, but if you end up at BCG let me know, would love to connect!

like

Related Posts

like

Hey Guys, what would be the salary of 11+ years experienced person, in Mainframe Technology in CSG International, Bangalore.
Designation is SDE Senior or SDE Lead.

like

I gave interview (Manager round) last Friday at Deloitte India. Haven't heart back tried calling hr but no luck. When can I expect result or feedback, is this a dead end for me? Deloitte @deloitteindia.

like
like

Can anyone help with the avg pay for Sr. Program Manager (Non Tech) with Amazon in London?

Comparative view:
India (Blr) - 46 LPA + ESOP

Amazon- 80K GBP (Base + Bonus)

What makes more sense?

like

Can someone please let me know what is the maximum salary that Deloitte India offers to Consultant?
YOE : 4.5
Current offer from Deloitte: 16 fixed
Offer from another MNC: 18.9 fixed

Will Deloitte India be able to match the offer if I renegotiate?

like

Is JP Morgan Chase still giving laptop rembursement to new hires ?

like

Is Koch good company to work? How is culture& work life balance?

like

Hi Fishes, I've got an offer from CGI that is less than 10 LPA. Then I got offer from other company that is 14 LPA. Can CGI match that offer? (YOE - around 3 years) #CGI

Any idea about google project in HCL ?

like
like

I joined tcs on feb 2022
Recently I resigned, i know it was worst decision to leave tcs early but also worst to join 😁🥲

like

Hi All,

One of my friend got interviewed in Deloitte and she was asked to rethink her salary ask in the HR round. She reduced it to 1L less than initial ask. Now the status is in benchmarking approval. What does that mean ? Will they release the offer letter ?

like

Hello Fishes.
I am working in TCS as a BA (Third party), recently I have been initaited to join TCS on permanent basis. My domain is Business Intelligence / Data analytics with 4 years of experience. Current CTC is 7 LPA. How much increment can I expect ? is there room for negotiation ?

like

Hi,

Does KPMG lighhouse India provides Internet Charges reimbursemenr, if yes how to claim it?

TIA

Hi Folks,
What is annual hike in kyndryl like? Also what is wlb for band 7a ? Is company giving wfh for this year or is it wfo?
Seeking these info as i have to take a decision of joining it. TIA

like

Hi... Anyone joining at UBS this week or next?

Is Coforge giving anything on Diwali this time?Coforge

Hi,

is anyone joined ANSR for NAB ( National Australian Bank) ?

like

More Posts

Hi Guys,
Tom is my interview with IBM first round.
Tech : java, spring boot ,microservices.
Yoe: 2
What kind of questions to expect.
Any help will be appreciated.
Thanks

Any advice for understanding whether sourcing would be a good match for your personality/innate skill set?

Im pretty extroverted, I have been told in reviews that I peak in verbal communication, and I have really loved conducting expert interviews in DDs.

However, I’ve worked some sales jobs in the past, and I had a hard time with the variability and staying positive bad times when nothing is sticking.

like

Are there any scrum masters out there willing to take me on as a mentee? I recently received my CSM, but I know that is not enough to get a job. I am looking for someone to show me the ropes and help me apply what I learned in the CSM course so I can start applying for jobs within the next 6 months. I am currently a business development consultant dealing with enterprise accounts. I want to stay in tech but I HAVE to get out of sales. It’s just not for me. Thank you in advance!

like

Would you say your job got easier or harder since Covid started?

Hi all, I'm trying to break into sales coming from a technical background. It's been very difficult as a lot of recruiters only see the technical aspects of my previous role, even though I've added in some sales aspects from those roles. Any advice on how to break past the initial view of my resume/past technical experiences to get interviews?

like

How are the salary hikes at nagarro? I heard the hikes has decreased! If yes what can I expect after a year? I am 4 year experienced

likehelpful

1. Need some feedback how anyone proceed during HCL Technologies Discover portal login. It's showing me invalid login continuously and using forget password options, able to login one time by luck 2. BGV documents uploading links are routing to smart portal. Will it be the same credentials which is being used during discover portal login? Asked my recruiter HR, but no reply so far
3. Anywhere we need to accept the offer Letter?
HCL Technologies

like

Hi Fishers,

I have appeared for the HCL Devops position and after clearing the 1st round they have sent the mail for the Client Interview.
Can anyone please suggest how it would be !!

like

How do you get over the anxiety of an impending deadline and just write?

like

Just signed onto a less hectic project simply bc it allows me to continue my job search. Am I terrible?

like

Hola Fishes! Welcome to the Canada specific bowl. We can discuss about jobs, products, preferences, research, IT, digital and consulting in Canada!

like

How is PwC’s Salesforce Practice in general? Are they more into Strategy, Assessment type work or do implementations as well? Which vertical is strong (TMT, CM, H&LS, FinServ)?

like
like
like

What was your experience with the LSAT? Do you think it's gatekeeping, preventing students who can't afford it (often people of color) from entering the field? OR is it helping future attorney's of color by giving them a chance to go to a top school regardless of grades? I've seen questions about the LSAT all day and just want to know how people feel.

likesmart

Hello All, In the next couple of months i am targeting companies like Apple , American express, Salesforce, Microsoft etc. Can anyone please share the required skill set and preparation strategy for these companies? YoE - 4 years Current skill set - Advanced SQL , Pyspark,Azure services, Hadoop ecosystem , shell scripting, Power BI

I am not very good at DSA.

Apple Microsoft Salesforce Amazon

like
like

In PwC India, How much hike is given in general when one gets promoted from Associate(Consultant) to Senior Associate level (Senior Consultant)

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Looking to target PE firms as clients, need to do some research on how they work so we can speak intelligently when trying to sell operational work to them. Any book recommendations ?

likefunny

My flight is three hours delayed. I have collected so many pokeballs.

like

Republican here. But what kinda guy we have here. Disgraceful!

like

Anyone know where to find the best Tumi Black Friday deals? - looking to buy a new laptop bag

like

EVERYONE! Whats the stereotype of the workers at:
Deloitte
Accenture
Booz Allen
Google
Facebook
Salesforce
PWC
KPMG
Mcbee
Leidos
Bain

like

What are some good phone apps to use for practicing case math?

like
like

Any recs for CIPM study books?

like

What’s a good hotel to stay near time square , Ny? Preferably close to the time sq subway

like

All the big 4 consulting practices should split off and form one mega firm without independence nonsense. We can call it Strategy&Friends

likefunnysmart

If you remove all client specific data and alter data around so it is not client specific, can you then send yourself the file so you know what you did?

like

Best consulting firms with best WLB? Do they exist? Young professional starting to think about where I'd like to work hard to end up in the next 5-10 years.

like

To everyone struggling today, I recently started doing gratitude lists and it has helped put things into perspective. Not to be THAT person, but finding a way to reflect can work wonders on the soul.

like

Which city would you choose and why? I am considering a move from D.C. , single male, no kids, and like; Chicago, Denver, Minneapolis, Boston or San Diego. List your pref from that list in order.

like

Nothing worse than being sick on flyday. Any tips to make it through my flight?

like
like

What are the top consulting firms in the retail/CPG space?

like

Is there a hard limit on how frequent you can apply in a year at FAANG? (For instance: Amazon, Google)

Also, how many positions are we allowed to apply?
There are just many positions at different teams right.

like

Best stepping stone to get into MBB? MBA vs experience at Big 4 / other second-tier consulting firms?

like

Uber driver handed me this today.

Post Photo
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal