Have anyone been low balled when they joined a consulting firm? If yes, how did you go about fixing the gap in salary? I think I was low balled as a senior consultant and there was a gap of about 20-25% when I was made the offer. I was naive and did not negotiate - still living with the consequences.

likehelpfulsmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I was too because I came from a small liberal arts school rather than a big state school as KPMG prefers. I’m told we all even out over the years, but I’m worried about it under the current climate. Obviously I’m grateful for the job, but I was told to expect a 12-15% raise this year after a year of high performance and early consideration for a promotion. That’s on par with what others in my position received the year prior, so the figures checked out. However, the gap is likely to grow this year rather than shrink... associates who’ve been here less than a year longer already got the big bump and I’ll miss mine :(

like

It will not even out. I was in the same situation. Plan to leave within 2 years

likesmart

I would talk to your partner with this kind of talk track: I love working here, and view this team as where I want to build my career. But I’m seeing a pretty significant compensation gap open up with calls I’m getting. I know things are tight right now, but I’d like to work with you to close the gap over the next 12-24 months. What do you think?

Obviously, I would wait until the dust settles from all this stuff in the near-term

likesmarthelpful

The pay is similar depending on firm. One firm I’m working with is great for two professional homes. They don’t bill as many hours so bonuses are lower. Benefits of not being public or over levered.

Recent IconRecent

Why do you think you were lowballed at PwC? The pay bands are so tight at the junior levels that I seriously doubt you were. If you think there is a gap of 20-25% I think it’s more likely that someone is lying about what they make or came in as an external hire with higher comp and is an outlier.

likesmartfunny

What is the average bump from analyst to senior analyst?

likesmart

I am convinced I was low balled because people talk and the pay bands are not tight at all. Also I’m not with the US firm

likesmartfunny

jumping ship is the only way

like

Does not work that way when you are on a visa and the firm knows that very well and uses that as a leverage . There is clear discrimination based on visa status for career growth and comp.

like

I thought I got a big raise when I joined consulting until I realized how many hours I was working. I ended taking a pay cut instead :/

likesmart

Yeah exactly. There is no such thing as a raise in consulting

like

Have been and am still being lowballed. I keep trying to prove myself but it still doesn't reach what I expect, making my salary below average in the industry. Jumping ship is the only way I guess

like

Looks like it’s time to jump ship soon

like

Not all of them. Quite a few firms are hiring right now

Not really the time to push the issue. Big layoffs are coming. Be lucky you have a job.

like

Agree thanks

I got lowballed when I joined PWC US as a inter company transfer and have always remained at the lower range even after being the top performer every year and my partner loving me for delivering on every fire drill project I was assigned.
Also being a technology consultant did not help my cause as the firm does not care if you are not working on the business/functional side

like

Sad story. I was a transfer as well and global mobility did nothing for me

Young consultants... Google "Kris Kross - Jump"

There's your answer. We all had to do it. Jump around until you get as close as possible to market value and consummate with your experience and contribution to the P&L

likesmart

I came in low having transferred from audit to consulting at a time when the firm wasn’t making comp adjustments for transferees. I remained low for 3 years until the next promo level and I had proven my worth and found a mentor with political capital. I got a $35k comp adjustment outside of the normal year end process. The key is building your brand and your relationships to have someone powerful make the ask for you. An average employee will never get adjusted because they don’t care if you leave.

like

I was also low balled - when it came time for promo, I simply made the case on why I deserved a higher than usual increase and was fairly candid that I knew I wasn’t in the same pay band to bolster that argument - I gave a number that was not entirely outrageous (i.e more towards lower level of band) to justify the % increase to leadership. Got approved. While this worked for me - may not work for everyone. Feel free to DM me and Ill share a tactic that helped me a ton as well

like

It’s not. And I would never initiate it without another offer in hand. Post-promo would be better for sure.

Also remember, you only get to go to the well once.

I discussed with My manager, they took it up the chain of command, and I was told to wait six months. Instead of waiting, I found a new job

like

I was high balled and then black balled. It's all lead to blue balls.

funny

I see that makes sense thanks. You are right if I don’t ask I will not get it. My partner loves me and makes a lot of money off my delivery

like

Thread lightly. I have seen this happen and the answer is always the same...that you accepted the offer made to you. No renegotiation. That has been my experience with this topic (coachees, peers, jr staff).

like

Yes, and I’m working on it, idk how well it’s going tho

like

Good luck!

Came in at the absolute bottom. Proved my value. Got another offer. Paid to stay

like

Second this - always good to have an offer before going to the PPMDs. I was low balled when I started - the partners said there would be adjustment a year later but nothing happened till I got offers for them to take it seriously. For a lack of good term they kept jerking me around for a year saying it’ll happen at the year end and then at year end they said they’d missed my name and that they didn’t do mid year adjustments. Luckily I’d prepared for the worst case scenario had 2 offers in hand!

This was during my last job at uncle D!

like

That’s true. I don’t mind the long hours given my age right now and the learning curve but getting the right compensation compared to peers seems to be motivating . Money is never everything though

like

I quit and joined industry. Have more than recovered what I lost.

like

Related Posts

Anyone here know anything about reference point? Culture, pay, etc?

Need Advice on two job offers. One is in accounting advisory role at Crowe. The other is fund accounting analyst at Goldman Sachs. Comp is similar. Which one would have better exit opportunities? What one would you guys choose? Thank you guys.

likehelpful

Can anyone please share any insights on the National Federal Tax Services (NFTS) of Deloitte? Such as subgroups, salaries and hours for first year manager? Thanks!

like

A CRO offerred me an internal consulting/biz dev role. They offered 145k TC (20% bump) and slightly better benefits. They also offered accelerated path (6mo to 1yr) to MC. While promotion to MC at my current company is at least 1 year away. The job is interesting to me and fits my careery goal. But my big concern is that I've only been with my current company for a year (this is my first job, post PhD). Would this affect my resume in the future in terms of being viewed as "job hopping"?

like

I got an offer from OPTUM.
can someone please tell, how they pay the RRP (the average percentage )
and what will be the take home amount.
YOE - 7.5
Java Full Stack

Post Photo
like

Anyone able to share assistant manager/experienced associate and manager pay bands for deal advisory (FDD, CF) roles at the big 4 in london?

like
likefunny

What is the variable pay given in Schneider Electric
HR said that it would be minimum 100-200% ?

like

Hi, I’m interviewing for Laboratory supervisor positions at ARUP in the Salt Lake City, UT area. I have less than 2 years supervisor experience and I would like to negotiate if I get any offers. What are other people experiences/ salaries in same positions? Thanks!

like

Where do you live, what is your title, what is your salary?

Include employer if you want.

UX Designer, Toronto. $73k CAD

like

Hi,

Can someone help me with the inhand salary for the below mentioned.

Post Photo

What would be my in hand salary?


Is this most silly question (and mostly asked) when there are really good in hand salary calculator available online? Example: Ambitionbox

like

Salary vs rent poll: Salary / Monthly Rent / Living Situation (roommates, apt type, borough?)

like

I don't understand the point of hiring candidates. Its been more than two months and i am sitting idle. There is no updates from management. I am getting info like i will get half salary this month because of the bench policy. I m confused what to do next

like

If you get an offer a few days before you have a final interview (or while you're waiting to hear back), is it okay to ask for some time? Or do they expect you to answer right there?

i'm in the final round for 2 different media positions in 2 completely different places (NYC and NC) and things are moving really quickly for both. the NYC job is my dream one but they're both offering $40k so i'm conflicted. any advice would be helpful lol

like

Hi anyone aware of maximum fixed ctc LTI will offer for p2 level.
Yoe 4.8

What’s the high-end base salary one can expect for a commercial SC without an MBA?

like

Senior Manager, specialty tax practices in NYC: what was your base salary and bonus for the first year? Please also mention your firm.

like

What is the CTC offered for grade C4.3E in Software AG in Bangalore?

like

More Posts

I got an offer from OPTUM.
can someone please tell, how they pay the RRP (the average percentage )
and what will be the take home amount.
YOE - 7.5
Java Full Stack

Post Photo
like

How is Intel project in infosys?

Is infosys onboarding laterals virtually or physical onboarding.?

like

Anyone able to share assistant manager/experienced associate and manager pay bands for deal advisory (FDD, CF) roles at the big 4 in london?

like

Just heard EY is about to make more layoffs in audit too

like

With a recession around the corner - two questions:
1) will there be layoffs at Deloitte? My concern is we hired so much ppl this year.
2) will there be more work in org design? Just saw the Robinhood 9% workforce layoff announcement.

likehelpful

Accenture folks!
Can I submit the Time report in the next fortnight if I missed current fortnight (1st -15th sep).
Will there be any consequences?
I have recently joined Accenture (DOJ- 1st Sept) and I am yet to receive the WBSe details for time report submission.

Please help as I continuously receiving automated mails to submit the time report.

Thanks in advance!!

like

Newly joined birlasoft, how can I know the policies and workarround of the my world portal. Any idea who can help me on this..??

like

What is the eligibility or time period needed to move from 6B to 7A in IBM? I have 4.7 years of experience and joined IBM recently in JL 6B.

Thanks in advance.

Is it a bad sign if the company that typically moves fast (as said by former interviewees) is taking a long time to tell you whether or not you move forward to the next round in an interview?

like

Can anyone please share the work culture at Luxoft?

Hi All, I’m thinking about getting certified in change management but not sure if I should go the Prosci route or CCMP route. CCMP is a lot cheaper compared to Prosci but would it measure up just the same?

I guess it would be similar to the discussion of the SHRM-SCP vs SPHR.

like

Guys, on average, how many hours did you study before GMAT test?

like

Chances at SOM, Tuck, Fuqua, Darden? 3.7 from T100, 324 GRE (162/162), white lgbt male, 4 YOE with two promotions, on “young executive board” and 6 years of committed extracurricular

like

Are senior specialist / SME / Senior Manager at Deloitte all the same level? Just slightly different responsibilities?

like

YOE: 11.5 Tech: QA Automation with Selenium-Java, BDD, API automation, Mobile Automation - Perfecto cloud, Appium. All the 11 years I am with automation only. Is it possible for me to learn new technology and switch. Recently acquired AWS cloud practitioner certification which is of no use to me now as they are asking for exp. I wanted to move to devops role. But without experience no one is giving opportunity and they are considering my profile as QA only 😒

like

Looking to learn coding. Any thoughts on learning code through a website like Udemy, CodeAcadeny, etc.?

like

Hi.. I am happy to join here. Seems to be an amazing platform.

like

My 30th birthday present just arrived and I'm so incredibly excited

Post Photo
likeuplifting

I just discovered a brand called Cuervo y Sobrinos.

Some pieces intrigue me but I know nothing of the brand.

Is anyone familiar with this brand or even own one? If so, what do you think?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Did they remove the post showing year over year salary from earlier today?

like

Upcoming bain interview final round, i was told that it would be four 30 min case interviews, but the recruiter said it would be three 45 ones, with one of them a behavioral. I’m applying for the ACI

like

Someone give me a glass of wine... we only made it 10 min into dinner before mentioning Trump

like

Out of curiosity: what percentage of men in your office do you estimate to have cheated on their SO’s? Percentage of women? I think I’m naive about these things

like

So with the release of the Fyre Festival documentaries on Netflix and Hulu (Netflix was better than Hulu), did anyone get caught in that disaster? What did you think of the docs?

like

What would you do in this situation?
I have my last day at employer A right before thanksgiving and will be covered on their health insurance through 11/30. I am taking some time off before starting a new position with employer B in mid January but their insurance wouldn’t be effective until 2/1. I have 60 days to elect COBRA under employer A, which leaves me with 2 days where I wouldn’t have coverage (Jan30/31). What would you do in this situation? (Cont)

like

KPMG advisory ($115k) or TCS ($125k)? Relatively similar roles. Things to consider on these two companies? Thanks in advance for any insights!

like

Does B4 let people go the same day as their resignation only if they’re going to a direct competitor? How about MBB or a tier 2 consulting firm?

Have people been let go immediately in case they go to FAANG or other industry firms?

like

Any good books recommendation on effective client communication/business writing?

like

Save the cheerleader...

like

Does Accenture have a faster promotion cycle compared to the big 4?

like

Always forget how great meditation can be

likeupliftingsmart

Anyone here trade options?

like

Hey BCG 🐠, anyone in the Technology Advantage Practice? Care to provide some insight on the company culture and type of work?

like

Books to learn more about how to drive sales in consulting? Any recommendations?

likehelpful

Anyone heard of this firm The Berkeley Partnership? How good or bad is the work culture, work and the perks?

like

Fish w family- I have three kids, ages 4-12. Family vaca - House on the beach (Destin) or Bahamas? Same price sans transportation. Will we be overwhelmed w kids at Atlantis if Bahamas?

like

Top tips for moderating a panel? Also ideas for including audience interaction?

likehelpful

So i have been fortunate that i have managed to go through my career without the need for a degree. I was lucky enough to have been hired by one of the worlds top consulting firms, worked with a whole lot of big clients and travelled a lot. It's gotten to the point where I am not even asked about the lack of a degree on my resume. Personally though, it bothers me. I have a whole bunch of certifications in my industry…but just no formal degree. (cont'd)

like

Applied at Accenture and just finished the skills & behavioral interviews. Waiting to hear back from recruiter but today they reposted the exact job I was applying for, does that mean I didnt' get it?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal