How do you handle disagreements with your manager about technical decisions? I’ve learned to pick my battles and always come with data instead of opinions when I do push back. It doesn’t always work, but it at least keeps the conversation productive. How do you approach it?

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I've been fortunate to work with and for some brilliant and ethical engineers. One fixed equipment engineer recognized a serious process safety hazard risk on some equipment. He wrote an internal memo that spelled out the facts, including hard data that could not be ignored. He was advised the equipment would remain in service despite the known safety risk. He signed the memo witnessed by a notary public, stamped it with his PE stamp and submitted it. The equipment was used at risk. He resigned a few months later. Several of his staff followed him out the door.

like

I'm a structural engineer so it is pretty easy... The engineer of record (aka the person whose stamp goes on the drawings) makes the decisions. They take the responsibility so it doesn't matter if the person disagreeing is the manager or CEO. Generally speaking, however, I believe the data/logic-driven approach is the way to go. I find the approach of asking the manager questions rooted in data/logic is more successful than directly challenging with data/logic.

like

Where I work, you state the issue.

And they will ignore it even if you raise a valid concern...

like

Hahaha I think we work at the same place

like

Same

like

Thanks for sharing

As a manager myself, I tell my team that as far as technical issues go, I am just another peer opinion. However, when decisions need to be made regarding priority, business risk or other business-related issues, I would certainly listen to my team but ultimately, I would make the final call.

like

Pointless. You can say what the problem will be, and then it occurs, and they blame you for it. The whole thing is just a club.

One time, I strongly disagreed with a change in direction in a product that was going to replace our bread and butter device. I thought we would piss off our existing customers trying to attract a much smaller additional market.

I brought it up with my manager and he said we could discuss it over lunch. He took me to a nice Chinese restaurant and we talked. I left the meeting still disagreeing, but willing to do my best to implement the changes. I hid the old code behind #define statements just in case we needed to switch back quickly.

Unfortunately because of a major mistake made by a different group in our company, we never got to find out who was right.

Related Posts

My morning coffee is the most comforting thing in my life this past year. It’s 2pm on a Friday and tomorrow’s coffee is the only thing I’m looking forward to.

likehelpful

Hi Fishes, Great to connect here. I cleared my R1 for PepsiCo for L4 level. The HR told me I would have to attend 2 more rounds and they would get scheduled based on the panel's availability. Can anyone please help me with what kind of rounds they are going to be? Any insights would really help me in my preparation.

like

How suspicious is it that the client that just gave the pitch of VW in the US to Johannes Leonardo used to be one of the executives from Johannes Leonardo?

like

How much yearly hike can one expect at Société Générale ?
"Depends on performance" seems to be a very vague answer.
Can someone please elaborate on a better answer.

Also, Can someone shed some light on promotions?

Is there any policy, like you have to work for X years to be eligible for promotion etc.

Thanks in advance.

Société Générale

like

Hi Fishes, Anyone who can refer for a job in Informatica for senior software engineer role? Please DM. Thanks in advance 😊

Can anyone offer insight on Human Capital M&A interviews from the Big 4? What’s the process like? Case or behavioral?

like

How easy internal mobility in Atlassian India for EMs if they don’t like work in the team?

People over 40, what advice (career, financial, relationship) would you give to people in their early 30s? I see people in their 20s asking this for those over 30 so I'm curious 😊

likehelpfulsmart

I’ve been working in finance strategy / transformation consulting for the last two years and would like to pivot into construction project management. Looking to get some insights of if something like this is even feasible or if anyone else has done something similar.

like

Has anyone transitioned from solely doing HR functions into Talent Acquisition/ Recruiting ? If so, how has your experience been? Did/do you like it?Has it been difficult?

like

Hi! Any career coaches who offer a full support throughout job search?

-Experience: 8 years of project/program management and communication
-Companies of interest: Google, Microsoft, Facebook
-Location: Washington DC or VA

I'm currently working as a SWE and am interested in learning about the PM role and the experiences of others who switched to PM from a different role.
I enjoy customer engagement and planning/timelining work in an agile manner. These make me think I'd be a good fit for the role but I have some concerns/questions:
1. What is the pay-range compared to the average SWE pay range?
2. What skills are critical for the PM role?
3. Should I obtain Agile PM certificates?
4. Anything else I should know :)

like

Any recommendations for executive product management programs that might help transitioning from tech program management (engg experience too) to a product manager role.

like

Q for JPM crowd: Is manager notified when employee sends a request for 360insight feedback to a colleague? (Want to make sure manager has no way of influencing the feedback provider). Thanks

like

Hi Fishes, Please share this bowl with colleagues and friends. Thanks 🙏.

like

A question from a youngster. Is working at a big big company with slightly low pay better or working at a much smaller company with higher pay better?

In the future, after a few years, let’s say I’m at a small company and want to switch to big big company, will the “small names” hurt my chance to get into the big doors?

I mean big big company is like 10x bigger than the small one if this was a factor. Assume everything else the same, WLB, commute, teams, etc.

like
like

Hey Fishes ,
I am a QA/SDET with 8 YOE , good in building framework for UI and API Testing , right now working on improving coding (DSA) and AWS (SAA certification). I am at 25 LPA now and my aim is to get in FAANG what all i need to get in my bucket to crack that (or atleast improve my chance of getting in ), please guide me .

like

Looking for a referral for a Data Entry position or any position that doesn’t require me to answer phone calls, that also is 100% Remote!!!

Post Photo
like

What should be expected compensation in MasterCard for Senior BizOps Engineer in ITIL/ITSM team.

YOE : 7 year 6 Months
Current CTC : 21 LPA + 20% variable on top of ctc

like

Additional Posts in Engineering

Is it ever actually a problem for engineers in other parts of the world that US measurements are done in the imperial system?

like

Is it true that less than 20% of engineers are women, even when there are so many programs specifically focused on getting females into STEM fields? It seems like it should be more evenly distributed

like

I don't know if anyone can answer this. But how much do most civil engineers make? There are so many conflicting reports about "overpaid consultants" and it's almost impossible to get an actual answer

like

My boss asked me to take care of some of the details of a project for her—the stuff that isn't really my area of expertise. And now I feel like a shirker because I haven't been able to finish them yet.

like

What’s a failure you’ve experienced at work and how did you come back from it?

like

Any advice for a young engineer trying to land their very first job out of college?

likesmart

I recently visited for the first time the Santiago Bernabeu stadium, the stadium of the world-famous Real Madrid team, and despite being a physical engineer, I can not help but recognize that civil engineers are magicians, my congratulations to them.

like

I've noticed that the engineers keep their mouths shut whenever they're asked for feedback, but when they're alone, they talk about how much they wish they could change management.

Why is that?

like

During WWII a brilliant engineer found a way to encrypt radio transmissions, which led to the wireless network we use today. Who? Hedy Lamarr (yes, THAT Hedy Lamarr, the actress). A pretty face does not have to mean a lack of intelligence!

like

I am a newly graduated fresher mechanical engineer working in an electro mechanical company at Dubai, My current salary is 2500 AED, I would like to know about your comments and suggestions regarding my career which could help me through my future ventures.

like

I just got a new job, but it's not what I expected. I was expecting a career opportunity and a chance to learn and grow in my field, but instead I'm stuck doing the same thing as before, just from home.

like

As a chemical engineer, I have a lot of job opportunities, but as a recent graduate, I have had a hard time getting my first job. After my internship, I have only had 3 interviews. Does anyone know about any job bank for chemical engineers?

like

Do you ever regret your career choice? I’m beginning to realize I may not have wanted to be a mechanical engineer after all. What other career options are there for me with my current degree?

like

How difficult is it to switch from civil engineering to electrical engineering?

like

If anyone in the US is looking for a job in the field of civil/construction/environmental engineering doing a wide variety of work in real estate land development shoot me a DM. Remote and Hybrid options.

like

People who work in any engineering capacity are usually very hardworking but it's not just because we have to be, it's also that we find this stuff really fascinating, kind of like a book you can't put down

like

Hello, who can help me?
I am interested in knowing how much an oilfield engineer earns. I currently have a job offer from a medium-sized company, but as a recent graduate, I don't know if the pay is adequate.

like

I’m a recent grad struggling to look after my health when I’m stuck in a cubicle 10+ hours a day. How do you juggle a healthy lifestyle with long hours at a desk?

like

Curious about what kind of hobbies other engineers have, personally I love knitting in my free time

likeupliftingfunny

Aside from all the usual benefits like paid vacation time, health insurance, 401k matching program, have you ever seen a truly unique business perk?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal