I hired an employee who had a killer interview who turned out to be a dud and severely under qualified for their current role. Anyone else have someone like this? Any good advice on how to handle/develop or any good interview tips that I can try out so this doesn’t happen again?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Confession: I always feel like I am this person.

likefunny

For every one smooth talker, there are two shy curmudgeons doing the real work behind the scenes. Look for signs of competence rather than charm.

like

It’s annoying to not have the right support to help you on your account. But this is just advertising so it’s better to be the good person and get the resources to help groom them. If they still fail after all that, then at least you know you led with integrity and they’ll (hopefully) look back in gratitude at the time you took to spend on them.

like

It's unavoidable. Hasn't happened to me yet but I'm sure it will. I always get drawn in by folks with passion and energy, one of these days that will lead to me finding a fraud . Don't beat yourself up, happens all the time

like

I get it's disappointing to hire a "dud" but is there no potential for growth and development with them? It's nice to hire a rockstar right out the gate but that's not always the case

like

What kind of position are they in? Do they lack technical skills? Computer skills? People skills?

Are they open to learning and growing? Or do they think they are above that?

like

What Creative Director 1 said. Look for signs of competence with the ones who don’t smooth talk but actually do the work. Smooth talking full-of-it charmers are the worst.
Also, how about contracting first, then full time hire? That’s a good way to see if someone has what it takes before hiring them on full time.

like

Have you tried being direct with them about what you feel like they’re underperforming on? And building a growth plan with them with actionable ways they can improve? It’s a talents market right now, so a lot of people are making jumps for promotions they’re not necessarily qualified for. Also, something could be off with them personally (feeling anxious about RTO, family issues, etc).

For future interviewing tips: if this is an account services position ask them about a project they were passionate about and what their role was. Should be able to tell pretty quickly how knowledgeable they are.

like

Slow to hire quick to fire is the best way to get the work done. Manage out the dud as quick as possible (work with your HR team), and make sure you thoroughly vet the next candidate. Do you have set questions for your applicants? What questions are you asking? Do your questions touch on all the important aspects of the role (functional knowledge, collaboration, culture, etc)?

Related Posts

Dear Fishes

I am looking for job change. I am a social media marketer who resides in India. If there is any lead or referral it would be really helpful. I am open to work remotely even to relocate to cities like- Bangalore & Pune.

Regards
Digital Marketer
(Experience- 4 years)


#job #jobreferral #digitalmarketing #socialmediamarketing

like

Hey Guys,
I applied for UBS for Selenium Java QA profile and they have sent a hackerearth test. Can somebody share what the test-level is like ?
The test has 2 questions and 135 mins duration, will it be Java focused or can it have Selenium as well ?

#UBS #Selenium

How much time BNY mellon takes to reply after we submit all the documents they asked for once we complete all rounds of interviews.

@BNY Mellon

like

So, a recruiter gave me feedback that my lack SPHR or SHRM-SCP is causing my resume to be knock out by AI and human recruiters despite my position and work history in Multinationals and being in Technology. They suggested that we put SPHR ( Lapsed). I let it lapse in 2017. What is your opinion? Plus if I were to take another certification - should I take SPHR or SHRM-SCP?

like

Tier 2 to MBB fish... How has recruiting for other jobs compare at the two firms?

like

I have my first round interview (phone case) with McKinsey tomorrow. Any tips on what to expect with the phone case? Will there be an introduction (elevator pitch + why McKinsey?) or will they jump straight into the case? It’s only 30 mins.

like

Hey fishies! Been a GVP consultant for 3.5 years now, hard work, tough “in trouble” clients, and just haven’t had the chance to work with a team long term! Been in the industry a while, current Head of DSPV and looking to jump back into FT work. Non-MD so it’s hard to find companies that will hire me even though I teach in grad school and headed for my PhD. Any thoughts? Openings?

like

Anyone have insight on how quickly large and medium firms will resume hiring after quarantine lifts? Currently at an Am 100 but started looking just before Covid.

like

Is there someone who could provide a referral to Facebook

At what level, would one start getting technical questions in an interview for an industry position? - manager? SM?

like

How long do y’all like resume bullets to be? I know to keep them to 1-2 lines and to keep the resume to 1 page but I’m conflicted about how to balance details vs white space. I’m in product and see some resumes with bullets averaging 5-10 words that state “Manage roadmap for $200mm product” while others use ~20 words per bullet and highlight product info, process, or impact in a bit more detail.

Reallocated some of my WPF position to PSFE. They are post SPAC merger but both will be long term holds for me.

like

I’m supposedly going to get promoted to a managerial position next spring. I’ve been with the company for 3 years already. Do you get to negotiate salary when you get promoted?

like

Hello, in my previous organisation I worked in development domain (Oracle IAM Tool and Java)and my post was software Engineer, i joined Wipro as project Engineer in April 2022 and was assigned non technical project as an analyst.

I fought my way hard to get released from the project. However my designation is changed as Analyst. Should I ask for change in designation as I know that analyst is non-technical profile? Would my designation impact my future role as well?

like
like

Hello All,
If anyone is interested in getting an Amex card as first year free, please dm me. I can help with referral so that you get the card FYF and 2000 bonus points on spending just Rs. 5000 in 90 days.

like
likehelpful

EY India openings for AI/ ML

Post Photo
like

Hi Fishies, I have got offer from Salesforce for Success engineer role. But I am working as a Salesforce developer. I do have a offer of Salesforce developer role from Deloitte. Can anyone please help me about the role and responsibilities of support role? Will it be good idea to switch from developer to support role? My YOE is 2.6.

like

More Posts

Hey you, weary teacher, I see you.
I hear you sigh,
eyes closed,
Head in your hands...

I know the things you think,
the doubts,
fears,
the frustrated pain...

I know you are trying.
I know you work hard.
Sometimes it seems like you’re the only one
in the whole damn school who cares...

I know.
I see.
I hear.
I care.

You are the difference.
You are power.
Through you flows the future.
You author the stories of the world.

I care about the tale you are creating.
Please keep writing. Please.

likeupliftinghelpful

I will be working at a brand new elementary school this fall, and have signed up to be on the "equity committee". Have others had this experience? What topics did you delve into?

like

I have been offered by Amazon. Have one doubt, they have stated that for relocation, if done by self managed...we will be getting lumpsum amount of 1.5 lacs. My question is, will it be reimbursed against bills or it will be paid as one time amount without any bills..
Experienced Amazonians views needed. Thanks!

like

Hey, would you guys recommend working as an operations analyst at Brex, SDA at Affirm or Business Analyst at capital one. Recent grad here that got the offers but is having some issues deciding

like

Any Recommendation institute or website that offered access to SAP ARIBA or EWM Instance Training Server ?

like

Persistent Systems Limited or Billdesk or Capgemini
Which one is better?

like

I am going to India for a month. May have to change my return date. Any suggestion on what insurance/other option to reduce the ticket update cost impact.

which firm would most value a supply chain background? mck?

like

Had a final round at BCG last Friday. After the interviews they said that the would release results today. Then I got an email today saying they will only give the results on the next Friday. What could have happened?? I also know some people how interviewed on the same day as mine and got a rejection email today.

like

Anyone else struggling with hormones / mood swings? I am almost 16 weeks and been having a real tough time lately, feeling really down and stressed about things. Sadly, causing tension between me and my partner as well as he cannot relate and seems preoccupied with business as usual. Trying to get out the funk and just telling myself it’s all the hormones.

Give suggestions on companies to apply in Bangalore.
Want a transition from Data Engineer to ml engineer/data scientist.
Yoe - 1
Engineering- tier 1 nit
Skills:
AWS Associate solution architect.
Azure agile working environment.
Python, sql,Hadoop, spark big data, ci/cd pipeline, aws cloud computing
Regression, pca, knn, ensembles , decision tree etc
Currently working in pharma industry.
Please provide refrell if you have any.

like

What are some good product based companies to work as Data Engineer?
Good in terms of learning, interesting work and good work culture.

like

What salary can I expect for this role in Kyndyl? I just need a base for negotiation. I have three years of experience in IBM/Kyndryl and the role is System administrator.

like

I’m so bad at writing the background/ facts section for briefs… it always gets heavily edited and no one is giving me constructive feedback other than “advocate more”. In contrast, my legal argument section is generally without edits. For context, first defense lit job post appellate clerkship. Is this normal?? Any tips for getting better other than “advocating more”?

likehelpful

What is the scoop on med mal defense vs. plaintiff work? Is defense more respected by other practice areas if I were to switch somewhere else later?

I applied to a position that brands itself as civil litigation and apparently the role is med mal defense. Not sure what to go by but would like to do a little research before I call them back.

like

How do you not go absolutely batshit with anxiety while job hunting?

like

Any parents here? How did you originally explain the Covid pandemic to your children?

like

Do you get a bonus? How much? Do you count it in your salary when posting here?

180 base, 50 bonus, plus 50-75k profit sharing and 50k equity a year.

Still feel underpaid on initial base salary :/

funnylike
like

Additional Posts in Advertising

I really need to know. Does anyone genuinely care about their jobs anymore? Money aside.

likefunny

Tips for dealing with procrastination?

like

Any other integrated agencies working in Agile across the full agency? Trying to understand how this plays out as we roll it out.

like

What’s up with SCC Chicago?

like

Why do companies do this? I interviewed with a company. They loved my work and told me that I’m going to start the following week. They made me sign all of the onboarding papers and poof ghosted me! 🤦‍♀️ I feel so down right now! And I feel like I won’t be able to ever land a job!

likehelpful

Does anyone know the stories behind KFC's "I love you Colonel Sanders" dating sim game and Wendy's D&D rpg? Were agencies involved or did they start in-house?

like

Any agencies that have a good reputation, but suck when you actually work there? Wonder why that happens?

like

When should you stop following up after a great interview? Was told I was too pricey for one market, so they asked me if I would consider another in the future. I said yes, and now it’s been a week.

like

Books on human psychology that have affected you. I'll start: influence, sales Bible, on killing.

like

NYC: my wife has about 16 years of professional graphic design experience in the garment industry. She wants out. She’s thinking about branding, UX, or digital design. Continued....

like

Looking to hire a freelance paid media buyer, specializing in performance marketing across paid social + search channels.

~10-12 hrs a week!

DM me if interested or if you know anyone that’s be a good fit!

likehelpful

Food/bar recos in CHS?

like

Modern problems require modern solutions.

Post Photo
likefunny

What are some questions to ask/things to look for before the first time you’re jumping ship that helped you decide whether it was worth it (other than remoteness, salary, and benefits)?

like

Most beautiful places to escape within three hours' driving of NYC? Forests, lakes, ocean, camping.

like

Hiring managers and recruiters: a lot of well-respected schools (Harvard, BC, Cornell, Penn State, MIT) now have pretty robust online programs. Contd

like

Nice Ronald McDonald spot, Subway. Enjoy your cease and desist letter tomorrow morning!

like

Pretty over agency life, best brands to go client-side?

like

What kind of work is done by Junior Talent in Data & Analytics?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal