i need a some perspective about the big 4 and mbb. i’m a senior undergrad recruiting for consulting and this cycle didn’t go as well as planned. i had an interview w mckinsey (no offer) and never heard back from rest of big 4/mbb. got an offer from UHG which is not bad at all but can’t help but feel hopeless that i didn’t get where i wanna be. i feel like i’m obsessing over the name/prestige of these firms even though ik there’s so much more out there than the name of your company and i’m young

likesmartfunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I didn't know about consulting out of college, but after my first job I received a lot more offers so it should be easy to jump after half a yr

also everyone says prestige doesn't matter but for young people like us I definitely took it into account just don't let it get to your head

likehelpful

I’m in the exact same boat. Comparison is the thief of joy. No one cares where you went out of college. All things people have told me that I’m also trying to rationalize. Regardless, it’ll probably be ok in the grand scheme of things.

like

I joined McKinsey out of undergrad and I was honestly surprised how many people were there who were a few years older than me but started over as a BA at McKinsey after getting a couple of years of experience. They’re definitely better equipped than fresh graduates and if you want to go down that path later you definitely can- patience is key and nothing needs to happen overnight!

like

Identical experience here. +1

like

Go tech. On par salary for literally .3 - .5 X work.

like

As long as you get good experience/learn a lot during your first year you can easily hop over to somewhere more prestigious if you want

like

Just get some work experience and you can always apply for other jobs with 1-2 years of work experience. UHG is a great company and a great place to start a career. It can even give you a leg up applying to consulting if you are interested in life science / health care as an industry

like

The average person on the street doesn't even know what these b4/mbb acronyms mean. Our own family members look at us like we have 3 heads when we try to explain what we do all day. People really don't care - and that's freeing!

Sticking around at UHG for a bit will make you a really interesting experienced hire - you'll have some really unique Healthcare/life sciences experiences to boost your resume when you go for the firm you want.

This isn't a bad hand at all - play it well🙂

like

UHG is a great company to start out at and it is recognized as so. After 9-15 months you could absolutely jump into an experienced role at any of the big4. MBB will be a lot tougher but I’ve seen ppl get a BA role after 2 yoe outside

like

Ultimately, congratulations!! You should be excited for all you’ve accomplished and what’s ahead. And try to start your first job with an open mind, no matter where you are at.

like

Chill homie. Undergrad is just the beginning! Consulting will always be there! Getting a foot In the door will give you the experience you need to go to the next place. Be proud of where you are.

like

I was in the exact same boat. I hated my experience at EY during my junior internship. I didn’t make the final round for MBB, started at an industry analytics role, and then got an offer for mbb after more than a year. Not the end of the world, just treat your experience as a learning journey. Don’t give up!

like

My advice would be to find another firm. The mentality when going into consulting recruiting is to apply to any and all firms regardless of size, prestige, reputation, etc and consider all offers you recieve at the end.

I didn’t get MBB/Big 4 offers as a senior in college. I got 2 offers and choose the better fit for me at the time. I currently work for a firm that is tech focused, but bench is ridiculously big right now.

I think you can definitely break into consulting if you put your mind to it. Even if it’s not your first choice firm, just breaking into the industry outta undergrad is a milestone. U can always switch firms down the road.

Even once you break in, you may not have a most ideal start. I have been benched since end of training for 3.25 months now and I am now considering alternative careers/firms. Don’t care about size or prestige as long as I am staffed.

like

Work at a firm somewhere else for a year. Then apply, offers will come flowing in (competitive as well depending on how well u utilized year 1- knock if out the park so u can truly negotiate)


I’m only 2 years out of college & went from 70k to 110k (excluding (signing)bonus) all from that 1 year at a lower firm & getting a couple certifications while there.

Offers from big 4 came as well, so I def recommend you keep your linkedin updated always - as they all reached out to me but definitely look into which company culture you feel is the best fit for you. Big 4 may sound lit but i know alot of miserable ppl scared they will be let go due to the economy & time on the bench 😭

like

My first job was at a terrible consulting firm. Be happy you got an offer with UHG! Get that experience. There’s always opportunities to jump to prestigious firms after you gain more experience in consulting.

like

UHG as in united healthcare group?

I hope no one from UHG is on fishbowl and sees the HR new hire speaking negatively about their new firm….

I was in talks with a hiring manager at McKinsey and that particular team had a hiring freeze out in place until further notice just FYI

Be focused on what you wanna do, doesn’t matter where. I started in EY and then I decided to join a “smaller” firm a few months ago. I learning way more in Management Solutions, so again don’t be obsessed over the name itself

Related Posts

What are benefits like at Accenture?

Interviewing now, chances of being hired before the new year?

likefunny

I am asked during this RE analyst interview to build a real estate model from scratch. My background is commercial banking and I am used to analyzing real estate deals from the lender side not the developer. The interviewer is generous I must say he’s giving me a few days to complete. However this model is for a ground up multifamily development. I have no prior experience building one. I can find models online but all very complexe to reproduce. How would you handle? Do you have model to share?

like

Anyone put on administrative processing when applying for a b1/b2?

Had several great interviews at a company. Reached out to internal recruiter a few days ago. No word back. Should I send a LinkedIn message to the person that would be my boss to check in?

How much money do you get for referring someone that is hired at Deloitte?

like

Any Deloitte consulting managers transfer from US to UK? What was your starting salary? Been at the M level for a couple years. Lots of industry expertise in my field too. Wondering what to expect for M level. Hoping for £90k + Benefits. Unreasonable?

like

Hey sharks! Kindly suggest!
Goldman Sachs yoe 7 and role: BA
fixed: 24 LPA
Designation: Operations Specialist

Is this justified for yoe, salary and designation? Absolutely no clue, kindly help…

like
like
like

What would be an ideal pay package for an Operations Manager at Syngene/GSK/Pfizer for someone with 10yrs work exp? And what grade does it fall under?

Hi Fishes, Can you please help me with Salary Range for Grade 7A at GSK?
They're Matching my Current Offer's Fixed Part with Fixed + Yearly Bonus. Which I think is a downside.
Want to know the range to know limits of negotiation without losing the offer

like

Hi all, Currently I am 1.6yrs experienced.I had completed my interview with HCL Technologies along with HR discussion around 1st week of July.On 20th July I received an email from HR saying I need to wait for 3 more weeks to get the offer letter. My salary was 3.8 LPA at the time of interview(it became 4LPA from August) and i asked for 6.5 LPA Need advice on whether or not to expect the Offer Letter in hand once 3 weeks are over? HCL Technologies

like

IBM - 19.7L fixed + 2L JB

FIS Global - 19.8L fixed + 1.90L variable + 1L JB

YOE - 7 years
Tech - .Net

Which one in terms of Job security(main concern) , WLB , yearly average hike , better projects ?

like

I've cleared 2Technical rounds in @EY, waiting for HR round.
I've one offer for 23lpa, but not got it in hand. Hr discussion was over in that company.
Now how much I can ask in @EY Can I tell about that offer discussion and yet to receive it in hand.?? Please suggest. EY

like

Hi Fishes,

Need advice,

I recently got laid off by PS and my notice period just got over,

I have offers from:

PineLabs,

HealthKart,

Recro,

Rojo Consultancy

All are offering almost same ctc around 19-22 LPA,

I have 3 years of experience as a backend developer,

working on Spring Boot, REST API, Java 8.

Any help is really appreciated,

Thanks in Advance 😅



like

How onsite opportunity thorugh IJP work in CitiCorp

like

Does PwC SDC (AC Bangalore) reimburse phones for employees? Heard that Deloitte reimburses upto 30k.

like

I have offer letter from Accenture and they have asked me to fill the compensation excel sheet.

Does anyone has any idea how to do that?

like

More Posts

Best gyms in Philly? Pre-covid I was doing a mix of OrangeTheory, F45, Corepower Yoga, with a few other places mixed in from ClassPass. Thoughts on the nicest gym? Located in Fishtown but would go down to nolibs/old city/midtown village too

like

Currently interviewing for a remote account manager position with USI Insurance in NC. I have over 20 years experience in personal lines as an agent. Can anyone provide insight as to the average pay for this position?

like

I am serving notice period and in october month salary I haven’t received night shift allowance while other members of team have received it. Can anyone please confirm if there is such rule that within notice period Night shift allowance goes on hold and will be paid in FnF. Or should I raise this concern with my manager.

like

Can I get some real helpful guidance here?

Current finances:
-75k in the market (VTI,QQQ, ETFs and stocks)
-20k in Emergency find /Cash
-30k in Roth(maxing since 2019)
-60k in 401k (maxing since 2019

I don’t got much money expenses and wanted to know where to put my money during this market for the next couple months. Is it smart to DCA? Put limit orders in? Just hold cash?

Additional info:
-minimal rent / expenses (~1000/mo)
- started HSA this year
-130k, 3 YOE
- no debt

like

What agency do you work at and how many productions do you go to in a 1 year period?

like

3 weeks in as an experienced hire and still struggling in terms of understanding my role on projects, networking, organization structure, firm initiatives and career development process. How long did it take you to settle in? Any tips?

like

Butter chicken and coconut flour tortillas

Post Photo
like

Hi All,can you please let me give me some idea about the following things:

1. what kind of technologies are used in Data Engineering projects in ANZ? Do they work with open source frameworks like Pandas, Pyspark etc. Or everything is done using their internal tools?

2. And is there any opportunity of internal project switch after 12-15 months if I want to work in some different tech stack?

3. How is the work-life balance and job security for people working in India office?

Thanks in advance.

I have been selected by Cargill as an ML engineer, but they are not releasing the offer letter. It has been over a month now after all the negotiations. Can someone tell me what is the typical amount of time they take for releasing it?

Hi Fishes, I have interview for Product Controller in Credit suisse. Can anyone please let me know which topics should I study ?

Hello Fishes,

I need some advice regarding this situation and what to do. So I work for a company that offers outsourcing services to major investment banks around the world. I have been working for a new client for about six months now and they seem to like my work so far. Recently I saw that they're hiring to get people on their team at my level. My question is, should I talk to my client and try to pursue them to consider me for the role they're hiring for?

Interviewer : Why do you need this job?
Me :

Post Photo
likefunny

I really feel like I should be excused from this "diversity and inclusiveness" training stuff lmao. It's about implicit bias and I'm sorry it's just not believable coming from an old white man's mouth when there are maybe 4 non-white associates. We're having these meetings 3 times this week. 🤦🏽‍♀️

like

Hi fishes, how can I keep a track of my leaves? How many I have applied, how many are left etc? Please paste the path here, thanks.

like

Hi,
Can there be a case when you are hired for a specific role and later on you are aligned to a different project ?
Thanks

like

The only ones who get hurt riding a roller coaster are the ones who jump off. Don't panic and sell, everyone! Time in the market > timing the market.

like

Hi How's the bonus payout in crisil for Mumbai?

If someone can help with the benefits in comparison with other companies

That time of year... friends in the office giving me funny/cool gifts. I’ll need to reciprocate but am just brain dead these days.

What are some of the best “office” gifts you’ve received in the past?

like

Any insight into Jackson Lewis NYC office? Compensation, billable hours, WLB? I would be a 2-3 year

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal