I'm an EY Manager. Got an offer at Consultant at McKinsey for $25k more. Would you take it for a demotion in title? Also, I've heard mixed reviews on culture. Any insight?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I would take it. 10 years down the line you won't know the title difference but it is a great brand name and that does mean something :)

like

Great advise here. McK is a huge step above EY. Got nothing to lose and everything to gain.

like
Recent IconRecent

Yes. Exit opportunities are significantly better.

like

A demotion with more money means a higher income ceiling down the road

like

Take it. More money and it's McKinsey. Plus, exit opps much better with the McKinsey brand name. It's not even comparable.

like

I Don't know guys... McKinsey is pretty brutal in terms of up or out. Would suck to be a manager, go to consultant, then get kicked out... And now you are a jobless consultant not a jobless manager...

like

exit opportunities McK > EY

like

Definite yes.

like

OP - I was a Manager at a Big 4 and made the move to McK, took the title "demotion". Best decision I've made, McK has been v good to fast track (particularly for experienced hires in our situation) and I made EM early. Would not have had it any other way - being an Associate and actually knowing what you're doing gives you the headspace to spend time navigating the firm, building your network and learning how projects are run (because it is different!). Would beg to differ with D2, I have not felt like it is an up or out culture at all (unless you have serious performance issues, which I have faith that you don't!), we have many different options and tracks for if you want to take a longer pathway. Other consideration is the practice / area you're joining though - it can make a difference.

like

Op if you don't take, I will.

like

I was in a similar situation. Depends on what year of Manager you are. May make a little more sense at M1 only if you want to move to Strategy real bad. Have you explored our Strategy competency or talked to someone at Parthenon? FYI, I declined and have not looked back since. Hope this helps.

like

As for mixed reviews about culture, the NY office does not have a great reputation w/n the firm so I'd think hard about heading there. Most of the other offices are good people though.

like

Take itttttttt you fool

like

You could easily go back to EY if that's and what you felt like doing.

like

What helps me in evaluating opportunities is looking at LinkedIn profiles of others in the same position. Looking at their backgrounds and experiences. And for those who have left, looking at where they're at

like

@d757p so? I'm cleaning up one of your messes right now, but you don't see me talking shit about your firm.

like

Our risk practice certainly seems to be doing well.

like

I'm leaning towards ey2. If you want to do consulting for a longer period of time, switch. If you're at the higher M level and is thinking about leaving consulting, that's another story.

Btw how did you get this opp?

like

That was a pretty dumb comment, D2. You're 0 for 2.

like

OP and EY 2 what practice? Any tips on how to get into this same situation?

like

Related Posts

Any EAs make the make the switch to virtual EA? Have you noticed a decrease in pay and benefits?

like

Hi folks .. I recently got selected in Amazon for L4 position in Bangalore for the role HR Specialist U.S .. my recruiter said my CTC would be 7.7 lpa and my current CTC is 4.75 lpa .. please advise how much I can negotiate here. I am looking for more than 10lpa per annum minimum.. Amazon

Looking at a job in Kobo (Rakuten) for Data Analyst, any insights as in the technical portion of the interview ? Also, any recommendations regarding the company? Thank you!

like

Do Salesforce offers permanent WFH ? Have anyone asked for this? The role is Technical support. Anyone who asked for this within company?
Ty in adv

like

Is there anyone who is working in DVT dialysis project in citiustech in hmt2 market.
Need some inputs about project.
Please help me
Thanks

like

Current market rate for federal tax S2 in NYC?

Anybody know anything about Essence? Good place to work? A recruiter reached out about a potential opening but I know nothing about the company

like

Transactions salary range for experienced managers or senior managers SF/LA location. Exploring options with other big 4. Any suggestions.

like

Oracle im .Net developer with 7 YOE. I've cleared 1st round of oracle. Anyone attended interview recently can help me with what the 2nd round would be?( Coding/questions/ architecture etc.,)

Anyone have advice for advancing in your current role? My co-worker was hired in at manager level but somehow “proved” he was actually doing director level work and got a title promotion and salary increase in less than a year. I also went above and beyond my job as well (covering for him for a month while he was away on paternity leave) while taking on other projects outside of my job title and got zip—no raise or recognition. Any advice would be appreciated!

like
like

I’m a WMCA that has been with Merrill 2 1/2 years and my current team 2 years and have never had a raise despite positive annual reviews. Fully paid by FA’s. Is this normal?

Is workers comp a bottom of the barrel practice area?

like

Does HCL technology stop giving Joining Incentive?

like

Hi

I got an offer from accenture 8lpa fixed 1.68 variable n the position is level 11.
Now i have better offers from pwc n kpmg
10lpa fixed.
Will accenture increase their offer. They wer not even ready to go till 8.5 last time. But now i have other offers in hand. Is it possible to go back and ask for improved offer n position even though i have accepted the old 8lpa offer from accenture 1 month back.

like

Is SAP labs going to extend wfh post June? Or in hybrid model can we choose to work 1 week in a month in office and rest wfh. Basically I live in a different city(chennai - in laws home) and got an offer from SAP Bangalore(parents home) . I can travel once a month to work in office and stay rest of the month in chennai. Is it feasible to do this?SAP

like

Looking for referrals for a Technical Sales Executive position that is Remote (USA), possibly in the industrial sector. Last year I made $109k at AT&T so I'm hoping to at least stay in the same ball park but want a change. I have lots of experience selling IT/telecom, but I also have a Mechanical Engineering background so I'm a good fit for a wide range of technical sales. I have been thinking a role in the industrial sector with a longer sales cycle may be a good fit, can travel up to 25%

like

Hi all,
Anyone working in Nineleaps company Bangalore?
Please share your working experience? Hows the working environment and about work life balance?Nineleaps

like
like

I am done with my HR round. And said I am selected in Siemens, balewadi, but not yet received the offer letter. Its been a month now They are waiting for approvals. Any idea when will I get the offer letter.

More Posts

Hows the Mphasis directcore division...what project are there in mumbai...hows the culture?

like
like

I’m looking to have my CV done professionally. Can anyone recommend any good professional cv writer?

like

Any good squash clubs in the City?

like

Hy guys
I’m looking for a job as a associate project manager, in market research company. Like CINT , KANATAR and all. Can any one help me in this!
Thanks in advance

What's one way you're committing to a more inclusive workplace this year?

likeuplifting

I am hearing that MBB is pausing majority of the interviews - should I be worried about my offer getting rescinded? I luckily got my offer a few months ago and received my signing bonus already.

like

Do tech companies like FAANG hire strategy consultants? Starting at an MBB/T2 next year and curious if tech companies leverage consultants as much as other industries. Part of me wonders if they are in such high growth right now that consultants can’t add as much value, thus maybe a smaller presence. Thoughts?

like

Looking for referrals for PwC Australia ..

Can someone tell me what is the role of a Salesforce Developer/Technical Consultant at Salesforce company? I thought they used to hire Salesforce Developers for support profiles only.

like

Emtec I am switching from automation engineer (python) to bigdata. 8 yoe and current ctc 13L. Got an offer from emtec inc for 18L. What kind of clients do they have? Should i accept the offer? Dont have any other offer yet but final round in 2 more service based companies.

like

$25k budget, build your best 3 watch collection. Thoughts?!

My initial hypothesis:
1) Omega Speedmaster Pro
2) Rolex GMT Master ii (batman, ideally)
3) IWC petite prince

like

I am an IT manager in a Telcom company. I am a Canadian wanting to move to Florida. Any advice what Telcom companies are in there. Do they hire Canadians? Any Canadians who had applied tn visa before? Please advise

like

DM me if anyone wants a referral to PwC!

like

Is getting an ICF certification really with it? Pros and cons, please.

like
like

IBM - 19.7L fixed + 2L JB

FIS Global - 19.8L fixed + 1.90L variable + 1L JB

YOE - 7 years
Tech - .Net

Which one in terms of Job security(main concern) , WLB , yearly average hike , better projects ?

like

Can someone explain to me what the big whoop is about working in IB? Hours seem nuts from what I read in the bowls. What am I missing? Is it the pay?

like

Hi folks, I have a experience of 1.5yrs in mulesoft but I want a role as Java developer. please provide me a referral. TIA

like

I have an interview lined up for Autodesk US as an Data Engineer. Wanted to understand a bit more about salary structure and how company really is?. Autodesk

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

All I know is Legolas, Aragorn, Gimli, and Gandalf would NOT have taken a L last night against the Night King and his army

like

Honest question here-hw do I work better with Indians who come over frm India(on-site) to client?My patience with them is at an all time low since they jst dnt gt the methodology & hate owning anythng

My Delta flight is overbooked and they're offering $800 (can increase to $1000) currently to move to a later flight tomorrow morning. Only if I could WFH tomorrow 😞

like

Do you have to return the sign on bonus if you get laid off, sign on period (2 years) has not yet passed. I would also like to know the firm's severance policy.

like

What is the best consultancy for Media and Entertainment work? Considering a move…

like

Best business-oriented, but novel-style books with good writing, style, & interesting characters? Not really self-help/advise focused, more of actual literature with business themes/plots. Any recs?

like

Running late so I left my car in front of the terminal. Called Avis and told them if they want their car it's in front of terminal 2

like

can someone please recommend a good newsletter or site I can read about analytics just be abreast with the latest news, tech, tutorials and methodologies?

like

I'm looking for breast aug recommendations in NYC-I've done some research online but would like to hear about price and how happy you are with the results from anyone that had it done. Thanks!

like

TFW they ask you if you can assist in case of an emergency and you nod yes but you're actually not sure bc you're drunk AF 😬

like

What is everyone’s top 1 or 2 favorite books on personal finance? I’m always looking for a new one to bring into the fold of what I’m doing

like

Any recommendations for a good adult swim coach in NOVA?

like

What are the best data privacy certs to aim for? 4 year exp in cyber risk consulting. Want to move to a privacy related role outside the big 4. Should I go for the CDPSE or CIPP or CIPM?

like

What is it with you people leaving shit stains on the toilet seat? Is it because so many Americans are lard asses?

like

After a year using my home office setup, especially the 27 inch monitor, how can I ever go back to the traveling life with tiny laptop screen? 😔

likesmart

This call is a cure for insomnia.

funnylike

Bombed a case interview 😢

likeuplifting

How often does United upgrade people using Regional Premier Upgrades? Flying back from Honolulu and hoping to get into first.

like

How is utilization calculated? What happens if we are on the bench?

like

Anyone have a test bank for the Azure 900 cert or have any recommendations on how to pass it asap. Also looking into AWS cloud practitioner

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal