Hi,
I’m graduating from my undergraduate program and I have two offers:

1) Research Analyst - Corporate Finance at BCG ValueScience Center
2) Financial Analyst - Private Wealth Management at Goldman Sachs

If my ultimate goal is to become a management consultant, which one should I choose? Are the any major differences between BCG Value Science Center and BCG? Any insights on either role and company would be much appreciated!

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Is this a serious question — there is a huge difference. This is like asking if the accountant of the LA Lakers is the same as being a player on the team.

like

Fair but the analogy holds.

Go to Goldman Sachs. Looks better and good experience

like

I would agree. Learning finance specific tools will pay dividends down the road.

The BCG research analyst role seems like it’s part of ‘BST/support functions/knowledge team instead of the core consulting pathway .

The BCG support functions/Knowledge team WLB is great and not expected to work long hours. The downside is that it’s not the consulting part so you ll always be considered second tier. Knowledge roles are what you make of it (you can either Network get staffed on cases and do well or sit back be lazy and do the minimal but there’s no up or out system). I have seen people in knowledge roles for 10-15 years they don’t move up or not but are content as BCG is one of the best places to work in terms of ppl , benefits, training, work/social events (all employees are treated at part whether it’s HR marketing or knowledge team)

The only downside of the research/knowledge team is that changing to the main consulting track is very hard (requires support of partners , normal interview process) I.e there’s only a slight advantage vs applying externally .

If you want to do consulting in the long term either take option 2 or take a core consulting role!

like

Thank you so much! I really appreciate the advice!!

like

Related Posts

How is PwC AC at senior levels? What is hierarchy

like
like
like

Just became an ACD. Im in a limbo. Half of the time im being treated as a Super Senior AD and the other half im being treated as a Almost CD. Then when im scoped over work that my CD and I oversee, some people are asking me how does my role differ from the CD’s, as they tend to look at me as an unnecessary layer for approvals. In a way, i do the job so well that i get asked to do more AD projs and guide more projs — but then: wtf does my CD do? They mostly just 👍🏻what i direct n approve

likehelpful

Can anyone please help me with a referral in JP Morgan.i have the job id.Thanks in advance

Is there such thing as a true account role at major branding agencies? Ex. Interbrand, Landor, Pentagram...Sounds like in many cases it’s actually just PM under a different name.

like

Hi All,

Need a referral for an in-house legal role at GS. Kindly connect through DM or comment here if you can help me with your referral.

like
like
like

Any paralegals here working at Nesenoff & Miltenberg LLP in Manhattan? How’s the culture, pay, and work and life balance?

like

Anyone here with experience as a Product Manager? I’ve close to decade of consumer lending experience including Sales/Advisory, Supervisor and Underwriting. I have have been looking to pivot into a more impactful role this year. I am due for an interview for a Product Manager next week. The company ticks all my boxes but the job description a bit vague. I will be grateful if anybody willing to share what the day role looks like and what I need to look out for in an interview. Thanks. Cheers.

Any thoughts or opinions on IBM or SAP projects
Work culture, Pay, Experiance

like

Do you think consulting is not the right path for core technical people ?

like

Hey , i want to know the transport facility in cognizant Gurgaon as i am not getting proper information from HR for Day shift role. Can someone please help. Its an urgent request.

like

Marsh & McLennan Hi Fishes,

I am currently serving notice period and 30th sept 2022 is my LWD.

Role : Java App Support Analyst

Tech stack : Java,Linux,SQL,ITIL, Jenkins

Current CTC : 5.7LPA

I have offer from Marsh : 14.LPA fixed + 10% variable

BOA is offering 13.5 LPA Fixed+ 1.5 JB

However, BOA is giving DOJ as 7 Novemeber.

I am looking for your suggestions which one to join. Kindly help.

Bank of America Marsh McLennan

How is the work culture for a DevOps in QuestionPro Pvt. Ltd Pune?

like

I am getting trained in mainframe.
Is it worth to get trained in such old technology and which kind of work I have to do in this tech.

Hi

I have a current CTC of 6.6 and Mastercard is offering 8.9 (including variable ) . I also have an offer from infosys of 10 ( including variable). Which one should I pick considering work life balance and
appraisal.My entire doubt is that will they bring me on market rate after appraisals as currently they are not offering very good hike.

I will be joining HR team

Any recommended books to read prior to beginning a summer associate position? Transactional/ Corporate & Finance

like

What all companies have openings for Informatica Developer for 7.5 YOE...
if anyone has any referrals pls post
Currently serving notice period....

More Posts

I survived the cull and consider myself lucky for that.

Anyone who hasn't, please post here with your background and industry alignment.

I'm sure many others on here would be willing to put you in touch with personal contacts to help you get back in employment.

Now more than ever, remember that this too shall pass.

like

I pity those who revel in the "accomplishment" of have 100+ YTD utilization. Y'all got suckered by the firm.

like

I love my Nintendo Switch. If I'm too depressed to get out of bed, I can still practice my speedrun.

like

Considering lateraling to a bigger firm that pays closer to market or market. I really like my current firm and coworkers and WLB, but I am being underpaid. Based on conversations with my PG leader and supervising partner, I might make NEP/Counsel this year or next. How do you go about asking what the pay bump for that is? If it’s sizable I might just stay.

like

Are we all small training sets waiting to experience and learn it all and eventually be part of the master AI aka God?

like

Hi All ,

Is anyone working in Fujitsu as associate technical service engineer ? I was interviewed for Azure & windows admin profile but the designation mentioned as Infrastructure Associate technical service engineer . I'm wondering if this is okay ?

Thanks,
Nagarjun

Had a 3.2 in undergrad at UC Berkeley. Struggled with mental health 2 of my semesters, which reflects in my transcript pretty evidently. Is it worth writing an optional essay about? Just don’t want to be dinged and not seen as capable for grad level courses bc of that

like

Trying to do some initial research on laptops for business school and trying to determine if a new Mac book pro could be used at Wharton (or honestly any school!) for finance (not quant finance major though!)

like

Any one here from magneti marelli account?

like
like

What is alight noida in wipro ?

like

Has anyone had a client request zoom and virtual house showings?

like
like

Have any one used a resume coach or service for in house job search, particularly for IP and product counsel positions? If so, how did you find a good one? Thanks!

like

Ok! What would be the manager promotion increase and bonus this year for a National firm in the northeast region?? Any guesses?!

likehelpful

What should i go for TCS 9.5Lpa or Rategain 11.5 lpa

like

Creative recruiters. When looking at candidates, how much does the resume matter vs. the portfolio? Do you even look at the resume? Thanks

like

What are the hours like for a program manager in the Bay Area?

like

What are the criteria for LTI Grant to individuals and what are the amounts for Level 8,7 and 6 if it gets offered in India ? TIA

like

What’s the best site to put your condo on rent other than Kijiji & MLS?

Additional Posts in Consulting

HR Transformation, Workforce Transformation, Change Management.

Which has a better career path and pay? Are they all similar?

like

Anyone have a recommendation on a good place to get a bespoke suit in the DC area? I’m a odd size so places like Suit Supply and Indochino tend to not work out. I’m thinking I might have to take a weekend trip up to NYC but obviously would prefer not to.

like

Has anyone interviewed at Huge ? Just got contacted about a potential role and would love some insight

like

Almost 4YOE at Big 4 TAS. Seen high turnovers this year. Thoughts on the following options: FPA vs. CorpDev vs. MM IB vs. MBA to BB/EB or MBB?

like

Any audio book recommendations to listen to when backpacking / vacationing?

like

How common are layoffs in IB compared to consulting?

like

Any book recommendations for someone looking to get into a Product Owner / Manager role?

like

Best books on leadership and sales skills?

like

The only good thing about social distancing is no one’s coming to my place either. I can set my house up however the fuck I want to work effectively 😂😂🤣

like

What is your max daily value of added sugars ? I heard the FDA inflates their recommendations.

like

I have a consulting/PE interview on Friday, please recommend consulting books or sites to read. Need to speak consulting language

like

Can someone please tell me what ah M&A due diligence consists of? Type of work you would be doing at analyst level, skills required, hours etc. thank you!

like

For those with pets, how much do you spend on training/activity (not food or toys) a year? And what kind of pet? Trying to figure out budget

like

Anyone under 30 fit all this criteria? If no, which one is missing and why? If yes, how do you manage it?
1. TC > $200k
2. Dream job, feel fulfilled
3. Healthy and athletic (think six-pack, regularly workout)
4. Vibrant/healthy social life
5. Married or have a serious sigO
6. Mentally healthy

likefunny

Best consulting firms without the massive ego?

like

Best books on leadership and self development?

like

Long shot but anyone has periodontist / dentist recommendations in/around ATL by any chance?

like

When the senior client asked for my perspective on AWS vs Azure

Post Photo
funnylike

Thinking about getting my husband a weekend bag for Christmas- he usually uses a small suitcase or backpack when we go on weekend trips. Suggestions under $500?

like

Singapore locking back up. Let’s see what happens in America. Always thought my home of spore is smarter than the rest of the world but seems backwards?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal