{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "I’m up for promotion for a senior role, but also got a management consulting offer (associate) at a B4. The consulting role sounds more interesting on paper, but not sure which to choose", "post_id": "5ab9d7bba1bab50013ccf7ed", "reply_count": 22, "vote_count": 4, "bowl_id": "564a5cdb94887803001dd07c", "bowl_name": "Accounting" }

I’m up for promotion for a senior role, but also got a management consulting offer (associate) at a B4. The consulting role sounds more interesting on paper, but not sure which to choose

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Curious as well what they are paying for senior in that role


Not the greatest public speaker/presenter, worried about resetting my career again (27 yrs old) or burning out from travel or making the wrong decision. Quarter life crisis is hitting me hard and causing me a ton of stress. I’m at a crossroads at my career and not sure which to choose. It’s a good problem to have, but still keeps me up at night


Can you elaborate on the consulting role? There have been a lot of bullshit jobs parading around like management consulting lately (both in and outside of B4). I’d recommend a lot of scrutiny if this is anything outside of the actual management consulting arms of whichever firm this is.


How much do they pay?


The consulting job is with KPMGs financial management group. It deals with improving budgeting and forecasting, month close, working capital improvements for clients. Kinda like an FP&A/cash flow consulting if that makes sense

I knew this would be KPMG FM. They’re literally hiring anybody and everybody right now in my market. Personally I’d be worried about what whether their growth will meet all this hiring.

That sounds like a decent gig tbh. If you’re worried about travel I would just straight up ask someone in the group what you can expect. It also seems exit ops for that would be fp&a roles and possibly even some strategy in industry.

I’m a senior now going through the same dilemma. Except now that I have the promotion I have more leverage in getting a senior type position at mgmt consulting or strategic. You’ll prolly have a lot more lucrative and exciting prospects once you are able to update your resume with senior

EY2 which market and area are you at? I’m in the Midwest. Also did KPMG announce anything similar to vision 2020 to cause this much aggressive hiring for that line of service?

I’m also in the Midwest. I know KPMG FM is looking to hire about 10 experienced associates in Chicago right now. I’m not sure if there is anything like vision 2020.

FWIW I don’t think the aggressive hiring would stop me from taking the job as long as I knew what was driving that.

10 experiences hires!? How do you know it’s that high? That seems pretty interesting wonder why that’s the case

10 experienced hires over about 3 months. Someone I worked with just left EY to join and he told me that was what they said in the interview. He also got staffed immediately so it does seem there’s a need.

Hmm I wonder why that’s the case, it’s not like their consulting practice is new. Did kpmg score a big client or something?

Still curious!

PwC 3 asking the important question

OP- I answered your question earlier about the recruiting process in FM. I’m happy to see that you got an offer! Travel seems to vary between projects and is expected but you know your travel schedule well ahead of time. That’s better in my opinion to plan your personal life. As far as making the wrong decision, I’d say if you want to be promoted to senior in your current job (and generally enjoy the work) and can see more of a future there for your own professional growth, might be worth it to stay if you really hate travel and starting brand new. You can DM me (is that a thing here?) any specific questions you may have.

KPMG1, thanks for your message before! Could you tell me more about how many hours you’re working and pros/cons of the role. Also on this post thread, it looks like KPMG FM is hiring a lot of people, is there a reason (winning a big engagement/growing practice, etc). Also could you tell me what salary range should be around to make sure I’m not being lowballed?

OP- look on Glassdoor for salary ranges and judge based on that. FM is growing a lot with winning more engagements so that is why they are hiring people. I work about 45 hours a week excluding travel time. Hope that helps!

Thanks KPMG 1, appreciate your help! If you don’t mind me asking, how’s the team? Staff/Senior? All the people I talked to were manager/director level

Related Posts

Hi! Everyone, I am a PhD turned consultant with 2 years at big 4. I was wondering if there are openings at MBB that I can apply to? I am a molecular biologist by training and do life sciences consulting in the cell and gene therapy domain.


I am looking for Austin based or remote jobs as a Recruiter or Sourcer or Account Manager. I am on H1b and have total 5 yrs of experience including agency and corporate. I am also CDR certified. If you know anyone hiring, please let me know.


Promotion letter received for October cycle 2021?

What firm gives out the best laptops? B4, MBB, etc.?


PwC FDD’ers - what was your mid year raise and your level?

SAP 30% Hike 220% AIP Promotion from C to S.Con Rating - Strong


Those who are or have been AUSAs, what sort of letters of recommendation make the most impact on an application (outside of a former AUSA/judge etc..)? My issue is prior to my current firm doesn’t seem to value the AUSA experience, we have no former AUSA’s in my office and only a view in the whole firm nationwide (same goes for clerks), and I was a transactional associate at my first firm so don’t think anything anyone would have to say would be particularly interesting to a hiring panel...

I’m seeing a lot of job req’s for Bain’s Advanced Analytics Group nationwide: does this group operate like a centralized Analytics COE to onsite strategy teams? (I.e. Consultants advise executives/leads on An analytics roadmap, and AAG come in and implement, rather than go with a Big 4 / Indian IT shop?) Thanks guys.


How much raise do you look for when exiting PA in Canada? Looks like 20%-50% is what people get in US

Got a 15% raise this year with promo to SC, bringing me into the low 6 figures. I'm happy with the large bump, but wondering how much I'm still leaving on the table by not looking elsewhere? 4 YOE, primarily federal, implementation, transformation, and tech projects


I started in tax under a year ago and don’t see myself here long term. Please make me aware of other job opportunities with 50-60 hours a week max that pay same (or better) than B4. I have an undergrad Finance degree as well.


PDM specialist at 96k. I have an option to select PDM Specialist 2 or PDM Manager for my promotion with the PPMD. Which one is advisable to prefer Pay wise? I am thinking to take PDM 2 to increase my base pay for the manager.


More time for DPW or Cravath to match means re-raise is more likely...right!?


Hi Folks, Can you please help me with the below queries, I am working as a contractor for Walmart. 1) In case, they convert me to FTE, can I expect any hike? 2) When are Walmart offices opening? 3) My payroll company mentioned my work location as Bangalore but the project I am assigned to is based out of Chennai, how will that work? 4) What is the expected salary for an SAP Consultant in Walmart with 7 years of experience?

What’s the rank hierarchy like in IBM? Where would an “Associate Partner” sit in comparison to a big 4 consulting firm? Got an offer I am evaluating

Did they kick big 4 out yet?

I am in PDM Specialist/ senior consultant 1 &2. This is my promotion year. How do i conform the next title is PDM specialist 2 or the PDM manager?

Additional Posts

Got an offer from EY(london) for manager level position. Fixed pay is 82k GBP for 7 years of industry experience in credit risk management. Could someone pls share the experience about annual raise at EY(london) and how career progress/promotion for someone at manager level.


Don't forget to eat well and exercise daily because our future doctors are skipping online classes !


I got another meeting going back to back.. Yeah, going back to back. Glad that Drake understands my struggle. I didn't choose the PMO life, the PMO life chose me.


Working for a U.S. company remote from Europe - please share experiences.


I'm sick of Starbucks. What are some good coffee places downtown? I know I could use google/yelp but I value your opinion more


For KPMG India for Consultant role in IT Advisory, how much salary one should expect during negotiations with HR. My current yoe is 5+ years with 8lpa.


Need advice. I’m a 2nd year Analyst making $80K/yr. I contribute 6% to my 401k, $100/mth to a ETF index fund, and save ~10k year. How is my saving strategy? Am I doing pretty well?


Has anybody had success pivoting off the bench into a non-managerial role?


I can only pick one... going back for my masters or continue teaching at my same job. Help!


If you get a "Career Discussion" meeting with your partner and an HR rep, it's about the end of your career at PwC


Which is the best company among the following in terms of benefits & wlb? Please pour your comments. 1. FIS 2. Maersk

What is the Best app to find the best and worst performers of the day?


Does anyone know how good does project manager at optum in gurgaon get hike


Life is crazy, we went from $92K (household) total income with $107K in debt in 2016 to $400K household with 0 debt, and $570K Net worth in 2021 (including 2 mortgages). Crazy, but super grateful. And yes, we are way happier and healthier. Personally, I am also realizing I am more gentle and kinder to others as well. I used to be on edge and pissed, now I eat ice cream and wish people the best in life.


I worked for a hotel mgmt company n was just laid off. What are my options other than finding a job within 60 days? Looks impossible in this market to find a new employer and have h1b transferred cont


Ladies, trying my luck here for help with comfy shoes.

Post Photo

Have any of you left for startups? How did you land the gig?


I don’t have a relationship with my parents they are very toxic and i choose to love them from a distance but my SO keeps on insisting on meeting them.. he’s old fashioned and has a close relationship with his parents so he doesn’t understand how hard it is


Hi! This is my first post in a bowl so be kind! I’m 26, and am going through my first (hopefully last) divorce. My ex-wife is my best friend but because of obvious reasons, I think I need new ones (friends). Through our own isolation were in the same boat of not having any friends outside of the mutual ones we built through our relationship. So, LGBT bowl, I ask you: How does one go about building new friendships? 🥺


Anyone attended Zenius's technical interview? I am attending for backend developer role. Interview is of 90mins. Advice will be helpful.

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or