Is it sketchy to ask someone I know within a company to send my resume directly to a hiring manager when an external recruiter reaches out?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

To me it would depend on the recruiter. Someone reputable, no. Creative Circle? Definitely go for it, screw em.... oops this is the recruiter bowl. Interested to hear their POV.

like

Cool. Good question.
Previously we discussed how shitty it is for external recruiters to not reveal which agency it is upon first communication with a potential candidate.
This is an example of why they keep it to themselves.

Now, to answer your question:
If the recruiter communicated with you only once and was inexperienced enough to reveal the agency in that first communication, you may write back and say, "thanks for reaching out, but I already have a connection to that agency and they will let me know if there is a role for me, so I'd prefer to go through my direct connections"
If you had a phone or in person interview with the external recruiter, then, yep, it's really bad form to go behind the recruiter's back to get the job, especially if he or she works independently and relies on commission for his or her livelihood.
Additionally, that recruiter may one day end up at an agency in house where you want to work. If you act shady, he or she will remember and feel you are a dishonest person.

Let's talk about creative circle. There are a lot of good people there, but they do take too big of a cut and sometimes their practices are less than on the up and up. Make sure if you sign up with them that you know what you're agreeing to. Tell them you want to be alerted BEFORE you are submitted to any agency. That said, I have been introduced to a plethora of juniors through cc who've gone on to become really successful senior level employees and I'd have never met them without them having gone through CC.

👻

like

No go for it!

@Talent Recruiter - super helpful insight, thank you. What if I work through the recruiter to let him know about the internal contact before making any intros to the HM? My goal is to add further heat to my application by having someone within the organization vouch for work we did together, not undercut/bypass the recruiter who I very much want to keep a good relationship with.

As good as your contact might be, they may not be a fan favorite at the agency. Sometimes it hurts you. Why not try to find out who the recruiter is instead?

Related Posts

EY Is ey taag in a hiring freeze for exp associates?

like

I applied for one position at amdocs some time back, online interview was scheduled but I couldn't attend the interview for some reason.

Is this situation considered in 6 months criteria?

like

Hey everyone! I’m looking to move out to London, I lost my projects due to COVID and if anyone could help me out with a referral in the UK or Europe I’d be very grateful! I can offer a good wine and dine in exchange! 🍾🍱

like

Waiting to hear from Novartis on a job I interviewed for 2 weeks ago. They emailed me a Conflict of Interest Form to sign last week, which got me thinking an offer was coming but I'm still waiting. Thoughts on whether this form means anything? I daydream about quitting my current toxic job :/

like

Throwing this out there. My company was recently acquired and I was laid off yesterday. I’m currently 6m pregnant so looking for a company that isn’t going to have a problem with my giving birth in 3m (looking for a miracle). 13 YOE in Marketing (Brand, Digital, Product, Ops). You name it, I’ve probably done it. Team management exp but not required in next role. Just looking for 100% remote, flexibility, and company that puts families first and won’t give me a hard time about doctor appts 🙏🏻

likesmart

Anyone at Google wiling to give a referral for Strategy & Operations / FP&?

like

Been hearing a lot of discussion about AI playing a role in the future of talent acquisition. Anyone else feeling concerned that this can add more biases when it comes to hiring?

like

Has anyone taken the SHRM-SCP? Any study suggestions and impressions of the test?

like

Hello, after doing some research I believe I’m being underpaid. About 4 months ago HR did a market analysis for my role. They bumped my salary for about $2k. I’m a mid-level Executive assistant with 6 years of experience and currently supporting 5 executives at a fortune 50 company. One C level and 4 Vice Presidents. I’m currently making $61,000 with bonus included. Based on my research I should at least be making $71,400. I have a check in with my boss tomorrow and I am asking for a raise.

like

I'm wondering if an introvert can excel and be happy in a BizOps role? Any introverts here who can testify? Is it feasible? What factors need to be considered?

Finally landed a Product Manager interview. It's taken 30+ applications to get one. Generally, what should I expect? (In terms of questions). This interview is with 2 senior managers. I got passed the initial recruiter screening.

like

I received a call for Engagement Manager position with AWS. Even though I have the JD for the same, it appears kind of cluttered, with lots of Agile flavour thrown in, hence reaching out to the audience to understand what exactly this role entails?
Is it a sales oriented role, is P & L an integral part of being an Engagement Manager with AWS?
Any inputs will be much appreciated.

like

Hi Fishes! I am searching for an opportunity in Financial Planning and Analysis role (Finance) with 7.7 years of experience. Any leads ? Appreciations in advance !!

like

Do all applicants get invited to complete McKinsey’s Solve game?

like

Those of you in restructuring (I’m in banking side) - what role in RX is the most interesting in your mind and why? IB, Law, Consulting, Hedge Fund, PE

like

Hi Team,

I have cleared all the interview rounds (WebEx & HR on call) for the position: VERIFIER, and also submitted documents (authentic as per my knowledge) for background verification on Aug. 25, 2022.

How much time usually ICICI bank takes to generate Offer Letter, after all the verification process??

Anyone have recommendations for ADHD coaches, preferably focused on managing it in a senior-level role? Also preferably if focused on the female ADHD experience. Open to remote coaching with folks in other locations but I'm based in NYC.

like

Looking for a position in the ICU at Loyola Gottlieb Memorial Hospital, are there any recruiters out there?

like

Hi Everyone, Started my career in government 5 years ago working in an operational role, then focussed on HR for 3 years working my way up to a middle manager role in HR as a business partner and completed my Level 7 CIPD. I don’t think HR or government is for me anymore and looking to find something new, now 24 feel I have a lot of transferable skills and knowledge but worried about private companies in other professions taking me seriously. Grateful for any advice - thanks in advance!

like

Got offer and accepted but other firm that I applied ask for additional interview. Please advisd how to tell them "no" nicely ?

like

More Posts

Can I get likes to unlock the DMs please 🙏

Post Photo
likesmartuplifting

What should I expect during my call with Deloitte’s recruitment advisor? I received a verbal offer last week, and a meeting invite this week with the advisor. Is this typically where salary and signing bonus are negotiated? If so, can anyone share insights into the typical base range for experienced hires going into Consultant positions (2yrs experience w/ undergrad)?

like

If I was hired in your company, what will be my approx CTC ? 😜

YOE: 6.2 years in Fullstack development with hands-on experience in devops tasks.

Skills: Golang, Python, NodeJS, ReactJS, CICD, Docker, Kubernetes, Helm, AWS, Terraform.

Things to note, Not too good in Data Structure & Algorithms 🙁

This can help others to benchmark as well.

Be honest please.

#salary #benchmarking #fullstack

like

Best movie ever?

like

Someone works at or with PwC Experience Center?

like

When you start a new job, About how long should it take for you to get acclimated to your role? Getting overwhelmed with having to learn new processes but I’m sure that this is normal…right?

like

What is the salary of a SQL server DBA 10 years experienced in Toronto if he goes onsite from India?

like

Hi fishes,

Looking for devops opening.
Yoe: 2.3
Certified in aws and azure.
Tech/tools: Kubernetes, aws,docker, Jenkins, gitlab, terraform, Ansible.
Let me know if any leads..
Thanks

like

Considering moving to Denver to be closer to nature and family. Husband and I can easily transfer jobs. No kids yet but ideally soon.

We live in Chicago (Lincoln park) and love it - the walkability, bar and restaurant scene, shopping, cleanliness, etc. - and are trying to find similar neighborhoods in the Denver area. I’d like something bougie (not afraid to admit it), safe, with single family homes and that’s not too hipster/crunchy/west coast grunge. Any neighborhood recommendations?

I have recently received offer from Wipro can some help me with the take home Salary per month

Post Photo
like

Wiproites anybody joined wipro through a conversion from vendor payroll?how does contract to hire work in wipro?my wife works for wipro, but on 3rd party payroll. She was told by wipro manager that even if her parent company doesnt agree, wipro has the clause to automatically convert contractors into permanent hires. Whats the procedure?pls throw light

like

Hi 🐠!

Im current at EY in a consulting group that does not focus on deals, but have completed few due diligence type engagements. We focus mostly on ODD (Operational Due Diligence) for private equity firms. I really want to make it into IB. I have an interview for a Valuation and Opinions Role. Would that help in transitioning in as an IB Analyst? I would have a substantial pay cut (100K to 85K - excluding bonus). My current experience has not been seen as valuable by recruiters.

like

Am I the only one who is happy I got into IT?

like

Has EY gds ever revoked their offer letter??

Recommendations on shoes that goes well with Jeans?

Best custom handmade Italian dress shoes?

like

Would like to add scarves to my wardrobe, any recommendations for a male 🐟 ?

like

Pretty sure work is giving me a bedsore...

like

I’m going to be a dad! But I have some questions. When should I tell my manager/teams? I’m up for senior promotion this year, will this impact that promotion? For those of you that work in public what tips do you have for managing your work and family responsibilities? For context, my wife, once she’s done with maternity leave, will only work 25-30 hours a week. I know working in public and having a new born is probably going to be a lot to juggle, but I have to make it work.

likeupliftingfunny

Additional Posts in Ask A Recruiter - Advertising

What’s the best way to make your email stand out to a recruiter?

Hi All! What does that mean when hiring manager responds back on follow-up email, saying “I’ll keep you posted on the next steps”Are they still considering or is it just a new way of rejection?waiting is so painful. :(

like

What types of questions do you like to ask candidates during your first initial conversation with them?

like

Agency recruiters, how would you rate today’s market for creatives? Is it more of a freelancers’ market or is it tight for everyone at the moment?

like

Here’s a question for the recruiters out there: do you want to see my portfolio?
I just started freelancing after having been FT for a long time. Top agency experience, Cannes Lions, NYC-based, DM me!

When messaging a recruiter on LinkedIn, is it best to send a short note about why I’m the best fit for the gig, write a mini cover letter, ask for a time to chat, or something else? Thanks in advance!

like

Feel like everytime I have a potential job the moment I interview face to face it all falls apart. Are there certain key mistakes you guys notice that detract from someone even if they have good work?

like

Any recruiters on here who have never reached out about a job and then not followed up? Asking for an industry.

like

Looking for a good recruiter in central to puppet Florida...anyone have any one that they can recommend?

Where are there openings for a lead strategist / head of strategy at the moment? Not asking for a friend.

like

If you’re working with a freelance recruiter/ headhunter but know of open positions outside the ones they’ve brought to you, is it best to reach out to the agencies yourself or through the recruiter?

like

ISO: experienced recruiter for a career consultation. Laid off a few times. Trying to make sure the next job sticks. I’ll compensate for your time!

like

Recruiters, is it frowned upon for candidates to reach out to you on DM on Linkedin? Or does it show that they’re more interested than just submitting an application?

likehelpfulfunny

Is it concerning if a recruiter is dancing around giving you an offer? or is it just busy bc of Q4, coordinating teams, start dates, and covid?

like

Creative recruiters. When looking at candidates, how much does the resume matter vs. the portfolio? Do you even look at the resume? Thanks

like

Hey all, started my role as a recruiter at an agency recently and had my first placement! It was great until the candidate wants to renegotiate the base and benefits after the current company counter-offered when the candidate no longer sees the future. Any tips on what to say to bring back to focus? The current role is a Sr. Acct Receivable (less than 2yr) and going into collections specialist at a global law firm.

like

Found out my interview this week will be with PMs of different levels so they can decide who wants me on their team, but recruiter won’t give me any specifics on client/brand, print or digital, etc...

like

Hey guys. I recently graduated with a bach in business, a graphic design bach, and an MBA this past May. I thought this would help make me look like a stand out on job applications along w/ my international internship but I can’t get an interview for an entry level job at big companies like Deloitte, Goldman Sachs, or Leo Burnett. Should I take my MBA off my resume?? What am I missing??

like

Why don’t recruiters tell you upfront about the role they contacted you about? I had a message from a recruiter yesterday from a recruiter about a copywriter role she’s working on...

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal