Some places have started doing "silent" hiring where they don't even post the role publicly and just take recommendations from current staff. It feels like a way to keep the circle small, but it also means missing out on a lot of good talent. Would you rather work somewhere that only hires friends of friends, or does that usually just lead to a cliquey and toxic environment?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Referral hiring can work if it is still structured and merit based. The problem is when it turns into favoritism instead of networking. If roles are never posted and the circle stays small, it can absolutely become cliquey. A healthy company should balance referrals with open opportunity.

like

Yeah I definitely agree it needs outsiders!

It can lead to an environment prone to have cliques, but referrals tend to be the easiest and quickest way to hire, which is why so many companies incentivize referrals with bonuses

Yeah I get that and I have used our referral system a few times which has been beneficially but just feels it's potentially missing talent out...

Silent hiring can make things feel exclusive and comfortable for current staff, but it often shuts out fresh perspectives. I’d prefer a mix good recommendations plus open applications, so you get talent without creating a clique.

There is nothing wrong with that if they are still finding qualified people. Why waste the time of candidates and sort through 200 applications if you have a direct line to someone who would be a great fit for the job.

Related Posts

TVC Googler here looking to switch teams into a PMM role. Anyone looking for marketing management talent, please let me know.

like

Just saw an investment banking analyst position at Raymond James that I was interested in, would anybody working there be willing to give me a referral? Thanks!

like

Hey guys!

Does anyone know if your CV gets blocked in big 4s for a certain amount of time if you get rejected?

I had an HR discussion at PWC UK 3 months ago which fell through and now I'm noticing any time I apply for a role there my resume doesn't clear the shortlist. Surprising cos I meet all the requirements

like

Anyone here exit from consulting into HR M&A Role, preferably at tech/fintech? I’d love to connect

like

Any Tik Tok referrals? I applied today for the Learning and Development business partner, US safety role in Los Angeles. Thank you!

like

Feel like I missed the boat years back to get into Director of Product role. Back in the day there was only Senior in between a Director role, now there’s Lead and Group levels, so much hierarchy now.

like

What is the perception of a McKinsey solution role that is a CSP? Can I exit to tech? Would the role be better than the T2 role I have now?

like

Hi Folks, I'm looking for supply chain consulting role in UK. Preferably in digital transformation.

I'll need a visa sponsorship

Any insights on what is the compensation range for regional managing director role at coinbase?

like
like

Boston Consulting Group EY-Parthenon - Folks, Whats the BCG equivalent position for a EY-P Assistant Director/Associate Director? Is it a Principal or a Project Leader? What factors could drive this decision in an interview.

Looking for Java, Springboot Developers. Kindly DM if you looking out for change or anyone you know is looking having experience in these Skill-set.

Flexible work culture with Prominent WFH.

P. S: Hiring very aggressively, can offer better CTC as per the market standards.

like

I’m relocating to the Charlotte area soon and looking for a new leadership role (hybrid/remote/onsite). I have over 12 years of experience in corporate management around Supply Chain, Asset Protection, and Project Management. Thank you for your recommendations and referrals in advance 😊

like

Guys Please help me I looking for any entry level job or internship in PWC
I'm a MBA Finance graduate

Can I get any referral or help from anybody

Thank you

likefunny

I am offered a role with S&p global, salary negotiation yet to have.
Can someone please tell if s&p global is recession proof or not, I’m planning to join only if i get job security
I have offer from lti paying me 12 on 3.5 yoe??

LTI Information Technology Deloitte PwC IBM S&P Global

like
like

McKinsey & Company Hi guys,

Please help me with the referral.

Senior/Lead data Engineer

Exp -- 8.5 years
Notice period -- 30 days
Tech stack -- Big data,Hadoop, Spark, Kafka, Azure,Python,Scala,Sql

Please ping your email id .I will share the Cisco" class="linkified" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" >resume.Cisco Target Bosch Intuit Amazon McKinsey & Company Indeed Flipkart JPMorgan Chase Morgan Stanley VMware Intel Corporation Hewlett Packard Enterprise Paypal Salesforce

Can someone refer me in Wipro for AWS Devops role Yoe- 3.9Wipro

like

More Posts

I have a few black spots like these on my face. How do I get rid of them? TIA!

Post Photo
like

Is there any intel you would ask your recruiter before your loop that they may give you as help or advice?

Any advice from ex-Consultants here on how to prepare for interviews for a Strategy Analyst position at Visa Inc?

like

How is the cafeteria in BACI Gurugram location?
Is lunch free like we have in BACI Mumbai location?

like

How can I DM people? I just joined!

Update: I need to get likes. Please help me get likes so I can DM someone.

Follow up question: do I need to get likes every-time I want to DM someone or its a beginner thing? And how many likes?

like

Personal finance/investing advice for recent college graduates? Best personal finance and investing books/websites/subscriptions/YouTube channels? Thanks!

like

Bad idea to reneg on an internship offer for a better offer?

like

Sorry if this has been asked ad nauseum around here, but can anyone recommend a really good (yet easy and basic) skincare routine? Specific products/brands would be really helpful.

Mid-20’s here. TIA, I really appreciate it.

like

I️ am pursuing a Product Management Internship in Big Tech for next summer. I️ am comfortable reaching out to people to network and know who to reach out to. However, I️ have not found the convos to be all that helpful. Any advice on how to make these convos useful?

like
like

Anyone taking SSRI and Bupropion at the same time for ADHD? Diagnosed as high functioning ADHD with anxiety. Curious to see how this combo has worked for you. Day 3 on it and not sure if I’m feeling a bit of placebo or if it’s actually helping my focus.

like

Do any of you use Jo Malone ?

Hello Fishes and Shark, For Murex roles is it better to go for foreign banks as a BA or PWC as BA?
Honest opinions would matter a lot. Thanks.

like

How did you guys become good at Excel? Did you utilize youtube to learn, please share your thoughts 😀

like

I just earned my Masters i. Health administration and i am looking for a nursing home administrator in training positions in thd state of ohio; in order to obtain my license.

like

Does anyone have a preferred job board or recruitment company for finding new producer jobs?

like

I just got an offer from EY in London but considering based on what the maternity policy is which doesn’t seem to be spelt out in contract or benefits pdf. Does anyone know a) if there’s a minimum employment period to qualify and b) what the enhanced maternity pay is. I’ve read both 16 weeks and 18 weeks.

like

Did it happen with someone in the last quarter that although you got nominated by L1 for band progression but the promotion did not happen?

like

What is average Hike % in Nielsen? and in which Quarter they will be rolling it out?

like

Could anyone please help me about Azure interview process in Germany. Just got it scheduled, so any leads about question pattern so that I can prepare.

Thanks in advance

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal