The only way real estate investment is better than stocks is if there is significant appreciation. Otherwise it’s tons of work for worse returns. Thoughts?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

It’s definitely more work, it’s not “passive” income like online gurus say in order to trick people into buying their course. That said, is RE going to be better than stocks is completely deal dependent.

Stocks, etfs and mutual funds are way easier to get returns. You can buy a stock in 30 seconds and never worry about it again. So for the majority of people, I agree, it’s prob better for them just to focus on equities and move on with their lives.

That said, the right RE deals can be far superior but require more leg work. It requires a good amount of time to do your due diligence, your properties, get contractors, ect. Then if you hold and rent it can be a pain dealing with tenants. But if you do the work and find the right deals, the returns are superior. Even outside of appreciation, the cash on cash return alone can be better than stocks (at least in my experience), and the cherry on top is you usually don’t even pay taxes on profits because of the tax deductions. Most people don’t like doing the work on top of their regular job, cut corners or get lazy and get negative or sub optimal results.

Regardless, I invest in both and it’s worked out very well for me.

like

Luck is preparation meeting opportunity. Yes, there will always be hindrances, but that doesnt mean it’s not worth it. Everyone has their own tolerance, so if it’s too much you might just not be a RE person, that’s ok too.

The part of high cash flow properties don’t appreciate much, if you just leave your property the way you bought it, sure. But if you make improvements you can often times force some appreciation. There is almost always more you can do to make money in this. There is an element of perseverance and creativity.

On you point about high interest rates impacting cash flow. Yes, it has def made it harder, I won’t disagree with that. Impossible, no. From personal experience, it made my search for my second property 3x longer than it did with my first, that said the time was well worth it, I found a great deal. They’re out there it just takes extra patience.

like

Real estate has a lot of tax advantages that stocks don’t have. Depreciation makes annual cash flow nearly tax free, and vehicles like 1031 exchanges and bonus depreciation can erase taxable gains.

like

You can 1031 into a REIT 🤷

I make $125,000 net profit on one property but that’s because I purchased pre-Covid. That investment was worth it regardless of appreciation. Based on where prices and rates are now it’s much harder to cash flow, but you do also get advantages from a write off perspective and you are building significant equity.

But that profit was appreciation right? Even with cash flow and equity, returns would be better throwing it into an index fund.

Leverage multiples the appreciation though. A 10% increase in value could be a 100% increase in equity.

MD1, yes, my calculation is over simplified. I’m making 2 assumptions. 1/ that this is a primary residence, so if we weren’t paying a mortgage with principal and interest, we’d be paying the same in rent anyway, and 2/ that if we had paid cash instead of using leverage, we’d be losing out on the opportunity of investing that rent/mortgage payment elsewhere. So really, in an appreciating housing market, getting a mortgage is a win-win because you collect appreciation on somebody else’s money, and you are still free to invest your own money in the stock market. If you pay cash, your money is all tied up.

like

Do you use a margin account in trading? Thats what houses are. You put in 10k on a 100k house. You get 5% historical returns. So in my example I get 5k return. I take the same 10k and put it an index fund I’d get 8% or around $800 return. Obviously there are expenses, it’s not passive income on real estate. Then I have other strategies I apply, like tax avoidance or not paying interest. I keep a stock portfolio and a real estate portfolio. I like both for different reasons.

That 10K return is not yours since you don’t own the house until the loan is paid off. If you put down 10K on a house, how much equity do you have? Probably around 10K until you starting paying it down. If you sell it in one year for example, how much are you getting back?

Real estate is an illiquid, long term asset class. If you have short term goals publicly traded REITs would be a better option.

Related Posts

Hey Londoners! I’m about to move to London and hunting for a place to live (on a mid-level salary).
Could you please share how much rent do you currently pay and where do you live (area/no. of rooms)?

I was hoping to live alone but everything seems over the top expensive

like

Base is at 180k, after tax, insurance , 401k and ESPP (max out), my bi-weekly pay is only like 3600 (like 8000 monthly). Can people really save this kind of money, or most people rely on their stock appreciation?

like

Whats the biggest tip you have for FIRE?

For me, I think “pay yourself first” is the most important. It forces me to save money first so I wouldn’t need to worry about making a budget for expenses, since I can see how much “disposable” money I have to spend.

I just started this recently. Each month, I allocate $1k of my pay to my brokerage acct and $1k to HYSA (to buy property). I max out 401k and do backdoor roth. And save all my bonus. So each yr, it’s around 70k: 24k + 20k + 6k + 20k bonus.

like
like

Is Argyle, TX good place to buy home and raise family?

like

Newbie trying to get a better understanding: is it better to max the 401K or just hit company 401K match and max Roth IRA first?

like
like

Just moved from US to USI, do you guys know the preferred banker for Deloitte in India? I need to open a bank account but not sure which bank to pick

(1/2) People who work in the Bay Arae peninsula (Menlo Park) and live in the east bay- which is a good place to buy a house, upcoming, easy to rent or Airbnb in case I have to move back to my country! Prefer single family home as young as possible.
1- brentwood
2- Pleasanton
3- Dublin (expensive)
4- San Ramon (very expensive)
5- what else?

like

I consolidated grad loans in ‘15, kept federal separate from private (w SoFi @6.75%). Can I refinance w SoFi or w Earnest? Should I combine the federal and lose the protections for better %?

I have started working in ADP . How can we get or download payslips into our personal laptops.

Thoughts on purchasing leads?

like

Based on the Gross salary offered I have calculated the in hand salary per month would be around 152000 considering 150000 in 80C, 50000 in NPS and 200000 deductions due to home loan interest. Total tax liability is around 400000. Any other options do I have to save tax further (other than HRA, LTA)? Thanks in advance.

Post Photo
like

Noogler question: are approved Amex expenses from concur directly paid by google to Amex? Or I gotta to pay? My expense was approved but has not yet been fully received in my account..

like

Guys ..
When will final settlement take place? What will be the components of it?

Can I get a commercial loan without 25% down?

like

Still using Ally Bank savings account, but the APY had dropped to .60%. Time to move. Any recs on personal savings account? This is my emergency “savings”

like

If I sell my ether on Coinbase for cash, how quickly can I direct deposit it into my bank?

The only thing I truly care about is money and I’ve tried hard to not be this way but I can’t help it. My parents came from nothing and I refuse to ever “feel poor” again

likeupliftingfunny

If a company matches 50% of 401k contributions to 6% of salary, does that mean they’ll put in 6% if I put in 12% or will they put in max of 3% on my 6% contribution? Curious what their wording means

like

More Posts

Currently clerking, but have accepted a post-clerkship offer at a biglaw firm. Thoughts on whether the firm would give me a referral bonus if I refer one of my friends and they get hired before I officially start?

likefunny

Is it mandatory to work from office in Virtusa? Or they are calling employees on hybrid model?

Is there permanent WFH?

like

Need a sanity check here.

When I joined my current company, we were on a quarterly bonus structure with guaranteed payouts each quarter. This was, in fact, how the recruiter said he could meet my salary request.

The company just announced we are moving to annual payouts only, with no payments for 2023 until May 2024. There are no raises happening.

This amounts to 12% less money in my pocket in 2023 plus inflation.

Is this standard, or should I be looking for opportunities elsewhere?

like

Any warehouse mangers in this bowl?

like

Your loss, The Community 🤗 I’m sure I would have done a great job.

Post Photo
likefunny

Please explain if we get internet reimbursement outside the CTC?? Not the tax exemption part . I have heard we get 1200 per month for internet . Is it true ?

like

The finance industry needs to change. People shouldn't be forced to work backbreaking hours. Period.

like

Thoughts on Mark Meldrum’s CFA prep material for Level 1? Also any general tips on how to prepare are appreciated, thanks!

like

Hello Verizon fellows, In Deloitte, there's a facility to claim a certain reimbursement for purchasing mobile devices through their portal or something. Similarly, do VDSI employees have any discounts or reimbursement for purchasing devices through Verizon? If so, kindly let me know how to check it out. Thanks in advance.

like

Anyone here from LPA and willing to talk or give insights into the company, projects and current situation?

Not much to be found online.

PwC is getting a lot of hate out there :(

What's the fixed package of a Level 8 Associate Project Manager at Accenture technology at an experience of about 12.5 years?

like

Is it a good idea to leave Accenture AI and join MBB's Analytics wing?

like

My wife has a degree in sales and is looking for a company with a healthy work environment. She’s also looking for a place that is not crazy overworking their employees and allows a flexible work schedule. Anyone have any recommendations on remote options she might be interested in?

like

Interviewing at DocuSign, pretty excited but should I be concerned about where SaaS is headed with recent talks of recession and how it’s affecting tech?

Is there anyone from pega profile un IBM? Want to know about work env, work pressure as well as work life balance. Please need some suggestion. Good to join or not

What's the point of Delta drink vouchers when they serve alcohol on request anyway? (Even in economy)

like

Mental Health, inherited or choice? I am finding myself struggling with processing that ADD, Depression, or Bipolar is a chemical imbalance in the brain vs. behavioral therapy. The best analogy given to me is you would treat diabetics with insulin so why not consider prescriptions to help mental health. 2020 has thrown more at me than I’m able to handle. Has anyone here noticed a significant improvement after a prescription to help psych issues?

like

Any idea how much monthly does Landmark pay to BIMTECH MBA students who they recruit for Dubai?

Additional Posts in The Real Estate Bowl

I'm early in my career, managed to save $30K to invest, and want to get my hands dirty with a rental property without too much risk (e.g. no HML/flipping). It sounds like that's a tall order in the NY/CT area given the prices, not to mention whether I'd be able to get a mortgage on anything below $100K, but I figure I'll give it a shot anyway. Any advice on what you might do in my position? Am I being crazy with this idea?

like

Our appraisal came through exactly as the offer price we put. Apparently by lenders 3rd party. Isnt that a bit fishy? If it came in lower our contract has the option to negotiate a bit with seller. Is lender just trying to push this along faster? I'm pretty sure in this crazy market the home is not valued at what we offered. Why would seller put a much lower asking price then? Make no sense. Please advise!

likehelpful

Is it safe to buy new home now with high interest rates ,high home prices and recession in near future?

likefunny

Any investors in the woodlands Texas for single family homes, rent looks good as per Zillow , good school district and houses are still affordable compared to Dallas and Austin

like

Due to a family situation we are looking to move to a different state. Normally we would sell our current home and buy a new home in our new location. However, with todays prices and interest, will it make more sense to rent out our current home and rent a home ourselves vs. selling and buying immediately when we move? We are moving from Vegas to Sacramento and we are not sure how long we would stay in the new area. Thoughts?

My assumption is that one makes money in RE with leverage. So, would you never let your equity in any given property get above certain% (I.e re-leverage and invest elsewhere) or would one eventually want to own a property outright?

like

For people who recently refinanced, bought or is in the process of buying a new home, what APR did you get?

like

I am wanting to start investing in real estate in the new year… I’m using this month to read up on it and familiarize myself with it. I am a true beginner and wanted to ask for any tips, tricks, advice, books, videos, magazines, podcasts, etc to start? Please let me know!

like

Looking to buy a vacation home on the west coast not in a major city. West coast so it doesn’t take too long to get there. Could consider other areas, but don’t want to spend too much time traveling there. Budget is under $700k for 3 bedroom, at least 2k sqft. Any ideas?

like

Is a sloped floor of 1/2” over 10’ noticeable? I have to make room for conduit and cannot trench in my current place

likesmart

For anyone that has bought a townhome from Lennar, are the walls fairly well insulated for sound?

What, if any, were your main complaints?

like

Just bought a new primary residence that needs work. Current home has ~$100k equity after buying in 2019 with <$20k down (appreciated around 20% in the last 3 years, in a major metro area). Would you:

1) Lock in the appreciation & sell now. Use some for renovations/other investments.

2) Keep for another 2-3 years & rent out for a small cash flow (<100/month if self-managing), get a HELOC if needed. Note it would not pass my investment criteria if buying today.

3) other approach?

like

I thought the answer is yes but now double checking. Can we write off the interest we pay on our primary residence mortgage?

like

Has anyone bought property where the EPA has remediated the site for lead contamination in the soil? If so what’s your experience?

like

How might I start to evaluate whether or not it’s worth it to keep my current primary residence and turn it into a rental, instead of selling and using the cash to roll into the next down payment for our next home? Currently in our “starter home” and thinking to upgrade in a few years. Some figures to consider for current house - 299k purchase price, 240k left on mortgage, could prob rent for 2250-2500/month, or sell for 375k. It’s in a desired school district, but in the “city” tax district.

like

Does anyone have experience managing an out of state property yourself? Are there any tips/services you use?

like

Under contract to buy my first home - house hacking a triplex. Property has been leased by the same three tenants for the last 5+ yrs, rents haven’t been raised since they moved in. Market rents have risen 70-100% in the same timeframe. All seem like ideal tenants (retired and take great care of the units) but I’d like advice on how to approach the rent increase conversation. Rents don’t make/break my mortgage payment but I’m leaving a lot on the table if I don’t increase significantly.

like

This isn’t relating to investing but we are looking buy a SFH in South Orange NJ. We are have a 2 yo and we are moving from Sacramento. It is a close to a train station to New York.
Does any one here have any info, good or bad things to know about the area. We toured 3 different homes and they were relatively affordable by (600-750k) and it seemed like a small town community but we are not familiar with east coast/ New England. It’s going to be our first move there.

like

If u have a house under my name if i move it to an llc what happens? Do i refinance to prevent a due on sale clause?

like

How can I invest in real estate ? Looking for an additional passive income source

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal