Tip: When you interview with more than one person in a second round and that new person doesn't ask many questions, this is a code for "no" being communicated to the manager and the panel. They won't dig further because they already made the decision and the manager knows this as well. So, at the end of the interview don't ask a lot of questions when is your turn because it won't matter.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I’m curious if you heard back after the interview about moving forward or not????

If not, my take on this: I think this is reading way too much into one aspect of an interview. There are so many reasons one person on a panel might not ask many questions, and many, if not most of them, have nothing to do with whether you’ve been ruled out.

Sometimes they’ve already reviewed your background and don’t need anything clarified. Sometimes they’re there to observe how you communicate with the rest of the panel. Other times, another interviewer has already asked the questions they planned to cover, or they’re simply quieter by nature. Could be that they are observing how you interact with the rest of the panel rather than leading the conversation or that they have been assigned to evaluate only one specific competency.

I’ve had interviews where one panelist barely said a word, and I still got the job. I’ve also had interviews where everyone was incredibly engaged, and I wasn’t selected. There just isn’t a reliable “tell.”

Based on this, I feel that a huge mistake that candidates can make is trying to decode every facial expression, pause, or question. None of us knows what’s happening behind the scenes. The best approach is to stay present, answer confidently, ask the questions that matter to you, and finish the interview strong. The hiring decision—not the number of questions someone asked—is the only thing that tells you how it actually went.

likefunny

You're spot-on on everything. You 100% get in a rumination phase after interviews, and since interviews roughly have a 30% chance of success, you start to gaslight yourself at times into thinking you can pick up on all the signals.

With experience, you come to realize that chance plays a big part, and different people will have a completely different body language.

like

I’m not sure I agree with that. It could be the person is new and sitting in on the interview process. Or maybe they feel threatened. A lot of factors. But I wouldn’t necessarily take that as a no. And, I would still ask questions.

like

Agreed.

You're going through all the time and effort for the entire interview anyways so you might as well just disregard this thought even if there's some vague correlation (which I don't really think there is)

like

No, I would rather be at home then spent an extra minute with something I have no chance of getting.

I have had interviews (3 rounds for the same role) where any of them barely asked any questions. They just told me they had everything they needed and flattered me quite a bit before sending me a rejection email. They had clearly made up their minds before they even heard me.
HOWEVER I would still caution against this always being the case. Interview like you normally do because otherwise what’s the point. But do not get your hopes up

like

I agree it means they don't need more info, but it doesn't necessarily mean they'll reject you.

I had a panel interview after a great first round, the HM was dead seet on hiring me, and I had met 2/3 of them. The third person barely interacted with me. Still got to the next round and got the job.

Though I will say that I see your point if you're applying as an external candidate. It'd be odd to never interact with a person you may work with in the near future and who is not in the company yet.

Related Posts

I have an interview coming up with Church & Dwight. When the recruiter emailed me with 3 interview times I thought he was asking me what time works best. Turns out he was telling me I was scheduled for 3 different interviews for 3 different teams in one day. Has anyone heard of a company doing that or gone through this for an interview? It seems odd to me

Hello Guys,

I joined
Cognizant recently, the project interview calls which I am getting is not from my base location.
I have the location constraint, should I wait for the right opportunity or raise this concern to ADP team so they can look in to it?

As per ADP policy, one should not have any constraints and take the project as FCFS basis.
Cognizant

like

Hi Fishes,

Have interview with UBS in Tech Software Engineer in Test role what can we expect my stack is CoreJava,Selenium,API testing.

Exp-8 years.

Thanks in Advance !

How many times has an interviewer no-showed and the recruiter profusely apologizing on their behalf?
Happened to me with Mindtree recruiter, for an IoT leadership position where the interviewing VP chose to no show twice… after which I thanked the recruiter that I was impressed by their book of busi-ness and that it was intimidating to be thinking about the prospect of working for Mindtree… as I’m too incapable for those performance standards… 😂😂

like

Hi all,i have been taking interviews for my department since the last 3 months.Should the company be paying me for the extra efforts?

like

Hello Fishes,
I am currently interviewing at EY GDS and HR discussion is done.
But the HR is saying they can offer only 36% hike.
YOE: 6
CCTC : 12 LPA fixed.

How should I proceed with this.

like

Hi Fishes,
I have cleared L1 round interview with LTI, can anyone tell me what can I expect in L2? Is it going to be technical round again?
It's for Angular Developer position.

Thank you!

like

Hi Fishes,
How is the Manager, Program Management profile in Amazon in the Selection & Catalogue team, Chennai?
I have an interview with Senior Program Manager scheduled.

like

I’ve been working for a company for 25yrs, looking for advancement. I’m considered an SME, managing people, Vendors and working on large system conversions. Have provided long term goals. When requesting feedback I’m told I’m on the right path, no suggestions on what to improve. I asked about timelines for advancement and not being given anything concrete. Recently interviewed with another company as a Vendor Mgmt partner. Individual contributor, high visible position with potential. Thoughts?

like

During interview I was speaking to the hiring manager. Felt interview was going well. He seemed impressed by my answers, excited by my skills, and even gave me a tour of the office. At the end, he asked about my home life. When I spoke of my 3 young kiddos, the manager got a little taken back and replied Oh you have children? I said yes ages 3, 5, and 7. He then proceeded to ask me about daycare arrangements and if I can be reliable. Red flag as his demeanor changed and made me feel unworthy.

likesmart

Anyone work for BCG Digital Ventures ? I have a screener interview this week and would love any advice or insights you're willing to share. Thanks!

like

I had an interview last week and waiting is raising my anxiety. I am on anxiety medications and it doesn’t seem to help. I don’t know why I am getting anxious as I already know I can not control the

Persistent conducts interviews just for timepass. After clearing all rounds they don't offer. Aspiring candidate dont attend interviews.

like

Is it worth it to go back to school for a better track to a FAANG company? The division I’m currently in seems like there are no good opportunities, and I have the funds available to finish my undergraduate full time (Canada). I applied to Amazon before for a highly senior position and made it to final interview so I think I would have a better chance for a new grad type role.

like

I am relocating to Charlotte NC November 30th and on the career hunt . I have experience in HR, hospitality, social work, customer service, and education. I’ll graduate with my Master of Social Work in May 2023. I’ve been applying to a few things but no luck. I’m open to trying new career fields and to hybrid, on-site , or remote work. Please point me in the direction of a great opportunity!

like

How long does it take for PwC to send out rejection email? I interviewed with the team like a month ago, the recruiter called me the next day and told me that congrats, everyone likes me and told that they were working on my official offer. 3 weeks later, nothing. I followed up 3 times already and got the answer that I should expect to hear by the end of the week. My last follow up email, no response lol. Should I just move on now?

like

Hi dear friends ,
I am working as cyber security professional.
Currently on Resign - serving notice period.
If someone can help me to refer or schedule interview in their organisation that will be a great favour.

like

Any tips for someone trying to break into consulting in the GCC from the US? Applying blindly hasn't worked out. Head hunter recommendations would be great as well!

like

Looking for recommendations on financial modeling courses (paid) that I can take for 3 statements/operating model, valuations, M&A, & LBO. Have been getting interviews with banks (3 in 2 months) but I come up short with the modeling experience (and weak on the technicals too). I’m thinking doing a modeling course will help with the no modeling experience + update my technicals? Thanks.

like

Has anyone felt that they are incapable of cracking coding interview no matter how much they practice , I for eg feel I CANNOT think fast in a timed test to solve a coding problem no matter how much I practice ,it's not just my cup of tea and that leaves me with a lot of frustration .Anyone else as well ,what to do😢

like

More Posts

What is the salary of a Grade 2 Manager

like

Is there a good website other than Upwork/Fiverr to find part time work? I have 15+ years of experience and currently a engagement lead. How do I find jobs that pay $150/hr?

like

Our RIA will be presenting to a group of FAs on COI strategy in a few months. Curious if anyone has had success obtaining referrals from centers of influence?

like

At Johnny’s Hideaway in ATL. Ask me anything.

likefunny

Can someone offer some advice on how to potentially join finance transformation at the Big 4?

like

Any recommendations for good recruiting agencies in the Carolinas? Trying to find someone to help me navigate my potential lateral career options based on my experience and interests since I’ve been in litigation almost two years and it’s not for me and I will be relocating there.

like

Need 11 likes for DM

like

Juneteenth is just around the corner. This is the first year I get the day off as a company holiday -- not sure if my company is having any programs or events. How about yours? And if not, are you doing anything on your own to recognize/celebrate this day?

like

During interview I was speaking to the hiring manager. Felt interview was going well. He seemed impressed by my answers, excited by my skills, and even gave me a tour of the office. At the end, he asked about my home life. When I spoke of my 3 young kiddos, the manager got a little taken back and replied Oh you have children? I said yes ages 3, 5, and 7. He then proceeded to ask me about daycare arrangements and if I can be reliable. Red flag as his demeanor changed and made me feel unworthy.

likesmart

How long does bgv process take in boa india ?
I have submitted my documents more than a month ago and waiting for offer..

like

Hi everyone. I saw on insta that some ambassador elite got gifts. I only got the voucher despite getting ambassador this year regardless of covid extension. Am I going to get something?

like

How's it like at Anomaly?

like

Leaving this here

Post Photo
funnylike

What happens in case of OBI violation any idea in Morgan Stanley?

More than halfway through a 90 in 90 and I’m so grateful for NY AA and that there are so many meetings! Also 90 in 90 is actually kinda great

like

What’s happening with the Chinese stocks? Do you think it’ll continue going down or will it go back up?

like

Curious to hear thoughts on how the recent rally is being perceived. Is it another of those temporary moves? Or does it reflect a view that the market bottom is behind us now?

like

Are you feeling a slowdown in recruitment business? If you are, how are you combatting this?

like

Anyone here in EY USA and can point me to the maternity policy? I can only find Canadian or UK versions ok the policy site!

Additional Posts in Interview Tips

Any tips or advice for the Amazon Senior Program Manager Interview? This is the hiring manager zoom interview. I am excited and preparing as much as I can.

like

I’m shooting for the moon and applying to jobs I am mentally ready for and can qualify for but my resume is very short sweet and to the point because I’ve worked at the same place for 6 year and climbed the ladder & wanting something new. How do I explain that to my future employer?

like

Who knows about Goosehead insurances work culture. 5 min into sourcing I’m seeing some discouraging statistics about who they move up faster vs who they don’t. I have a interview this week and I don’t know if I should even continue forward. My main goal is growth and if it’s going to be an unfair environment then that’s a no go.

like

What can you do if you’re getting interviewed by the same person who didn’t choose you in the first place?
Context: I applied for a position a while back and got interviewed, but didn’t go to the next round. I found the same position open again a month later at a different location and applied. Almost immediately, I was called for an interview, but with the same interviewer. What does this mean? Is this going to get awkward?

I’m new on the job search and still employed. I’m looking to grow further in the logistics industry. While I look for work, it’s a bit discouraging seeing how hundreds of people apply for positions I see on LinkedIn. I still apply because you never know and AI plays a huge effect in selections. Should I even bother applying when there are more than 100 applications?

like

I have an interview for a financial advisor at TD any tips would appreciated on nailing this interview. Please also tell me about negotiatiating a reasonable salary for the position

like

What is the best way to reach out after not getting the job to ask for feedback? Do interviewers really ahve time to provide feedback for the candidate they didn't go with?

like

I had an interview w/ the Hiring Manager at  Boston Consulting Group  for a position and it went so well that the HM said on the spot I was going to be moving onto the next round. Its been weeks since that interview & I've had to follow up w/ the recruiter 3x asking for an update. I mentioned interviewing elsewhere but prioritizing BCG. He finally responded to that saying he was going to debrief with the HM and get back to me but nothing... what gives?

like

I have an interview coming up with Church & Dwight. When the recruiter emailed me with 3 interview times I thought he was asking me what time works best. Turns out he was telling me I was scheduled for 3 different interviews for 3 different teams in one day. Has anyone heard of a company doing that or gone through this for an interview? It seems odd to me

Anyone in the consulting industry willing to do an informational interview? I have 2 years of industry experience in corporate operations

I've gotten feedback that I'm too honest in my interviews, is that really a con for future employers? 🫤 How do I refrain from doing that anymore?

like

Over the last couple of months I’ve interviewed for a number of jobs and made it to second and third round interviews but never got an offer. My last interview was on Monday and I got feedback that I did not get selected because it did not seem like I was a a team player. Ive got three interviews coming up and l am wondering how I can improve my chances of getting an offer. Any ideas are welcome. I need a new job like yesterday.

like

Is it common to need to do a mock case presentation for an entry level/early career interview?

like

Hello, we've recently started a community focused on FAANG Interview preps. Wondering what kind of content people might be interested to see in such communities.

like

Random, but valid/persistent thought.

After 2 years of a pandemic and working independently for many years, I am not feeling interviews AT ALL. There are points in the interview where I want to just say "Look! Either hire me or don't".

How can I get over this feeling? I'm over the whole "stand in the line of fire to prove how good I am" bs. Any recommendations for getting over this or possible industries to pivot into to avoid bs interview processes and ghosting?

like

What is the average time now to hear back from interviews? Are people just getting ghosted or is there feedback?

like

Can anyone share Scrum Master interview tips for Fannie Mae?

likesmart

I recently had an interview with BNY for an Analyst role located in DE. The interview went well and I was informed by the recruiter that the team was interested. They asked if I was willing to relocate immediately, and I told him that my decision would be best made if I see an offer. I have not yet received a follow up after this(coming on two weeks) so I know that I've been ghosted. My question is, was I wrong to ask to see the offer before making a decision?

like

Was scheduled for an interview today for a Director pos. early morning I get a Reschedule request to next Wednesday but I cannot make it due to personal commitment .
Called recuit
mgr.to let him know and he tells me the director is very busy as she’s the IT. Dir for the whole org.politely asked him to send her availability other than next Haven’t received anything since then . Wondering if such co. Is worth pursuing that doesn’t value others time and that too a replacement pos for the same busy role 🥹

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal