Two offers comparison:
Senior Solutions Analyst at Mckinsey (Healthcare space)
vs
Marketing Measurement Analyst (Grade 14) US BANK

PS: US bank base and total compensation is higher than McKinsey

I have 3 yrs experience with Pharma consulting (ZS) and a Master’s in Business Anlaytics

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Think about the respective career paths and then potential different exit ops over time from those two positions. Seems very different on both respects. Which would better align with where you want your career to go?

like

Whichever you prefer

Do you want to stay in healthcare consulting or move into financial services? That’s the main question as you are managing a career, less about the short term comp. if you are more interested in exiting consulting and staying in healthcare then keep looking.

Related Posts

I am considering moving from US to Canada within EY if my visa doesn’t work out. Joined EY TAS- OTS from MBA as a Senior last year with base of 150k. How much salary should I expect in Toronto?

Hello Fishes, Please help me choose: Cognizant - 35 LPA(31.5 fixed+ 1.5 var+ 2 JB), Noida location Adobe- 35(31 fixed), Bangalore HTC global services- 18k Malaysian ringgits pm(~39 LPA) Kuala Lumpur, malaysia location Tech stack- Boomi Yoe- 12 yrs Current location - Noida P.S. - my tech stack will change if i join adobe Adobe Cognizant HTC Global Services Boomi

like

YOE:1
I have just started my journey in Salesforce and I have started working on Salesforce Vlocity. Order management to be specific. I wanted to know what are the opportunities and what kind of job market is there in Salesforce/Vlocity.

Also is it good for learning to start off with Vlocity/Order Management right off cause it is a bit confusing for me.

Some guidance would be useful

like

What’s the wlb like at VCA?

like

Recently received an offer from Ogletree to do only class action work. It'll be a big change for me, I'll be starting as a fourth year. Double my current salary, etc.

What will this be like? It's more of a niche, but lucrative, part of their practice, right? Will I really get good WLB like they claim? I have a nice 40 hour a week job right now, no billables.

like

Hi fishes,
Iam a production support engineer (ETL,JAVA)with 5 years experience and 8LPA. Iam planning to switch my career. Will salesforce be a good choice for me? Please suggest.

Can someone provide insights about the work life balance in gateway and lending team. I have a offer from paytm and the recruiter informed me that I am being considered for one of the above teams. So can someone please provide insights about the work life balance and work culture?

Is verizon service based or product based company?

I’m getting really discouraged by the process of finding a daycare. Currently 32w pregnant and it’s crazy to me that literally no daycare I’ve spoken to can speak to availabilities in the Spring. It’s nothing but waitlists. Should I have started looking sooner? Starting to get worried that my maternity leave will and and we will still have zero plan on how to get childcare.

like

EY, what is the current maternity leave policy? Does the firm allow leave starting at 38 weeks? Is disability (6-8 weeks) separate from parental leave (16 weeks)? When is full eligibility - after 12 months of employment?

like

What sort of opportunities are available in Canadian government for commercial insurance professionals?

like

Hi Folks,
I have got an offer from
Luxoft and they have kept a probation of 3 months. Can someone please let me know do they have a probation for all employees.
Also my designation in my current organization is Deputy Manager and they have give me Sr. Consultant not very happy with the designation.
Any suggestions?Luxoft

like

I’ve noticed on Glassdoor, salaries for my level (Director) are higher than my base but have similar bonus opportunity. At what level of pay gap would you push or make a stink? In hindsight I should have pushed more during the hiring process. At 160k base now, seeing ranges in the 170s to low 180s. These are specific to my current company.

like

Hi guys,

I just received my offer letter from Infosys and the compensation is as follows:
What is the approx in hand I would get from this approx?

Any advice would be appreciated.

Post Photo
like

I have recently joined Capgemini. When can I expect my joining bonus?

Is moving from Product management to management consulting a right move given the future growth and compensation ? I have around 11 plus years of IT experience largely in Product Management.When I see LinkedIn profile of management consultants I see few of them get hired on C level positions in other companies but do not see that for Product manager except starting their own startup.Need suggestions if i should keep this transition dream or not

like

I have got an offer for the System Architect role at Pegasystems, Current CTC- 20( 18 fixed)..3 days office is must. Offered CTC- 20 fixed...vp and stocks may come upto 23 or so. And permanent WFH. Yoe-5.2 years Tech stack - Pega Am i getting the right package and or is it good make this switch? PS: NOT SERVING NOTICE (90DAYS)

like

Current student looking for advice. I interned at RBC Wealth Management last summer and currently have 2 offers for summer 2023 that require a decision next week: 1 for BASF (chemical manufacturing) and 1 for Peraton (defense technology); I am also waiting to hear back from SMBC (S&T), Point72, Lord Abbett, Boeing, and Shell. I hope to break into banking next summer, and I’m interested in the Natural Resources, Industrials, and Real Estate industry groups. Any advice on what to do? Thanks!

like

Happy to join a group that’s about the medical field .. I’m thinking of moving to Memphis .. anyone know the rate for a CCMA .. 17 yrs in pediatrics dept

like

More Posts

Hi all, M here. DM me if interested

like

What is a good salary for a physicist with PhD and 5 years of post PhD work experience in Europe? Semiconductor industry, R&D roles, KLA, Applied materials.... Etc.

like

Looking for a casing buddy! Fairly new to casing and come from a science background not business. 2nd round BCG interview coming up. :)

like

As someone who gets an offer to work in PwC, can I relocate internationally within PwC to other countries ? PwC

like

People who have cheated in their previous relationships, how did you come to realize the reason behind your behavior? A close friend confided in me that she has cheated in all her previous relationships and struggles to understand the reasoning behind it. She feels a lot of shame and is trying to understand why she does what she does.I have suggested therapy but she is not ready yet. How did you folks arrive at the root cause behind your behavior? Advice? Book suggestions that I can pass along?

like

First post-transfer blood work came back with “ok” progesterone reading. Doc wants to supplement with pills before bed. Any recommendations of how to boost progesterone? Is there something before or after the shot that can be done to increase effects?

like

Hi fishes ,
Anyone can share the data privacy in India and across aisa pacific regions

like

In HCl offer, there are 2 components for variable pay, one is paid monthly and one is paid yearly. Do we get the complete amount mentioned in both the parameters in variable pay?

like

What’s the average salary range for a GAS?

like

Hi , Can someone please let me know how is IQVIA and does it provide permanent WFH or has hybrid ?

like

What are you reading currently, that's related to Product Management. Any book or article? I'm currently reading Measure What Matters.

likehelpful

Hi, I'm almost at the end of NP. I've two offers in hand with different roles and similar packages.
1. Product manager at EY
2. Product analyst at Livspace.

While package is my second priority, role and job security is more important me.. My aim is to get into product manager roles and I've been waiting for this since forever.
Which one should I go for after considering the pros and cons?

like

Hi everyone!

Is someone willing to refer me for Product Manager roles in their company? I don't have a relevant experience per say but I work as a Solutions Consultant which comes really close. I can share my resume with those willing to help. Thanks :)

Total work experience - 6 years

like

How is insaids PM course

like

Received a less than stellar feedback for a short project I was on. I didn’t get any ongoing feedback throughout the project so I feel completely blindsided. MANAGERS PLS DON’T BE THAT GIRL/GUY !!

like

Accenture 🐠, anyone willing to provide a referral to Business Process Architect role in Dallas? I will PM my work experience and qualifications if anyone is willing to chat! TYIA

like

Anyone have insight on salary for Fragoman/BAL in SF for a 6th year?

like

I've got a job offer from Deloitte Latvia ( Deloitte Central Europe) for the Riga City. The gross compensation is 3000€/monthly along with one time 2500€ as a relocation allowance with other benefits like 45€/month as Telephone reimbursement etc & other usual Deloitte benefits. Currently I've a ctc of 11 LPA at EY & 3.5 YOE. Is it worth accepting the offer after all calculations. #Deloitte #Europe #Latvia . Deloitte EY . Kindly provide some insights if u have any .

like

Anyone use the Apple Card to buy iPhone on monthly installments and submit Apple statements for the cell reimbursement? Or do we have to buy phone through cell carrier?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

From the latest NYT college admissions scandal article... 🤔

Post Photo
likefunny

Poll: What dress code do you follow at your home office?

What types of technical skills, trainings, or certifications are valuable for a general management consultant? Obviously excel and PowerPoint, but are trainings in: tableau, design thinking,etc useful

like

Mckinsey fishes - I have a first call with a recruiter next week. What should I expect from the call? Any insights on the interview process? Thanks in advance.

like

Hey 🐟 fam. I’m starting a new gig next week that’s 90% WFH. I’d love some recommendations on a second monitor. Nothing crazy pricy, but something that’ll work well with my MacBook Pro. Thanks y’all.

like

Help: I’m flying Ethiopian in a few weeks, there’s no good alternatives to get me to my destination in less than 25hrs / $5k. Not flying the max plane but still consumed by anxiety. Any advice?

like

Is MBA worth it if the goal is to stay local? From Chicago and considering Booth/Kellogg, and will be paying 100% out of pocket while continuing to work FT. Consulting for 4 yrs now Is there an ROI?

like

Anyone happen to have EY Corporate code for Hyatt properties?

like

McKinsey fishes: I’m now in final round of interviews. Realized I don’t know anything about the benefits package. What are the key things you like about benefits, e.g. the free health plans?

likefunny

Are any top consulting firms hiring for experienced analysts currently? I know ACN and some others are cyclical for resources 2-3 years out of college, but I’m looking to make a move sooner than fall

like

Best consulting firms with best WLB? Do they exist? Young professional starting to think about where I'd like to work hard to end up in the next 5-10 years.

like

Books you would recommend for consulting or personal development?

likesmarthelpful

Anyone with experience working for Bridgewater Associates, LP? Had a recruiter reach out for a BA/PM role. Associate level/experienced hire, on portfolio transformation team.

How’s the whole experience? Comp package, benefits, work life balance, etc.

like

Does working in FAANG really open up that many opportunities?

like

I’m a Program Manager @ G. Currently have an Msc in Management from a great international bschool, and transitioned from banking before the masters. Debating getting an MBA from H.S/W. Thoughts?

like

Feeling really low, like I'll never be able to find my person and always be alone

like

What are the senior manager titles at PwC worth ? Experience wise and salary wise, in Assurance and Consulting?

likeuplifting

What do you guys get your parents for gifts when they've said they don't need or want anything? My mom doesn't really have any hobbies... Or interests...

like

Does 401k count as savings?

likefunny

What do you recommend as Delta platinum choice benefit?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal