You hit every KPI, but the vibe wasn't right.

I brought in 20% more MQLs than my target. I was expecting the top bonus tier. My manager gave me a "Meets Expectations" instead of "Exceeds" because I "need to work on my executive presence in meetings." It feels like a subjective excuse to save budget.
How do you fight subjective reviews when your hard numbers are flawless?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Yeah, that sounds like some creative quibbling to save money. I suppose you could have asked for some pointers on your executive presence, just to make sure that next time around it's absolutely stellar. But who knows, next time around there may be some other (made up) deficiency that emerges.

Whenever someone give me feedback I feel is subjective ask for examples on how to improve. I lakes these are tangible things that can be measured/witnessed. And then as I achieve I ask for feedback on that item from that individual so that you’re building that history of overcoming that criticism

"Executive presence" is the performance review equivalent of "culture fit" — vague enough to mean anything, hard enough to disprove that it sticks. And it conveniently costs your manager a bonus tier.
First, document everything. Put your KPI results in writing and formally request specific, measurable examples of the executive presence gaps. Vague feedback that can't be defined can't be fixed — and most managers won't double down when forced to get concrete.
Second, understand what's actually happening. Budget constraints often get laundered through subjective criteria. If everyone on your team got "Meets" this cycle, you have your answer.
Third, use this at your next offer negotiation externally. 20% above MQL target is a number you own — no one can take that off your resume.
Fight the review on paper. Leave with your leverage intact.
What's your relationship with your manager's manager — is there an escalation path?

Related Posts

My younger brother has the opportunity to do Software Engineering at FAANG and consulting at MBB as a fresh grad. I told him to do SWE, but I’m afraid I’m giving him biased advise cause I’m jaded in this industry. If you were me, what would you advise him?

likehelpful
like

I’m currently a Grade 11 at Cisco. With the recent pay structure changes my annual comp will be $150k + 12% bonus. I live in a large metro area in the middle of the US. I’m looking to move around the company so that I can make commission but I don’t want to be an account manager. Can anyone tell me if there are Customer Success Managers, etc positions that manage customers post sale and have a similar range base as me with commission plans? I’m just trying to understand income potential.

like

Hey Mates,

There are talks of focusing on talent retention & offering competitive pay in meetings by Higher Leadership so
Is there any salary correction actually happening for current employees or some salary equity policy being made?

like

I make $100K with 12% bonus and was offered a role $130k with 15-20% bonus. 4YOE in provider industry.

I am in a comfortable spot with a good team but the work is dull, new role would be consulting with more work & travel

I would appreciate pros/cons etc! Thank you.

like

It is in appropriate to ask what the compensation for a position is after a first interview if they want you to go on three more and the interviewers on my first told me that was above their pay grade to tell me?????

Seems kind of ridiculous for a business to want to waste so much time to find out after a handful of interviews that the pay isnt aligned with my needs ......

I can see in biglaw not bringing up knowing damn well if you get an offer itll likely be high, but this is a midsize

likesmart

I’m a defense attorney looking to make the switch to the plaintiff side. I’m in Los Angeles and I’m wondering what a reasonable compensation package would be. What percentage should I be making off of the cases?

like

With some of the big tech firms stock prices taking a hit..Meta layoffs announced last week and a few others revealing some teething issues. How do you see the tech market Outlook over the next few years.

Software Engineering compensation
Demand for tech hiring
Are we seeing a shift within the FAANG club and are we going to see new arrivals to the table?

Is the life-span of big tech companies usually only a few decades. If companies stagnate, they die...is this just a sign of more to come

like

Looking for insight on avg total comp for registered middle management with big bank. Considering making the jump from a branch advisor to managing a team of branch advisors. I’m newly 9/10 licensed. I’ve been building book in a bank branch but the consumer bank side of the job is draining. I’m making $155k total, $75k of that is salary. Anticipating a $130k salary offer if I go management route, with small annual bonus. Any others with experience that can speak to this?

like
like

Rate my offer for a business valuations associate role at a boutique firm in Toronto:
- $90k + ~7.5% annual performance bonus
- $5k in clawback reimbursement
- will pay all professional fees throughout term of employment (CPA & CBV)

My background:
- SA1 in assurance
- Master of Accounting
- passed CFE, qualify in about half a year
- enrolled in CBV program of studies
- 24 yrs old

like

What is B3 band in Wipro? Roles and responsibilities and the salary expectation for B3.

like

What is the salary range for CGP cyber senior 2->senior 3 in a HCOL?
Recently moved to the practice and wanted to get an idea! Any input is appreciated!

like

What does the salary band look like for a Senior Associate, IFS at PwC? Trying to answer the salary expectations question on the application

like

Anyone know when new comp for FAAS will be communicated?

like

What tends to have better salary progression up to "senior manager" levels in industry: business roles or technical roles (e.g. Data, BI)?

like

McK & BCG Folks - Any news on salary increases in your London office? Do you think it's likely there will be a compensation increase by end of year or do you think they'll just offer a COVID retention bonus and leave it at that?

like

Salary nyc pwc tax?

like

1.What are different band levels in LTI?
2.Is senior specialist level above the manager level in terms of payscale/destination?
3.What does working in salesforce vertical looks like & onshore opp. for US visa holders?
4.Avg hike / variable pay per year?
5.What is the notice period in LTI?
6.Any hidden components included in salary that can be avoided or restructed before joining?
7.What can be avg hike for 9 yrs of Exp in senior specialist track?

Thanks in advance,it will cover most of the quer

like

What is the starting salary for a strategy consulting analyst at deloitte?

like

More Posts

Any idea how to claims for goods movement in Wipro

I am new joiner to Wipro

any budget limit for this

If I could go back again, I wouldn’t have sex. I’d wait. “Someone special” is cliche, but nothing I’ve had was meaningful. Fun, sure, but not meaningful.

likehelpful

Has anyone here have the ridge or ekster wallet? If so what are your thoughts

like

Good morning everyone! I certainly hope you all are doing well on this beautiful Saturday morning. I’m creating this post because I am desperately looking for a job. Currently, I am pursuing my PhD in education and will be finished by December. I have experience in the legal field, higher education field, mental illness, and a few other fields. If you know of any companies that are hiring people with graduate degrees, please forward me their information. I am anxious to work! I also don’t min

How is the work culture and policies at Hexaware?
I have cleared the interview rounds and about to negotiate for salary.
With 10 years of IT experience and expertise in cloud computing how much can one expect? Already holding an offer of 23 LPA.

helpful

Alvarez & Marsal Hi y'all, Any recruiters from Alvarez & Marsal? Healthcare division

likesmart

i'm working on a white paper and planning out where to publish it. It's a technical paper about Active Learning, so it's primarily for other data scientists.
For anyone who has published a white paper in the past, what were some good places that you posted it to?

like

Ever did that??
😂😂

#Meme #MondayMotivation

Post Photo
funnylike

Hi folks,
I have cleared my L2 round in wipro. I am waiting for the HR round. I have an experience of 8.11 years in .net. what band should i get ( i guess it should be B3 or C1 ) in wipro and how much package should I ask. My current CTC is 12.5

Thanks.

like

Laid off, 10 years exp, tired of acct management. Feel so lost. Don't want to go back to agency side. What should I do? I feel like 💩

like

Is Phenomenon really still that awful? Shocked by the reviews.

like

Are there any NYC ad agencies that have flexible remote WFH policies or is everyone required to be in the office a few days a week?

like

Anyone from AMEX project?

like

Hey, please help me out.
I have 3.5 YOE and I'm into development. I want to move into management. Upon advice from some people I decided to pursue Executive MBA.

How is MBA in Consultancy Management from BITS Pilani?

Post Photo
like

Anyone working as a 2 years + lawyer for Fragomen in Canada can share their salaries and working advantages? (holidays, billable hours etc). Got an interview coming up and want to make sure not to under-sale my profile!

like

I've been working as a host for an expensive restaurant for a year. Considering how much a dish costs here, I don't understand why we can't be paid well instead of having to rely on tips to survive.

like

Tata Consultancy not giving anniversary hike new joners?

like

Additional Posts in Salaries in Advertising & Marketing

Do New Business roles pay higher than traditional account roles?

like

CD in Detroit ? Any idea?

Question about remote job negotiations

I'm currently interviewing for a remote role for a company based in NY.

The thing is I'm based in a different city (southern U.S.)

My question is:

When it comes time to talk compensation, should I base the market rate for the role on my city of residence or NY?

Would it make sense to ask them directly how they determine comp for NY-bases vs. other city-based employees?

Anyone have experience with this?

like

What’s the going rate for an Account Director in NYC? My current company doesn’t pay enough and want to know what’s acceptable to ask for in the interviewing process (within reason)?

What’s the salary range for social strategists in Austin? ~3 years experience and thinking about making a move from NYC

Here's a question: are you happy?

And why or why not?

likefunny

How much can I ask for with 4+ years experience at strong nyc agencies?

I live in NY and make $40k a year as a Copywriter, I have 2.6 years of experience. Pls rip on me and tell me I’m being underpaid, thx fam

like

Any producers from Publicis want to share what they’re making? Please specify whether integrated, executive, broadcast etc

Are annual raises really not a thing in this industry? I’ve been with my company a year and a half and asked for one and was basically told they don’t happen unless the company does really well overal

like

What does a new band 4 bonus range look like at Bank of America?

like

Strategy Director Salary / LA / 8-10 years exp?

like

These numbers are really irrelevant unless you know the agency. It would take a lot less dough to get me into w+k than say, a Translation or similar.

like

I’m making 55k in Chicago. Am I underpaid?

helpfulfunny

138k as an ACD in San Francisco - too low?

like

26 / F / Sr Strat / 5yrs exp

Company announced a 20% pay cut for every employee. What happens to bonuses in such a situation? I wasn’t supposed to get one but I’m curious.

like

How do you calculate your years of experience? Curious-if I include roles outside of my current dept I have 8. If only counting production, 3. How does that impact your salary negotiations?

VML Sr Art Director position assuming 7-10 years experience. What’s a fair salary expectation for the Midwest? Chicago/Kansas City area.

like

For arguments sake let’s say you make $180k as a Senior Creative in Los Angeles, and you’re asked by a recruiter what you’re looking for what do you say?

Scenarios
A) Lateral Move
B) Title Change

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal