You hit every KPI, but the vibe wasn't right.

I brought in 20% more MQLs than my target. I was expecting the top bonus tier. My manager gave me a "Meets Expectations" instead of "Exceeds" because I "need to work on my executive presence in meetings." It feels like a subjective excuse to save budget.
How do you fight subjective reviews when your hard numbers are flawless?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Yeah, that sounds like some creative quibbling to save money. I suppose you could have asked for some pointers on your executive presence, just to make sure that next time around it's absolutely stellar. But who knows, next time around there may be some other (made up) deficiency that emerges.

Whenever someone give me feedback I feel is subjective ask for examples on how to improve. I lakes these are tangible things that can be measured/witnessed. And then as I achieve I ask for feedback on that item from that individual so that you’re building that history of overcoming that criticism

"Executive presence" is the performance review equivalent of "culture fit" — vague enough to mean anything, hard enough to disprove that it sticks. And it conveniently costs your manager a bonus tier.
First, document everything. Put your KPI results in writing and formally request specific, measurable examples of the executive presence gaps. Vague feedback that can't be defined can't be fixed — and most managers won't double down when forced to get concrete.
Second, understand what's actually happening. Budget constraints often get laundered through subjective criteria. If everyone on your team got "Meets" this cycle, you have your answer.
Third, use this at your next offer negotiation externally. 20% above MQL target is a number you own — no one can take that off your resume.
Fight the review on paper. Leave with your leverage intact.
What's your relationship with your manager's manager — is there an escalation path?

Related Posts

What will be the inhand salary at tcs on 10 lpa

like

What will be in-hand salary for 43L base component.

like

Salary of business at addverb
@addverb

like

What would the in hand salary be for this compensation. Thanks in advance.

Post Photo
like

What is the salary range for Grade 9 in India in data management department or operations of Market Intelligence?

What’s a decent amount of stock options when joining a series B startup probs about 3-5 years from exit? Salary is £75k shares expected to sell for £3-4 a share

like

Hi All,
Can someone please tell me what is the salary range for STL (Tech lead) role at mindtree ? Also please let me know how many days will HR take to release offer letter ?

like

Hi all, wondering what the salary is for associates in consulting, London based please

Tia

like

Hi, I’m trying to evaluate an offer at intuitive,
175K base, 150K Stock over 4 years, 15% Bonus - Bay Area

Currently I’m making 175K in Texas!
Would this be a better move? Please suggest#tech #Offer

like

Please remember, when you’re asking for salary information, it’s important to mention where you are located. For example, $100,000 is going to be a lot more in Mississippi than in San Francisco. Thanks guys.

like

What are the monetary benefits of going to client's location(another city) for 3 months. Is there any provision of additional salary?

Hi all, just looking for a range, what should should someone with ~3YOE in consulting (targeting Senior Associate) expect for a base salary.

And when giving a range is it better to overshoot knowing they’ll bring it down?

like

Just got promoted to SC. How much bonus can I expect?

like

What is the salary range look for supply chain senior managers?

like

I got Medical Reimbursement of around in current month salary, but I don't think I had applied any bill or submitted any such amount. Can someone tell what exactly is this amount for?

like

What is a good salary for a physicist with PhD and 5 years of post PhD work experience in Europe? Semiconductor industry, R&D roles, KLA, Applied materials.... Etc.

like

Hello Fishies,

How much salary does Accenture offer for Level10 candidate
Profile : SAP EWM
Experience : 3+ yrs
Current CtC : 11.7lpa

like

What is the average salary for a project manager at a social media agency? NYC-based with 5 years experience.

like
like

What would be the average salary for a principal engineer at UNUM in Atlanta, USA?
Profile 12+ years of experience, full-stack tech-lead/sol architect

like

More Posts

Anyone here work on Microsoft Word as a PM? Why can’t you autosave a doc regardless of it being in onedrive/hard drive/other cloud location?

like

Any advice to AE starting at new agency with OCD/controlling supervisor close in age? I leave feeling defeated and in a competition rather than on a team.

Starting to get more involved in the project sales process - any recommendations for books or resources to develop skills in this area?

like

I’m a senior in advisory at a B4 firm. I’m aiming for partner, but secretly would like to be part of firm leadership. Is there anything I should do differently on my way up the ladder?

funnylikeuplifting
like

Any good books for someone trying to understand the business side of marketing? Just got my review an they're asking I bring more of that MBA mindset to projects I'm on.

like

KPMG is hiring. Fusion Financials, HCM, SCM, Procurement, Security/GRC, and more. DM for referrals.

like

Hi everyone!

Currently in social media marketing but looking to transition to a career in SEO/SEM. Any tips or advice you can give? As well as recommendations for companies I can look into?

like

What is a decent annual billable requirement? Also, billing tips are appreciated. For some reason I am really struggling. Am I self sabotaging?!

like

How's it like at Anomaly?

like

Is Visa a stingy company?

like

I have my first round interview (phone case) with McKinsey tomorrow. Any tips on what to expect with the phone case? Will there be an introduction (elevator pitch + why McKinsey?) or will they jump straight into the case? It’s only 30 mins.

like
like

TSYS or Sopra banking ?

like

Anyone has any clue when the promotion will be announced to the promoted candidates ?? For EY gds India

1st year SPED teacher here, If you had $700 to spend on your classroom what would you get?? I don't know what I am missing out on. :)

like

If some of the key creative leaders in your agency are actively advocating against recommending our clients take action for George Floyd or Black Lives Matter, what would you recommend doing?

like

How can I and to who can i raise a request for a specific shift timmings as a Customer service associate (CSA) Level 2 at Amazon? What reason would most likely make it acceptable to them? Kindly guide me. Thank you.

like

Additional Posts in Salaries in Advertising & Marketing

26 / F / Sr Strat / 5yrs exp

Strategy Director Salary / LA / 8-10 years exp?

like

How long should it typically take for a company/agency to send over an offer after they’ve asked you for your compensation details? I can’t tell if I’m being ghosted or they’re just getting their ducks in rows. 😅

like

Copywriter, 30/M/NYC/5 year’s exp. Currently at 90k. In-house at major global brand. Hoping to ask for raise/promo soon. What’s a realistic number?

Going from 165 as an ACD to 210 as a CD? Is that about right?

like

What’s the going rate for an Account Director in NYC? My current company doesn’t pay enough and want to know what’s acceptable to ask for in the interviewing process (within reason)?

What’s the salary range for social strategists in Austin? ~3 years experience and thinking about making a move from NYC

Any producers from Publicis want to share what they’re making? Please specify whether integrated, executive, broadcast etc

How much do Jr. creatives make at BBDO NY?

like

Any other freelancers/creatives getting late payments from WPP lately? I know of two agencies. Am I conflating two things or is this WPP going belly under?

like

I’m making 55k in Chicago. Am I underpaid?

helpfulfunny

How do you calculate your years of experience? Curious-if I include roles outside of my current dept I have 8. If only counting production, 3. How does that impact your salary negotiations?

Besides salary is there any additional bonuses, stock options, etc to expect as you advance to SVP and EVP?

like

Advice for someone having their first annual review? I have been well exceeding my role and am going to negotiate for a higher pay raise.

like

VML Sr Art Director position assuming 7-10 years experience. What’s a fair salary expectation for the Midwest? Chicago/Kansas City area.

like

Are annual raises really not a thing in this industry? I’ve been with my company a year and a half and asked for one and was basically told they don’t happen unless the company does really well overal

like

138k as an ACD in San Francisco - too low?

like

Review coming up. Is now an okay time to ask for a raise? Part of me is nervous if I get a raise I’ll be the first to go if layoffs happen with the way things are going right now

like

CD in Detroit ? Any idea?

Jr. Cw Salary in LA?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal