Considering moving to Hudson Valley, and commuting to NYC. Curious how I’ll see my 1 year old during daylight hours, and also still show up for work with a 3 hr RT commute. Anyone doing this? Advice?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

So I do this from Westchester and I’m not going to lie it’s tough. I’m lucky that I have a somewhat flexible schedule. I typically take an 8:15 train (so I do wake up, breakfast and getting ready with kids) and am in office around 9:45. I leave as close to 5 as possible and since bedtime for my kids is 7:30 and 8:30 pm (3 and 7 year olds), I often get to see them for half and hour + before bed. WFH one day a week when I take them to school and or daycare to stay connected to their teachers, etc. Not easy even with this flexibility.

like

My advice is that you have to be really clear on your priorities before you make that decision. Here’s my story. When my daughter was 1, we moved to northern Westchester just outside Peekskill. We loved the nature and the space (not to mention we bought a giant, frozen in time mid century house with a mortgage payment less than the rent on our 1 bed apt in Harlem). I was also lucky that I have a very flexible work situation, only coming in for client meetings so working from home 2-3 days a week. I started out taking the train but that was just over an hour on the train, 15 mins to the train station, 20 after the train to the office. It was a drag. So then I started driving which shaved off about 30 mins on average but I can’t work in the car, other than calls. So if I wanted even a few minutes home while my kid was awake, I was working when I got home at night or early in the morning before she woke up (and she wakes up really early).

Some other challenges- with a kid that young, if you have a partner, you have to have two cars because cabs/ubers are basically a joke anywhere further north than Croton and your kid falls asleep too early to get a pickup from your partner.

In the end, we couldn’t hack it because my priority was really having as much time with my daughter as possible. So about a year ago, when my daughter was 3.5, we decided to leave. However we’d also made too much of a life up there to just go back to the city. Now we’re renting out our house and we’re renting an apartment in Yonkers literally right in back of the Greystone train station (35 min train) until we make a decision that we know we can hang with for the long term. HaHa - what a ridiculous situation.🙄

This is why I think it’s important to assess your priorities. Mine was time with my kid - I genuinely like hanging with her. That’s not everyone though and that’s ok. Maybe you just want to have nice weekends in more nature or a big house, 🤷‍♀️ everyone is different.

I also feel like I had it really easy because both my boyfriend and I have flexible jobs where we don’t have to go in all the time. So that’s another data point.

Last thing to mention - at one point a few months ago there was a big thread about this on the NYC board and it seemed completely split along gender lines. Every guy was like “it’s awesome, I have such nice weekends” and every women was like “ugh, it’s probably not worth it” - I’m generalizing to some extent, of course but it might be worth digging through there for some more perspectives.

likehelpful

I love our move to new rochelle. I get home kind of late (7pm) but i guess that's to be expected when you work fulltime in the city.
Our weekends are great out here, and i don't regret for one second moving here from the city.
I walk my daughter to school in the am, and take a 8.45am train in.

like

I love my area, around webster ave between coligni and to the high school. There are shops all over north ave in that area

My commute downtown is 1.5hrs ish door to door and I have an 8mo old. Most mornings I don’t see here because she sleeps “late” and I take a 7:15 bus into the city. I leave the office between 4-4:30 and am home/picked up by 5-5:30 so I have at least 1.5hrs with her in the evening. I WFH 2x a week so I can be “with” her while my mom watches her but it sucks and I know being a SAHM isn’t for me, but I want it to be so badly.

like

I don’t have a contract. It’s something I discussed with my boss.

like

I’ve been doing a 1.5-2 hour commute each way from Princeton for the past 15 years. It was brutal when my 3 kids were young but now they’re tweens/teens and it’s much more manageable. Like the previous posters said, it’s all about setting priorities and having flexibility.

like

You have to set your priorities & that’s just that. I generally leave the office at 4, home by 6, but work on the commute. Then am offline a few hours with the kids & back on as needed. Just tell your people what your boundaries are & protect them, as family is where it counts. But - the commute wherever you are in this situation will always suck! Good luck.

like

Do you find this affects your ability to get freelance jobs? And when do you lay this schedule out for them? Where do you commute from? I am also freelance.

There’s a lot of us advertising people around Hastings, Sleepyhollow, Tarrytown, Peekskill and Croton. It’s difficult commuting but if you can have one wfh a week OR every other week it makes life easier. Whole Foods delivery (finally) and a good cleaning lady also help. What also helps is being at an agency close to grand central. I love it up here and daycare is significantly cheaper. I wouldn’t look further than croton the train ride gets too long.

like

Agreed on the train but also, fresh direct, Whole Foods etc don’t deliver past croton. It’s part of the reason why Greystone has worked out for us. Not only is the commute way closer but we also save a lot of time by having all of the same delivery conveniences of the city. And yet we’re walking distance to downtown Hastings, parks etc.

like

Did the commute as a freelancer from Westchester with a 3YO. I did the morning routine and then my husband did drop off and pick up at pre-school. We were walking distance to metro north, and that is the only way I could have made it work. I often scrambled to make it home by 7pm for a little QT before bed, and in the thick of a production I missed my fair share of goodnight kisses. But my young one was fairly understanding. Plan to factor in a lot of extra Uber$$. The real luxury was driving in every now and again. I think it would have been too touch with a child younger than 3- sleep training, potty training, etc. I definitely would have needed to be closer to home for all of that. And I have no idea how I would do it beyond Westchester. Will your partner be working in/around Hudson?

like

Pretty much what everyone has said. I have a toddler, and now WFH 3x a week and go in to the office the other days...it’s been a Godsend. I do pick up and dropoff on my wfh days, hubby does the other days.

Love White Plains, great for walks in the warmer weather and lots of activities for kids and families.

like

Related Posts

I need to get out of a toxic relationship. I don’t have a car. I feel stuck like that scene from Maid. I’m pre-approved and have a small down payment saved. I just need to do it. What should I be thinking about to stay positive?

like

I want to find out what are CDM, CFPP being paid in California,LA area.

like

Is 200k TC a good expectation for a PGM at Google L4? Non tech PMO.

like

Anyone know anything about the clients/work at DDB New York, Tribal DDB in New York or adam&eve DDB in New York?

like

Is there any easy way to handle FedEx/ups tracking numbers? I’d like to have some formula that would just show the status in another cell.

like

What’s a typical associate principal salary at ClearView?

like

Does your PhD define your research for your career?

like

Leased a new Mercedes and the dealership filed for new registration two months after the purchase. Now the temporary tags have expired and they won’t send me a new one. What can I do in this situation?

like

Moving from cpg marketing into tech product marketing. Looking for news outlets or channels to follow for trends and developments in the industry- thanks!

like

Please feel free to start posting some lines/games you guys interested in. I started this chat since I bet on basketball and football for more excitement when watching the games!

Post Photo
like

How is ondemand Agility organization in terms of projects,job security, wlb, overall opinion
What about its clients credit suisse bank.

like

Yuval Noah Harari refers to an emerging "useless class", of those who are disrupted by technology but can't or won't develop skills to adapt. Is this a problem for companies, gov, or the individuals?

like

Tata Consultancy
HCL Technologies
Cognizant

I am in a confusion,
I work for tcs and for retention, tcs is offering Canada onsite and they need 4 to 5 months to process the visa
I have 2 offers in hand one is CTS (16.3+ 70000) and HCL (19+3)
Hcl is pakka support project (operations) no chance of development. I am having 10 YOE and completely in development.
CTS not sure about project.

Fishes, can you please help me understand which is a better option that I have.

like

9 year experienced full stack developer asp.net and angular. What should be the CTC ask?

like

I know I'm no help, but wish more people posted here

likehelpful

What are some fun things your office or team has implemented to bring the team together during work from home?

like
like

Has anyone gone through process to buy in Hawaii and use for vacation home / Airbnb? How was the experience? Does it make financial sense? Any lessens learned?

like

Additional Posts in Moms in Advertising

I thought my nausea was gone (16w) and have been puking the most today. Whyyyy. What happened to magical 2nd tri.

like

Poll: how many moms here had the occasional drink or two during pregnancy?

Just finished Expecting Better and am curious how common this is.

like

Have begun staying off mute in every meeting to remind my co-workers of the absolute chaos parents are still working through. They were supportive at first but kinda forgot along the way.

likesmart

My 2 yo toddler has been waking up at night a couple of times sometimes. I can’t function on the next day properly. I’m too tired and getting depressed. Afraid to lose my job. Tips pls?!!

like

I’m a single mom, working in advertising (obvs) and the executor of an estate which is like a part time job. I’ve outsourced things to a point where I don’t cook, I don’t shop for groceries and I don’t do deep housecleaning. What other time/sweat saving activities am I missing or can I outsource?

like

My fashion is in such a rut. I’m wearing the same basic clothes every day. Trying to pay down a lot of debt so I just don’t have a lot of disposable income to buy new clothes. (Continued)

When did you start feeling tired during your pregnancy? I’m 5 weeks away from due date and I’m starting to feel slow and wanting to take naps during the day 😓

like

Anyone in the Philly market have school age kids? We want to move there but worry private school is the only way. What has your public school experience been?

like

I just did my nails for the first time in over a year. (Pregnancy.. childbirth.. raising an infant who needed me every 2 hours all day and all night until recently...) A small bit o sun.

like

Just got some bad fertility results. Feel like I’m probably going to have to do IVF. If there any IVF moms in here I could use some words of encouragement 😢

like

Anyone had experience promotion during/after pregnancy? I’m working in a team I love and planning to get pregnant. But last week, my boss quit which throws me to an awkward position. If my boss didn’t quit, I have high chance to get promoted at the end of year. But now, everything is uncertain. If I don’t get promoted this year, I prob won’t next year bc I will take a lot of maternity leave. Need some advice here.

like

Toddler Moms... Anyone have tips for getting a threenager to sleep (& stay) in their bed?!? Trying to save my marriage and sanity over here...

like

Anyone have suggestions on activities for kids 3/4 that don’t require a ton of supervision? We have done watercolor paint, play doh, coloring, etc...all the basics ha. Need something new.

like

Are daycares tax deductible?

like

I don’t know if it’s age (late 30s) or being a mom now, but I feel my communication style is more direct and I have less patience in taking sht from people, at the risk of sounding slightly less like “the model employee.” Anyone relate?

like

Anyone in here NY-based? I’m feeling really stagnant and wondering if NY is calling. The market I’m in is lame and there isn’t much opportunity at my current spot. Keep it real - what’s it like?

like

Anyone have 3 children? Tips to making it work?

like

Just took a positive pregnancy test this morning!! I can’t focus on work!! I got off the pill in March and figured it would take us a little while to get pregnant. I missed my period last week so took a pregnancy test yesterday (oh the irony) and it was positive! Part of me didn’t believe it so I bought a test from a diff brand, took it this AM, and it was positive again. I’m half terrified and half want to shout from the rooftops!! (It’s our first.) So posting here bc I can’t tell anyone yet!!!

likeuplifting

So, what if your kid is in a 6 person Montessori class with no interaction outside of their “pod”, serious disinfection and prevention practices and all the other parents are super socially conscious and aware. 2 teachers per classroom and no infections during summer school on campus.
Yay or nay?

like

I had a miscarriage and I am scared to get pregnant.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal