Curious how other managers handle this, what’s your tiebreaker when you’re choosing between two great candidates? I’ve got two finalists who are both strong but bring slightly different strengths, and I’m torn. Do you go with the one who fits more seamlessly into the team or the one who might stretch the team in a new way? Or is it just a gut call in the end?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

A stretch candidate might bring fresh perspective, but if the team is already overwhelmed or in a high-pressure phase, I lean toward someone who can plug in quickly. Depends a lot on what the team needs right now.

like

i always go for the person that brings the most unique set of skills or background. Someone that complements the team.

like

I would go with the one who fits more seamlessly into the team. It is so important to have strong team dynamics, but I'd recommend going with your gut. Not sure if the rest of your team has had a chance to meet the candidate and ask them questions (one call with candidate, you, and rest of team with a roundtable Q&A), but I found this to very valuable despite hating the concept initially.

like

I'd lean toward the team...but I'd also happily drop an underperformer to replace them with the second candidate if all signs point to yes.

like

I trust my gut

like

I go with my gut! Had the same situation recently and honestly just had to go with my gut. So far so good.

like

Why does the one fit “more seamlessly”? How do you know that? And do you think the advertising program is in a state of maturity or growing to that point?

My preference is the person that stretches the team because they can get the team to the next level when needed.

like

That largely depends on priorities and requirements for now and into the future, if efficiency RIGHT NOW is a key requirement definitely the candidate who fits into the team as it is currently configured is the way to go. If rapid transition and innovation IN FUTURE PROJECTS is more important, then perhaps the candidate who will somewhat disrupt the status quo is a better way to go. It depends on requirements.

like

Related Posts

What's the funniest retail customer story you've ever heard?

like

Any book recommendations for philosophy, psychology, and business? Or any book you read last year changed your values? Going to fly international, gonna read it on flight. 😍

like

Did Pinterest lift their ban on advertising branded/unbranded pharma? It got brought up in a brainstorm today and almost spit out my coffee...

like

Consultants, would you join the Fed is given the opportunity?

like

Looking for SC and Managers to join the Financial Crime team at FTI, DM if interested.

likehelpful

Following up on a similar post about NYC, for those in SF - salary and what do you pay in rent?

What do you guys think about 3 piece suits? I think they look great, but I'm not sure if they are ok for our job...

Did anyone in EY Forensics who was up for agile actually get it?

like

Any freelance Digital Advertising opportunities available related to Ad Operations or Campaign Management? Let me know! Thanks!

like

Any ZS 🐠 here willing to chat? I’m interested in a few positions and need help understanding the org structure.

like

Hello Fishes,

I have total 4years of experience (joined my current company last year). Current package is 7.5LPA.
I am happy with my work life right now but need the hike. Also i am working as frontend developer (react.js) but my tech stack is MERN and i also have about 1year experience with springboot. In my current company my ctc will be revised on January,2023  as i am not completing 365 days before July 1(only missing for a couple of days). What should i do right now? What should be my ctc

like

Could someone please refer me at Deloitte USI ?? I have the Job Ids with me

like

Any guys have a good recommendation for a barber in the city? Seems like most of the places downtown are upwards of $40. Just looking for a homie who does a good job. Happy to pay that much if they’re solid, but will be bothered if they’re not.

like

My first job out of law school was incredibly toxic and I'm gradually learning that all the skills I learned there are actually the worst way to do things. How do I recover from that in a job interview perspective?

like

T3 firm reached out re: direct admit to the partnership with some runway to grow the practice. I am at a firm now where there aren’t bright line metrics to make PPMD, but think I could make it in 2-5 years. This would be a step down in brand, but might be better from a WLB and getting to start at partner. Haven’t had firm comp talks yet but range was well north of 50% increase in cash comp from current (plus LT equity, draws, etc). Anyone take $ over brand? what are some traps to watch for?

like

Anyone in GT Accounting Advisory? What's the day to day like and how is the WLB?

likehelpful

How is Atos Syntel for a BA role?
How is the work culture, WLB, learning and onsite opportunities?

like

Does an independent landlord have to honor a mistake (discounted rent) they made on an online listing in California / SF?

like

What is your current salary / YOE / Title / Industry? I'll start

$200k / 9 / Product Director / Tech

like

If anyone needs an intro to an awesome, well-connected and super smart recruiter who is genuinely a nice guy (and ethical!) l, please DM me. Helped me land my dream job (twice) and would like to pay it forward...

likeuplifting

Additional Posts in Leadership

My Creative Directors, who are strong copywriters, are really struggling to collaborate with Art Directors. Are there programs or classes that teach creative collaboration and the creative process?

like

Ideas for gifts that can be bought in bulk for a team of 35? Don’t want to get them junk, but also don’t want to break the bank.

like

Our annual reviews are approaching & one of my direct reports has been with us for almost six years w/ little growth. My reco was to let him go & find a stronger, hungrier & more motivated designer at the same level. However, my boss instead wants us to promote him in hopes that will spark some motivation. I am not behind this decision & have voiced my multitude of concerns in promoting an employee who doesn't deserve it. HR is behind the decision! Thoughts on promoting an undeserving report?

I am currently looking for a mentor and not sure the best way to approach finding one. Any advice?

like

"Everybody can be a leader" some say... "Leaders are nurtured not born" say others... True.

But... this is also true: "not everybody wants to be a leader" (whether they can or can't be). It is a fairly common practice in organizations with traditional career management structures for people to "be promoted" into leadership roles as the "end steps of the corporate ladder" that was climbed doing technical work. And, unfortunately, this doesn't work all the time

Post Photo
like

I had a great review and a 5.5% raise and a great bonus at my company. But I also got a new Director and a peer manager of mine left the company, so I will be absorbing her team. In addition, my director said I will be receiving 'deep delegation' from them. I don't mind more work, but deep delegation is a new term I've never heard. What does that mean lol?

like
like

I have been in management for the past 8 years and part of large corporations. I just recently joined a small organization that I have wanted to be a part of for the past 2 years, accepted the role of general manager. This organization knew that I don’t have general manager experience, no payroll experience, no experience setting prices, no purchasing experience and today, 6 days after starting, I have been asked to step down due to not being confident that I will be ready in 3 weeks…

like

Hi everyone!

After years of hard work, I just got my first position in a leadership role! Yay! I’ll be leading a team of 12.
I wanted to know if you had any tips for me, things you wish you knew before, or things previous leaders did for/to you that you found admirable or stayed with you. I want to make sure I’m there for them and want to be a leader they will remember positively.

Thank you so much!!

like

My remit quadrupled+ in a recent re-org with no increase in pay/promotion, my new director is new to the company and was zero help, and I was passed over for recent promotion during the comp cycle. The new director essentially began shutting me down any time I ask for clarity in my career progression. Now they have taken credit for the project I’ve been building over the past year+ without giving me props whatsoever to higher ups. What is the best plan of action here?

like

Heading into 2023, here are some phrases I'm eliminating:

1. "No worries."
2. "No problem."
3. "Sorry to bother you."
4. "Does this make sense?"
5. "Sorry, I'll fix that right now."

Here's what I'm replacing them with: ⤵
1. My pleasure.
2. Of course, happy to help.
3. When you have a minute, can I get your opinion on ____?
4. Does this help you clarify things?
5. Thank you for catching that! 

Words are powerful.

Use it wisely.

Never sell yourself short when you know you have good intentions

likeupliftingsmart

Any advice for a first time manager ?
Context: after ~10y in technical then marketing role, taking over a team of analysts, first management position.
Tips, readings, stories, … are welcome 😁

like

Let’s start this bowl by sharing our learnings: What has been you biggest learning as a leader so far?

like

What is your job title? As it right now I’m managing a team of product owners and I’m unofficially being called “Chief Product Owner.” I’m in the process of working with a coach to get my resume updated so I can begin applying for external roles. But I don’t even know what job titles to target.

like

If you wold like some assistance with classroom management or even managing your owe children, check this out this resource.

likehelpful

Is an MBA really worth it?

What does an online MBA look like in terms of class time, work load, realistic time to complete etc?

like

Have you been invited to join The Human Gathering?
Did you do it? Was it worth it?

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal