Got an offer for product strategy lead at Facebook and a similar but more data science driven role at Google. Two cents?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Facebook is dying google is not

likesmart
Recent IconRecent

My two cents is you didn’t get that offer as an associate lol

likefunnyuplifting

Facebook is destroying our country and Google is not. Easy call.

like

For the good samaritans on this post -

1. The Facebook role is on product strategy for ideation on business growth products, so the exposure will increment my commercial insight / intuition. Down the road I plan on starting a manufacturing business. Additionally, Facebook has six month performance cycles and promotions are truly merit based, so a normal 1 year promotion in 6 months is quite plausible, hence more responsibility and growth at a quicker pace.
2. For those who might have google blinders on. Don’t be fooled by Facebook’s PR debacle. They are engineering innovators on several fronts. Facebook stories on community growth for SMEs, foundations, etc and giving voice to the average person are very powerful and commendable achievements, and something I resonate with. They’ve been strategic winners with their acquisitions and are betting big on VR and AR.
3. Google is second to none - always had an engineering crush on it. I do plan on doing a data science masters, so the role makes sense to further my intellectual growth, but Google functions like any big corporation with significant bureaucracy and its frustrating for engineers when pushing ideas and products quickly. This concept transcends on several fronts of the culture / work at this point. Facebook is more fast paced in this aspect.
4. My gut feeling is Facebook, but it’s truly a tough decision especially given Googles push on AI. Thus, both roles are rewarding for my interested and career growth. Hence the dilemma.

like

Google ... just think that’s the better overall company

like

If you passed google interviews you’re a rock star

likesmart

@OP - small clarification — Google also does performance reviews 2x a year

likehelpful

Did you ask the question just because you knew the answer ?

like

@PwC 1 - no trust me, I have imposter syndrome getting an offer from either of these places, and am very grateful. I asked the question because I wanted two cents from a like minded community in real time.

like

What do you enjoy more? Will either of these roles lead you to somewhere you want to be?

likesmart

My 2 cents: focus on culture where you will thrive. Many of the items you raised are moot. For instance, working on data science at G and later getting a MSc in the topic is an extrapolation of your current state. Once you join either of these companies, your career interests and prospects will definitely change (you'll have access to cutting edge tech that you currently don't even know exists). In terms of promotion and career progression, both are meritocracy-driven cultures, one with a larger employee base than the other, thus moving at different speeds. Why focus on "promotion" now as opposed to learning opportunities? You're young, making 20-30k more won't change your life, but enjoying work you're doing PLUS work adjacent to your role is definitely going to engage you more than the titles they'll dangle in front of you. Focus on progression, not promotion. As to switching cost, they're almost non-existent! You see people switching back and forth among FAANG companies - thus my advice is to choose culture coupled with type of work, and "promotion" opportunities last. Earning potential down the road has to be very similar. If you really like what you do and enjoy projects/people who you have contact with, you're going to thrive because you'll be engaged.

likesmart

@Data Analytics Consultant 1:

1) BSc in Electrical and Computer Engineering

2) - 2.5 years of financial service consulting: got lucky with some cool projects. To name a few: a) post merger strategy for a bank 2) data analytics project on algorithms for derivatives with a trading team 3) digital product launches in equity space - hands on experience throughout the SDLC cycle, learning business logic and development code of the product engines.
- past 6-7 months focused on robot process automation initiatives and data science (ML predictive analytics)

3) Have experience building financial models as well. Built a cool tool in an internship to find reduction potentials for an automative conglomerate.

4) I do want to mention that I’ve been rejected multiple times at 2nd / 3rd or final rounds for such roles in competitive companies. Learning from failures and augmenting lacking skills along the way is key to growth and eventual success! The interview processes are grueling and so many random variables can upset your chances. Of course life / visa issues and other variables can be road blocks as well.

like

Facebook. Hands down doing much more innovation. But, people have Google blinders on.

like

My 2 cents : stop drinking !!

likefunny

@Google 1 - appreciate that insight. The FB recruiter is an ex Google recruiter and voiced that FB promotions tend to happen at a faster pace than some of the other tech firms if the candidate is excelling and showcasing his ability to perform at the next level.

I know Google recognizes such individuals as well, but I’ve noticed it’s more common at FB (a couple of my friends from college who started out at FB had exceedingly rapid promotions, albeit these are stellar people, but still)

like

People at Facebook enjoy the culture and great perks

like

The reason I’m still at Google despite the near-zero switching costs (which would probably give me a $40-$50k bump):

Work-life balance. I maybe clock 45 hours a week as a product manager.

Internal opportunities. Google has more products, more offices, and more appetite to experiment with new products and services. Transferring internally can feel like taking a job with a whole new company, except you keep your comp, tenure, and historical knowledge.

Both are great choices, and having an offer from both almost certainly means that you won’t be lowballed in the negotiation stage. Agree with P2 — very thoughtful post — pick the one that feels right because the other will be easily available

like

Toss a coin and go. Post a yr or two u can switch to either place with the experience 😃

like

What's the role and pay if you don't mind share

like

What did you did you do in Advisory?
What was your undergrad degree in?
How many yrs of experience?

smart

Related Posts

like

Will UST provide 100% of variable pay or what is the percentage they give us and when will they provide like end of the year

Hello Fishes,

I would like to know the appraisal cycle in UST, If I join by December, when will be the next cycle(april to april or dec to dec)?

like

Hi Fishes,
Can someone tell me the shift timings at Tiger Analytics? I have heard that they have flexible shifts is 8-5 possible?

like

Hello friends, been offline for a while and trying to get a sense what the vibe in the NY market is at the moment? Hiring freezes and everyone is afraid of an approaching recession?

like

EY gds

Please tell me in-hand mnthly.

New tax regime


EY

Post Photo
like

How much hike(%) you got in NielsenIQ? Year 2022, 2021 ?

like

Is there any Job opening for bcom or mcom freshers. Please let me know if any.

like

Anyone work at Spotify or someplace similarly music-centric (Tidal, Apple Music)? What’s the lifestyle / WLB like? How’s your team?

like

Thoughtworks hiring for senior data engineer. DM me for details

Post Photo
like

What’s Opus London like?

like

Hello Fishes,

I have got an offer at
Wells Fargo for the role Technology Business Systems Consultant and my total YOE is 4.8 into Testing (Manual and Automation)
Is this role relevant to my experience or is it a role for much experienced person than me?

Any idea or information that what is the pay usually offered for this position?
Please provide your thoughts and suggest whether I should change 1. My role or 2. Request for more pay

Thanks in Advance!Wells Fargo

like

Hi All,

What is the wlb in Areteans for a pega developer.

like

Been at SEI 10 years, star of every team that I've worked on, and only make $87,000 annually with a $6,500 IC target. Asking for an increase this June to take me to $100,000 in some combination of salary and/or stock options. Any tips for asking for stock options in lieu of a company being able to meet a salary request? TIA

like
like

Hi fishes, can you please tell me why do ppl say join EY GDS and not EY India. I am into Java Fullstack, yoe-4, location -Pune recently cleared online test and given interview and later get to know it's EY India not GDS. Now m worried should I join or not. I have 2 other offers from WITCH companies. EY EY India

like

Guys , pls help, How much Cognizant can pay for Manager projects , 8.5 Yrs , Azure , Databricks , Pyspark

likeuplifting

Could anyone speak to what it’s like to work for HHS as an attorney advisory? Culture, substance of the work, would be interested to hear anything really. Thank you.

More Posts

I'm accepting an offer with a new company... Start in early Aug. Senior Manager role, though in this company that equates to Manager at most consulting farms. They did not had hunt me. I came to them for the job.

I have COVID delayed vacations planned for the last week in August and the first week in October.

Should I just cancel one of them? Or should I at least put both on the table and see what they say? They're going to hire me either way, but I wonder if it's a bad start to ask for both.

like

How many folks here looking to actually connect for serious relationship (potentially converting to marriage)?

I’ll start 🙋🏻‍♂️ 30, located in the US (east coast) - open to worldwide relocation.

like

How do you deal with a manager / junior partner who is always nitpicking and questioning why you did what you did, or telling you what you did is the wrong way to do things? It’s generally prefaced with them only doing this to help you grow, but has the exact opposite effect on me. And then when you try to explain your POV, you’re tagged as being defensive. Generally ends me with saying I’m sorry. No other partners at the firm have ever raised any concerns on my communications or work product.

like

How much salary does jp pay to promoted associates in India? Which are not in tech

like

EY Sharks, can anyone help me how can I get EY T-shirt 👕.???
Also the access card which we get, is there any benefit of using it for lunch purposes.??

Can I save tax/money or whatever if I use or not use this access card.
EY

like

Fav trust drafting software and why?

Top 3 ways senior bankers can make junior bankers' lives better/ more rewarding...

like
likeuplifting

Damn, I gained probably 10-15 pounds since traveling M-F this past month.... So fat I hate sitting down working thinking about how fat I am. I'm not even that fat but my clothes getting tight

like

Considering boomeranging back to the firm I left last year. What is reasonable to expect for an offer to return?

likefunny

Whats S1 salary atm for big 4 tax? MCOL and HCOL

A&M fishes ! Waiting for an offer from PEPI MAS today. What’s a realistic TC for a manager on average ? I know it’s very much dependent on utilization but I’m looking for average numbers that someone you have seen during your time at the firm. Lowest and highest in addition to average are appreciated as well 😊

like

How much does a Senior in audit make in Big4s ? Looking for an upgrade and switch. TIA

like

Can anyone tell me about which pharma/health companies OR agencies have great WFH/remote/flex policies? I feel like Glassdoor and Indeed don't highlight that enough when it's one of the things I care about the most.

like

Need advice: I want to ask my firm to move me to another office permanently. How do I bring it up? I think my firm will understand and try to move me, but not guaranteed. Need to plan for it well.

likehelpful

Anyone want to give me retroactive FOMO by sharing stories from their summer associate programs? Mine is entirely virtual, and needless to say we are less than enthused by what we’re missing out on

like

How much medical insurance is provided by Tech Mahindra?

I applied for one position at amdocs some time back, online interview was scheduled but I couldn't attend the interview for some reason.

Is this situation considered in 6 months criteria?

like

Hi,

I have interview with
Amazon for Business Analyst role. Any tips for preparation would be really helpful. Thanks !!!

Amazon

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Is it worth a 10k mileage run to get to 150k EQMs and get the 2 extra SWUs?

like

Been in FSO PI for a few years out of undergrad, and I haven't really had any projects with quantitative analysis, am I just really off the mark or is this typical?

like

Lots of us are skilled at delivery but most sales books seem to focus on the pitch and closing... What are your best resources for learning to develop and nurture strong, lasting client relationships?

like

Does TSA stand for The Stupidest Agency?

like

Assuming this causes a recession like in 2008, and many people get laid off, how long to take to find another similar paying job? I’m currently a strat manager in FS. Scared for job.

likefunny

Cynical Tuesday - just realize all this time, what pushed me forward was intrinsic motivation. At the end of the day, my hard work was not recognized, I was given a petty raise...no extrinsic motiv

like

Backpacks - for students, not consultants...

like

Watched the cub win with the team in a bar in Chicago. Best experience 💖👯‍♂️👬👬

like

Surrounded by Giants and Patriots fans @ Penn Station .... People move out of the way I need to get to Newark Airport 😒

like

So hammed on a 5 hour flight right now with so much work I should be doing but 🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼

like

Which top consulting firms, if any, will pay for your MBA?

like

What service lines, and sub service lines have the most amount of work? I'm thinking about EY specifically, but I'm interested in other firms as well.

like

Not a Trump fan but Kellyanne Conway is a MVP. White women: what's your thoughts on her?

like

What are the BCG ring fences and how is each one? Can you join any of them or are you required to do the one closest to your home office

like
like

Anyone at mgr level making >200 K? Location and practice?

like

So apparently the human error was PwC fault for announcing the wrong best picture 🤦🏻‍♂️ I could just see a an EY MD trying to swoop up the Oscar account right now

like

A senior I know just closed on a 2 million condo (parents helped out). They feel like they should just lie when people ask if her if she rents or buy? Thoughts on if that is the right move?

like

Soooo if you hate your job so much, for so long. Wtf are you still doing here?! Plz enlighten me. I srsly do not compute.

like

Book recommendations? All genre welcome but I usually read nonfiction

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal