I am currently a gov attorney at a major metro area in the northeast. I recently received an offer from a ID private firm (1900 billable hours) in the area for about 40k more than my currently salary. I was going to accept, but now I’m having second thoughts about leaving a secure gov job with good benefits. Really not sure what to do.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Please compare benefits. I switched from a firm to a nonprofit, which came with a 35k pay cut. But once I looked at the benefits (way lower employee contribution for insurance, 401k matching and extra retirement contributions) it was barely a pay cut at all, but my quality of life was way better.

like

This is really on point advice. Consider entire compensation, including benefits, when comparing.

like

I would remind you (and everyone on this thread) that not all ID work is created equal. PL and L&E ID work are very different in practice and reputation than the slip and fall type ID work that most people think of first when they see the term “ID”.

likefunny

I wasn’t aware. Thanks!

Recent IconRecent

The posts I’ve seen about ID make it seem awful with minimal opportunity for long-term career or salary growth. I’d stick with government and try to get a job at a different firm instead of in a niche field for lawyers that isn’t well-respected across the profession.

like

This was me in March 2020. I didn’t go to ID but the firm had me in a small white collar and general commercial lit practice.

Not sure of your experience level, but for me the worst part about it was not billables per se but the following, in order:
1) I went from a high-volume calendar as a supervising prosecutor trying violent crimes and high profile cases to not being allowed on the record in virtual court
2) above, but my role was reduced to scheduling meet-and-confers and emails from partners asking me to email others the exact thing that they wrote in the email to me
3) discovering that vacation didn’t exist, both in practice (worked on my one vacation I took) and policy (have to make up the hours instead)

I’m now back in govt

likehelpful

This was my story but I left to make 100k more than I was making and I still question it now whether it was a right move.

helpful

Do NOT get tricked into becoming trapped in insurance defense. Not worth it under any circumstances.

like

ID is a major grind, also $120k for 1800 seems underpaid as well. I did ID for a little bit and worked probably 10 hour days to bill 8 hours, and was insanely stressed the whole time (had too many cases, couldn’t work up cases as much as I wanted, etc).

I would maybe consider switching if it was to biglaw (with much more $ and a better firm reputation so that if I wanted to go back to government I’d have the good firm reputation backing me).

like

I would like to know what your current salary is and what other benefits/perks each position offers, but assuming you’d be working a lot more at the ID job, I wouldn’t take it unless you really needed the money. If anything, I’d look to secure a federal government gig that very well could pay close to (or more) than some ID jobs

like

A fiend of mine was in a similar boat.
80k gov job! Decided to go ID to be able to work from home ! Salary 115k. When I speak with her she sounds like she likes the substantive work, loves the group she is in, likes being able to work from home and be around her kids, saves on commute!
Benefits suck as she has to pay out of pocket 2k for the family plan (it’s a decent plan but costs too much);
Has unlimited PTO but she has to make up all the hours;
Billing overall sucks especially for ppl who never done it before..
And constantly has the work mode on, if she is off she always complaints how much she has yet to
Bill.lol

helpful

Run Forest run. Stay out of ID Work at all costs.

like

The firm is Wilson Elser if that helps

like

I still work here… the pay is biased….severely biased. It is based off of how much HR likes you and not experienced. As a non-asian I have seen a lot of asian discrimination (Indian included). Also their medical is suck my medicaid is far better which says a lot. They also overwork their associates!

If you don’t absolutely need the money…don’t. Do. It.

like

I know the money sounds appealing, but the cost to what you will be giving up will be a lot more. That firm is a bit of a factory and rates are low. You can find a better practice area with better long term potential and it will prob pay you more if you want to go to a firm. ID is tough and I would never suggest moving to it for someone who has been practicing for a bit and doesn’t need the experience.

like

Are you going to be doing the same type of work that you were doing before? Or is this a totally different area of law?

like

The same work I’m doing right now

like

Hard to really make a recommendation at this point, and it of course depends on whether you like/are happy at your government job and if you are actually interested in ID. One thing I wanted to note, though, is that the government benefits (assuming Fed) are really worth a lot - For example: I save multiple thousands a year on health insurance, disability insurance, and life insurance, the TSP match gives you another 5% of your Income; and you can try and figure out the value of your pension by seeing what an annuity with a cola would cost with the same terms. Also, there’s a lot to be said for no billing and government job security, especially in the current economic client.

Related Posts

What’s the general range for Sr. Manager in Accenture Digital? Considering a position there and I already have been given an acceptable base salary range. Need to gauge the over/under.

like

Any reviews about Salesforce role in Intellect Design Arena? How is the work life balance? What are the benefits one get in this company?

like

TCS HR is negotiating me and offering 9.5 LPA with 1 lakh bonus amount over 8.93 offer of IBM in which 8.3 is in hand. And i demand for 12 LPA as QA Automation engineer total 3.8 year of experience. Should i stick to 12 lpa and join IBM at 8.93?

like

Is M. Design from IIT-IDC Bombay really worth it?

I am working for 1.5 years in a Hyderabad startup as UI/UX Designer. After Btech I did a certification in UI/UX and got job from the institute placement only. Will a master's from IIT-IDC Bombay will be worth or should I climb the regular conventional ladder by jumping from company to company for package hikes?

like

Assuming that I'm okay with a salary of 70K and more, and that I really don't want to work at a law firm. Is it going to be difficult for me to return to law with two years of experience and one year working in a legal adjacent role.

like

Hello Fishes,

Current CTC: 24 LPA

YOE: 5 years

Tech: Backend Developer - Java

I have got the below offers :

Paytm: 32 fixed + 1 Joining Bonus

Mobileum: 32 fixed + 3 Variable

Yubi: 30 fixed

Payu: 28 fixed + 4 Variable

I am confused. Please suggest which one would be a better company to join.

like

I return to work from maternity leave (PwC) next Monday. Am I supposed to contact someone or just login as per usual? I figured someone would contact me to get me back into things. Maybe I think they care too much HA.

like

How is Pwc digital? If I do an RPA position within pwc digital, am I only limited to rpa work or can I also be looped into other digital work?

likesmart

For experienced accounting professionals considering a transition into a career with solid work/life balance, a fast-growing biotech company near San Francisco is hiring for a SOX Compliance Manager and Senior Accountant/Manager roles. Roles pay well over $100k.

Generous benefits, fun company culture, and VERY favorable stock options. Message me if interested, and I will try to screen you for an interview!

I’m a healthcare recruiter that specializes in physician and CRNA recruitment across multiple specialties. I’m curious from the other side of the same nickel, what do you want in a new job? Are you interested in travel contract work?

like

How is EXL HEALTH (SCIO) Chennai In term of WLB and job security, Pay for 4 years experience

like

I just recently promoted to HR assistant manager. I have my PHR and working towards my SPHR. I am the lowest paid employee in the depth. We have a senior specialist and a general specialist both make more than I do. They have been employed longer with the company. What is your advice on this issue?

like

What is the average TC for pharma associate directors in business roles (e.g., business development, portfolio strategy)? What’s the average timeline for promotion to director?

like

Hello Fishers,

I am having 12 Years of Experience in Technical and Operational Management & Recently I have done ML/DS and Done my PMP Certification.

Please suggest to me how to switch my job and how much I can expect Package. At present my CTC is 14 Lac PA.

I Need Suggestion and Support. Please Help me how to change my Path and how to put it in a track.

like
like

what is the billable hours requirement for a senior tax manager at EY?

like

Lowe's What’s the salary expectation for analytics lead at Lowe’s?
YoE 5
Current ctc 18
Lowe's

I make $140k in New York. Should I invest a Traditional 401K or a Roth 401K or do a split?

like

Anyone experience a significant salary bump shifting from a more traditional or comms-focused shop to tech-heavy digital work? Or vice versa being told your salary is now too high to go back?

More Posts

Hello Everyone, I’m new on this Fishbowl group , i want to make some new connections and get some solid relationships as well as business acquaintance on this group as I learn and contribute to the growth of this group.

like

Neutral colored Louboutins at work, yay/nay? Thinking about the 100mm height in black or nude. Work in tech with all guys at manufacturing client and cautious about being too “fashion forward”.

like

Anyone have any suggestions on a RIA-Friendly custodian for 529 Plans? TD Ameritrade has an affiliation w the Nebraska Educational Savings Plan Trust (NEST). Has anyone had any experience with them?

like

5/25/22 check in! Happy hump day, what’s your workout for today?

like

F / NYC / SVP Strategy Director / 215k

like

6/9 😆 check in! What are you up to?

likefunny

Just finished egg retrieval. Only got 5 eggs which I’m a little bummed about. Has anyone had luck with a number that low? We are doing a fresh transfer.

likehelpful

Chances at MIT Sloan with 1 YOE in data analytics and 3 YOE in socially responsible investing? 3.5 GPA from t10 STEM. Did not submit GRE (was at lower range of Sloan’s 80%). Great LOR, video, and cover letter.

like

Please keep me active

like

Anyone currently at EY-Parthenon as an experienced hire? Looking to hear about your interview/hiring process

like

I’ve spent a long time working in nonprofits and higher education and I am so excited that I’ll finally be leaving. I feel like I’ve been in a cult for over 10 years and I feel extremely jaded and played. Yes I know many of you are going to laugh at me for believing that working for nonprofits or education was a good thing, but I sincerely did think that what I was doing was for the greater good. I’m embarrassed I used to think that way. I can’t wait to leave and never come back. 🏃🏾‍♀️

like

Can someone give me feedback on my long terms and short short essay for duke:

My short-term goal is to pursue management and leadership roles in strategy consulting in a consulting firm. I look forward to using the network, knowledge in finance, people management skills acquired at Fuqua to excel. This will equip me for my long-term goal of addressing the challenges of energy poverty in Africa.

(long term in comments)

like

Is anyone here a SWE who started from scratch? No education or background in tech or IT, was working in an unrelated area, self taught through free online resources and ended up getting a job? I failed the non technical assessment for a bootcamp and that was my shot at finally learning with a place that could help me. That really discouraged me and made me feel like I’m just not smart enough to be working in tech at all, let alone as a SWE.

like

Anyone tried the new Sanctions Certificate (CGSS) offered by ACAMS? Trying to see how difficult it is considering I don't have a lot of experience with sanctions compliance. I have CAMS & work in AML

like

Does JPMC has any policy for higher education? If yes, can anyone please elaborate on the same.

like

Hi All,

I have joined EY in APR 22, will i be eligible for variable pay and hike?
Also whats this prorated means ? 😓
Thanks

Does anyone know what industries / competencies got hit by the layoffs yesterday? A few people mentioned it, but no one gave any details.

like

I’m bringing my confession to you all: I want a poly relationship with someone emotionally available. More flirty than a friendship, no sex, but I’ll domme you if you’re into that

likefunny

Hi folks, I recently applied for a new role in EMEA for a Specialist Solutions Architect. Got through n received an offer letter. But seems like the base is a bit lower than what i saw online in a couple of places (not sure of years of experience there though). Is it worth it to bring it up and ask the HM to raise an exception? How much time will this take? Is it a risk? Already the entire process has dragged on cause of delays on recruitment's part etc. Any advice or insight would be helpful!

Additional Posts in Law

For a writing sample when applying, is it best to redact any identifying information of a client, even if the document has been filed publicly with the court? It has been years since I left law school and would like to use a more recent sample, if possible.

like

I put in my notice last week at my current firm. MP was shaking with anger when I told him. Toxic partners, commonplace sexism, and widespread bullying. I was only there 6 months. Walking out of that office, I felt 50lbs lighter. I just want to remind you all that you’re better than some people will try to make you feel, and no one can look out for your interests better than you!

like

Should an employment lawyer consider getting a PHR/SPHR certificate? Is it worthwhile?
A lot of in house opportunities seem to be looking for them

like

Thinking of starting my own law firm. Has anyone on here gone solo? how did you go about floating your paycheck up front. I was thinking family law while taking on PI?

like

Those of you who do commercial lending/finance on the lender’s side, how do you like it? Thinking of making the switch but not sure if it’s lucrative

likehelpful

Anyone here working in Legal at Coursera. I have an interview and wondering how the work environment/benefits/comp/etc is?

like

Has anyone ever left a job simply because a deal got SO bad that you knew if you stayed it would be looming over your head for probably another year? To the point where you had daily nightmares.

like

Anyone have experience with NDA for domestic employee?

like

Lol non lawyer just said “i mean imagine if lawyers didn’t get drug tested, it just would never happen.”

funnylike

Folks who have transitioned from M&A to ECVC work, what did you think of the differences between the two? Was it a rough transition at all?

like

I’m on a staycation week but work (and the overall situation) has been so stressful these past 5 months all I can think about is all the hours I’m not billing. What do attorneys on vacation do?

like

How does hourly contract lawyering work? I’m on a contract through a recruiting firm before the company hires me directly. My pay is hourly but I get time and a half for over time. I’m currently a policy atty for a think tank and did prosecution before that so I’ve never “billed.” I regularly check and respond to emails on my phone in the evening after work. Do I include that on my timesheet??

like

2019 is to David Boies as 2017 is to Louis CK

likefunny

Anyone know what’s the deal with Polsinelli? Just trying to figure out whether they’re the right fit for me. I’m currently in a boutique IP firm. I work pretty hard but it’s obviously not Big Law.

like

Average time between interview and offer? If long (over a month), should you assume the opportunity is dead in the water?

like

That moment when your "smart" plan to boost your hours this month by working the Labor Day weekend (thus turning down all the fun plans your friends made) becomes sitting on your hands & feeling dumb because all the partners are too busy to delegate anything. The worst kind of "off" day is one you planned to /wanted to work, but there's no billable work...

likefunny

Whoever said employers don’t care about grades and transcripts after your first job was a liar. Every lateral position that I’ve applied to as a 3rd year has requested transcripts. Why do we lie and tell grads that employers don’t check transcripts when they do. My coworker, a 5th yr, had to submit his transcripts also to lateral job. Side note - it speaks volume when multiple associates are trying to lateral at the same time

like

In a personal injury case not involving a motor vehicle accident, how can a plaintiff settle a case if only one of defendants’ carriers covering one year has appeared when defendants...(cont)

like

Should your raise be equal to or more inflation?

like

Any recruiter recommendations for LA / SoCal?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal