In my organization, performance reviews seem to reflect visibility more than results. Employees who speak the loudest in meetings are often rated higher than those who consistently deliver quality work. This raises the question of whether our evaluation process rewards substance or self-promotion. How should organizations balance outcomes versus presence?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I half agree. Reason being, loudest yes person vs loudest “risk sharing”

like

So when you say visibility, what do you mean? Do you mean in your role you interact with a lot of different levels of people or do you mean no matter your role you’re going to find the person that you feel is the right one to brown nose too? Because I’ve seen both.
True visibility is absolutely necessary in order to move up and or get the right people behind you. Brown nosing does do something, I don’t know whether that’s just promotions or pay increases or what.

I dont think it’s about being “loud” exactly. Employees who are speaking at these meetings are probably making good points and are engaging in the correct kind of conversations to help the company move forward and make good improvements to increase the bottom line in the end. Yes, it’s about being seen, but you must be seen by providing good quality content and discussions. Can’t just be loud and talk just for the sake of talking. Can’t really fake that for long because eventually people and good leaders will see through it and they will know you’re not actually providing real value. So yes, be “loud” and be “seen,” but make sure you’re providing real value

I do agree with Manager 1. I don't think it is necessarily because they are the loudest people in the room. Visibility does make a difference, but it is usually because you are doing the right things to be seen.

Visibility is always the case as more jobs get lost to offshore

Related Posts

What’s the best online course to raise GMAT Verbal score? Have ~2 months until test date and am currently scoring 36.

like

ConsultingHumor’s Instagram page (364k followers) did a massive compensation survey for top consulting firms in the US and internationally. Several thousand respondents with base and bonus salary for all the top (and some smaller) firms. Can be used when negotiating your next raise or to see if you want to jump ship to another firm. You can download the full spreadsheet of data at consultinghumor (dot) org

Post Photo
likehelpful

from logistic perspective..how are you guys transferring/moving your money from your US bank account? wire transfer? write yourself a check? idk about check, but cashing in $50k might raise a flag.

like

How much yearly hike can one expect at Société Générale ?
"Depends on performance" seems to be a very vague answer.
Can someone please elaborate on a better answer.

Also, Can someone shed some light on promotions?

Is there any policy, like you have to work for X years to be eligible for promotion etc.

Thanks in advance.

Société Générale

like

What’s an appropriate raise to ask for after a strong year? Last year I received close to 10%, though I’m still underpaid. Was thinking about asking for 15%?

like

Was accepted into a T15 program without a scholarship and currently waiting to hear back from a T20 where I feel I have a great shot. Only have 2 years of experience and no promotion, but I'm expecting a promotion in 2 months with our year end cycle. Do you think that promotion and/or a scholarship offer from the T20 would be enough negotiating leverage?

like

How to avoid job hopper perception when every 1-1.5 years I end up getting a recruiter contact then offer for 50% raise? 4 years out of school and about to accept my 4th offer and worried about future optics

likefunny

I have got an offer from Deloitte for 14LPA as a consultant. But my current organisation is trying to retain me by giving me a raise and promoting me to SSE with 11 LPA they have also promised to give me more interesting work according to my will. For now I have said yes to my current organisation. What should I do? Was this a correct decision?

like

Thoughts?
I’ve been working at my current company for 11 years, for the past year I have been waiting for a promised promotion. I have been fully remote for 7 years pretty much good work life. Busy. In April they said I have the job still waiting. I am a project accountant III to a finance business manager.Could be long nights &stress. Still unknown pay maybe 20k increase.. Last week I was offered a govt job at NGA (Budget analyst) 40k increase not guaranteed remote. 45 min drive +retirement

like

I have a question. I work as an assistant manager been a manager for a while worked for the company for 6 years. I know crew gets paid a dollar less than me yet a do a lot ( its part of my job ) I asked for a raise I was told wait 3 months. Waited I asked again was told I needed to do this this and that. I feel like I'm under paid, but I love my job and crew.

likeuplifting

This is my third cycle review graph, not sure if it's bad or average. Will 5th cycle promotion be possible?

Post Photo
like

What is a standard raise %? I’m about to ask for my first raise and I want to walk in confidently with a number. I’ve been leading my team well above my title for a year and know I deserve it.

like

Anyone know the raise amounts for BCG yet?

like

ZS Associates
I have a couple of questions for ZS fishes-

1. Is it possible to turn down a promotion at ZS? I'm currently happy with my responsibilities as a Decision Analytics Consultant and don't want any added responsibilities in the near future (next 5 years)

2. Is it possible to shape up a career path in the BC stream which doesn't involve business development? I don't want to get into working on SOWs and RFPs.

like

Hi, when is promotion list announced in Ey , is it july month? Can anyone share insight on this

like

What is the promotion % for Grade B2 approx?

Hi guys,
What's the annual hike at band 601 in CB LOB. How much time it takes to get promoted to next level 602. How much will be the annual bonus at 601 level & percentage hike we will get at the time of promotion.

like

At what point does the value of a degree fall off? I'm in my early 30s, and have five years of experience, and work on a very theoretically interesting project. I believe I'm on track to promotion in the next year. So, I could put in a year of full time school to check the box off, but I'd be sacrificing hobbies and social life (not to mention cost). Is this FOMO or is there real opportunity here?

like

I work at an agency and I'm about to be promoted from senior to lead designer. What do you think would be a fair % of salary raise?

like

Typical salary band for Consultant level for Risk & Advisory in HCOL? Got an offer for 90k + 10k signing so trying to see if this is high or just standard. 2 YOE, they mentioned promotion to SC in 6-8 months.

like

More Posts

What’s the going rate for a commercial senior underwriting role and what companies have you found to be most enjoyable with a solid work life balance? Personally love where I’m at, but curious to see what else is out there.

like

I’m in big law and on the cusp of making the jump to in-house. It sounds like the company I just interviewed with is getting ready to make me an offer. It’s definitely going to be a pay cut coming from big law but I do get some nice equity in the company. Is the jump worth it? I’m so burnt out by big law and this seems like an awesome opportunity to help shape a newish company. Any tips on how to figure out if this is the right move for me?

like

What is the back of an envelope kind of estimation of a drug’s market share considering there’s one in market already?

funnylike

Thinking about purchasing a property in the Turks and Caicos Islands. Anyone done this? Looking to learn more about the pros/cons of international / Caribbean property ownership.

like

I’ve been working for a company for 25yrs, looking for advancement. I’m considered an SME, managing people, Vendors and working on large system conversions. Have provided long term goals. When requesting feedback I’m told I’m on the right path, no suggestions on what to improve. I asked about timelines for advancement and not being given anything concrete. Recently interviewed with another company as a Vendor Mgmt partner. Individual contributor, high visible position with potential. Thoughts?

like

I’m feeling stagnant in my career and looking for ways to grow. I was considering obtaining a PMP certification and wondering how impactful this is. Is this certification well recognized?

like

Has anyone successfully moved out of claims into underwriting? I have been doing worker’s compensation claims for about 9 years now as an adjuster. I would really like to get into underwriting but have not had any success so far. What are some other roles I can transition to?

likehelpful

Hi fishes,
I have recently joined in a project as a Oracle JD Edwards finance Functional Consultant.
Is this a good ERP to kickstart your consulting career and whether there are good opportunities for this ERP in the future.

like

Defenestration as attorney risk management is not recommended - told you this one would be a scorcher!

Post Photo
likefunny

Just got an offer for amazon hardware. I'm worried about the culture. Anyone have experience working there?

like

An important announcement to Noob fishes :-
Just don't throw randomly which company to join with amount X, Y and Z Lakhs.
freaking tell us your YoE, Tech Stack and Cctc or else we won't be able to help.
Ps - We won't be asking for party or treat, calm down! and we are not your neighbors to hide!

likefunny

Any recommendations on data warehousing solutions? Struggling to find something that covers all the bases but is still economical. Considering looking into consultants at this point

like
like

Do anyone feel that they are not at right place/right track in their career?

like

Happy Friday! Please comment your YOE and LPA.. I'm felling low.

like

Not the results I was hoping for this morning. Went for my first appointment before starting injections this evening. Only 9 follicles. Was told birth control can suppress some so they may just not be visible yet but feeling very panicked now despite the doctor saying it was ok for my age.

This journey is taxing.
Sending you all positive vibes ❤️

like

How to look about for opportunities for Acca candidate who has 3y experience in external audit ? Looking for suggestions ! Thanks

funny

We’re using our downtime to redecorate/renovate our home to change it up during quarantine. Any apps to help with the planning and measurement, etc? We’re using Pinterest and Instagram to gather ideas.

like

0 partners of color in group of 20 partners

Was told the lack of diverse partnership was because there wasn’t good minorities to hire. How do I even address this stupidity.

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal