Is it possible to make manager at 4 YOE (4.5 with Co-Op) at Big 4/cyber consulting firms (e.g., Accenture) I am a newly promoted SC at D and recently passed my CISM/looking to get Sec+ and wanted to see anyone has jumped to a M role in that amount of time. Or if 5 YOE is the standard

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

To be honest, it’s possible, but most of the people I see get there that fast usually don’t have the necessary skills nor experience to be able to handle it well. Breaking it down, most people take about 1-2 years learning consulting nuances and how to “job” appropriately. Your next 2 years are learning the actual skill sets required to perform well and identify solutions to potential problems. Your next round is doing the solutioning faster and more thorough with a thought process behind it. Mid way through that is direct C-suite interaction and being able to present to leadership tactfully. Then comes the relationship building with clients with the mindset of selling additional work and doing all the proposal work on top of your client work. And I don’t mean pitching in to help a slide, I mean leading the initiative.

I’ve always been a fan of operate at the next level and then you get it, as opposed to the promote early and see if you’ll make it.

With 4 YOE, I’d have to be really impressed that it’s sustainable performance.

likehelpful

This is incredibly spot on and accurate. I couldn’t have said it any better. I currently in that boat right now where I’ll be promoted to manager and feel like it’s too early and not happy about it.

like

If we didn’t add analyst at D it was possible as I did it in 4. It may be hard to jump to M with that experience but is possible. I would just apply to the other Big4. Accenture will be tough because they automatically feed out based on YOE. Even though I had M title I got auto rejected after applying based on what I believe to be the YOE question.

like

I know of one person who did it from college -> 4 YOE

like

This was also pre-analyst

like

I’ve tried to promote someone to manager in that 3.5-4 year time frame and I was blocked by a VP. The person I was trying to promote was a top 1%. She checked every corporate box across the board, education, skills, utilization, clients loved her, current responsibility level, black, woman, LGBTQ. She basically checked every box. She deserved that promotion. I argued it out with the VP. His response was she needs more client experience and 4 years isn’t enough. I said if we don’t promote her and she checks all the boxes for a promotion her next move is leaving. We’ll promote some that sits at the same level for a number of years, but we can’t promote a top 1% for excelling at her work over her peers in a shorter time frame. He said I’m inspired by your passion, but no. Come back next year. Which I fired back she won’t be here next year. I still put a 1 year promotion plan in place for her. She left as soon as she could. She now works at SalesForce and she got her promotion. Im happy for her. Good luck!

like

Not sure that “black, woman, and LGBTQ” are really checkboxes.

Also, your VP is probably right. It takes time and experience to be good, and with that it takes a lot of tough situations and failures. As G1 mentioned, you have to be ready for tough questions because there’s only so many times someone can say “great question, let me take that offline and get back to you” and retain credibility.

It’s better for her to keep learning and be at the top 1% at her level than for her to get a reality check and all of the sudden be on the bottom 50%. Could she also have excelled? Sure, but the risks associated with that are firm reputation lost, projects going side ways, staff don’t get appropriate mentorship, and she gets on a PIP anyways along with a lower salary band since it was a fast promote. Your VP has to look at the entire picture on a macro scale and make tough choices even when they aren’t popular.

It took me a bit of time to understand this as I was also young and chasing the next level every time, but now 12 years into it and experiencing it, the decisions make more sense now.

like

Accenture you can make manager in 4 yrs:
analyst to senior 1 year
Senior to consultant 1 yr
Consultant to manager 2 years

Yes, 4 years definitely possible. I know one person who did it in 3 (but was an experienced hire at associate level). Will depend ultimately how strong you are in Cyber skillset, and if you have partner support.

Yes, I made it in 4 at pwc. Director at 7. Hopefully partner at 11.

Btw - I took the long route to manager and above...always 1-2 years longer than others. Upside of all of that was that when I made it to Mgr or higher...the work was super easy.

Which allowed me to do well against my peers.

There is an upside to taking the long route.

I did it in 4 and so did a few others I know - definitely possible

Related Posts

I am starting a new job where I will be investigating sexual discrimination cases. Employment law will be a new practice area for me. Do you have any recommendations on good learning resources? Any treatises?

like

I'm a Communications major and a Management major. I have a Marketing concentration and a System Information & Business Analytics concentration. I accomplished this in 4 years and will be graduating this semester.

I have experience working as a Business developer and account executive at a start up company in the robotics industry.

Questions:
What type of job should I be looking for?

What type of certifications should i be looking at?

Any over all advice in to my career path is welcomed.

like

Can anyone help me with a referral at Google for a TPM role.🙏

like

Can anyone help me with a referral at Strategy & at PriceWaterCooper PwC PwC India Pwc AC


Would be great to hear back from someone working at Strategy &(formerly booz and co). Big 4 Strategy&

How is Flipkart for Work life balance? I have ~5 years of exp and hold an offer of 32 + Stocks. Also the expectation is to know Java but during the interview process , there was no discussion of Java or any questions asked. Although the team has asked me to invest some time in learning Java but I’m skeptical about all of this as the position is Data Engineer II so not sure how the expectations will change. Even if I invest time in learning Java I can be at a beginner level.

like

I’m looking to transition from healthcare to healthtech. I’m the head of marketing at my organization but I’m open to non leadership roles- demand gen, brand, communications and product. Please send me your recommendations!

like

What does commercial finance work (lender side) look like for a junior-mid level associate? Is it possible to lateral as an ECVC associate to this kind of work? Any transferable skills?

like
like

Hi Fishes,

I've got offer from Dunnhumby, Fractal and Gartner for the role of Data engineer. Which one should I go for?

Tech Stack - Python, PySpark, Azure Data Factory and Synapse analytics.
YOE - 2.2
Gartner - 16LPA
Dunnhumby - 15 fixed + 1.5 Joining bonus+ 10% variable
Fractal - 13.5 LPA

like

Intl Tax folks, how long did it take before you were confident in your role? I've worked for the past 3 years in a practice that is heavily consulting based (inbound and outbound structuring) and I feel like I'm only just starting to understand the foundational concepts (where I can explain them clearly to clients) and offering a shred of value. Then I'll have calls where partners discuss complex tax, legal, treasury and other related concepts that all go over my head.. it becomes overwhelming

like

In Intl tax, receiving recruiting offers for all remote work at the manager level. However, I am about to get promoted. Only concern is if I don’t jump soon, I’ll be stuck at the big 4. Any thoughts? Should I entertain?

like

Hi All, For B8 position having 8 years of experience in Project Manageme ,how much should someone quote and negotiate with the HR.

like

Ah the great Ad Agency Bubble, your agency is doing great, growing exponentially then boom, clients are lost, there are layoffs and there are no raises/promotions for a year. What do you do jump ship?

like

Hi everyone!

I recently just finished my interview with Accenture and is looking very promising. We have yet discuss salary, I would like to know other people's salary who work in the Industry X so that I'm not getting low-balled. I currently work at HDR inc. making 69K (Salary).

2 YOE., Mechanical Engineer

The position is "Analyst - Industry X Development Program" in Detroit, Michigan.

like

Hello, after doing some research I believe I’m being underpaid. About 4 months ago HR did a market analysis for my role. They bumped my salary for about $2k. I’m a mid-level Executive assistant with 6 years of experience and currently supporting 5 executives at a fortune 50 company. One C level and 4 Vice Presidents. I’m currently making $61,000 with bonus included. Based on my research I should at least be making $71,400. I have a check in with my boss tomorrow and I am asking for a raise.

like

I’m a second year BigLaw associate that pays market. I was offered the position at a modified salary and hourly expectation due to their expected work flow needs. I’m wondering what is the best way to approach the topic of getting on the full salary/hours. Do I wait until the bonuses are given at the end of my first year? Or bring it up at mid-year review? I won’t have any problem meeting my hourly so I’m starting to think I’m being underpaid. I’ve been reading on here that not meeting

like

Feels like the interviewing process needs a lot of disruption. In what world is it okay for currently employed people to be expected to have multiple face to face meetings for a potential role?

likehelpful

ResQ Ltd. is hiring for an Inside Sales Account Executive role and a Field Account Executive in Toronto. If you know anyone who has done tech, hospitality, or restaurant sales please reach out to connect!

Hi fishers,

I'm a Programmer Analyst with over 2.8 years of experience in SAS and SQL.
My preferred location is Chennai/Bangalore.
Currently I'm looking for a job switch and it's kind of urgent.
Can someone please refer me if your company has any opening for SAS and SQL.

Thanks in advance..

like

Hi all, I am trying for role - Customer Engineer GCP. I have 5 years exp in (GCP cloud predominant for 3 years now) DevOps field in Financial Services area including FinTech (Fidelity Investments), Bank (HSBC) & Insurance(CNA Insurance - currently working). Also have a Masters in MIS. I have got & cleared calls from AWS for AWS Developer, Architect roles & failed on-site FB Production Engineer role interview. I have applied but not got a callback from Google? Any advice, highly appreciated.

like

More Posts

Any consulting firms that are particularly good for Jews or which honor Jewish holidays? My firm has a Jewish diversity team but I’d love to learn about others.

like

January 13th is Korean-American Day!

Don't forget to honor those Korean-Americans that have made sacrifices and contributions to pave way for a better life and nation.

like

I have my final round interviews with Amazon next week! I’m going for the Campaign and Creative Manager role - any tips/advice? How did you manage 4, one hour long interviews? What to expect from a TC standpoint? I am based in NYC.

like

Currently last year student looking for consulting jobs / jobs in technology. Applying at Deloitte, Accenture, EY, Cisco. What would you guys recommend? Got even some interviews with start/scale ups. Wanne hear your thoughts 🙌

like

How did everyone do in terms of their bonus this year? Mine didn’t exactly meet my expectations to say the least and I feel like any reason they give after the year we had just sounds ridiculous.

like

How come in TV shows there are different salaries for different actors? And it's even worse when you bring numbers in. Per episode, there have been cases where some people make twice as much as others.

like

Has anyone had an interview with Aston Carter before? If so, what would be some advice you would give?

like

I'm 40F. Any point to my being in this bowl? Not being facetious, just see a lot of chat here and in the WhatsApp group about how the people in their early 30s are old, so don't want to waste my or anyone else's time...

like

Anyone have experience on a credit strategy fund especially a credit hedge fund? Do they recruit non bankers? I saw an interesting opp but I have very little relevant background with debt (consulting background)

like

Will be in Dallas for work next week, any recommendations (must see, restaurants, tours or shows)?

What have you been doing for dealing with being alone in your apartment? (Besides video chat or working out)

like

Any pathologists here?
How do you feel about the use of AI in Pathology, and Digital Pathology?

like

Writing a book on developing an educators toolbox. it is a process oriented book that helps teachers and admin leverage technology. Anyone interested? If so, interested in collaborating?

I have salary discussion with infy tomorrow. How much should I ask? CCTC-8.1 , YOE-3.9
I left infy an year ago only🙈

like

Anyone looking to relocate or in Cinci Ohio to work for a great team in a wonderful top 100 firm… dm me please! :)

If you only stay a year after returning what happens to the 10K relocation and 20K early signing? Are you required to pay back half or is it all yours?

like

How diligent is Mintz background check. When it comes to education? My references, credit, criminal and work experiences will check out. However said I already graduated school when I am in reality a month away from graduating. The company sent over the contract and start date at the same time as the background check.

like

Just found out our local Natural History Museum has an AMAZING STEM program. They’ll do outreach with scholarships! I’m so excited! What are your other favorite STEM organizations to partner with?

Thoughts for a upscale networking event

Post Photo
like

Additional Posts in Cyber Security Bowl

Anyone got insights on IBM Security? Areas of expertise? QoL? Pay, etc.

Thinking of moving from Big4 cyber to Accenture cyber. Any major differences (other than no channel restrictions).

like

Risk assurance senior and planning to leave for industry to do security compliance soon. Would want to come back to big 4 to do security consulting, how should I plan out my career route? Just a lost young soul who graduated from college 2 years back...

like

Could anyone provide insight on Deloitte Senior Consultant and/or Manager salary bands (estimates) for Cyber?

like

Anyone working in Pharma industry?

like

Other than a client project, what's a good way to get trained up on cloud security?

like

Wonder if anyone can offer advice on which cert to pursue next? I obtained my CompTIA Security+ last year and wondering if I should go for the CySA+ or Pentest+ next. I also have my AWS CCP and will be sitting for the Solutions Architect soon as well. Currently not doing security stuff at work but would love to keep my skills going. I was hoping one of these next certs will help me finally break into a security role and love the idea of pentesting but not sure if the CySA+ is more beneficial.

like

How to make a jump to cloud security when I just have SOC experience? Currently studying for Solutions Architect cert

like

How long did you guys study for The new cissp exam , and how are the questions like on the exam

like

On a phone call today, my client suggested our project team provide 24/7 coverage for scanning support. My team size is two, including myself.

Post Photo
likefunnysmart

Cyber managers in Ontario, could you please help me with approx salary ranges?

like

For those who have passed the CIPM exam, what is it like (and how does it compare to the CIPP/US exam)?

I am considering a different career: On the Director or executive level, who earns more: Cybersecurity executive or the head of marketing/ head of commerce?
Trying to understand the glass ceiling here

like

For 🐠 who got your CISSP, about how much study time did it take you? E.g. how many weeks/months did you study for, and how many hrs/week? It's a goal of mine to get certified, just trying to (cont.)

likefunny

How is Booz Allen cyber strategy and risk management consulting? Got a recruiter inquiry

like

Hey all, I have been working in Identity and access management space at EY for past 4 years. Need help with understanding best exit opportunities?

Looking for a job dojng cloud security. Which are the best and worst companies to work for? Optiv any good?

like

Any recommended study material for CIPP and/or CIPM (still debating the two)?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal