Just curious How do people afford apartments in the city with avg rents of $5000? What kind of income are y’all making?

likeuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I think it comes down to poor judgment for most of the people spending $5k/month to rent a small NYC apartment. My husband and I could easily afford that (our home mortgage is $1k higher) but it's such a huge waste of money when there are alternatives like commuting from NJ, LI, or further out in Brooklyn/Queens. I know many people want to live right in the heart of it all, but at such a huge cost it ends up eating away your disposable income, and then can you really enjoy being in the heart of it all anyway? I guess for people making like $1m a year who don't plan to stay in the city forever it's fine to spend so much in rent but for others who want to be able to save and not feel like they have to sacrifice in every other aspect of their lifestyle, it's just poor judgment to spend so much on rent.

likefunnysmarthelpful

There’s decent 1brs in Manhattan between 3-4k. Just be willing to climb stairs.

I agree with this sentiment. Too many folks spending their income on rent. I try to abide by the 30% rule even in NYC when most people use the 40x income rule which is about half your take home. By that logic my partner and I can rent a 7-8k a month apartment but instead our rent is 3200 and we split that so 1600 and use the rest to invest, travel and nice dinners each month.

Why live in Manhattan if you can’t enjoy it stress free?

I do expect my rent to go up at renewal which is December but it’s a while away so let’s see. Fingers crossed the market cools

like

I make $350k/year….I pay $3800/month in Manhattan for a 3 bed 2 bath. When I moved to Manhattan 9 years ago, I made $70k and paid $2300/month for a 2 bed 1 bath. Supported my wife and two kids on that salary….it’s a grind, but the opportunity is worth it for those willing to grind it out.

likeupliftinghelpfulfunny

I’m UES and hired a broker. Worth every penny.

Recent IconRecent

HHI - $500-600K

Easier when you have a working partner and are both have a bit more experience which generally means more comp to deal with these ridiculous prices.

Rent $5600 2/2

like

Wife and I make 350-400 combined and absolutely need two separate spaces to WFH. Would prefer to have a studio but seems like companies have now downsized office space to the point of requiring WFH if you need to take phone calls.

like

5.7k for luxury 2bed. About 500k with partner.

like

I make $250k and my mortgage is $3k. Manhattan isn’t the only place in NYC

like

We moved to Montclair NJ. Rents are lower but still high compared to some parts of the Northeast.

like

What if I told you that you can actually find cheap housing (I.e. - apartments for less than $2.5-3k) in the city

But here’s the caveat… it’s not in Manhattan, you have to go to the outer boroughs

like

We don’t live in Manhattan Darling! We tend to live in Brooklyn, Queens etc. Or live with roommates 🤷🏽‍♀️

like

Roommate(s) & budgeting. People over complicate things. Use an app/Excel to track your finances and tweak it to create a budget with your monthly income and rent. Also, the 30% of monthly income goes to housing rule goes out the window in NYC - people on average in NYC pay about 40% of their monthly income on rent, without bills. Get a broker, use StreetEasy religiously & find a no fee apartment with heat and hot water included in the rent - it just won’t be 10 mins away from work, more like 40 mins, but that’s not a big deal. And please get a roommate or two! I personally do not know a single SOUL paying remotely close to 5K in rent a month & I’m a native New Yorker. My friends and I all have roommates and each pay less than 2k a month in rent.

like

How old are you ?

You live outside Manhattan and take the subway

like

You should be asking how many people are they splitting the rent with

like

My husband and I pay $2500 for a 1 BR condo in upper UWS. There are still many reasonable options out there in Manhattan, you just need to search or be willing to commute 20 min by train….

like

You have to be making a minimum of 40x monthly rent in order to afford it and that’s the benchmark most landlords use

like

Pre war building in Astoria. 1bd 700 sq feet for 1800. Lived in Woodside and sunnyside too. Plenty of pretentious transplants think Manhattan is the only "real" NYC experience but I can get anything I want here between Broadway and 30th ave. Plus Steinway is a great strip for nightlife.

*In before some silver spoon fed transplant says "cope"

like

My partner and I got a nice Covid deal with our place but it’s up to 4K a month now& will be at least 5k next lease term. We make 170-180 combined plus his parents help out occasionally and I still struggle to save. We won’t be able to afford to resign the lease and will probably relocate from the city then.

350k between me and fiancé

Combined income - $310k

200 something

Wife and I combo make $250 base. But we pay about $3.4K for a 3br. Have a great landlord

You can definitely get a nice one bedroom for less than $3K.

We pay 3,600 for a massive 1 BR in pre war building midtown east. Bathroom and kitchen are extremely old and nothing is new, but it’s amazing. Praying it doesn’t go past 4,000 when we renew. We make about 325K combined.

Related Posts

Based on the Gross salary offered I have calculated the in hand salary per month would be around 152000 considering 150000 in 80C, 50000 in NPS and 200000 deductions due to home loan interest. Total tax liability is around 400000. Any other options do I have to save tax further (other than HRA, LTA)? Thanks in advance.

Post Photo
like

Is retail quant trading on a massive rise?

likehelpful

Is it mandatory to submit previous employment declaration while submitting Income tax declaration. Or we can just skip this. Since this is my 2 nd company not aware of this much. What happens at the end of financial year if we don't declare previous employment declaration. Seniors kindly help🙏

Clever ways to get cheaper housing? What's your hack to beat the system?

Married, 2 kids under 3 yrs. Apartment is too small, but we can't afford bigger. Do we rent a 2-story house and split it with another family? Do we stay in our small apartment and get creative with bunk beds and storage solutions?

How can a family, with kids, and one crappy income ($82,000) get a comfortable living situation here?

like

Does it make sense to buy a 50,000 dollar car if your yearly package before tax is 120,000?
I have 100K in savings and want to buy in cash, to avoid monthly payments. Appreciate any mentorship or advice.

Why have cryptos crashed so much since yesterday eve?

like

Guide to mining ETH

Hey guys, Can anyone please tell me if there is any restrictions on SPI in mutual funds in MS for employees.

like

Regarding purchasing coins is it better to swap BTC/Coin or BTC-> USDT ->Coin

like

Want to buy a house in bay area? Is this a good time? Thoughts?

like

How's Manor as a city in terms of buying a single-family home: school-wise, future price appreciation of houses etc ..?

like

Anybody have insight into Winston & Strawn real estate in dallas? Do they pay market? Is it a sweatshop? Any info would help. Thanks!

like

What is the best-kept secret among realtors?

like

Sad that I missed out on this deal 😭 brand new & tax free

Post Photo
like

Starting apartment hunting in NYC soon. Any tips and recommendations for studios & 1 bedrooms in the city in terms of price range, ROI, neighborhood, down payment, best time to invest etc.

Folks - please share your thoughts on True Wind Capital.

What’s the fastest WI-FI provider in Austin? I have Spectrum abs it’s not fast enough for my house of 5

like

What are some personal finance actions that, if needed, must be done by end of year? Let's try to make a checklist!

Tax loss harvesting

Retirement accounts for 2022: can contribute or withdraw over-contributions until April 18, 2023 IIRC

HSA: same as retirement accounts

...?

like

Why are properties in NYC so damn expensive? At this point should I just move elsewhere?

like

More Posts

It means ICOs are no longer open to anyone. You have to be a certified investor with the SEC. This is why Filecoin is conducting their ICO with CoinList instead of on their own. CoinList ensures their ICO is only open to certified Wall Street investors and makes sure FileCoin's ICO is treated as a normal IPO.

Granted please correct me because IPO investing is something I don't know a ton about.

like

Thoughts on R129 SL500? I’m debating about buying one for post Covid summer. For mid 20s they seem like a steal.

like

What is the courtesy of withdrawing an offer you already accepted?

Hey guys, who are joining tomorrow from hyderabad campus?

like

BGC becoming strict in all companies these days

Post Photo
like
like

Is anyone’s wfh office chair getting less “springy” over time? Mine just doesn’t have the same umph it had before, constantly lowering throughout the day.

like

A little late here, but any suggestions/recommendations or watch outs for an automatic standing desk preferably with charging attachments? Looking to invest in a decent one around $2-300 !

like

Anyone have fee based fiduciary financial advisors they’d recommend? TIA!

like

From 180k full time to 200k and 10 percent sweat equity in a boutique consulting firm as their cto, to kickstart their AWS practice .. any thoughts. This new company does not have any product thinking or strategy and full lifecycle cloud delivery pedigree yet ..

like

Hello,

I have 3.5 years of experience in customer service and I am looking for a change, preferably non voice, please let me know in comments if there are any referrals.

like

Hiii Fishies, can you please help me?

Hello fishes,
I am actively looking for a change. please let me know if there is any opportunity for me.
Thanks
Tech Stack: node js, git, angular, javascript, sql, mongodb
YOE : 2.7 years
Last working day: 26 th August

like

Accenture MDs - if you participate in VEIP, what is your % invest going into CY19? I really want to do the full 30% but as a new MD, but curious to hear others thought process / logic.

like

Do you feel like Latinos are being left out of the discussion or overlooked as more companies commit to anti-racism and inclusion efforts?

likesmart

Which one to join GSK(X+3 bonus + 1 JB) as Data Engineer or Fujitsu consulting (x+3) fixed as System Architect??

like
like

One of my friends has been given a choice, to work with an extremely outrageous target or to leave the firm. If he chooses to stay, he will be bound to serve a total time of 6 months. And if he refuses, tomorrow will be his last day, what can I suggest to him?

It's a critical decision and he is overwhelmed by this sudden obstacle. Any leads would be helpful.

like

How's your side hustle game as the world "goes back to normal"?

Additional Posts in New York City

Looking for someone to take over my lease on the UES in Dec. 1bd, renovated kitchen, well maintained and quiet with super on site. The best part: only $2175. 1.5 blocks from the Q. DM for pics.

like

We are two males in our mid 20s looking for a clean and respectful 3rd roommate to sign a new lease for a 3-bedroom apartment in LES starting 9/1. It is close to several restaurants, bars, grocery stores and the building is a luxury building with several amenities. Trader Joe’s is a 5 min walk and the subway is right by the building. The room we are looking to fill will be priced at 2050. You will be sharing the bathroom with one person only.

like

Where did you meet your significant other in the city? Looking for ideas to meet new people!

likehelpful

Is Hell's Kitchen a bad area to live? If so why

like

Anyone joined top social clubs (i.e. Zero Bond, Norwood, Metropolitan)? Why were you accepted in & did it meet your expectations?

like

Tips for questions to ask or things to check to make sure an apartment is pest free or doesn't have other issues not readily evident when apartment hunting?

like

Has anyone’s landlord ask to come and take picture of your apartment for their insurance? Shouldn’t this be done before someone moves in?

like

Hey all, moving to the city in Feb. Pros and cons about living in west village?

like

it’s disgusting to see in this city how people pay more attention to the dogs homeless people have than the people themselves - it’s dehumanizing and makes me sick when people give a strained smile to the homeless person while patting their pup like come on

like

This is a bit specific of a Q, but has anyone here gone to an ED treatment center in NY? Which one/Did you find it helpful?

like

Best website or realtor o company or way to find and buy a condo in NYC(Queens, Bronx or Manhattan), 2-3 bedroom.

like

Is there anything inherently sketchy about an apartment with a mandatory lease term of over a year (eg 15 or 18 months)? I assume they just want to lock us down for longer, but committing to a place for that long is a little daunting

like

Do I have to bring proof of my medical condition to my covid vaccine appointment? Just wondering if they give you any trouble.

like

Good gyms (besides equinox) that aren’t crowded/small?
Debating between Blink or Crunch, any preferences?

like

Looking for a therapist, ideally in person, lower Manhattan and CIGNA. Any recommendations?

like

Anybody get a hair transplant in nyc and could recommend their doctor? Also would you recommend the procedure and going through the process (i.e., FUE vs FUT vs Bald)?

Also what was the recovery like? Nervous to look even worse as it grows back coming into the office. How much PTO did you take?

Asking for a friend ofc!

like

Has anyone had roommates who got sick with Covid and they managed to not catch it from them? If so, what precautions did you take? We have a good relationship and so far he’s been staying in his room and using a mask whenever he needs to use the restroom or grab water from the kitchen. I am the only one who touches the fridge and takes his food out so he can eat. What else can we really do?

like

Is a New York Sports Club Elite Membership worth it?

like

How do I cancel my New York Sports Club membership?

likefunny

Hi NYC female fish! Room available in our apt for 12-month sublet beginning 8/1. Midtown east (57/3) in doorman elevator laundry building, $1350 monthly rent. PM me if interested!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal