Just curious How do people afford apartments in the city with avg rents of $5000? What kind of income are y’all making?

likeuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I think it comes down to poor judgment for most of the people spending $5k/month to rent a small NYC apartment. My husband and I could easily afford that (our home mortgage is $1k higher) but it's such a huge waste of money when there are alternatives like commuting from NJ, LI, or further out in Brooklyn/Queens. I know many people want to live right in the heart of it all, but at such a huge cost it ends up eating away your disposable income, and then can you really enjoy being in the heart of it all anyway? I guess for people making like $1m a year who don't plan to stay in the city forever it's fine to spend so much in rent but for others who want to be able to save and not feel like they have to sacrifice in every other aspect of their lifestyle, it's just poor judgment to spend so much on rent.

likefunnysmarthelpful

There’s decent 1brs in Manhattan between 3-4k. Just be willing to climb stairs.

I agree with this sentiment. Too many folks spending their income on rent. I try to abide by the 30% rule even in NYC when most people use the 40x income rule which is about half your take home. By that logic my partner and I can rent a 7-8k a month apartment but instead our rent is 3200 and we split that so 1600 and use the rest to invest, travel and nice dinners each month.

Why live in Manhattan if you can’t enjoy it stress free?

I do expect my rent to go up at renewal which is December but it’s a while away so let’s see. Fingers crossed the market cools

like

I make $350k/year….I pay $3800/month in Manhattan for a 3 bed 2 bath. When I moved to Manhattan 9 years ago, I made $70k and paid $2300/month for a 2 bed 1 bath. Supported my wife and two kids on that salary….it’s a grind, but the opportunity is worth it for those willing to grind it out.

likeupliftinghelpfulfunny

I’m UES and hired a broker. Worth every penny.

Recent IconRecent

We’re like $800k - $850k and do $7250 for a 2br luxury building in LES. I’d like to be cheaper but am making my wife happy and she doesn’t feel comfortable in a non-doorman building. Buying the equivalent apartment is even more of a rip off, so we’re continuing to do this.

like

Nice! Never buy an apartment not worth it!

Sharing a one bedroom in an old walk up with my boyfriend. Rent is 2500/2=1250pp

like

Same here too!

Wife and I pay $4k/month for our 1 bedroom ($380k HHI) - we’re moving out though as we want more space.

like

HHI- 390k. Both 27. We got a COVID deal paying 3K for a large 1 bedroom in midtown. Raised rent to 4.7K, we left to Jersey city and pay 3K for a large 1 bedroom in a luxury building with every amenity you can think of. Also we save money on no NYC income tax.

like

Once you hit a certain income level, that extra 3.8%-4% not going to the city tax adds up!

like

I live 2 hours away and pay 1k lol

like

Staten Island? Pete, is that you? How’s Kim!😂

funny

Keep in mind the median income in Manhattan it’s about 60,000 and the per capita income in New York City is a lot lower. 20% of New York City lives at or below the poverty line.

like

OW you know a lot of 22–44 work normal hourly jobs in stores and restaurants or blue collar. 50-60k is avg.

200

like

A year? Wow

I pay 4100 split 2800/1300 between me and my girlfriend. We got lucky, our apt is now renting for 4800.

like

I make 170 she makes 120 but she has law school loans

likefunny

50k ~ 4 flatmates

like

With how expensive everything is, we could probably share a room. Hah

like

The 5k rent is not necessarily for an individual, it can be for a family where both family members are earning. We have a 7 year old and ensuring we have short commute is a trade off we have to the crazy rent we pay.

like

I ate ramen and paper all day

like

Look past the headline if you want to get anywhere in life. $5000 is the mean which is dragged up by luxury buildings. The median is $4000 and that’s including apartments with > 1 bedroom. Also you don’t have to live in pricy lower Manhattan. I hope you can guess where this is going.

like

BF and I make 310k combined base salary and pay $3900 for a 2 bed (one is used as an office) and terrace space on the UES. For me this was the max I’d want to pay and still hit my savings goals and travel

likesmart

I pay 2600

like

Flex bedrooms

like

Last apt was a 2 bed flexed to 4 people. New apt is a 1 bed flexed to 2 people. Moving up in the world!!

like

We are old and we make slightly more $. If you are 23, you certainly aren’t here for the “affordable apartments”, it’s likely you will make double in 5 years and voila

like

Roommates! I make 120k and share a 3BR on UES w/ 2 friends, rent comes to $1.3k and I have automatic friends to hang out with. Economies of scale

like

5k for 1b with roommate. Can’t really afford it tbh

like

1BR with roommate?

Related Posts

Heard a lot of people saying the rental market was going to get better/ keep going up, but now it's cooling down. What is causing it to cool down so much?

like
like

I’m seeing lots of posts about really bad losses. If you trade you’re going to lose money - hopefully not all the time, but many positions will be mistakes. But you need a process to find ideas and manage positions. Two books you should read are “The New Trading for a Livinng” and “The Laws of Trading.” Both look at psychology, process, and risk in different ways that can help you work out your own process. The next 18 months will be much harder than the last 18 - time to start learning.

likehelpful

Is a 900k net worth for a single person at almost 40 good or terrible? I see posts from our US counterparts on net worth and salary and feel so behind yet we have such a high COL in Toronto.

like

Does anyone know a Shariah compliant mutual fund that won't violate Independence policies?

What is personal independence??
Why Pwc asked me to fill all investment details for me and my dependant.
Can anyone please help me on this ??

@pwc

like

If I had a realized capital loss in stock last year can I use that to neutralize any realized crypto gains this year ?

TRON correction anytime soon or buy at .20?

like

Is it technically possible for a realtor to both represent buyer and seller and earn from both ends?

Hi, amateur question. Is there any difference tax wise on letting an option expire vs sell for nothing? I assume both are tax losses that you can compensate with gains in other options right? TIA

like

Angel investors invest at the most risky time & take exit at the most lucrative time

That’s why they’re called angels, but why is it VC with the GOD complex.

like

What are some personal finance actions that, if needed, must be done by end of year? Let's try to make a checklist!

Tax loss harvesting

Retirement accounts for 2022: can contribute or withdraw over-contributions until April 18, 2023 IIRC

HSA: same as retirement accounts

...?

like

Where to buy a 3 bed flat in London on a budget of £500-600k for max growth opportunities in the future? ~1000sqft, (share of freehold) or long lease, close to Crossrail. Or is it best to wait it out?

Does Donald Trump's evasion about releasing his tax returns bother you?

like

People worrying today should read books on trading psychology! Not being patronizing- it will help you in the future, not just for investments but for doing better in life!

like

[US FBI: Cryptocurrency ATMs are becoming the main tool of investment scammers]

In addition to conventional payment methods such as wire transfers and prepaid cards, cryptocurrency ATMs are also becoming a major tool for cryptocurrency investment scammers, according to the FBI

Post Photo
like

Want to start saving/investing from this year. Got £11K and will have £2K a month to invest - any recommendations? I don’t want to take crazy risks, somewhere where this is steady long term growth. Have already maxed out pension and I assume next step is maxing out ISA? After that, what is best? (From UK)

like

What percentage of your income do you save, invest and spend?

like

Hi IBMers,
Do we need to mandatorily submit the rental agreement, rental proofs and landlord's PAN to claim HRA for any amount?
Please help me with your suggestions. Thanks in advance 😊

like

What would be a reasonable cost of renting for a single expat dude in Singapore living in decent area ? Would sgd 4K suffice ?

like

More Posts

MBA admit here and have to put down a deposit soon, having serious cold feet right now due to the covid situation and potentially having to start virtually. Would love any perspective on how it's been particularly socially and what your schools' outlook on the fall is

like

Any international transfer suffering from ACCA?

like

Just over 6 years in B4 financial services tax in PNW area. Mostly doing compliance work pumping out K1s and returns. Just got an industry offer at 155k 15% bonus and 100k equity (4year vesting). Fully remote position with occasional travel. Should I accept? I know it's a long shot but deep down I always had an ambition to pursue PA to see if I can make a partner. Please share your experience.

like

Hi all, has anyone temporarily transferred to the Canadian office of their firm and done the Canadian PR application while they were there on work visa?

like

Hi Fishes,

Could you please help me with with below scenario :
My YOE is 4.3 and ctc is 13 lpa. I am currently nominated for H1B 2023 and my petition is pending with USCIS for approval after lottery. I have heard H1B process could take months to complete. Should I waiting for the H1B or make a swtich? Is it worth waiting for H1B and how much saving one can make per month if traveling to US?

Kindly share your thoughts

IBM Infosys Wipro Amazon TCS Cognizant
Capegemini Accenture PwC KPMG EY

like

Asking for a friend:
My friend received two job offers for Account Executive roles: a Mid-Market role with Confluent and an Enterprise role with ThoughtSpot. He’s conflicted because Confluent is a more established company, ThoughtSpot is Pre-IPO. Confluent is a lucrative product to sell and has established SDR reps so there’s a good blend of inbound and outbound sales. Thoughtspot is more of a startup culture where most of the sales comes from outbound and it’s a tougher sell.

like

R.I.P. Takeoff, such a shame to lose a great artist to senseless gun violence. So young too…

like

Hi Folks,
Need your urgent help!!

Need your valuable suggestion on the below.
I Have 2 offers
TIAA:28LPA(fixed) +2L JB
SS&C(DST) :33LPA(fixed) +1JB
I have already accepted offer from TIAA and have received the Onboarding link. Will it be okay to renegotiate the CTC now by providing a counter offer.
Also,Do you know of any instance , when TIAA has declined the JB post joining.

Hi guys,
Going to my first 49ers game this weekend and was wondering what do you guys recommend for pre game, Tailgate in the parking lot? Or how early could I go have a couple beers in the bars by the gates. Thanks!

like

Any tips for moving up in a medium/large-sized legal department, aside from switching companies? I work in a collegial environment with plenty of opportunities to create more value, but the management level is fairly crowded and it seems the clearest path to get one of those roles is to be hired into it. What has been your experience? Thanks!

like

Looking for recommendations in the VA or DMV area for small biz:
1. Attorney 2. SBA banker 3.Accountant

like

Hii guys, need 11 likes to dm. 😊 Thanks

like

I feel special.

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Any one moved from mid tier cpa firm to a 65 lawyer law firm?

What's the safest area to live in Dallas as a young, single female?

like

Does anyone have experience taking the Marketing Management and Digital Strategy Graduate Certificate at Harvard Extension School or other certificate? Thoughts?

like

I have 400 CRS score and I don't see it increasing much. Is it advisable to move to Canada on ICtransfer. Not sure if i will hit PNP. Have EB2-2015 priority date in USA. Already in USA from last 10 years? Appreciate any comments.

like

Onboarding new member today. He is a PhD so has lots of theoretical knowledge but knows nothing about the business at large. Any suggested reading materials I can forward to him to help ramp up?

like

Additional Posts in New York City

it’s disgusting to see in this city how people pay more attention to the dogs homeless people have than the people themselves - it’s dehumanizing and makes me sick when people give a strained smile to the homeless person while patting their pup like come on

like

For the NJ folks who work in NYC - my potential new employer has offices in both NJ and NYC. The NJ office is a 1.5 hour drive vs. NYC ~40 min commute via train. Still very much hybrid work arrangement. Given the option, which office would you prefer to be based out of and why? Mostly asking from a tax perspective. While I believe it’ll even out when filing, I’d be paying state tax in both states throughout the year, right?

like

Is Hell's Kitchen a bad area to live? If so why

like

Hey all, moving to the city in Feb. Pros and cons about living in west village?

like

Any Visual Designer's looking for a new job opportunity?
Contract or Contract to hire
Remote

Need to be a able to work in the USA

How much do you typically spend on groceries each week?

like

Recs for golf lessons? Once things are open of course.

like

This is a bit specific of a Q, but has anyone here gone to an ED treatment center in NY? Which one/Did you find it helpful?

like

Anyone have experience with rentopia for Brooklyn listings? They seem to control most listings in the area I’m looking and are very unresponsive

like

Looking for freelance writing opportunities for small businesses or bloggers who need additional support. I currently work in healthcare PR and have extensive experience with ghost writing for senior executive teams on a wide range of topics including healthcare and business. Will send examples of work if anyone is interested.

like

What is everyone’s take on the NYC housing market? More people and businesses are moving out. I’d imagine it has to continue to dip. Also, they’re considering turning adding more units by converting commercial space into residential space. Inventory is going to be through the roof for rentals. I’d think that has to ultimately impact home prices.

like

For those who have most of their money invested, when a building wants to see your bank statements for a new lease, can you show them that your money is elsewhere?

like

Anyone in NYC have GMAT books they want to give away? Applying this coming year.

like

I’m currently in a 1BR for $2400. Am I crazy to pay $3k for a studio in a much nicer building in the same area? My current building is trash and I realized having an updated kitchen, bathroom, and laundry room would be really nice, but not sure if it’s worth the price tag vs finding another place at $2500ish. I’ll be local for the foreseeable future even post-COVID

like

Anyone live in the Ventura building on the UES? Thoughts?

like

Are bars now open later in the city? Saw people still hanging out at places after midnight, on my way back from a friend's. Curious what the deal is

like

Salary vs rent poll: Salary / Monthly Rent / Living Situation (roommates, apt type, borough?)

like

any suggestions on where to rent? preferably manhattan downtown or midtown. budget is ~2.1k or so. priorities are having a doorman, elevator, laundry in building at the very least

like

Has anyone’s landlord ask to come and take picture of your apartment for their insurance? Shouldn’t this be done before someone moves in?

like

How do I cancel my New York Sports Club membership?

likefunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal