Just resigned but received a counter offer from my current job with matching salary and title increase, leaving me stumped about what to do. Curious on thoughts about taking a counter offer?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

if you considered leaving the first time around, it'll happen again in 2 months when the excitement of the raise and promotion go away.

like

I'm a big advocate for never accepting a counter. Your current job obviously values you (at least right now), but if there's ever a situation that comes into play where they need to make cuts they may look at you first since you had one foot out the door.

like

👆🏽Excellent point above. Since the offers are the same, think about which one excites you more and which one will advance your personal development and career goals.

like

Once you have one foot out the door everyone knows it and you are now tainted goods, IMO.

like

To play devil's advocate, why not stay for x more months and enjoy the extra money then jump for even more?

like

I've seen it play out all ways - I have coworkers who left for more money and came back. I have coworkers who stayed and regretted it. I have coworkers who left and it was the right call. I've seen coworkers take the counter and stay and been promoted multiple times since then. Sometimes the threat of leaving is needed to make things happen.

like

One item I would look at is what is your current job's motivation for the counter. Is it because they value you and want to keep you on the team or is it because your departure would cause a short term issue for them. If the latter, definitely move on. Otherwise the above wisdoms apply. Just always important to look at the other party's motivation.

like

If you're lucky enough to have money be the only reason you were leaving, maybe. But if you went through the whole process of interviewing and getting an offer from another place, seems like it's time to spread those wings.

like

If it's just about money, push your current job higher - and then if you find that whatever other issues are still at play down the line, interview and leave again (but for real real).

If you do go back though, consider whether the new place will be salty. Is it a place you really would like to work someday? Which position fits better with your longterm goals?

like

Yeah with even money in the table you can just choose the best work available, or best commute.

like

The devil you know...

like

Be honest with yourself about WHY you wanted to leave. Just money, ok. Other reasons, then you might be making a good ok fashioned chexklist

Never take the counter.

Related Posts

How is Capgemini in terms of job security and work culture?
How much CTC to expect from Capgemini with 10 years of experience in QA domain?
Capgemini

like
like

What's a product manager's expected salary with
Total YOE - 3.5 years (PM experience 2yrs)

like

Can a person just say that he cannot disclose his current salary while negotiating an offer and just mention his expected salary (which may be 2x current one) , because if the current salary is low ,the expected salary can't be too higher than current one ? Never seen such a case so just asking

like

Thinking of starting and Only Fans account for extra side money. Don’t know what it would be yet though. Sounds wild but my salary barely covers the cost of living and I’ve been living with school debt. Anyone have one on the side? Serious answers only please!

likesmart

I have 5 years of experience in 3D design & operations. I accepted the offer of 10L from Accenture to come on notice period (90 days). Now John Deere is offering 11.5L based upon Accenture office. Having global economic slowdown in consideration shall I take this offer? Accenture John Deere

like

What package does Zeta offer to freshers for Product Management role?
YOE :- 1 in MBB
Current role :- Data Analyst

Zeta suite Zeta

like

Anyone from the strategy & transaction team @EY-P willing to chat about culture, pay etc? Specifically for director position.

like

GSK is hiring aggressively for GCC. How much salary should i ask for a manager 8a designation? Will they give 30+?

🐠, I was laid off from industry during covid and started consulting this year, which was a step back in terms of level and salary. I have received an offer that would allow me to course-correct and advance past where I was before. I like my current firm and have put a lot of effort into making it my new home; however I don’t like my project and am stuck on it. I am terrified of making a move so soon into a role that isn’t a fit or worse, results in another layoff. Appreciate all perspective!

like

How should a structural engineer with 2 and a half years of experience be earning?

I’m a second year BigLaw associate that pays market. I was offered the position at a modified salary and hourly expectation due to their expected work flow needs. I’m wondering what is the best way to approach the topic of getting on the full salary/hours. Do I wait until the bonuses are given at the end of my first year? Or bring it up at mid-year review? I won’t have any problem meeting my hourly so I’m starting to think I’m being underpaid. I’ve been reading on here that not meeting

like

I am a Certified Pharmacy Technician, with 21 years of experience. I work at an independent pharmacy outside of Charlotte, NC. I make $18.75 an hour and had to fight/beg for that. I do not feel that I am being paid near enough for the work I do. I am wondering what others in the area make, so I can go back to my boss and ask for more. I am so fed up, I want to move on to something else, but I have no idea where to start.

like

family depends on me for money, i love helping them but only making 65k in HCOL, 1+ year experience, CPA. What career path/jobs should i aim to boost my salary? really only care about comp

like

The severance package at Meta for laid off employees almost makes it nice to be laid off depending on what your personal situation is….. personally wouldn’t mind getting 4+ months of full pay to reset and think about what’s next 😬

like

CapG Folks, What should be average CTC of C2 Manager grade at CapG in FS domain. Have received offer. YOE 3.8 CCTC 11.10

like

Hi fishes,
What's the bonus payout month for Deloitte India?
In case I resign before that but have completed one performance year will I get the bonus or not?
Kindly advise

like

What is the average % bonus of base in big AM firms? Have an offer and debating between that and another finance route that I know pays a large bonus if performing well

like

Pwc salary structure? Benefits

Urgent

like

Hi everyone,

I'm going for a role for Account Director and have gone through the interviews with the head of accounts, BD as well as the ECD's. I received the following email at the end of the day:

"You are one of two candidates in the final round.

One thing we haven’t spoken about are your salary expectations. Could you have a think and let me know early next week as well as your employment status (residency permit)."

What would be the best way to answer this response? Appreciate the help

like

More Posts

Hi fishes, Need help!!!!! Is gratuity deduction mandatory in Infosys from salary, if yes if leave the organisation after 1 year, are we eligible to receive the paid amount? Or only after 4 years we will receive? How one can opt out of gratuity???? Please suggest!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Infosys Infosys Limited

like

Cheers to the weekend!

Post Photo
like

Hello,

How is Kotak Mahindra Bank project of Wipro.......is work life balance maintained?

Please let me know...

Wipro

Kotak Mahindra Bank

like
like

Hi Fishes, Please help me choose which company to join on the basis of work culture and job security.

TCS -> 20 LPA

Mindtree -> 24.05 LPA

YOE -> 8 years 

Tech Stack -> Frontend (Angular)

CCTC -> 18.10 LPA

like

Whenever I open LinkedIn these days 🙃

Post Photo
likefunny

Can anyone please let me know the highest package for F grade in Operations Recon?

When’s the next CT 3 for $99 sale? Or a comparable quality/price point from another brand?

Realized I have a lot of blue shirts and need to add some more color to the rotation

like

I’m looking to go back to school for my bachelors in health administration but I have 3 kids and a full time job so I’m looking to do online classes, does anyone know if a online degree from SNHU is respected in healthcare at all

like

when exactly is the ey split happening??

like
like

Need referral, SAP consulting profile

How much does KPMG KGS offer for
Role: Consultant
Location: Pune
YOE: 9
Profile: BA, Financial Services Solutions

like

****KGS-FNF****
Hi, I have paid medical insurance premium of 27300 in the month of April 2022. My last working day was 17th October. I have talked with finance team, they told me I will get the 27300 rupees on FNF
Today I received mail from KPMG. On FNF , 27300 rupees in not included.

What should I do? Need your help guys!

like

What will be the effect of US recession on KGS?
What should we be ideally prepared for in worst case scenario

like

Any PPMDs who moved from the West open to chatting?

Looking for inspiration from real people versus youtubers..

Post a picture of your home office. Starting my first WFH job and I'm looking for ideas! Top accessories? 13x13 guest room is the desired location. TIA 😊

like

3 Things to keep in mind which changing jobs:
1. Always ask dedicated budget for the job before you tell your expectations.

2. Always have atleast 2 weeks of gap before you join any company. You might not understand significance of that but just have a gap.

3. Always talk to people of team you will be joining before you accept offer or atleast before you join company.

like

Looking for creative ways to generate demand for demos that don’t require big ad spend - any advice or tactics you’ve done to great success? (SaaS product in niche industry)

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Any recommendations for websites that will fax a word doc for free, without making me sign up for a membership?

like

I hate open floor plans!!! Give me back my office!!! It’s truly inefficient. I spend half the day trying to tune out the chaos around me and the other half trying to book a conference room!!

likefunnyupliftingsmart

Anyone know how to deal with a very cold and distant superior? I'm starting to feel a little ostracized and devalued by my manger.. Should this be something that I should be worrying about?

like

Need advice: how to turn this years Cannes shortlists into a job at good agency?

like

Fishbowl gentlemen, what are you wearing to your holiday party? 👔👗👙👘🎩

like

Why has Strategy & Creative turned into Crips & Bloods mentality? 🤔

likesmartfunny

Which agency has the best analytics department in your opinion?

like

Anyone have recruiter contact info for squarespace?

like

Anyone knows anything about Pathway Group (Omnicom)?

like
like

Has anyone heard of Corona cases within the industry? Nervous that WFH policies were implemented too late.

like

Does Havas has any tuition reimbursement programs? And has anyone done one?

like

Team size: Billings aside, how many account people, strategists, and creatives are on your teams?

like

How do you guys deal with that one person in the office who just makes very bad jokes that make you look bad, in front of the team? How do you get ahead of them? Tired, sad, annoyed, fed-up, etc.

like

Trying to get into a big, famous shop. But everything good dies at smaller shops in my town (not NY or LA) bc of the client or CDs that never made it. Feel like I’m stuck in a loop 🔄

like

What's the avarage salary for a Senior Art Director in Melbourne, Australia?

like

Hate to say it but uber is definitely in tune

Post Photo
likefunny

Does anyone know about the culture around the Walmart team at Publicis

like

I like the feeling of unfamiliarity especially when I'm abroad. Happy where I'm working at now (not US) & I'm considering to move elsewhere few years down the line. How did moving abroad affect you?

like

I haven't seen an AdAge or AdWeek news story about the work in over 6 months (sans Superbowl). All industry news is aquesitions or layoffs... Just me?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal