Received an offer for an EA position for $57k. I informed the company I would like $80k-$90k and they came back and offered $80k (+ bonuses, profit sharing 401k). Now my current company wants 24 hours to counter, I was paid $66k and recently got a raise to $72k but now they will minimally have to offer $90k+ for me to even consider staying.

Should I set sail for new horizons ? Should I counter again with the new company or is that greedy considering how far they came up? EA is a new position.

likehelpfulsmartuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

There is a reason that most people who accept counter offers still end up leaving within a few months; because money alone is usually not the only factor that causes people to look. If they could have been paying you $12k+ more for a year or more before you sought another offer elsewhere, then you know that they don't value you or they would have paid you more sooner.

Take the new offer. Congrats and good luck!

likehelpfulsmart

Agreed, one of my regrets to be completely honest. I walked into my boss’s office told him that I was quitting. Got a better job offer across the street. He stood up, walked across the room, closed the door and said how much money is it gonna take to keep you here. I gave him the number he didn’t even flinch. He gave it to me. Then the next six months was pretty miserable. I got more money, but still hated the culture the structure the environment and then ended up quitting six months later. I should’ve just accepted the job, stuck to my guns and left. By staying I missed a great opportunity to join a great company. 

like

As someone who worked in recruitment, taking a counter offer is never good.

likehelpfulsmart

Why be loyal to a company that could RIF a person, maybes give the person 15 min to get their stuff and escort them to their car or the property gate to ensure they leave. If two weeks notice is the minimum professional standards for employees, why aren’t large company’s held to the same standard.
My last company did give me two weeks, but I’ve seen the same company pop a surprise HR meeting and the person barely got time to get their personal stuff, and it wasn’t for cause.

like
Recent IconRecent

Set sail, me hearty! On a serious note, never take a counter offer. At best, your company will resent you for having coerced them into paying you and you will be treated differently. At worst, your company will think they bought your soul and expect you to "go beyond, go the extra mile, live eat and breathe the company culture" and other unresonable expectations.

Never stay with a company that counteroffers just to keep you… It’s a temporary loss to them while they find a cheaper replacement for you before finding some reason to fire or lay you off. You have a great offer on the table, it’s time to part ways with your current company while you are still on good terms. Remember, there was obviously a reason why you were looking for a new job anyway!

Sail away, sail away, sail away! Even if they come in at $90k there will be hard feelings, a larger workload, and a target on your back at the current employer because they only value you at $72k. Take the extra $8k and pay off any debt higher than 5% and invest the rest in retirement, HSA, 529 for kids or whatever else and move on up!

Congrats on your new adventure! Good Choice!

I would accept the new offer. They are only countering because you have decided to go elsewhere. They should have given you a better increase to show your worth; they did not. Accept your new offer and best wishes for the future.

Don't get emotionally tangled to accept the increment in the current role. They've already lost trust and now they are wary of your moves more than before. They'll likely be on the look out for replacements who are probably entry level and whom they know will stick and continue to do the same with the new replacement for a few years (give them crumbs or less than) until they look for greener pastures and the cycle repeats.
New start is good anyways because you get to look through a fresh perspective. New people, new experiences these will likely enrich your life.

Good on ya dude! I countered a 47k offer at 60k, stating my last 2 roles were 67 and 75, and they rescinded 8 days later, Your post restored some lost confidence in my self perceived worth. Have fun with the games, sounds like a sweet gig.

If your reason was for salaries to quit for me, stay with your current company.
But, if the reason to find a new job was to join a new company to learn a new culture and learn new knowledge, take a new EA position offer. $80k (+ bonuses, profit sharing 401k).

If this negotiation went high that fast might be a scam ? Or something is wrong in this new organization. What is the industry average? Why does your current employer even know you got this offer and why do they care that you make a bigger bid ? Wouldn't they want you to stay? so many questions and red flags be careful. - Fashion and Beauty CEO

If this negotiation went high that fast might be a scam ? Or something is wrong in this new organization. What is the industry average? Why does your current employer even know you got this offer and why do they care that you make a bigger bid ? Wouldn't they want you to stay? so many questions and red flags be careful. - Fashion and Beauty CEO

It seems the company that you are with now knows that you know your true worth and the devil that you know is better than the one you don't. You never know if the new company will keep up to with their commitment. But I can definitely see the attraction to a new company that shows you value by increasing your pay. You also have to remember that they would have paid you $57k if you said nothing and taken advantage of you as well. Can you trust them? Doing some research on the new company would be smart.

Hello Friend , Is there any job available at your workplace ?

They should have compensated you properly for your job BEFORE you felt the need to look. Happy people don't look for new jobs. Not in this economy. The new employer listened to what you needed. They could have said no. You are worth it!

Hi Missy Barber,
I dissagree with your "happy people arguement"
No one should expect a soulless multinational corporation to be a source of their happiness.
Everyone at certain points in their period of employment conduct an evaluation of their employer. It's always the smart to look at what your alternatives are & reevaluate what your value is to your current employer. Being happy or not is irrelevant.

I worked in a petrochemical environment as a controls engineer/ IEC lead. The competing Refinery in the Midwest offered a 15% increase in a comparable position plus relocation. I accepted the competing Refinery offer and notified my engineering manager.. Within one hour I was informed that after a conversation with Refinery management, they informed my boss that the refinery had a standing policy of exceeding the competition's offers rather than lose employees to the competition. Management egos' at the top drove this policy. I ended up staying even after refinery offering the position upped the final salary offer. As an employee, all you really have is your negotiating power especially after you have honed your skill set..

Counter offers are what they will reluctantly pay you while looking for a replacement, now that they have been alerted to the fact that you have been looking for new opportunities.
i.e. counter-offers are usually not a good medium-term or long-term idea.

Hello my friends ... how can I get a commis chef

Okay if the company low ball at the beginning and then they increase it by almost 30K more, don't know but it seems the hiring manager, to be a volatile one, guess the raise in the current position is a safer choice

Totally agree . Bigger and better. Move on!

If you never asked your first company for a raise to begin wiht then I would let your current company counter. As long as you are happy there.

I'm interested in remote work opportunities like this. Are there any open roles or hiring processes i could check out

Related Posts

Hi fishes,

My CTC is around 12 lpa per annum. How can i avail max tax benefits?

like

Looking for referral in JP Morgan for credit analyst role . Location Mumbai/Bangalore preferable@jpmorgan

like

LTI-Larsen & Toubro Hiring Drive on 1st OCT.
DM your Email id with Jobid to Get registered.

Post Photo

How steep is the drop off in terms of VC comp, prestige, etc. if you’re not at one of the top firms?

like

Have been looking for accounting advisory jobs and can’t seem to find any. Are firms hiring again?

like

Anybody here who gave interview for senior business analyst role in IQVIA?

like
like

Can all technicians share if you're registered or certified and how much you're currently making? (Hospital, retail, independent, etc.) I'm transferring from retail where I'm underpaid to a Hospital trainee position and I don't know the pay range or what I should ask for. I'm registered already and this position requires it within 1yr. But I applied because I don't have Hospital experience. I want my compensation to reflect I'm already registered.

like

What are you hoping to exit into post consulting? Looking for ideas because nothing is catching my interest 🙁

likehelpful

Accenture India Lately there are so many hr openings with Accenture in almost all portals naukri, indeed, monster, linked in etc but there is not a single response infact I have the cc number wherein status is reflecting as hr will contact you ..but I have not received any revert, tried emailing the hr through a reference got an auto email stating out of office nd shared his contact number to connect, when tried calling hr,he was annoyed but I guess he forgot that he himself has shared the number. Accenture Ind

like

Hi All,

I am looking for a job in automobile after sales position. Please help me/refer me for any opportunity.

I have experience of 9 years in handling after sales operations.

like

Hi folks

Wanted to know growth and opportunities in Novartis Consultant role I have a offer from
Novartis for Consultant role - ctc - 24.2 + 70k joining bonus
And have another offer from Amazon for Program Manager fixed- 28 lac + 1 rsu (3.5 lac every year) + 1.5 relocation bonus.

Need some thoughts on which one to join.

Thanks in advance

like

Hi Fishes,
I've been offered for Engineering expert position at Novartis India. I've received offer letter 2 weeks back and my DOJ is updated to Mid December. I told the HR that my current company's last working day is on mid January and resend the offer letter with mid Jan as my DOJ. But they told that they can send the revised offer letter 3 weeks before the joining date.
Is this normal process? Has anyone gone through similar experience?

like

Would anyone in a product analyst role at Visa or senior product role be open to chatting? Looking to pivot into payments industry from financial services and would love to get a better sense of product

like

Weighing whether another year of IB experience would be helpful, or would just make me one year older at the same starting point in PE.
I’m 1.5 years out of college as an analyst at a middle market bank within the healthcare M&A group. Getting worked a lot but starting to operate as an associate on deals. Debating accepting an offer for a newer, lower-MM healthcare and growth focused PE firm. I know I want to go to PE at some point, but what are some thoughts on when you should go?

like

HCOL audit SM looking to leave big 4. What should be my comp expectation?

like

Hello everyone,
Can someone please give me referral at
Cognizant , Due to money flow issue my present company is downsizing and they are forcing me to resign otherwise they will fire me .
So someone please me for this Job ID: 00041450002.
Cognizant

like

Senior Program Manager / Director looking for EU based remote work. Planning to relocate back to the EU on a permanent basis in the next 4-6 months. Open to work & would appreciate any kind of referral!

like
like

More Posts

Can some of you experienced folk recommend some good books for rookies? What are your favorites for investment strategies, marketing, selling, etc.?

like

Good morning Saints, Happy Sunday!

I wonder if we still have people who believe in God’s promises and love God as the WORD tells us” I find in David a man after my own heart” 1 Samuel 13:14! How can we incorporate this love into our school we work for? Isn’t our voice enough?

like

Best places to stay in Newport, Rhode Island? Planning on going for Memorial Day weekend.

like

Hi guys,

How if Capgemini Invent? Is it a different company or SL? How are the projects and opportunities?

like

EY GDS vs DELOITTE INDIA..?

Which one is better in terms of wlb, hike, career growth and job security.

like

Is it worth joining Accenture Strategy as a Consultant (L9) with 6 YoE? How is the quality of projects ? What is work life balance like? How about base salary, bonus, perks?

like

600sqft 1 bedroom in kips bay, $1800 (walk-up, no laundry in building, no doorman) for year lease

Would be moving from 6th floor walk up $1400 month to month in prime LES with two roommates(not my best friends but nice).

Would you move?

Considering:
1. costs to make the move itself
2. I like to run so options downtown seem better but not familiar with kips Bay Area
3. Commuting anywhere
4. Restaurants
5. I’m 23

like
likeuplifting

Incoming!

Rolex 116234 Datejust 36 with fluted bezel, jubilee, silver dial, and LNIB (note: not my photo).

Post Photo
like

acd: “would you do meth everyday for a year for ten million dollars? you'd be able to choose where you rehab for free and —”

ad: “i’d do it for one million”

likefunny

I did one interview yesterday with flipkart but still they didn't invited me for second interview.
What shall I assume about my result ?
Meanwhile I got interview call from CSS Corp , shall I start attending other interviews?

like

I currently have an offer from both IBM and TCS for database developer role. IBM's package is a slightly less than what TCS has offered. While my plan is to join TCS but i have no clue about what project/account i will be onboarded to. I am very much comfortable in my current organization and they have agreed to match the IBM offer. Hence, i am slightly confused.

Is there any way HR or recruiting partner at TCS can give the details around my project? Im left with 40 days of notice period.

like

Can anyone shed some light on quant funds please? https://groww.in/mutual-funds/escorts-tax-plan-direct-growth
I am seeing stellar returns and extremely low expense ratios but apparently since they're quantitatively managed algorithms, they don't account for things like corona for example.

like

Guys, I had very less HRA for April 2022 till August 2022. I was showing 1 lac annual rent .I joined new organisation in sept and now HRA is 43000 per month. Would that be okay to show high rent as 30000 per month to my wife as landlord. Earlier I was paying 9000 rs per month to different landlord. @ IBM

like

Is there such thing as a true account role at major branding agencies? Ex. Interbrand, Landor, Pentagram...Sounds like in many cases it’s actually just PM under a different name.

like

Anyone from Havas London here? If so, what are your biggest dislikes about the agency?

like

Anyone nearby Barclays kharadi?

like

Hi, how much should I ask for ontario
Yoe : 10 years
Desig: test automation lead
Any suggestions or pointers to basic expenses(insurance, tax, accomodation) are welcome.

like

Hi there. What is considered a good salary for a project manager?

like

Additional Posts in Salary Negotiations

I'm working in the US under H1B, I got a chance to face an interview for another company. My current company started the PERM application also and results will be out within the next 3 months. Is it okay to transfer my H1B to a new company? Can my H1B transfer be denied? How long will my green card application delay if I move to a new company and start to apply for a green card from scratch?

like

How realistic is it to land an AD position as a fresh grad (with a doctorates) and a handful of pharma & FDA interships? Context: I'll have over a year of (consistent) work experience at a large pharma company and I have prior leadership/mgt experience (< 10 yrs) in a gov't role prior to changing careers and pursuing a doctorates.

Also, whats the pay difference between Sr Manager and AD at a large pharma company? TIA!

like

Hello everyone I worked as a house remodeler before I got Covid now I am handyman/maintenance/property manager I would like an idea of what people are charging

Looking to understand the salary range for an executive level/managing account director at a large advertising agency.

like

I have a friend moving to North Carolina in a few months. Does anyone know what the salary range is for a Commercial Banker job grade 10 at Fifth Third?

like

Any Hazmat drivers here? Just curious on the going salary for CDL A hazmat driver. Home just about every day. Off weekends. Any info would be appreciated.

like

For expert witnesses/lawyers

I’m a former forensic scientist that left the field several years ago. I recently received a subpoena from a case I worked and suggested to DA to have evidence re-worked by the lab or stipulation. If I am required to testify (as an expert witness), I would need to book a flight, hotel, etc. My question is this: can I ask for my requested hourly rate, travel, and hotel to be covered when speaking with DA or is that “not how this works” as the investigator put it?

like

Anyone ever pay for a prep service for an interview with Amazon or any other FAANGs for a non tech role?

like

I’m interviewing for a marketing manager role at a company based in SF. I’m genuinely excited about the role and the company but we’ve yet to discuss salary. I expect to be asked at some point, but my research has given me a VERY broad range. So I’m here to do a bit more research. I’ve got 5 very relevant years of experience and will have an associate manager directly reporting to me. Are there any marketers out there who can share their salaries in similar regions and experience levels?

like

Any HR pros able to explain the process for hiring US citizens to Canadian offices, and if that process is so onerous you would rather offer a much higher US salary to avoid it?

like

Program Manager Healthcare Foundation $85,000. Worth it? Or too low?

like

I'm new to all this. Is it best to save 10% of my salary all in my company's 401k (with 20% match, increasing by 5% every year)... or saving 5% in 401k and 5% in a Roth IRA?

like

Amazonians - curious to know what internal ops L5 and L6 make? Thanks in advanced!

like

Started a new job a year ago, high performer. My manager suggested a promotion to Product Manager since that‘s the work I’m doing, but that would be a 50% raise. Higher ups decided instead to make a “new role” (not PM), that has no analog in the company and is hard to price via Glassdoor, etc. I feel like this is to limit my promotion salary to something like 10% from where it currently is. Is there anything I can do? FWIW: I have a PhD from top 5 program and am working in that field. Thanks!

likehelpful

I’m interviewing with a startup and the range has a 40k difference from the lowest to highest point. It’s also pre-seed and comes with equity, and health, 401k benefits. It’s a director of sales role so I would eventually be recruiting and managing a team along with building the processes and strategy. What would you consider a fair compensation package? If they offer me something on the lower end of the range, is it still appropriate to counter with an offer that is over their stated range?

like

Hello all,

I have an Interview with Atlassian for a pre sales solutions engineer role in Canada that requires 5-8 YOE . What's the salary range I should be aiming for ?

like

If job posting pay was $36.66 hourly (no range) what would be an acceptable offer and counter offer?

like

I am negotiating an Engineer position in Ottawa. Is 90k a good starting point? I’ve checked Glassdoor, Indeed, and the PEO salary survey, but I want to have as much info as possible. Any pointers are appreciated!

like

Anybody know salary range for VP Operations for GS in SLC?

I’ve been approached my by company that one of our large clients (who im currently project managing for) is looking for a consultant of sorts, and if they hire us, I’d be the first person asked to take on this consultant role. This isn’t something my company typically offers and would greatly change the scope of my role. Has anyone ever taken on a role like this? If so, were you able to negotiate a percentage of the consulting fee? Or was it a bump in salary during the project?

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal