Related Posts
Marcus HYSA rate cut down to 2.0% :(
More Posts
Please bada do yaar😂

11 likes please
Thank you!
Strategy Director Salary / LA / 8-10 years exp?
Additional Posts in The Real Estate Bowl
Can I get a commercial loan without 25% down?
New to Fishbowl?
Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.







I would pick the better location.
Coach
Then I’d say keep looking. I agree with you on split level.
The answer is obvious. Put the $300k into the older home.
Can you do an extension with that though?
I agree to pick the older home, unless you're stretching your resources and don't expect upward income mobility-- if you don't have the resources and patience to take on renovation, take the easy road. Otherwise, older home sounds like a great choice.
I chose home over location and kind of regret it. The saying “location location, location” is kind of true. Sounds like you’re in a good spot either way though given good school district either way so congratulations!
Coach
I don’t trust the bones of any recently built homes. If you do the renovation yourself on the older home, you can guarantee it is done well.
Subject Expert
How much cash do you have? What’s the difference in payments between the two?
Do you have any experience renovating and upgrading? Would you do the work yourself, or hire it out? How long do you expect to be there? Do you like the idea of having an acre of land, or is the smaller footprint more desirable because it’s less groundskeeping to do?
Personally, I like the value add opportunity because I’m comfortable managing renovations and adding my own personal touches and style. But I also don’t like the idea of an entire acre of land…
I had a similar choice and I chose the location and fixer upper.
No regrets.
Location, location, location….got with the flat acre and add dormer later.
The two homes you are describing sounds like my area in LI.
Keep looking and waiting. If you’re someone who loves the “perfect location”, then you’ll be annoyed to feel the rumble and hear the sounds from the trains and road.
Neither. Would recommend to WAIT to buy the place that checks off all your major requirements. You’re spending so much money to NOT get what you want